
1164 CHAPTER 22 Carbohydrates
SUGAR SUBSTITUTES
The four major sugar substitutes vary widely in structure,
but all four are united by a single thread: Saccharin, cycla-
mate, aspartame, and sucralose were found not by a directed
search but by accident. Indeed, each of these four was dis-
covered when a chemist tasted a compound made for other
purposes. In fact, cyclamates were discovered because a ciga-
rette smoked in the lab tasted sweet. This observation may
seem like courting disaster to you—deliberately ingesting an
unknown laboratory chemical, not to mention smoking in a
chemistry lab—but it was quite common in the old days.
Even as recently as the 1960s it was normal to smell—
closely and carefully—just about everything one made. How
many chemists destroyed their sense of smell or succumbed
to the odor because of this practice, we will never know.
Now the laboratory is better ventilated and we gingerly waft
the fumes from a flask if we must test for an odor.
After 100 years of research and debate concerning sac-
charin (discovered in 1879), the consensus is that no ill
health effects are associated with moderate consumption.
Although cyclamate (discovered in 1937) is banned in the
United States, there is no evidence implicating it as a health
hazard according to the Food and Drug Administration
(FDA). Aspartame (discovered in 1965) may be the single
most studied food additive. It has been cleared for use,
except for phenylketonurics. People with this disease must
avoid phenylalanine, which is formed from the hydrolysis of
aspartame. Aspartame also releases methanol when heated,
but only extremely small amounts are produced. Sucralose
(discovered in 1976) has cleared all toxicology tests.
Although halogenated alkanes are known carcinogens, the
chlorinated sucralose is not lipophilic enough to be retained
in the body.
6
Lactose is found in milk and other dairy products, so it is often called milk sugar. Disaccharides such as lactose
need to be cleaved to monosaccharides in order to be absorbed into the bloodstream.The acetal bond in lactose is
cleaved by the enzyme lactase. Many adults are lactose intolerant because their bodies don’t make lactase.For such
individuals, consumed lactose doesn’t get absorbed into the bloodstream and the result is abdominal discomfort.
This hydrolysis liberates only the OH groups that in ()-lactose were tied up in
acetals; it leaves simple ether groups unchanged.It is the OH at C(4) of glucose that
is unmethylated, telling us that this is the glucose position con-
nected to galactose in the lactose molecule.
To determine whether the ()-lactose glycoside linkage is made
as the α or β anomer we turn to enzymes such as lactase
6
that have
evolved to cleave only β-glycosidic bonds,and to which α-linked dis-
accharides are inert. ()-Lactose is cleaved by lactase and therefore
must be β-linked.
1
H NMR spectroscopy can also be used to iden-
tify whether a disaccharide is linked as the α or β anomer.The hydro-
gen on the anomeric carbon is more deshielded than any of the other
hydrogens,and the C(1) equatorial hydrogen (δ 5.2 ppm) is further
downfield than the C(1) axial hydrogen (δ 4.6 ppm). Figure 22.64
shows the final three-dimensional representation of ()-lactose.
'
'
(+)-Lactose β linkage
HO
OH
O
O
OH
HO
HO
OH
O
OH
OH
WEB 3D
4
6
5
3
1
2
4
6
5
3
1
2
D-Galactose D-Glucose
FIGURE 22.64 The structure of the disaccharide
()-lactose.The monosaccharides
D-galactose and
D-glucose are joined by a β-glycosidic linkage between
C(1) of galactose and C(4) of glucose.
Cyclamate Aspartame
O
H
N
S
O
O
O
Saccharin Sucralose
O
O
NH
S
O
O
N
H
HOOC
NH
2
–
CH
2
OH
CH
2
Cl
CH
2
Cl
OCH
3
Ph
HO
HO
O
OH
OH
O
Cl
O