Искусственный интеллект
Информатика и вычислительная техника
  • формат pdf
  • размер 946.47 КБ
  • добавлен 26 октября 2011 г.
Crockett L.J. The Turing Test and the Frame Problem. AI's Mistaken Understanding of Intelligence
Издательство Ablex Publishing, 1994, -216 pp.

Part of what it means to be a researcher is to identify what appears to be a relationship that others either have not noticed or have not fully appreciated. Both the Turing test and the frame problem have been significant items of discussion for more than 20 years in the philosophy of artificial intelligence and the philosophy of mind, but there has been little effort during that time, as I read the literature, to distill how the frame problem bears on the Turing test. I believe that there is an important relationship and that this essay articulates that relationship. Of course, I must leave it to the reader to judge whether I have argued convincingly that such a relationship exists.
In a larger sense this essay is also an attempt to explain why there has been less progress in artificial intelligence research than AI proponents would have believed likely 25 to 30 years ago. As a first pass, the difficulty of the frame problem would account for some of the lack of progress. One could take this to mean that the progress will simply be much slower than originally anticipated because the problems are much more complex. An alteate interpretation, however, is that the research paradigm itself either is destined to be less productive than we might have hoped or must undergo radical change. In general terms, the view advanced here is that the future of AI depends in large part on whether the frame problem will fall to computational techniques. If it tus out that the frame problem is computationally intractable, if there is no way to solve it computationally by means of a program operating on formally defined constituents, which is AI's understanding of intelligence, then I suspect an increasing number of writers will reach the conclusion that AI embodies a fundamental misunderstanding of intelligence. In fact, that is the view I tentatively advance here.
In short, I defend the view that the Turing test is a good test for intelligence but that no computer will be able to pass the test unless there is a solution to the frame problem. Against those, such as Gunderson and Searle, who say that passage of the test would not necessarily signify that a machine was thinking, I argue that a computer passing the test would have to possess a solution to the frame problem and that such a solution should convince us that thinking is in fact occurring. Against those, such as Dennett and Turing, who imagine that passage of the test is just a matter of time, I argue that it is not at all clear that we will be able to solve the frame problem, and, as a result, it is not at all dear that a computer will ever pass the Turing test. In fact, I think the prospects for a solution to the frame problem are not good.

Introduction: The Turing Test in Light of the Frame Problem
Algorithmic Machines and Computer Leaing
Computer Simulation and User Illusions
The Dreyfus Critique and the Frame Problem
The Turing Test, Dennett's Defense of the Test, and Mindlike Programs
The Relation of the Frame Problem to the Turing Test
Two Major Critiques of the Test: Searle and Gunderson
The Frame Problem, Philosophy, and AI's Understanding of Intelligence
Похожие разделы
Смотрите также

Bramer M. (ed.) Artificial Intelligence. An International Perspective

Статья
  • формат pdf
  • размер 2.87 МБ
  • добавлен 17 ноября 2011 г.
Издательство Springer, 2009, -252 pp. This edited collection of papers entitled Artificial Intelligence: An International Perspective originated with a proposal by the President of the International Federation for Information Processing (IFIP), Professor Basie von Solms, for the IFIP Technical Committees to publish ‘position papers’ on their technical areas. Each Technical Committee has members nominated by national computer societies worldwide...

Encyclopedia of Artificial Intelligence

Энциклопедия
  • формат pdf
  • размер 24.43 МБ
  • добавлен 05 октября 2010 г.
Numerous real-life problems so complex as to be virtually insoluble by means of traditional computer science techniques can now be approached effectively with artificial intelligence techniques. Recently, artificial intelligence technologies have evolved at a rapid pace, raising significant challenges to the effort to stay current. PThe Encyclopedia of Artificial Intelligence is a comprehensive and in-depth reference to the most recent developmen...

Korb K.B., Nicholson A.E. Bayesian Artificial Intelligence

  • формат pdf
  • размер 3.71 МБ
  • добавлен 29 ноября 2011 г.
Издательство Chapman & Hall/CRC Press, 2004, -365 pp. Bayesian Artificial Intelligence, in our understanding, is the incorporation of Bayesian inferentialmethods in the development of a software architecture for an Artificial Intelligence (AI). We believe that important ingredients of such an architecture will be Bayesian networks and the Bayesian learning of Bayesian networks (Bayesian causal discovery) from observation and experiment. In t...

Mellouk A. (ed.) Advances in Reinforcement Learning

  • формат pdf
  • размер 12.29 МБ
  • добавлен 26 октября 2011 г.
Издательство InTech, 2011, -482 pp. Reinforcement Learning (RL) is oft en referred to as a branch of artificial intelligence and has been one of the central topics in a broad range of scientific fields for the last two decades. Understanding of RL is expected to provide a systematic understanding of adaptive behaviors, including simple classical and operant conditioning of animals as well as all complex social and economical human behaviors that...

Moss L.T., Atre S. Business intelligence roadmap: The complete project lifecycle for decision-support applications

  • формат pdf
  • размер 7.02 МБ
  • добавлен 29 августа 2011 г.
Addisоn-Wеsley Profеssional, 2003. - 576 p. Business Intelligence Roadmap is a visual guide to developing an effective business intelligence (BI) decision-support application. This book outlines a methodology that takes into account the complexity of developing applications in an integrated BI environment. The authors walk readers through every step of the process-from strategic planning to the selection of new technologies and the evaluation of...

Nayak R., Ichalkaranje N., Jain L.C. (eds.) Evolution of the Web in Artificial Intelligence Environments

  • формат pdf
  • размер 3.31 МБ
  • добавлен 14 января 2012 г.
Издательство Springer, 2008, -283 pp. The Web has revolutionized the way we seek information on all aspects of education, entertainment, business, health and so on. The Web has evolved into a publishing medium, global electronic market and increasingly, a platform for conducting electronic commerce. A part of this success can be attributed to the tremendous advances made in the Artificial Intelligence field. The popularity of the Web has opened...

Sammut C., Webb G.I. (eds.) Encyclopedia of Machine Learning

Энциклопедия
  • формат pdf
  • размер 34.6 МБ
  • добавлен 19 октября 2011 г.
Издательство Springer, 2011, -1058 pp. The term Machine Learning came into wide-spread use following the first workshop by that name, held at Carnegie-Mellon University in 1980. The papers from that workshop were published as Machine Learning: An Artificial Intelligence Approach, edited by Ryszard Michalski, Jaime Carbonell and Tom Mitchell. Machine Learning came to be identified as a research field in its own right as the workshops evolved into...

Sincak P., Vascak J., Hirota K. (editors) Machine Intelligence: Quo Vadis?

  • формат pdf
  • размер 22.97 МБ
  • добавлен 07 января 2011 г.
World Scientific Publishing Company, 2004. - 476 pages. This book brings together the contributions of leading researchers in the field of machine intelligence, covering areas such as fuzzy logic, neural networks, evolutionary computation and hybrid systems. There is wide coverage of the subject from simple tools, through industrial applications, to applications in high-level intelligent systems which are biologically motivated, such as humanoid...

Thielscher M. Action Programming Languages

  • формат pdf
  • размер 870.92 КБ
  • добавлен 25 января 2012 г.
Издательство Morgan & Claypool, 2008, -100 pp. Artificial systems that think and behave intelligently are one of the most exciting and challenging goals of Artificial Intelligence. Action Programming is the art and science of devising high-level control strategies for autonomous systems which employ a mental model of their environment and which reason about their actions as a means to achieve their goals. Applications of this programming par...

Van Harmelen F., Lifschitz V., Porter B. Handbook of Knowledge Representation

Справочник
  • формат pdf
  • размер 10.96 МБ
  • добавлен 06 января 2012 г.
Издательство Elsevier, 2008, -1035 pp. Knowledge Representation and Reasoning is at the heart of the great challenge of Artificial Intelligence: to understand the nature of intelligence and cognition so well that computers can be made to exhibit human-like abilities. As early as 1958, John McCarthy contemplated Artificial Intelligence systems that could exercise common sense. From this and other early work, researchers gained the conviction that...