Газетдинов Н.И. О цели и назначении уголовного судопроизводства
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
vr"oJroBHblfi
nPoqEcc
ffi
,roril
Ha3HaqeHnH
yrgfi
0BH0r0
cyflgnpgil3ggfrCTBa
Hgsuoqeuue
kMeer
hpKa
aatpaxehuad
Hcpl\AQrkB',ibtfi
v.gpaKre
Dt
rQK
KQK
HO
KOH:\L|TY:.4QHHOM
YpaaHe
u
B
yroitcqHo'
nporJeccyanbro*
ro*or"'
,pe6o,uou*,
o 3auJLtre
npas
u
:OrOl:t':^:irepecol
nuLl
k oprcHLfeauuil',
norepneBw!4x
or
noe-
crynneunil,
Q
rQK.*e
o
3OuJUre
'luLrHOCrh
or.
He3'KOHH
oro
u
per-'SocHaecH,orc a6auueuun,
OCyXAeHun'
orpcHuqeH'4F
ee
tlpo.
t4
c*oao'
Haunk
J"lu
io*prnneHr,te.
Ha3uaqe,-tue
yronoii*sra
CyEOnpck3BAACraA
OSecnequeQer
eA,HCfBa
fipot4s-
BoAcrBa
no
BCeM
yranoBHL,llA
AenqM
t4 cnyxr4r
rapati-tirei
saKan'dc,'cru
EeFrertbHacrh
erc
YqqcrHkKaB
3a
BCex
craqusx
Yra'
noEHoro
npouecco.
Designotiot't
has
a
normalive
choracter
as
the
,req
"'irent:tj't^:::l
os
prcf
e:t;an
af
rights
'ancJ
legitimote
inleresfs
ai
per-
sons
ond
orEOnizationsiuiterecJ
from
crines,
proteciion
of
a
perscn
f,-o-i
iilegar,ond
ins.ubstantioted
occusation,
ccnvic-
tion,
rimitotionof
#s
nghrs";riitirillti,
i.rr:;'i;;;i;.""'i'Ls.CI
...r
olicotton
6t
the ccnstitulioplllevel
ond
in
crimincrpro'
cedure
row"
Designotion
of
crim.ina!
p,sce.ecing'pi",,iiJu,
f
ir'the
.'n'for-,ty
cf
prcceeding
for oli
t-riminorcoses
ond
serves
cs
o
guarantee
of
legitim"a"V
,i
"riitriti
Lf
tt
pZiirip*li
o't
ai
st:ges
o{
c16nal
procedure'*
xoghMbtM
r eoxuefirurta
ycnoBheM
/ cpeACTBoM
Aocrhxe-
H he
H03HOLreH
hq
yronoBFforo
cyAOn
poh3Bo'qcrBo
CAno
ro
B
ro,recree
ognoil
raa 3oAoq
yronoBHoro
npouec-
co
poHee
rpoAtlqhoHHo
poccMorohBon/cb
ycroHoBrle-
Hrle
hcrhHbt
h
cnpoBeAnhBoe
HoKo3oHt4e
BhHoBHoror'
3rra
hHTeoecbl
iICXOAVI,V
rMeHHo
h3
3OAO'1
yronoBHofo
CyAO-
; ;";;;;.t;o- ibo.*p
o'.,
e
n
pecryn
n e
ann'
u3 06
nuuertue
erar-roaHoro).
YcroHoeneHtie
hcrhHbt
no
AenY
cLll''lTonocb
""*"o;
ropoHrhei
npoBocyAhe,
o
roKxe
n
soAexsoi
ro-
poHrr,iei
npoa
o6or'runeMoro
u
Apyfrlx
yeocrHhKoB
yronoB-
HOro
cyAonpoh3BoAcrBoj
llonnoe,
BcecropoHHee
u o6t-
eKThBHoe
llccneAoBoHhe
Bcex
o6crogrenscrB
yronoBHoro
Aeno
-
ocHoexoi
cnoco6
ycroHoeneHkff
hcrhHbl
no
Aefiy'
c vcroHoBneH
he
AcrvHllt
B cBolo
oqepeAb'
sanqercq
Heo6-
AoB
cn eAcrB
tll h cYAo
o
$o<rra'recrrax
o6cronrenbcrBox
qeJro
roMy/
qro
npoh3otlno
e
AeicrehrenbHocrht
rpyAHo
npeAcroBhrb,
KoK
MoxHo
orpr'1uorb
Heo6xoAruocrb
noc-
roHoBKr4
roKori
Llenh
cBonperN
3ThM
npocrbrta
u
y6egu'
rer
bH
bt
M
cyxAeH
hRM
14Crh
Hy.B
yro-n oB!1
oM
cyAonpoh3
BOAC-
rBe cge,ronH
npo6ner'+roi>4
O
B'
lee'leHro AocrhxeHhe
o6i,e<rqBHoi
hcrhHbl
poccMorphBoer
KoK
BoxHeHu:yto
ro-
DOHT'4|O
3ou-lhrbl
uhqHocrh
or
He3oKOHHoro
z
reo6ocuo-
BoHHoro
o6suueuv,s,
ocyxAeHhfl,
ofpoHl'lqeHhn
ee
npoB
h
cao6oas.
B.T.
Tor,rrn
MorepronbHyro
(o6rerrranyro)
racrrany
poc-
cMorol4Boer
KoK
eAHHcrBeHHoe
ocHoBoHfie
po3peuleHhf
vronoBHoTo
genou.
5e:ycnoBHo,
HoBoF
yronoBHo-npoBo-
u",
po*rpr"o, Koropofl
B npoueccyoabHoM
30KoHoAorerb-
crBe
BcnnouleHo
B
Ho3HOqeHhh
yrorloBHoro
cyAonpotl3-
BogcrBo,
npeAnororoer
Hosuti
noAxo'a
K
coAepxoHhro
uenei
r
3ogoll
yrolloBHofo
cyAonpoH3BoACTBo
BHe
3oBH-
chMocrH
or
roro,
oxBorblBoforcg
nA QtlV
noHRTtleM
HO3HO-
\.reHhr
yroroBHoro
cy[onpotl3BoAcrBO
nh6o
astrerotor
h:
Hero,
oxBorblBororcfl
nv
qen4
h 3QAQLlh
noHgTheM
(HO3HO-
qeHhe
yroroBHofo
cyAonpoh3BOACrBO)
hnn
Her'
Eonsu.tttHcreo
yqeHblx
coBercKoro
tl
nocneAyoli{ero
ne
phoAoBr
tlccfl eAoBo
Btl-l
rae
n
po6ne,''ry.,
uent,t
yronoBHoro
cy[onpoh3BoAcrBo,
B KoLlecrBe
roroaoi
yKo3blBoror
ycro-
HoBneHhe
hcrhHbr
no
Aery.
Honprlrep,,['C
Kopee
cqfiro-
er,
qro (HenocpeAcreeruoit
Llenbto
yforoBHoro
npoLiecco
no
KoxAoMy
yronoBHOMy Aery
ffBnfleTct
ycroHoBneHhe
hc-
ThHblr
onpeAeneHhe
cnpoBeAnhBoto
HoKo3oHHn
nl4ily'
co-
BeoukBUeMV
tlpecrynneHhe,
orpoxAeHqe
rpoxAoH
or
He-
o6ocu
oeo
HFtoro
o6ehH
eF{ht
r'1
oKo30H
he
Bocn
HToren
bHoro
Bo3AetcrB
hq
Anr
n
peAynpexAeH
hn
npecrynneH
r'l
i>7'
B.T.
Tor,ar.rH
Aoer
cneAyrou-lee
onpeAeneHhe
uenh:
<ilensro coBercKoro
yronoBHoro
npoLlecco
sensercq
hgo6-
nuqeHhe
IlhU,
BhliOBHblX
B COBepUeHhh
npecTyr'ne14'''
npqMeHeHhe
K
HhM
CnpoBeAnhBoro
HoKo3oHhq
vn4
AH6IX
Meo
rocvflo
pcrBeH
Horo
h
rocyAo
pcrBeHso-obulecrBeHHo-
io
!o.n"l.itun,
o6ecneuuBotou-lt4x
B
KoHKpe-rHoM
cnyqoe
A;;r;;;;*-uenei
yronoBHoro
HoKo3oHNs
6es
Ho3Hoqe-
H'1R
HQKO3OHilN)".
flo
ruHesrro
B.C.
Sonorur[Ho,
(uenb
AoKo3btBoHhfl
B
ToM
14 cocrotr,
uro6ul
c
noMoulbro AoKo3orenbcrB
MoK-
;;;";,i,
-t;
^6nr.r",
Houe
npe.qcroBneHhe
(<aeuls
Ann
"ocr)
r
/cKoMoN4y
$c<rv
(<aeuru
a ce6e>)'
KoKoBblM
B
yro-
noBHoM
npcuecce
FBnRtorcn
o6croqrenucreo
o6ulecrseH-
Ho onoc!1oio AeRHrq>t.
ynK
PO
npFMo
He
30Kpenrter
uenb
ycroHoBfleHhR
14c.ihHbl
no
Aeny,
xorfl
oHo
BblreKoer
h3
H03HOqeHhfl
yrofloBHoro
cygonpoh3BoAcrBo
h
11gqSv64ra'uocrtl
vcroHoBneHhfl
Bcex
o6atottenocrB,
noAnexoulHX
AoKo3btBo
H
hro''
huesso
orcvrcrBhe
npqMofo
yKo3oHhF
a
Yl-lK
PO
o6n:ouHocv
ycroHoBneHhfl
hcrl'lHbl
Bbl3Bono
ocrpble
;;;;;,
t
roprsrvec<oi
n/reporype
nocnerrHhx
ner'
Poc-
cMorpr,lBoe
hMe,ou]fiecn
g
c:'*ycc
^ orHochrenbHo-neo!;
xo.[hMocrh
h
Bo3MoxHocrt4
ycroHoBneHhq
obteKrhBHoh
(raorecron
uuoti)
rcl'rH
st, o6porrartrcn
K BblcKo3blBoHhfl
M
or-
),"no"Itt-outopbe.
B.l'l
3oxraqrrai
orMeqoer:
<flpN
pos-
po6orre
npoeKro
r-toBoro
yronoBHo-npoLleccyonbHo-
io
so*oHo
c
uoy'rHoi
rotlKM
3peHhF
r4cKn'oqhrenbHo
Bo-
*"* Otin
r,,torenunuri
oHonh3
roroi
ueroAonoruqec<oil
N
HDoBcrBeHHofi
loreropraz,
KoK
t4crhHo
B
yronoBHoM
cyAo-
;H;;t;;;.;*.
ra"*t'it
orHo{reH',e
K
ucr%He
Aonxuo
6ur-
no onpe.qenhru
ace
Qopr"rbl
H
l'lHcrhryTbl
B HoBoM
3cKoHe'
,[,onuurir
noAXoA
He
HoxoAhncfl
B
nporlBopeeak
c BoxHeH-
ur hMl
uen
nMtl
yron oe
u o
i $ cr
luvv,
cQo
ouyn
ro
o
B-o
H
H
blMl4
;;;;u*;r,
cyae6uoi
pe$opr'asr,
-
:Quilroil
.5luecreo
or
npecrynner-lrai
nyreu'
peonh3otlhh
yronoBHoro
3oKo-
Hq,
gou-lNroi
npoB
h 30KoHHblx
t4HrepecoB.rpoxAoH'
BoB-
neqeHHbrx
B cgepy
yronoeuoi
acrvtvt'
Honporna'
yc-
ToHoBneH/e
hcrhHbl
no
yronoBHblM Aenol'I
o6ecneqHeoer
ycneuHoe
AocrhxeHhe
roxNx
ueneil
[ocyaopcreo'
npe-
TeHAyloulee
Ho
ponb
npoBoBoro'
He
AonxHo
(3OLUBblpH-
BoTb))
hcrhHy
no
yrotloBHblM
AenoM
HO
HeAocFroeMoe
poc-
croRurerr3.
C
nozuwu
38poBoro
cMhlcFo
cr^'reqoerct
B
nooueccvonbuoi
nrreporype
,
npo6neMl
r4crhll!'l
B
npo-
;;;;';;;ono.t
oo,
HeAcrer
no'({Bbr
IrrF
cnopoe
Ecnra
noHhMorb
vlcrvHY
e rroi
c$epe
KoK
coorBelcrBhe
BblBo-
GozetdinovN't.
On
theffiose
ond
Designotion
of
CriminolProceeding
T-ocEfr
IicKHfi
-alliEAoBArEJrbD
vroJroBHbrft
nPorlEcc-
r foAxoAbt
K noHhMOHhto
vCfAH5t
B
yTOnOBHO-npoueccy-
oflbHo;
nhreporype
ToKXe
ornhqe|oTCq. floMhMo
Toro
qTo
o
$ranoco$croM
noHhMolihk
vcrrlHo
Moxer
6srru o6conror-
rioi n
orHoolrensuoi,
B npoueccyonuHorZ
uoyre
po3nhqo-
ror More
phon
bHyro h
rophAHq
ecKyro
(Sop,r,ron
sr-ryr;)
zcla uy.
Eule
Ao
peBorrol{hh
H.H.
Po:zs nhcon: <Cocrsso-
rerbHoMy npoueccy
He Moxer
6urru ceoicrBeHHo He-
orpoHhqeHHoe
crpeMneHrle
K MorephoruHoi
hcrnHe...
[lpraur-1ran, KoropbrM pyKoBo4crayercn
cyA B
cocre3orenb-
HOM npOUeCCe/
9BnReTCq
nphHllunoM
He Moreprlo-nbHot,
ropNgzvecroi vcrvHu,
roropuri
6onee
npoBtlnbHo
Ho3bt-
Bolb
nphHuhnoM
AoK03oHrocrx
o6erueHzq>10.
ilo uneHro V|.6.
Mnxai,noBcKoi,
(nphHur,ln
.qoKo3oH-
Hocrn
o6arrer-.rhfl
03Ho,-.roer,
qro
hcrrlHHocrb
(znra,
rro ro
xe coMoe,
AocroBepHocrb)
BbtBOAoB
cy,qo o
Qorrzvecrrx
o6cronrenuclBox
yroroeHoro
Aero
IBnqercn rpe6oeorz-
eM,
npeAleBnFeMbrM
3oKor-roAorereM ronbKo K
TeM
cy.qe6-
r rbrM
peueH
hRM/ Koropbre
ror-icrorN
pyror
B
h
HoB
Hocrb n hLlo
B
coBepueHhq npecrynneHv,n.
B
cutyowt,
Kor1o
o6ezHe-
i]Hlo He
yAonocb
npeAcroBhrb
cyAy
ToKyto
coBoKynHocrb
lloKo3orenbcrB,
KoropoF y6egnno
6ur
ero
B
BhHoBHocrh
o6ehHne^4oro,
crpeMneHhe
K Morephonbuoi
rcrNire
gonx-
uo no6yxAorb
ee nozcKh.
Ecnr,r xe
cyA cnepyer nphHl-{H-
ny
(HeAoKq3oHHoR
BhHoBHocrb poBHo
4orosour-roi
Heen-
r-rooHocrh),
ecnh
oH
v,cxa1.ar
r4s
o6s:oHHocru o6auueHrln
onpoBeprHyrb npe3yMnuho
HeBhHoBHocTt4,
ro B
cnyqoe
HeBbrnonHeHhq
rroi
o6s:oHHocrh
cy.q 6yaer
AoBorbcrBo-
Borbcq uct uu
oit
$opr'aon
sH
ofi
(roph.qh,recKo
i
)
r I
.
C
nouei roriKh
3peHhn, orcyrcrBr,le I
coMoM
3oKoHe
noHgTh9 AcTVHbt
h
\env
ee
ycToHoBneHhn,
oTcyTcTBhe 30-
,r.1o,lN
6urcrporo h
nonHoro pocKpbrrhq
npecrynneHhr
Mox-
rlo nhlub
o6uscsrru reM,
Lrro
yronoBHoe
cyAonpoh3BoAc-
rBo Poccr,i rZcKorZ
Oe.qe
po
q
nh
orxo
Avtr
or
06
B h H hren bH
o ro
lvtno
v HoqeneHo
Ho ro, vro5ut
crorb cocrn3orenbHbrM, nph
KOTOpOM, KOK
CnpOBeAnhBO
OrMeqO|or
OrAenbHbte
oBTo-
prrr,
cyulecTBeHHo
pocluhpnercn
cQepo
Ahcn03hThBHocTh
KOrOpOe
(no3BOnreT
cropoHoM nonb3o8orbcfl npeAocToB-
neHHbrMh
3oKoHoM
npoBoMh
hflh
oTKo3btBoTbcF oT Hhx no
co6crBeHHoMy
ycMorpeHhto
,
BnAAr;
clovMt4
peueHhrMh
Ho
HCXOA npOqeCCO
h r.n./
BxoAr,lr B
npol,lBopeq/e
c
nphHl{h-
n
ou
ny6n r,r v Hocla
(oQ
ra
qr,ronsnocrr)
h
Bbr Hyx.qoer
30
KoHo-
,qorenfl
hcKorb KoMnpoMhcc
laexAy nuuu. B
cnyLroqx,
KorAo
yKo3oH
HOe n poThBopeq
he
peuoercn
B
n on b3y
Afi
cn o3rlrvB-
HOCTh/
OLIeHKO
3OKOHHOCTh nphrOBOpO npOh3BOAhTCr
no
Kphrepho
cooTBeTcrBhR
hnh HecoorBercrBhn
BbtBoAoB
cy-
Ao
MorephonoM
Aeno.
YcroHoaneurie roKoro
coorBercrBhe
Jloer
ocHoBoHhe roBophTb
o
AocrhxeHhv
|r''cru{5t
ppr1q1
-
recroi,
o
He
Morepronuxofr.
lOpragrvecroe ACTt4Ho
Moxer
coorBercrBoBorb, o Moxer h
He
coorBercrBoBorb
$o<rorur,
hMeBUJrlM Mecro B
peonbHocrr4.
B
ppyrr,rx
cnyqonx 6onouc,
o6oeHo,reHHurfi
sorouogoreneM,
cBhAerenbcrByer
o
nph-
laore ny6nrvu
ocrt, A npoBo nphHenan
peuteHri/
BnhFtoulhx
rlo hcxoA
Aeno/
nonHocTbto
cocpeAoTor.lr4BoeTcfl B
pyKox
cy6uerroa
yronoBHo-npoueccyon
ur-roi
genrenuHocrz>l
2.
B roxora xe
Knpqe
poccyxgoer
N O.H. Oo*ynnrr,
no MHeHho Koroporo,
(noHflTl4iMh
o6uexlaexoi AcrvH;l
R
yfonoBHoM
npoqecce
oxBorbtBotorcq B nepByro
oqepeAb
AOCrOBepHbre
BbrBo.qbr
oproHoB npeABophrenbHoro
poc-
creAoBoHhe,
cyAo
h
npoKyporypbt
o
Hont4e/'n vnrl
OJc]frc-
rBh
h rex KoHKperH blx
o6cronren
scrB, Koropbre Hccn
eAylor-
cq no
Aeny)''.
B.lO.
MrapoxoB,
noAqepKheon
6eccnopusri
xopor-
Tep hcThHbr B
yfonoBHoM
cyAonpoh3BoAcTBe,
yKo3btBoer:
<(Dop,raonuuoq,
KoHBeHqhonbHor
h
o6uexrheHoR hcrtHo
HOnHqecTByeT
hcKnloqr4TenbHo
B MbltuneHhh
qenoBeKo
KoK
onpeAeneHHbre npoBhno
oproHh3orlhh n03HoBoTenbHoro
npoqecco,
ycroHoBnhBotoulhe
Kphrephh
npo8rnbHocrt4
ero
pe3ynbroro
gnr
cy6uerror>14.
Ho nour
B3rnfl,q, nph
roKoM noAXoAe
K noHhMoHhro l4c-
ru1Hbr/
KOTOpOfl
npoKThqecKh
3oBhchT oT Bo3MoxHocret,
xenoHLlr/
npo$eccrouonh3Mo
cropoH, BpFA
nh
ee
Mox-
Ho
Ho3Borb
ucruuoi'r,
goxe
$opl
onsuorZ.
Ecnz
npory-
pop
orKo3brBoercr
or npeArqBneHHoro
o6BhHeHAfl
B
cyAel
nphLteM
MoTrzBbr
ToKoro
oTKo3o ,raoryr
6srrs
po3Hbti\,\h,
Ho/
no
geicrnyrou-{eMy
30KoHoAoreflbcrBy,
leM
He MeHee
oHh
He hMeK)T
HTZKOKOTO
Oph.qhqecKoro
3HoLleHhfl
Ann
nphHg-
rhn
peueHhr
cyAoM.
B
-rorrx
cnyqoflx
cyA
AonxeH
npe-
Kporhrb
npoh3BoAcTBo
no
Aeny
l4fih yro|oBHoe
npecfle-
AoBoHhe/
nphqeM
6e:
y,lero
MHeHhe
norepneBUero nuSo
B
cnyqoex/
rorpo
o6euuqelluli
s nopnAKe
oco6oro npo-
h3BoAcrBo
nph3Hoer
cBOro Br,1Hy. Posee
tro
h
ecr6
lcrt-
Ho, nycrb
goxe
SopA
onuHoq?
[1orro,r,ry noeBneHhe roKoro
noHflThg/
KOK
(HO3HOr.teHZe
yronoBHoro
cyAonpoh3BoAc-
rBo
B
yronoBHo-npoqeccyonbHoM
3oKoHoAorenbcTBe),
no
MHeHh|o
oT.qenbHbtx
oBTopoB,
oXBoTblBofou]hx efo
KoK
uenb
h
3oAorrh
yronoBHoro
cyAonpoh3BoAcTBo, npeAcroB-
nrercq
6onee
qeM
yAorrHbrM,
coorBercrByroqee nepexoA-
HoMy
rhny
yronoBHoro
npoqecco.
K
rorray xe, no MHeHZp
M.A.
TxoryuhHoBo,
(B
HoBoM
yronoBHo-npol{eccyonb-
HOM
30KOHOAOTenbCTBe
(Uenb)
14
(3OAOqh)
OTOXAeCTBfle-
Hbl
h He
oTnhLlotoTcn
no
coAepxoHvlat
Hot no
ero
MHeHtto,
Korerophn
(qenbD
3Aecb HononueHo
Qrnoco+cKhM
co-
AepxoHheM
h B
pyccKoM
f3btKe
o3HoqoeT ro, K
qeMy
HqAo
crpeMHTbcF,
qro
HoAo
ocyulecrBhrb,
o
3oAoqo
-
Korero-
ph8,
zMetouon
6onee npoKrhqecKoe ynorpe6neH,,e
h
c.3-
Holroer
ro,
qro
rpe6yer
AcnonHer,tst
posperuerrn>15.
C
y,rerou
3roror
ecnh nonbrrorbcfl
npooHonhshpoBorb
L\enA
U
3OAOrlh
yronoBHoro
cy.qonpoh3BoAcTBo B KoHreKc-
Te
ero Ho3HoqeHhF/
cToHoBhTcfi
ogeBhAHbtM/
r.tTo
3OKOHO-
AOTenb
onpeAenneT
ABe
Llenh,
ABo
ocHoBHbtx HonpoBneHhg
yronoBHofo
cyAonpoh3BoAcrBo
AnR
op!-oHoB, ocyqecr-
Bnfl loulHX
yronoBHoe
cyAon
poh3BoAcTBo:
1)
:oulary npoB h
30KoHHbrx hHrepecoB
nhq h
oprq-
uuso1uir,
norepneBlxhx
or
npecrynneHNi
(n.
I
q.
I
cr. 6
Yr-rK
PO);
2)
sou1Nry nH{.rHocrh
or He3oKoHHoro N
Heo6ocHoBoH-
Horo
o6ahHeHhF,
ccyxAeHhfl,
orpoH14qeHHe
ee npoB h cBo-
6on
(n.
2
q.
I
cr. 6 YnK PO).
B n. I
.1.
I
cr. 6
ynK
PO Poccuircroil
Oe.qepoqhh
c$opuyn rapoBoHo
nphophrerHoe
Uen
b
yronoBHofo
cyAo-
npoH3BoAcrBo
-
3OU,lhTO npOB h
3OKOHHb|X
hHrepeCOB
nhLl h
oproHhzotluit, norepneBtrlhx
or
npecryn neaui'r.
3ou-{xro npoB
14 30KoHHbrx HHTepecoB
nhLl h
oproHh3o-
qr,ri,
norepneBluhx
or npecrynneHMit,
o6ecnequBoer
pe-
onh3or.thlo nonoxexri
cr.
52
Koucrraryqrara Poccuhcroit
Oeaepo'lrr,
ropoHrhpyrou.{ei
oxpoHy npoB norepneB-
rlhx
or
npecrynneHhil
h
o6ecneqeHhe
hM
Aocryno
K
npoBocyAhlo.
Ho a yronoaro-npoueccyonbHoM
30KoHe oKqeHr cge-
noH ToKXe
h Ho
3oqhTe nhqHocTt4
oT He3oKoHHOfO h He-
o6ocHoeoHHoro
o6elxeHhr,
ocyxAeHhfl, orpoHhveHhc
ee npoB rz
ceo6o4,
rlTo
RBnqercn
He MeHee
BoxHoi
qenbo
yfonoBHo-npoqeccyonbHoi
AeqrenuHocrH.
Hogxo,renhe
yronoBHo-npoqeccyonbHoi geRrenuxocrh
He Moxer
Ao-
crhrorbcn TorAo, KorAo
hMeer Mecro Heo6ocHoBoHHoe H
He3OKOHHOe
OfpOHl4eeHhe Hnh Hopyt.ueHhe KoHcrhryqh-
oHHbrx npoB
h
cBo6oA
rpoxAoH.
B
coorsercrBt'l
c
q.
2 ct. 6 YIK Poco.ricroi Oe-
AepoLlHh
yronoBHoe
npecneAoBoHhe
h
Ho3HoLleHhe
Bh-
HOBHbTM
CnpOBeAnhBOrO
HOKO3OHr,rel
O TOKXe OTKO3
Or
yfonoBHoro
npecneAoBoHhn
HeBhHoBHbrx/
ocBo6oxpeHr4e
or
orBercrBeHHocru u
peo6unutor{hh
He rBnfltorcc
qennMh
-yronogHsrfinPoI{Ecc
vronoBHoro
cvAonpoh3Bo6crBo
KoK
roKoBoro'
OHN
nnrus
oru"ro
ro,
o6ulei
n
po B03o
u-lurHoi
qen
r'l
cyAon
poh3BoAc-
rBo,
T.e.
coorBercrBytor
ei,
po6ororor
Ho
Hee/
o 3Hotlhrf
qBrerorcfl
3oAoqoMh
cropoH
o6ehHeHhq
t1 30ulhrbl
nph
py-
roeoAqulei
ponN
cYAol6.
^
/ \!nv
IpNrorou
noAxoAef
hcxoAfl
H3
cMblcno
q
l
cr'
o
vl
lN
PQ
ra'znsrx
HopM/
3oKpenneHHblx
B
yrofloBHo-npoqeccy-
onbHOM
30KOHe,
K 3OAOtlOM
yrofioBHOro
cyAonpoh3BoAc-
rBo
orHoctrcn:
yronoeioe.
npecneAoBoHhe
BhHoBHblx;
BbrFBneHtle
h
ycrpoHeHhe
o6croqrenucro'
cnoco6crBoBoB-
urhx
coBepureHhto
npecrynneHhR;
Bo3MeuleHhe
yutep6o'
npzrlhHeHHOro
npecrynneHheM;
HO3HOqeHHe
BhHoBHblM
cnpoBe,qnHBOro
HoKo3oHt4R;
OrKO3
OT
yronoBHOro
npecne-
AoBoHr,rr
HeBhHoBHblx;
oceo6oxgeHhe
HeBhHo-BHblx
or
Ho-
;;;;;;;;
peo6,,n,arou,aq
KqxAoro,
<ro,ueo6ocuoBoHHo
noABeprce
yrofl oBHoMy
npecfl
eAoBoHhro
"'
Bce
poco,torpeHHble
HoMtz
Bbltrle
noAxoAbl
K
noH'4Mo-
rr,1re
qenh
yfonoBHoro
cyAonpoh3BoAcrBo
He
uoryr
6utru
6eccnopnurt'lil,
ToK
KoK
KoreropHh:
uenb,
3qAotlo'
H03Hoqe-
uue
u,6onee
roro,
cnoco6bl
h cpeAcrBo
hx ocyu'l'ecrBneHi'1e
npe.qcroBntlor
noHRrhF
oAHoro
nopFAKO
r
esorauoo6ycnoa-
n"""i.
npr
3roM
Hh
Llenb,
H14 3oAoLlh
yronoBHoro
cyAonpo-
T43BOACTBO
Mbl
He
MoxeM
HO3BOTb
ocHoBononofoloulhMh
vIteeMrl
tpyKoBoAeulhMh
HOqonoMtl
yronoBHoro
cyAonpoh3-
uoAarao'r'a
rroi
ro'lrh
3peHhq
nph3HoHtle
roxAecrBo
qenH
14 3OAOtl
HO3HOLleHhlo
yronoBHOro
cyAonpoh3BOACrBO
npeA-
cloBnRerctcnopHblM,TOKKOKHO3HOLleHheo'qHOBpeMeHHo
e BnFerce
h nphHqhnoM
yf onoBHoro
cyAon
poh3BOACrBo'
3o<oHoAorenb
HO3HoqeHhto
yronoBHoro
cyAonpo-
i43BoAcrBo
nphAoer
oco6yio
ponb,
Bo3BblLloer
ero
HoA
ApyrhMh
nphHutlnoMh/
no3TOMy
Ho3HOqeHhe
flBngercq
He
ronbKo
nphHllhnoM,
HO
h
(np/Hl-lhnoM Bcex
nphHurnoB>/
ocH
oBHblM
nphHut'l
noM
BCero
yrofl oBHOro
cyAon
poh3
BOAC-
rBO,
nocKoubKy
Bce
nphHuHnbl
yronoBHofo
cyAonpoh3-
BOACTBo
noALlr,lHeHbl
aonnouleHraro
B
Xh3Hb
l'18eh
30u-{t'1Tbl
nooB
h
3OKOHHblx
hHTepecoB,
orpoxAeHHlo
rHqHOCTh
oT
He3oKoHHoTo
ra ueo6ocsoBoHHoro
o6sNleunn'
ocyxAe-
Hhql orpoHhtteHhfl
ee
npoB
h ceo6oA'
To,
'lro
Hq3HoqeHhe
yronoBHoro
cyAonpoh3Bo,qcrBo
B
peAoKtlhh
cr'
6
YtlK
PQ
3oKoenrleHoBKoqecrBecoMocTotTenbHoronphHl-ihno'
;;;;;;;
6onoro" AocrilxeH/e,
3HoKoBo€
co6srrre
e
pocoa
icro,r,r
yrofl oBHoM
cyAonpou3BoAcrae
(Jqesu
uerro
B cBoe
BpeMt
no 3roMy
noBoAy
yKo3blBon
3'[1'
lprarouzc:
(...coBercKoe orpocneBOe
3o
KOHOAorenbcrBor
no
h3Becr-
HbtM
nphLlHHOM/
He
yAengro
3HOqhrenbHOro
BHI'1MOHhfl
npo-
BOBbIM
npkHLl/noM/
He
BblAenflno
hx
B
OTAenbHbie
cToTbH-
nphHq/nbl,
croponocb
3OMOCKt4poBoTb
hx'
pocTBophTb
B
MOCCe
Apyrhx
BropocreneHHblx
14
rperbecreneHHblx
npoBo-
u r,*
"op*.
Toron
topl,rgraKo-rexH
hqecKOr
KoHcrpyKl-Ihl2:l
MOTHBHO-npoBoBblx
qKTOB,
BKyne
c
orKpoBeHHO
npeHeope-
xhrenbHblM
OTHOUeHheM
K
npoBy,
nphBoAt1
no
K
BOnhpu{hM
HopyueHhqM
npoB
h ceo6oA
qenoBeKot
K
H14BenhpoBoHhro
o6u-lero
cMblcno,
coqraonssoi
3HoqilMocrx
npoBo)l
8'
.[,oxe
npn
ru{orenbHoM
oHonx3e
c
roqKh
3peHfin
rpe-
6osourarZ,
KoropblM AonxHbl
orBeqorb
nphHL{hnbl
npoeof
B
TOM
qt4cne
yronoBHo-npoqeccyonbHOro
npoBo'
Ho3HOqe-
H he
yrono
BH o
ro cyAon
pou3
B
oAcrBo
o61c1o.e1
t-Yi^:.::
o6xograusrur
cuofictton"''
OHo
ngnqerct
pyKoBoAnqeh
H
oarotononotolou{efi
ugeeh,
hcxoAHblM
HoqonoM'
nexo-
ruHM
B ocHoBe
oproHh3oqztv
A
AenrenbHocrt4
Bcei
yronoB-
Ho-nPoqeccYonuHoi
cHcreMbt'
lazetgnxoaH'91"
flxreporypo
i
Mo.6innoexep
I
o.
o
ropournnx
nHrepeco'
nrLrtrocth
H npo-
Bocyar'e
/
I
Coa.
rocyA
npoBo
l
y/4'
Ns
o'
2.
B;;Ar#
rl
M.
Te'raeHqnu
n
npo6neubr
po3Bhriln
pcco4r4c-
Koro
yronoBHoro
npoqecco
//
f'lpo6neuu
yronoBHoro
cyAo-
npoi43BoAcrBo
o .u"'J
p"on"ou"
O"o"Blilloil
ueneBoi
noorooMMbt
nPoeu,l,J
&o"A*o;
chcreMbr
Poccrra
so
2007-
2bl
l'
ro,qoro.
Troruesu,2008,
3.
3oxrqxri
B.V.Vlcrvtuor/
cpeAcrBo
ee
ycroHoBneHhq
e YflK
PO:
re-
operhKo-npoBo
"on
o on):o
ff
focyAopcrao
il
npoBo'
2005'
No
6'
4.
.[o<osb|Bo'Hhe
B
yronoBHoM
npouecce:
-TpoAhut4u
,1
coBpeMeH-
Hocru/noApeA
BA
Bnocrxruo
M'zuuu'
S.
n".t"ir*o
O.B.
ytono""o-npoqeccyonbHoe
no3HoHhe
t'{ ero
ponb
B
ycroHoB
nelvtl
vcr
vl.;t
no
Aeny
f f
I ocy
popct
ao
i4
npo
Bo'
2003.
Ns
4.
6.
io"rn
B.T.
flpr'ruqr'rnul
oreqefiBeHHofo
yronoBHofo
npouecco
H. Hoeropos,
2007.
z.
Cou"t.*r;
yionoa"srrT
npoqecc
f
noA
pea'
'[
C
Kopeeo
M
'
I 968.
S.Tor"rraHB.T.flolgrraeqenhcoBeTcKoroyrolloBHoronpoqecco//
flooeoaeaeu!4e.
1969.
Ns
4
f.
il;*rr;
B.C.
.[oro:orenbcrBo
B
poco'ricror'a
yror]oBHoM
noouecce:
noHerhe,
.v*noit",
xnoccr$rroqrr'
EroreprH6ypr'
2X02.
10.
Po:rax
H.H.
Yronoexoe
cyAonpoh3Boncreo
Cfl6
'
l9l4'
ii.
I'a^.;".".*o,
h.E.
tien',
Sy"*u",1
npHHuhnbr
pocct'ricxoro
VronoBttoro
cyAonpor3Boqcr:o
M,
2UUJ'
t Z. Ooi.unnr"
O
H. O6u4z
e
npo6nerust
npoLieccyonbHoro
AoKo3br-
soFr/c.
Ko:ous,
1976.
I3
M;;;";t B.iO
.u,ocroeepHocrb
Aorio3oren'cas
vL'4x
3rloeeHhe
npr
nocroHoBneHhH
np,{roBopo
UpeHoypr"zuuo
14.
ilo*yrrnos
M.A.
PeonNsourq
nphHuhnoB
yronoBHoro
cyAo-
npot
3BOACTBO
B
yroroBHO-npoLleccyort"Hoi
genrenbHocTh
npo-
Kypolypbl
:
Ar'.c
....
A-po
ropr/A
Hoy(
Ll
'n,'
""-t-.
1 5.
i;;;;;;.
j.n.
Mu*o*,rM
rocyAoptrB-o
(teoperrro-npoBodoh
ocnext)
:
a/cc.
..
A-po
rop/A
HoyK
Ll
lo
'
luuu
I
Cru:
Moroarnoarep
9.O.
O
ropoHrhflx
l",t.ep,"T"
nfiqHoci'4
h
;;;;;;' /ICo'a.rocvA
npoBo
l974
No
6
C
100-102
,
C".,
B;;;pnHo
I
M.
TeH,qeHunn
H.npo6ner"rut
po3Bhrr'1e
lroc-
ctlilcKoro
yTorloBHofo
npoqecco
f f
ltpo6neuat
I:"::t"'::"
yAonpo'l3BoAcrBo
B
^cBere
peonx3ollh14
Qegeponsxon
qe-
neaoi
nporpoMMH
(r03BXrhe
9ya161o;
chcreMbl
Pocctzr
Ho
2OO7-201]
ronut>.
TroueHu,
2008'C
7
3
3oxuurri
B.l4'Vlctnrtoh
cpeAcl
Bo
ee
ycroHoBneHhq
a
YI-IK
P@:
reooer!-'rKo-nposoeoi
oHonh3
/ /
| ocylopcreo
ra
npoao
2005'
Ns
6.
C.
67.
o
Iloroaureouhe
B
yfo|oBHoM
npoLlecce:
]P:A2U\i
h
coBpeMeH-
;;;i;;;;s
'BA
B"o"*'uo
M
'
2ooo
C
l43'
t
C".,
tiuuu"n*o
O.B'
Yronoeuo-npolieccyonbHo.e
no3HoHhe
t.t
ero oonb
B
ycroHoBneHhA
vcrv'At't
no
Aeny
//
locyaopcreo
I
npoao.
2003.
Ns
4 C
68'
"
c*.,
io"rn
B.T.
[lpraHrlranur
oreqecrBeHHoro
yronoBHofo
npo-
u"..o.
l-l
Hoeropop,
2007
'
C
53',
n -
7
Coaercrri
yronoaHsti
npoqecc
/
noA
peA'
g
-'
Kopeao
M''
i12
1968.
C.
12.
Tor.az"
B.T.
noHcr!4e
qen!'
coBercKoro
yroroBHoro
npouecco
//
flpo"ou"n"*r".
1969'
Ns
4'C'74'
'il;;r;
B.C.
,D,oro:orenbcrBo
B
poccricrou
yronoBHoM
noouecce:
noHfl
The,
cyulHocrb,
xnoccr$rrourr'
Erorepr'rH6ypr'
Ann4 - rn
zvvz,
v.
Jw.
-A/ 1^r 1 a Q'7
PoghH
H.H.
YronoeFtoe
cyaonpoh3BoAcrBo'
Ll
lo
'
l7
r{'
u-'
u/
b"".'
fulr*o;n"tcron
h.6.'
UenN, QyHrqra.r
1lPf
",1'1"1
pocchhc-
Koro
vtonoBHoro
cyAonpoh3BoAcrBo'
M
'
ZUUJ'
\-'
r/
'
M;;Jffi
;;.;
ra.ri]
u,jnr, QvHrrlran
r'r npraHqrnst
poccricroro
vronoBHolo
cyAonpoh3BOACTBo'
M'
luuJ'
u
{ r'
6;;;";;,it.'H.
o6urue
npo6ne^au
npoueccyonbHoro
AoKo3br-
"o"rr.
Ko.ort,
197
6.
C.
28'
ilil;;;;
8"d.,flocroaepHocrb
AoKo3orenbcr'^t1.
hx
3HoqeH
he
npH
nocroHoBn""r,
np,'o'opo'
b
pen6ypr'
200-6'-C'
I 83
;;;;;;;;
M.A.
Peonr.soqlae
nprHqhno'
vronoBHoro
cYAo-
thliTi*::TT.':ilr*",'::eft?:id63:"t:ff
:rolo".
Cr'l.:Tor'a
xe.C.62
l1
t6
AOqeHr
xso
eplPbt
yJonoaHoro
nPoqeccs
u
Kpnnu*cltrnernKu
Kaggncxoro
tocyAo,Pcraerrofo
Y
HnB
eP Gntetc,
"<|giHAUA(,tloPuArqec'(ux
Hay
x
17
Cm:
Toa,r
xe.
C.
62.
'r
iprro-*ra'5.n.
M"ro"r.
,,^ rocvaopcTao
(reoperrro-npoBoBo14
ocneKrl
:AHcc
...
a-po
op',q'
*oy*'
Cne''
2000'
C'
55'
E