Божьев В.П. О властных субъектах уголовного процесса в досудебном производстве
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
ItA<pE
qPA
yIIPABJI
AHKSI
0
FIAHAIT,IH
PAC
CJIFAOBAHX.ISI
ilPFCTVHJIEH
Hft
BphroB,
3oMecrr'irerr lroqorbnllKo
ro$eapsr
14.n.
Ko-
reorhKoB,
H.Jl. fuenurr.tro,
npo$eccopo [3.1. Foxr,es r,l
[3.|"T. Jloapos,
roLleHrbr
ll A.
Uxonpe6cBo,
O.[J. Xzrponc.
frpeflolloBorenr,
C.[. L{o,uor A
Epy-'le
corpygnhKh
i<r:$eapr,r.
YqeHsre ro$e,qpsr
Bellvr
oKt-hoHyo noAroroeKy rcryrrro-
rcgorofhqecKrlx KollpoB.
Hc rr:$eppe
exeroalJo
B
cpe.queM
3oulhuloercr 15 ron4rzlcrcKrlx
r.t
ogrlo
tr\oKlopcKcre
ghccep-
rourr"
B Hocrorulee
Bpa,^r Ho r.o$eape
npoxoAsr nolroroa-
<y 40
,:21r,lorxroB
orrHOTo o6yueur-rr, 28 o.rllrorrrron
3oorrroro
o6yverNr,
50 coracrorcnci r versrpc
4cKroportro.
flog
pyro-
BoAcl.BoM npoQeccopoa
l,l
,qoueHroB
ro$eppnr
ycneuuo
3o-
tr
\k1't4
n h
Ko
l r/lt4,r.lorcKh
e
rl
IloKl
opcKhc
llhccepl
cl
uh
h MHoth
e
cohcKorenh
yrreHbrv
cr enereil:
-
6.9. [r:oprnoe
-
3 Kc]H;\hgcro roph[hqecKilx royK;
-
A.ll. KonecHr<os
-*
30 ronn/loloB roprlghlrecKhx
royK;
*
I-i.Il. E,uenuKhuo
-
I
rongr.rAor
toph/lrzL.recKhx HoyK,
-
B n. bclNuee
-
l9 roran;1oroa
rophr]hqecKhx noyK,
1
gorrop
topr.rAhLrecKhx
HoyK;
*
B.A.
MrxorTrroe
-
30
KOrAh4oroB
roph,qhqecKhx HoyK,
7
goxropoe
ophAhqecKhx f.royK;
-
B.fl. f
oopoe
*
42 <aagnporo
ropz,qhLrecKV x HoyK;
-
T.B. AaepsrfroBo
-
27 ro.l'puga:.oB ropz,qhqecKLrx
Ho-
yr,
4
goxropo
roph.qzqecKV
x ncryK;
-
A M.
Kycroa
-
6onee 30 KOHJl4tioroB ropr.ulhqecKhx
rroyr.
4
AoKropo
rophArLrecKhx HoyK;
-
C C.
Cov,ruleuro
-
5
rorgrporoo krph1lhlrecKhx
lr
oyK;
-
C.E. Eropoe
-
5
rorrgraoroB
opr.l4hqecKhx
r.ioyK;
-
O.B. Xrrpoao
-
4 roH4ra,qoro
rophAhilecKhx
HcyK;
-
A.A. Llxoape6oeo
--
5
rorgra.qoroB
,1-rphAhqecKhx
iloyK.
fl
po
rrrzrecrr Bce
H
oy,r
H br
e
po
5orr,r r:orpygH h KoB Ko
Oe!-
pbr
r.1
Arlcceprcul,1hl
BbrnorHeHHsle
AoKtopoHroMt,1
h
oAbrorl-
rlTCMh,
COAepXOT npeAnoxeHzs
no cosepueilcTBoBoH/r"c
yronoBHoro
h
yronoBuo"npoueccyorbHoro
3oKoHo[orerbc-
TBO/ BellO/,.^CTBer]
H brX HOpMOTtBHbtx
CIKTOB.
B
po6ore
Yveroro
conercl
Aro"qeMrh
npi.lnhMoer
yqocrrle
:oeegyoulnir Ka+c.qpci b.5i.
fonpNnoa,
Ahcceprout4orriblx
coBcroB
pnAo
By3oB I'ltijl
-
npo{eccopo T
13. Aaepr,rHoa<.r,
8.il.
boxr,ea,
B.fi. Iloopoe,
A.O. BonurHcr<nn, A.M. Kycroo,
C.C. Col,rruterr<o,
6.51. f
oopranos.
Ll-neHout.t
peiqoKuhor-1Ho-143IlorenbcKoro
coBero
Arope-
Mhil
ynpoBrerlar
MBI Poccur't rr]rflnrcr
eoaegyroulrrT
r.o-
$elpoi
6.9.
['ooprznoa,
3oMecrhrenb
ror.]crnbHhKo Ko+egpbl
Fl.l. Erraelrr,rzflo,
LrneuoM
MeroAhqecKoro
coBero
-
npeno-
noBorerb
C.B. Bonoe.
3o,raecrn renu HoqonbHhKo
Ko0e.qpbr /t.A.KonecsnKoB FB-
nqercn npe,qce[oreneM
:rcneprroii
KoMAccvrl
no
pexhMy
ceKpeTH ocTh
/
n
peflcenoTefi
erlr
xoH rypcHori
noAKoMrlccr
h
no
npoBegeHkto
o6Lueorcfler,rhqecKoro KoHKypco
HoyqHbrx
po-
6or clyuorerreil,
rneHor,a KoMlcckt4
no cny>re6roh
!,ucu,nn-
nrrre N npo$ccchortonbHorT
lrhKe.
KoflfierrHg
Ko$e,qpbr
c onrhMh3MoM Bcrpe,roer 80-re-
rze Arope,nl,tr ynpoBreHhF
MB!, Poccrz.
Cero.qrrLuurai
npo-
Qeccopcro-npeno.qoBorerbcr/i
cocrcrg
qrhr
noMsrb cBohx
npefluecrRcHr]hKoBi
hcnonbaycr
n caoei
nogcelHesrrori
Ac-
flTefibHocl'r4
HoyrlHoe HocfleAZe
yqeHbrx,
cTogBu.lhx
y
rlcToKorl
co3goHhg
Aroger,anr
N r<oSegpur,
po3B14Boer
Hoy.ribre
uKorbl
rz
6epcxlo xponhr
3onoxeHHbre vMh rpop\AgAn.
3 d rae crnten s
H rrtrct nbqn Ka xa
$e
gp
u
y
npoBn e Hun
apr aH a Mu
pd
ccn e4oBorus npecrynne
n nfi
,
AOUe
Ht, KdH
An ACrf
tO
Pu
AUg
e CKn
X HAy'(,
n
anKa
BH
nK Munn4u u H.fl. Euensxutto
floqexr
xoQeApbr,
KoHAuAar. Ktpu4nlecKux HoyK,
not KonHuK lu,trnLtllLtu
H.A. Itxaape6oaa
f:".8
BJra erx hrx
cyob e HTax
yron
0
B H
0 r0 n
p
0
ue
e ca
B
fl0eyAe6H0M
npoHsBoAeTne
B
crarae
pocct'AorpeHbt
HeKoropbte
Boripocbt yronoBHC-npoiteccyenbubtx
aruorucuun ilexyy BnocrHbtMn
cy6beKTaMh
yro-
JloBHoro
npolecco B
lj,ocy'ile5HoM
t!poks!3oflcrBe:
cnelloBoieneMt
pyKa'ollhreneNt
cnelJcr,eHtiora
oproHo, npaKypopoM.
14snoxettut
h3MeHeHun
B
perynupoloukk
npoueccyeitbnorc nofiaxeHHu yKo3otlt!btx y\aatlLlKoB
nporlecco/
Korophte
hMeflH
Mecro
B
cBtt3u c KoppeKruL)oBxoit u
rycnon,tenu:t^r'ri
!'i
/K lr(D.
The
article deals
with
cerloirtissues of crimtnol-procedure
relations
botween
powerful
subjects of criminol
procedLne
in
pre-iutlicictl
proceedinq:
int,estigotor,
heacJ
o{
investtgtttive
oqcncy,
prac,,Lrotor.
T he
author
presenis
the chonges in regulotion
of
procedural provision
of the
said
pctticiponts
o{
fhe
proceriitre,
vthtch
took
ploce
in
connection tvith
changles ond amend-
rne rtls
to
the
Criminal Procedure
Code
ol
the Russton Fecleralion.*
QegeponsHsre
30KoHbr or 5
uorn
2047 r. Ne 87-O3
11
6 v'nns,2007
r. Nq 90-03 noArBep[hrh
rolrhL]/e ro
)ronox
llocyAe6Horo
npoLl3BoAcrBo
ggoilrao,qeficrByK)ulr.lx
cy6r,eK-
IOB
yfof
OBflorO CyAOnpOh3BOIICTBO
CO CrOpOr.rbr OaAnHettnn,
g
KJr
rorr
o
ro
urrx
:
o)
n r 11,
p
o
cc-n e,q',vro
LLlh x n
pecrvnr
e
Fr h r,
--
cr e-
IlOBOlenq/
A()3HCrBOrenq;
OJ
t4X
BeAO'\CTBelJHbrX HOtrOJrbHrl-
KoB
-
pyKoBoAhrere
cneAcrBeHHofo
oprrlHo
(PCO),
uo.rons-
HhKo
no[po3Aere+ll
Ao3r]cfrhr
{Fln[);
ai nporypopo. Z,uen
oAHh H re xe
3ogoLrh
(pocxpurrne
h
poccnegoBoHhe
npecryn-
reHri;
scrulrry hHrepecoB nl\Hocrv,
o6ulecra<r
h
rocy,qopc-
reo),
yrc:crur-rbre
Bnocl{bre
cy6},eKTbr
co
cropoHhr o6suHeHnq
!lOBeneLtbr po3rhr.lHbrM14
npoqeccyorblrbrMl,1 norHoMoc!.i.aM|,i.
nph
npoh3BoIlcTBe
npeflBopzTerbHofo
cneAcTBhr
h,qo3Ho-
uvn. C
pn
u u:, n
p
o
ueccyor
b H br'rh n
or
H
oMoLllRM
h
yKo3o r'1 ll br
e
cy6rerrsr
yrc)roBHo-n
poueccyor
bHoro npoBo HoleneHbr
n
ph
npoh3BoacrBe npeABO p!1refi
bHoro
creAcrBr4r/
ApyrhMh
n
po-
BcrMh h
o5qsoHHocrqll'z
*
npv npoBe,qeHhr,l
.qo3HoH14R.
Ecrb
norl HoMoLrl,q/
nphcyu]he h reu
I
v
Apyf
hM.
l-lpnrnrsre
{ocnea:c
3cKoHoMh ar
5 n
6
nnua2007
r.) s
reqeHhe
nocfieAHhx
AByx
Jrer
MHoToqhcreHHbre
3oKoHbr
l)Q
o6
Bozhiev
V.P" On
Powerful
5ubjects
of
Criminol Proceciure
in ['re-Judiciol l'roceeciing
I{A@EAPA
vrrPABJrEHHg
OPrA[rAMriI
,
PAC CJTEAO
BAHH.g
nPECTynJrEHHr4
h3MeHeHrh
ynK
PO nhub npo,qonxonh,
yro,rHf,rh h
(coBep-
LUeHcrBoBoflrl)
ro,
rrro
6srno
gonoxeHo
ABo
ro.qo
xosog. flpr
lroM KoppeKrzpoaKo
rnoBribrM o6po:o,ra
uflo
B
trocrx
poc-
LrhpeHr4fi npoueccyonbHbrx npoB
pyKoBoA/renf
cne.qcrBeH-
Horo oprouo
r,1
coKpoqeHrq
nonsouoqnil
npoKypopo no
py-
KoBoAcrBy
,qeflTenbHocrblo
cneAoBorenei.
CooreercrBeHHo
6srnr
yrovHeHbr
H nonHoMoqhq cneAoBorenfl.
Heroropon KoppeKllpoBKo
npoB ra
o6qsoHHocreil
y'toc-
l
u h KOB
yf
onoBHoro cy.qonpoh3
BoAcrBo B
n
phHl-11.'1
ne Bo3Mox-
ro 11
lonycrh,uo.
O.qHoro
npk Bcex
ycnoBzrx seo6xoAruo
crporo
yqhrbrBorb
oco6ue c/creMHbre
rpe6oaonrn,
roro-
pbic
npe.qbrBnelorcfl
K HopMoM
yronoBHo-npoueccyonbHoro
npoac. Heco6rro4eHhe rrnx
rpe6ooounl'
npn
Qopr"rtpoeo-
rhr.1 h KoppeKrxpoBKe
Hopr.a YllK PO ne
ronsro o6ycnoanra-
BOeT ZX HeOIeKBCTTHOe
BOCnphtThe, HO h HeroTr|BHo
oTpoxo-
ercr
rc npoBonphMeHzrenusoi
npoKThKe.
Bor r nocne,qure
rouu
l2A0'/-2008
rr.), npe.qycMorphBofl
B npoeKrox 30Ko-
rios
pcclrhpeHhe
npoB
pyKoBoAhtenn
cfleAcrBeHHofo
opro-
iro,
pospo6orlvKl
)rr1x
npoeKroB
He s nonHoil
Mepe
yqhrbr-
BOrh
cyulecrByfoulyro
c,1creMy
yronoBHo-npoueccyonbHbrx
HopM h Honhqze Bo MHon4x
poioHox
crpoHbt
cfleAcrBeHHbtx
rolpo3llener'rhi
c,uonoqrcneHHbrM cocroBoAa
cneAosorenei.
Co::Aonr,re
xe uexpo rToH H brx
cnetrcrBeH
Hbrx noApo3geneur
ti
cyulecr8eHlro
ycfl
oxHqer
nocrogHHoe oproHh3olllloHHoe
py-
KoBo/lcrBo
Aefl
Ter bHocrbto creAosorenei.
L Co:[oercq
BneqorneHr4e,
L]To/
noAroroBnhBoR
npo-
UeCCyOtll)rlO-npOsOBylO
OCHOBy
.qnn
p0ctllilpeHuq BO3MOX-
rrr:crer7
y
cneAogorenq
il
pyKoBo.qhrenff
cleAcrBeHnoro
op-
fo!f o no o6xonoeoHhro
peueHrail
u
yrosouuit
(rpe6oaouui)
ir
poKypopo,
pospo6or'.rr
r/ npoeKro @egeponurroro 3oKoHc
or
5 upns 2007 r. k
cneAytou1hx
30
HtlM HopMoruBt{brx oKroB
cfronorhquoro
ypoBlrr,
freAocrorotrro
oLlerrhnl.l
ror
Soxr,
rrro
Bce
ouu
(nporypop,
cneAoBorenb,
pyKoBoAr.lre,rb
cre,qc-
'rBeirHoro
opror-ro)
npe1croBnsrcr
B
yronoBfroM npouecce oA-
rly
cropoHy
-
croporly
o6aNHeHZq.
florror,ay
npexge Bcero
troxrro o6ccncqhrb
hx
e4hHcrBo,
sgoil^ o4eicrgqe,
orBerc-
loc*uocrbr o
He
(BHyrpeHHtolo
cocrr3crerbHocrb).
[ 1pr
rror'a
rollo hMerb B BhAy/
t]ro
npoKypop
B yrouoBHoM
npollecce
-
3ro
|re rofll,Ko
oproH
Ho.q3opo 3o npoqeccyonbHot
Aefrenh-
uocrbro
oproroB
poccne.qoBoH'ls,
Ho t4
cy6uerr
ocyulecr-
oneunr
$yHrqhh
yronoBHoro
npecnegoBcHhq, o
B cyAe6nor'a
rrpoH3eolcrne
-
eule I
rccygopcrBeHHsri o6etlHilrenu
{v.
1
n 3
cr.37
YtlK).
!,orosorenbcTBeHHoq
xe 6oso
Arfl
ocyurecr-
ilJleirrlfl )Thx nonHoMo,tri
nporypopoM
B
3HotttlTenbHoh
Mepe
$op,r,rrpyercn
o
gocyge6nor',r
npoh3BoAcrBe.
[lclrouy ou
rte
r"roxer
6
srru rt h Lr.r b
co3e
p
uoren
e,ra :rro
i,n,efl Ten
b H
o crh.
Coo6po:Ho rroMy
rnoBHoe
B rcnorHeHZh ocHogrtutx
o5R-
:orlrocrei.t creaoBoreneM
*
3To
He
ero
Bo3MoxHocru 6ec-
Korcrrro
Bo3poxclrb
(nporraocronrs) pyrooogrrerlo
creAC-
rnernoro oproHo
N
(nnra)
nporypopy, o
B ro,u, vro6ut 6urcrpo,
noJilro ,1 rpoMoTHo
poccne8oBoTb
npecrynneH149
r,l
(He
npo-
r
opforb)
npil
]ToM
AoKo3orenbcrBo.
CneAosorenu
z
pyKoBo-
/ikrelrb
cneAcrBeHHoro oproHo,r\onxHbr
co3Aorb
npoKypopy
roKyro
AoKo3orerbcrseHHyro
6osy,
roropos 6t,t o6ecneqH-
rrcl
e,ray
gocrofrHylo
no3hul,lro nptl ocyuecTBneHilh
cBohx
non-
ro,rroqri a
cy.qe.
Zueuuo
npoKypop
(o
He cnegoaorenb
z He
oyKoBollhrer!
b
cne,qcrBerl
Horo
oprouoi
ocyuecrBnttor
Qyur-
uhro
rocyflapcrBeHHoro o6guHenun
a cyAe6rror'a
npor43Bo,qc-
roe
(r.ro
npeABopl-lTenbHoM cryuoHr14,
a
cyAe6HoM
po36tl-
porerbcrB-/
B sblllecTotu-lhx cyAoxJ.
Ero
AetrenbHocrb
B cy-
rlox
-
3ro
npoflonxeHhe ocyu]ecrBueHrr
SyHrqrar
o6aw4e-
rl
rn
{yroroouoro
npecregoBoHNr)
Ho
.qocy.qe6r-rutx
rronox,
Ko-
rofiyK)
ol-t ocyulecrBruer
HoprAy co cfleAoBorefieM
h
pyKoBo-
jl|Jrefi
eM cr]eAcTBeHHoro
oproHo.
{lolrour7 TpyilHo cornochrbcq
c
BbtcKo3oHHbtMfl
B neqo-
rr.1
BocropfoMh
no notsoAy KoppeKrhpoBrcr
q.
3
cr.
39
Yl-lK
ic'.r.
rrir.
<s>
n. 6
OeAeponuuoro 3oKoHo or
2
gero6pn
2008
r.
N:
226-03) h npeAocraBreHhh
creAoBoreno
npoao
o6xo-
roBorb nlo6oe
yKo3oHile pyKoBoAr,lrene
cre;1crBe-HHoro
op-
roHo/
Aoxe
ecnH oHo
AoHo
Ho ocHoBe
rpeooBoHtlh
npoKypo-
po. flonoroo,
qro
3ro
AoneKo
He
coMoe
nyquee
peLlleHz
e:
HeKOTOpbre
yKo3or'rH9 pyKoBoAZTe|b cfleAcrBeHHofo
opro-
uo,
6oer,rpyrcb
Ho npegnhcoHrlsx
npoKypopo,
npocro
o6n-
30H
Aorb
cneAoBorento.
3o.qoqo
xe cneAoBoreflq
He
AhcKy-
Tt4poBorb,
He
3or9fhBorb
BpeMq, o
BblnoflHtTb 3T1.1
yKO3Ol-thfl.
Ecnr, Honpnraep, cyA
B03Bporiln
npoKypopy
yronoBHoe.qe-
no
B
coorBercrBzh co cr.237
YtlK,
o
npoKypop
HonpoBhn
ero
(aeno) pyKoBoAhrento
cneAcrBeHHoro
oproHo,
conpoBo-
Ar4B
Onpe.qeneHHbrMr.l
peKoMeH,qoLll4gMh hrlh TpeooBoHrluMh,
ro
cne.qoBorento
reo6xo8zMo
He
yBneKortcq
xono6ol
l.1,
Ae-
MOHCTpZpyn
He3OBl,lCI4MOCTb OT
pyKOBOAhreil9
Cne,qcrBellHo-
ro
oproHo
h
or
npoKypopo, o
BblnoflHerb nonyqeHHble
yKo-
30Hl.1f C
rer"r, vro6ut
cBoeBpeMeHHo
h o6ocHosoHHo
npuHtlrb
peuieHhe
o
Bo3MoxHocTh
HonpoBneHr4n
yronoBHoro
Aeno
B
cy.r1.
K romy xe Ho.qo
hMerb B Bh,qy,
Llro
Aeno
Aroxer 6btrs
sos-
BpouleHo npoKypopy He
ronbKo
r43
npeABophrenbHoro
cay-
l.rloH/q, Ho t4 As cyge6Horo
po:6rporenscrao
(r.
2
ct.
256
YtlK), o
roKxe nocne
orMeHbr
nphrooopo cyAoM
Koccotlhort-
uoir
uircroHqnra
(c,v.
n.
,l3,
IB,23
ilocroHoeneuun
flneHytao
BC PO
or
23
gero6pq
2008
r. No 2B) h B nopn[Ke
Hcll3opcr
(cu.
n. 15, 17, IocroHoBreHhfl
flnerry,nao BC
PO
or
I
I nHsc-
on
2007
r,
Nq l
l
2.
OeneponuHbrM
3oKor'ioM or
2
gero6ps
2008
r. s
cr.
37 YUK
BKrroqeHo r. 2r
cnegyroutero
co,qepxoHztt:
<21.
flo
Mol4BhpoBOrHoMy
nhcbMeHHoMy 3onpocy
npoKy-
popo
eMy
npeAocToBrqercf
Bo3Moxtiocrb o3HoKoMhTbctl
c
MorepzonoMh HoxoAflulerocfl
B npoh3Bo[clBe
yrorloBHo-
ro
,qeno>.
3rrqecrzi
ypoBerJb
3rot7
Hoeenrur ocroBnfier
xe-
norb
nyquero. Ho
gonero
He
6e3ynpe,rHo
npoBoBofl
cocroB-
nnrouloq HopMbr. B
couou
Aene,
npoKypopy,
Ho Koroporo
q.
I
cr. 37
ynK
Bo3noxeH Hog3op 3cr
npoueccyonuHoi
ge-
grenbHocThro
oproHoB cfi e,qcTBhc/
Ilo3
BoreHo
03l'1o
KOMtlTbCtl
C
MOTepHOnOMh
yTOnOBHOTO
AenO
rhuit' npil llOn/qhh
(MO-
ThBhpoBoHHoro
nhcbMeHHoro 3onpoco).
[1pr.r
lror'a
B TeKc-
Te
3oKoHc
He
yKo3oHo,
KoMy
AonxeH
6strs ogpecoaori
ao-
npoc, KTo il
g
xororl cpoK ero
AorxeH
poccMorperb/
olletltlll,
ero
MoTrlBt4
poBoHHocTb
r1
nphHurb
peueHhe. Kpo,r,te
roro.
ne
yqreHo,
qro
npoKypop Moxer nory\lars
xono6y
(ttn^
wrch
o.rrnon)
e roroil
Sop,ue
/
no roKoMy noBoAy,
tlro
npexAe-
BpeMeHHOe
yBeAOMneHre
o
HeM
B
(MOThBhpoBoutloM
30llpo-
ce> c,qenoer 6eccl,tutcneHttuu,,l
g
AonsueiueM
He rortbKo 03-
HoKoMneHhe
c
AenoM,
Ho
lt
soo6ule npogerleHfie
KoKZX-nh-
6o
nporleccyonbHbrx
14 uHurx
.qeicretli.
6oree
roro,
AonycK
npoKypopo K o3r]oKoMneHh|o c
MorepHonoMh
yroroBHoro
,qeno
no
3onpocy
-
3ro
poBHoc/nbHo
ocyuecrBneHil|o
HoI|-
3opo c cornocHr
norHoA3opfroro.
Bo3HilKoer
Bonpoc:
r.ty-
xerf nH 8006ule roroi.r
uogsop? V1
uonsop nv
tro
vnn ero-
16
ppyroe?
Ooxrrqecru
pospo6orqrrh npoeKro soxoHo
Nq
226
trc
cronbKo o6ecneqrnn
ueneHonpoBtretrHocrb
ra
rQQer-
rh B Hocrb
ocyulecrBneHrn
n
poKypopoM ero n
po
Bo3o
u-lhrlr
ot
$yHrL1rr,
cKonbKo co3gontl
o,repepnoi
6opsep
rro
nyril K ee
peon
113or|1H.
3. flepeaovo
pyKoBoAr.lrento
ctrellcrBeHrroro
oproHo
pt-
lo
n
poueccyon
bHblx
non
I loMov
q
n, n
pN uognexoull4x
npex.qe
npoKypopy/ He 03Hoqoer,
qro
y nocnellHero tler cpeAcrB.qnf
ocyulecTBreH
hfl
Ho.q3opo
30
npcjBhn bH blM
hcnon Het
I heM 30-
KoHoB cte1oBorentMr
h
hx
pyKoBoAr4TertqMI,l.
Kor
z3necruo,
npoKypop no-npexHeMy
BnpoBe orMeHrrb
nocroHoBneH/e
o
aos6yxpeHran unu o6 orKo3e
u
no:6yxgeurh
yroroBflofo
Aeno
cfle,qoBoreng
Anv
pyKoBoAhrent
cneAcrBeHtloro
opfc-
no
(cr.
146,148
Y[1K), ecnrz
npz3Hoer
hx He3oKoHr.ibtMz
vnl
ueo6ocHosoHrrurr.ar,r.
Io o
Honorhq HbrM ocHoBO
It
hfl M orr o6n-
30H
OTMeH'1Tb
nOCTOHOBneHAe O
npeKpOl-ltrettrh
yronoBFlo-
ro
Aeno
ra Bo3o6roBhrb
npotl3Bo4crBo
no.qery
(v.
1 cr.
214
YflK). CornocHo
nouoxeHhnr.a
.r.
I ct.
221 Y[lK
npoxypop
BnpoBe nplHqrb
peueHhe
o Bo3BpouleHrh
yronoBHoro
.qe-
___'_'_-_'
u
^**
___-J'"
<
POCCilRCKIITI
CJIEIOBATEJIb'>
ItA$
B,,qpa
yn
PABJIEHH,fl
OPnAHAMII
PAC
fr J[
N-UCI BAFJH
g
NPECTYNJI
AHHfr
Jro
cnel]oBo re rK)
hr1,14
pyKajR(
)Jt k
rejt
lo
cfl ellcl.BeH
Horo o
LlI
oHt
(v
1
cr. 221
ynK|
Il
ynK
[)'+ ripe[)/c,\n,)roer]
pqr't
r-ipvrhx nnn-
uov,o,l.1r.i
npoKypopoi
coo6po3lo
Kcropbl\4
on
RnpoBei ric"
norb3yrr
npoueccyoJrr,ilbre
cDelcTBc,
peorhpoEoTb
Ito
BbtflB-
Ir
eH H ble llc.j
pyLUetl
hff
3cl
Kollar
opTo lro^/trJ ft
penBo
n
t fe'lL,H
of
.)
clreAcrB hfl.
B,,,.leCrC
C
TeM B IleKATOpblX
CIlyr.lOtiX lle COBCeM ';Ol
jtlTllarr
KOKT4M
o6po3ou
ic
yrero,u
coKpouleriltbtx npoUeccyorlbHblx
nonfror,{oLrhi}
npoKypop
Moxer
pccrM3oBcJrb
cBor
npoBcr.
norrphMep/
He
coBceM Rcfro/ KoKrlM
nyTeM
oH
MOXeT npt{-
3forr,
,rloKo3orerbcfBo
l]eJlonycn4NlrJlM,r
(v.
13
cr.
'i,
cr.
|
/,
q.
2 cr. 8B YilK).
Hogo norrcrrorb,
ofr
Moxer
lro cllerorb cBo-
hM nocToHOBneHheM
npz
c)3llcKOM.nellhh
c
MoTepuorlo,^tt1
yioiroBroro
Aero,
nocryrlrlBLrefo
or cnel
Borens
c o6Llrr-
rHretr irr'rbriu
3oKnrorreHheM
(u.
221
Yl-lK) Mexav reM xopo-
LllO rl3 BeCTI
1Or
LITO
OKO
flL{(]
I lt
i
e
rl
pelBO phl
eu bl
lOf
O
C,qeICTB!.1q
ilef)cilKo
hMeeT Meclo
no vcTeLreHhrl npoJ]orxhTenbHOro
BpeMeHh rloffe
npoBe/'leHhu
TOrO rtv
VttlOlA
Cne,D,CTBeFlHOrO
llcilclB14s.
L3
C|zry
:roro
.qonyLUeHHOe
r.lopyruelthe
llepe.|l(o
Dbr3 br BoeT
f reycTpo r.l hMbte
H
erorh
B tibte
nocne,[cTBh9. Bnrecre
c
'rcM
3oMerhM,
Llro
nll11
cBocBpeMeHHot
neoKuhh
npoKypopo
ToKhx
nocJrelcrarr e
pn,lie
crryLroeB Mox!ro
6uno 6sr
t:6exors.
rlo
/1rt
)To|o or1
lorxefr
riMerb
Jloclyn
K MCTephojloM
poc-
cJre/lyeMoro
[eJr
o
He roJt
bKo ro rgoi
KOf,no
]ro
ro
n
oxercte
r
r.lnH
,rlonycKo
er crcl.loLlorer
b h
thn
h)
pyKO
BoAn rer
b
cNe/lcrBeFl
Ho-
ro
oproHo. K
coxorerllro,
3oKOlollorerb, Kopt)eKrHpyr
npo-
BO
npoKypopo
(DegeponuH;r,ra
3<:KoroM or 5 ztorq 2007
r"
Ns
87-O3 H B
nocreAyloul.lx
olrc,rorlqrrb'x oKrox, He
clrefi
Bo3r{oxlr,rM
I
ro npe[ycMorperb.
MexJ]y reM
rerrrenbrocrb
no
lloKo3r,rBor.rhro
-
3To
soxHeiiLUog
cocroBrqtouloq
yToJ.roB-
roro npollecco!
flo:ror.ay peL|orb
lror
Bonpoc npruercF:
Jlyrlule
6t,r
pOHr,L!ei
LreM
nO3xe...
flpegycnaorpr.rBoff
npoLlo npoKypopo
o6xonoaori, a
cny-
tloe
Hecornoclua
EencrBVAMh
pyKoBolhre|r
crcllcrnenltoro
oproHoi
ynK
PO
ycroHoBhn
Ie
Bnonfre
'y'/1o'illt,r,
Mexcf]t13M
peorh3orthr.l
)rhx
npoB
iq. 6,:.r. 37
yl-lK)
Ofr
.{ocrqqro
:o-
hMcmoeou r.rs
c$epsr o6ulero rroll3opo
/ lre
yqhrhrBoer
cne-
t
p.t
Q
u <v,
yror
o
B
H
o-
n
po
uecc\,/ci.n
b n L.rx
o t l o t,Lt e
l
r
ir, rn
x
r, o
5
r,r
s
-
rrocThI
MHOrocTopoHilocr'rj/
cfro!.1f
1ocTh
4. Borrpcr<r.r
cltoxusLteircc
3cKofloiicrcrLrori nporrrre a
chc'reMy
yro-floB
Iro- n
poLlecc\/c.'r
b
f lbrx
orro
ue i+r
ir
Oeae
r,.cr
l-
rrbrM
3oKoroM i.ls
226 FrecroHilcprrbr).^
norje
,.ior,/
BBe[err
ciilc
olirzr
cy6lexr
vfoloBfro-n
poueccyonbroro
n
poBo
-
crer.o-
Boreirb-Kphr"tlfroJrr,rcr.
3ororropcrento
le norpe6osonocu
IUU
rrofo uHochrb
ll3MeHerrhe
B
rnoBy
Llrecrytrr
Y[lK, nocBq-
illc'rlrYK) yLiccTrhKoM yfo.,toBt.tor-o
npouecco
co cropoHsr
o6-
BpiH.jr'.rhu.
Ou
rrpe1lnoveJr ynpoLUcllbrrr
{e
6r,r
rlc
xa.
a'::.r:c
j
,
<npu,r-ttlrratrltrT:>)
npracv., FBeDr
)rv
drrn,ny t:
.r.{
iei.r!')1f oicD.
f iO-llpOUeCCVOjlhr.l
hrX
Crf
tOil te1
lv1l
<q,rc;: rFto
L)
XOItO),. ari'ftOlt
!-
Lr|1BLrr4cb
RKnnqcrr/eM
B reKcr
cr.
5
VflK
n. 40-'l.
'rF)etcro-
Rhg B
Hel,{
}le
Tr)ili-,i(0
O.rtJCOll!1e flOtlqThtr l{O8(lrO
\itrOCTlll.lKCl
!rilOileC(O
--'
<CrlC.lCilOTeJlF-(p!]MhilOrhCIO)/
tiO
'1
CnpeX.e-
nhB rc^4
xe
{lj
eret npcBogor:
croryc
lJo
fror
rogr.ri
cy6beKr
yroJroBlro-npoueccyorbt
ir.tx
or rrouterrifl.r IIe ToJthKo BBeAelt B
yrcnoouurir
npouecc
(cneqh0hqecKkl^
116pct3oM>. Fuy
eLLle
N
npeAocroBneHbt
Heo6btqHbte npoueccyorLlftbte
npoBo, KoTo-
pbrx
Her
.qoxe
rrl y
rrocrosluero
cregonorerr
{croryc
roro-
poro
cofnooro
06LuLlM
npoBhno/.n
onpe^ene
rr
rn. 6
YtlK), ura
y
ero
pyKoBollhrenq.
l4ueetcst B Bhly uolereHhe
cleAOBo-
'reut-KphMhfronrcTo
npoBoM npoz3Boj|1rb
c|eJl,crBeflrlble
h
hHble npoueccyorbrJbre
[eilcrn14n
6el
npu:;tun
VronoBHofo
Aeno
K
cBoeMy npoh3Bogcrly.
VI Bce
trc cllenoric B
poMKOX
cr.
5 YtlK,
hMeouleil
nogco6Hoe
cnpoBoLrfto-rexuhqecKoe
n
peiqH03
f toqeH he:
po3t,Rcll
e
H
L1
e oct o8
t{r,tx
not1lrv,t4,
l/cnoll
h-
3yeMbrx
B reKcre
ytlK
PO. Mexly reM B reKcre
VflK
lrr
no-
HqTl,1'
OTCVTCTBVK)T.
Coraopnn
Heo6L,rrrHbrM
nyreM
yKo30rHoro
cy6l,eKro
yfo-
fl
oBHo-npoLleccyonbHbtx
orlou.rerri,
po3po6orqhKh
npocK-
ro
OeAeporbr-roro
3oKoro or 2
[e-'Kc6pfl
2008
r.,
Moxer
6b
rb,
He xelrofl
frofo, KoK
6ur
<no4rorrrBOnr)
ero
K npoueccyonb-
HbrM npoBoHopyuleHhrMi
ToK KOK
cfleficreeHt]ble h hltbte
npo-
qeccyol
hH
bre
llef4crahu
o6srq
l sril
crello
Boren
b
.[1oxer r]
po-
BOAhTb
nhub
no
.qery/
nprlf tqroMy
K
cBoeMy
npoh3BoAcTBy
(cr.
156 VtlK),
nr6o
no
cneuhonbroMy nopyqeurro
Apyroro
crel\oBorerg,
)i
KoTopofo
B npor3BollctBe
ftoxolr.1Tca
yrc-
IroBl'roe
gerro
{r.
I
ct. 152 YtlK)
CooroercrBerro npoBeAeH-
Hble BonpeKh
rpe6oBouzrM
cr.
I
56
u l52YflK
cnelcroerrr,re
AeicrBte
re ^"roryr
o6peclr.r tophllhqecKyro
cv1,qy.
lotror"ly
co6polrHbre roKrM nyreM
cBeltcfrhr
le Moryr
6;rru
4onycr,r-
Mtru"{,4
rioKo3crerL,clBOMfl
{c,.,r.
r. 2
r:r
50
Korcrprryqrrn
PC,
q.
I
ct.74
nct.75
ytlK
PcD,
n. l6
flccrorrr:Bnefrrlri
[Tnery,,.ro
BC- PO
or 31
orrr6pq
.l995
r. Ns B, Onpe,qenerrc
KC
PO
or
2 <beBllorq
2006 r. Ns
57-0) :lo,rer"r xe
lro ctlenorro?
iie',rxenH
ronbKo
flnq
roro,
,]To6bt
ilcyqhrb
cne;1ogorerr
B
o,rena!lroL1
n.rl
npcor,loNeBoTt
hcKyccTBctlIo
co3,ilollrlbte
npelrtrctsIl?
Eox<rea 8.1'1,,
zocnytxennufi
Aectenb
noyxu
P(D,
AoKrop
,opnAuqecKHx
uayx, npoQeccop
KdQeApb,
Y n p
o e
n e
x
n n o
p
r ct H
a
M
H
p
rc<re.qoacH n n
npe ctynn ennfi
Axop,euuu
ynpaanexnr
MBA Poccuu
,1r
rF"t
:
3axoHogarefl
bcrBo,
cyge6Hafl
n
pa
KTr Ka.
lflli
OegepanuHas
cfiyx6a
P0
no KoHrpono
3a o6oporoM
Mexgy Ha
po,qH
oe corpyg
H t4
Lrecr
Bo rocyAa
pcrBe
H
H btx
cflyx6, Mepbt 6oprr6ur
c
He3aKoHHbtM
r/i3roroBreHileM,
3fi OynoTpe6reu Neu
(e
roM
q
Hcfl
e Heco BepueH HoneTH nM il).
pacn pocTpaHeHneM
HapKoTt4qecKilx
BeulecTB.
lOpegr,i
uec
K[4e cnocoSbt
peiueH
r4R
n
po6fi
eMbt HapKoMa H L4 14.
3apy6exnsrtr 0nbrr.
llrgarenbcKan rpynna
(lOpucrll
H A
p
H
0
H
0 H rp
0 n
b
fflf,lffif;
:
3HJHil
lll ;liilill;
XilliiJJ
"'