
contrast to the
South
the
West,
or
New England the
Midwest has neither a sharp, clear
historical identity nor a strong presence in contemporary popular culture. There are no
music or movie genres called “midwesterns” and no traditions of Midwest literature or
history comparable to that of the South or West. Even the geographic referent is
uncertain. For some, the Midwest refers to the “Old Northwest,” the states north of the
Ohio River, between the Allegheny Mountains and the Mississippi River. But for others
the heart of the Midwest lies in the plains states of Kansas and Nebraska, well to the west
of the Mississippi. While an inclusive twelve-state definition centered on the Upper
Mississippi-Missouri watershed—Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin,
Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska and the two Dakotas—is becoming
somewhat standard, there is no real consensus even on this most basic issue.
Another way of envisioning the Midwest is as the hinterland of
Chicago, IL
. The
Midwest is encompassed by a large semi-circle or arc of economic influence stretching
for some 500 miles around the great metropolis of the central US. But the strongest and
most common identifying characteristic of the Midwest is
agriculture
. The Midwest is
rural and agrarian, in contrast with the urban and industrial coasts. Because of this
identification of farming and region, the encroachment of urbanization and
industrialization from the east and the growth of cities like
Detroit, MI
and
Cleveland,
OH
have gradually shifted perceptions of the region more to the west. Michigan and
Ohio have lost some of their credentials as Midwestern states, and are more associated
with the industrial northeast. Iowa, Kansas and Nebraska are now the most typical
Midwest states.
Farming and pastoralism identify the Midwest with one of the abiding positive themes
of American culture, going back to Thomas Jefferson and Abraham Lincoln. Thus, the
Midwest is often seen as the best and most typical part of America, still resembling a
small town and rural “golden age,” before ‘America grew up and moved to the city,”
ringing all of the problems that have beset the urbanized nation. Americans think of the
Midwest as the safest, most honest, hard-working, friendly middle-class, egalitarian
center of American culture. The Midwest is Lawrence
Welk,
Harry
Truman
and Dwight
Eisenhower,
Dorothy and Auntie Em and Toto in
The Wizard of Oz,
and
Main Street
in
Disneyland
(made to resemble Walt Disney’s childhood hometown of Marcelline,
Missouri). Above all it is farmers and small towns—to test wide acceptability one asks
“How does it play in Peoria?” Hence, commentator George Will opined that if God were
an American, he would surely be a Midwesterner.
Nonetheless, the 1920s and 1930s were the apogee of Midwest pride and self-
confidence. Since the Second World War, the Midwest’s image has been somewhat
tarnished. It has seemed to many an increasingly old-fashioned and out of touch
ackwater in a cosmopolitan, modernizing and multicultural society Isolationism before
the Second World War and
McCarthyism
afterwards hurt the region’s reputation, in
spite of
Truman
and
Eisenhower’s
political roles as native sons. Subsequent
Midwesterners have led majority and minority parties in
Congress,
but Robert
Dole
lost
to a Southern incumbent in 1996.
Encyclopedia of Contemporary American Culture 734