
SPORTS IN AMERICA 1900–1919
2002). His single-season record of 96 sto-
len bases was the standard until 1962. 
Cobb combined batting skill and baserun-
ning expertise more than any other player 
before or since, a style that was perfect for 
the game at the time. Most teams relied 
on speed, “small baseball” (lots of little 
hits rather than big home runs, which 
were rare), and great pitching. 
Unfortunately, Cobb was also equally 
well known for his terrible temper and 
fearsome competitiveness. He was famous 
for sharpening his spikes, the better to try 
to inflict wounds on fielders guarding the 
bases he was stealing. He regularly got 
into arguments with umpires and oppos-
ing players. He once fought an umpire on 
the field after a game and nearly traded 
punches with the great Babe Ruth. “When 
I began playing the game,” Cobb wrote, 
“baseball was about as gentlemanly as a 
kick in the [groin].” In his most famous 
display of temper, which led to one of 
baseball’s oddest games, Cobb vaulted 
into the stands during a 1912 game to 
battle a fan who was berating him. After 
Cobb was suspended by the league for 
his actions, his teammates refused to play 
without him. 
Cobb led Detroit to only one A.L. title, 
in 1909 (see page 59), but the Tigers lost 
in the World Series. He became the team’s 
player-manager in 1921, but his fierce 
style did not work well. 
Cobb retired in 1928 and was one of 
the first players chosen to be in the new 
Baseball Hall of Fame in 1936. Cobb’s leg-
acy of skill on the diamond was clouded 
by his less-than-savory personality, but 
his place among baseball’s greatest is well 
deserved.
Masterful Mathewson
While Cobb was all spit, nails, and 
anger, New York Giants pitcher 
Christy Mathewson was calm, reserve, 
and prudence. This all-time baseball hero 
had his greatest moments on the field 
during the 1905 World Series.
A rarity in baseball, Mathewson had 
attended college, studying and playing 
baseball and other sports for Cornell Uni-
versity. He was a great all-around athlete 
as well as what was then considered a 
gentleman. A devout Baptist, he refused 
to pitch on Sundays, and he rarely took 
part in the postgame parties preferred by 
many players of the day.
In a time in which some hotels would 
not let baseball players stay for fear of 
their uncouth behavior, Mathewson was 
a shining light of good manners. Mathew-
son represented for many fans the exem-
plar of the athlete. Tall, strong, attractive, 
well-educated, and supremely talented, 
he mixed as well with his rougher team-
mates as he did in “polite society.” 
When he was not playing, he had 
other skills not usually associated with 
athletes. In fact, he also worked as a 
sportswriter covering some World Series 
games, and he published a series of novels 
for young readers based on the exploits of 
a fictional high school baseball player.
But back to the 1905 World Series. 
Mathewson's Giants faced the Philadel-
phia Athletics, champions of the American 
League, in October. New York, which had 
shunned the A.L. champions in 1904, had 
agreed to take on the Athletics. And a good 
thing for the Giants they did. In the space 
of six days, Mathewson threw three shut-
36