Лебедев В.В. Математическое моделирование социально-экономических процессов
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
•
I
I
B.n.JIEEE,lJ.E
.A .EMATWIECKOE
MO~EJIIIPOBAHHE
COUHAJIhHO-
3KOHOMWlECKlIX
TIPOUECCOB
M3,UaTeJIbCTBO
«H30fPACI>;.>
66K
16.22.9
JIll
11
II
JIe6CJ(CR
B.B.
MaTCManl'lCcKoC MO.uCJlHpOOarme cO/\I1a.J'bIlO-JKOIIOMI1_
qeCKl-lX
npo/leccon.
M.:
H301
pact>,
1997.
224
c.
B
KIIKre
113J11UllJ()'TCII
60JOUblC
MO,uCJIU
MIfKPO-
If
MaKp03KOIIO·
MKKK, 3
TlIIOKC
npKMcpb/
IICrrO
Jlb30nll
lflfU
MC'l'O,ua
6Konorlf'IecKoll
al/MOrKlf
Jl}/II
aliBI/IIl0
COUIUUJl,IfO-~)KO"OMIf'lecKKx
npOucccoll.
Oco60c
IIHKMUIlIfC )'.llClleHo
o6cYJI()~e1l1f10
KJlJO'IOIJI,IX
rllrroTc3,
J
IC)I{O
-
UlIlX II
ocrrone
paccMUTpKJlaOMI,lx
MOAMell,
KX
allWllf1Y
C TO'IKK 3rC·
Hill!
IlJIlISIlIlIlI
o6paTllbJx
clll/Jell
110
,uIfIlUMIfKY
npOI\ccca
II
YCTO!!'IIl-
IlOCTI. paUJlOneCliblX
pewel,"!!
.lI.n~~lIroKoro
KPyra
'1IiTaTCne!!, IlIlTCpecYJOU\IlXCII
nonpoc3MII
MOIICIJ7Cnalfllll
COUliunblfO :.lKOIIOMIl'ICCKIIX
IIpOI~eCCOIJ.
~l
/;LV
. 5 t
1-
9
;A,
,~
'/
'
113aallue
ocyu{ecm(Jllel/o
npu
noooef/:JIC/Ce
POCCUilCK020
IpOl/aa
IjJYl/alJ.Mellm(JJlbI//,/X
IICClleOOIJal/uil
no
npoe/Cmy
.M
96-06·
87082
ISBN 5-87113-055-0 ,
C
11
n Jle6e/lcll,
1997
C
H1JJljlelll.crllo
.H10f'l'AtJ)>>, 1997
IIp.,)UCAOWU.
ll
••
d.llur
o I'JIAIJJI
1<:11
J1
E
'fACTI> f.
Moml!MOmU'IUKUe
MlJllr..,fu
MUltp,r""Jllo,"""u
J"ADt1tl
I.
MOOCA"
npcl)~Q3ttm'u"
mtlflUplltI
I I
KOlllfNIltJYfI/lIIIIlI"
Afm},'lJf,
mJJI(mpmJYICmmlOiJ
flmpM'"
1/
uu}cPJIC"" npollliuuJrmtltJ
...
1
.2.
(/)YIII<ljflH
flJlPOAIJJI(n//liH
/ ,J.
Illlll/mllt!
1If1/1f)ltJO
IIlJ
npl~()nfJ'lIIuM"m",,',rKY1f1
(JK,,,,u,,w~m',
II
KPlItlOH
J/m/J(/Jf'ptJ
lirana 2.
MotJr"upolfa"u~
nt},,~(JelluH
nomp,(Jum'AJI
2.
1 t1>YIIK/(UII
nOAI''JIIOrltJlI
2.2.
MoiJtAt;
nntWfJi'IIIIJI
1I0mp,.(iumI!JlR
2.J. Cuoiicntll(l f/JYIIJC/(/JU cnporfJ
2.4
JIOIwcmutwCKQJI Kpunml
2.5.
M()(Jr.JII,
P"flIJII
i'paflUmU14IJOUlIOH
UlianUlIl»
IIJ111
fmpl'f1i'JI('IIUII
IIptr}!lOI/",,."UIJ
IItJmpl'fiumt'JJN
IAottu
J.
Mm}t'AupOtlUllut!
tJUIiUMUKU
pWII"14HWX
I4t'H
J. 1
""Itf)'IIIOI'
palll/OIlCrlll'
).2,
J1l1ymulloo(jpfl'lIIflH
MO(1f~JIII
C
IfllJfur}blHtIllUt'M
("po('u
1.
J
f/(lymwUJo6pfJ
'IJI(l)l
Mooenb
r '
Wntl'ltJ,,jHulIllrM
npt'IJnflWtfHUJI
J. 4 Ilaymllllou(Jpo'II/l"",
AfO(JI'AIl
r
()IJY'(f!IItU-M
.I.
5
11t'/lIllU'lJllflJl
Awr)t,.Ju,
"Ulmmlll4U11
I(t'lt
Iila"u 4. Madril"
061#,~IIJ
pUllllOtlt't!MH
"I
Ilpml
'1tItH)fm'U-IIIIaH
f/JYIIJCIiUN
KufitirhllYlJlII('n
42
MIJI)""h
tluyxnpUOYKtt/{'U"U
,1mI'M"'
.
U'·'W
II·,YHIUj'U
(hili
IIlU)t)
(UPfllltll/Plllnllx
pecypC'fJH
(Mudl'JJI.
2)(2)
•
4 J
(J(jll",,"
PfltlIWflt'CIlt'
"JKOIWMIUCU
(;"uUtJC'urmWlmlJ/
(/III)"""
}K2K})
4.4
)(tJllflAIIIIIt'C1WJI
AUU)I'JII,
ptJIIIW
Otty:<
fIIomJIJfJtl
45
.
IIptJAWIlt'1If1l'
MmJt'lIti
2
...
1)(2
'}
/IN
(llIIIIIU
'
IU
tllltmll,.u
mopltulJlU
r"utlu
:1.
lJIfUHIIU(f
MlJllOntJAU'IUU,UII
110
'4lfHW
U
nJI~f}AUJi(tHII~
mUl/upu
• •
.5.1
'/U(1mfJJt
MOJUUHJJIUH
5
2.
l(mwttlJII
(}ur"pIlAIJIII(J'~UJl
5, I
MmWIHl
J
III(,fml''''f
'KIIH
f((m"yp"fII~III'
(AItUJI'IIII tJYIJ/,fJ/IlUl)
}1
14
28
32
J/J
3'
1
42
44
$/
58
61
61
M
6/1
71
/10
N7
88
91
W
10J
107
III
III
liN
/JI
T_
"
~""'DlI'
a
........
"".,.,
__
.......
_01
---
--
--
--
__
.ex;:.-...
,....%5I>4l
.......
~
__
-
JI*A
~_
;10
.....
-- - --
----
--
--
~_
.Jfo,iea _
--.
----
----
.....
-
...
L»;a
,
aiJm&
__
_
?
IP
""'
__
..
.,-
......
,.
c-
L
"1
..
ije
...
~]
__
,.
0;
1
•••
u.
D-
i ..oe..
------
__
c - ........
'"'0
.....
---
-
c-
1.
..l7""-"'=",
"'A
..
""''''iAUiE
....
_
..
oia
.........
____________
_
7]
WHyr-
err?'
sm
7
wzaax
lIP'
iIid'.
c-
Jt.
&_rii_
jeww--.ue
K 1
..
1 ;,..".
....
""""'
......
~
,..,.
,.,...
c
qfjgrwr
-,., _____ _
1
1
;
!~::::::::
ma.
B!
r
-."....
a...:
.WUIJlLl
tw.r=rnr
3.
"
...
IID:
a
_III)JJ)
....
*"'*'"
1ioJ.t\or
_____
_
lfoS
Mam5epEo.J[qo
__
_
Vcs"
--------------
----------
'"-.-.-,,...
- -
----
It2
1
1 f
189
J
191
1'Ti
1
1111
liB
Ni
11.
115
l1i
1:11
2'E
,
«RI
lie
o}lba.-
60"
'ft,
'I£J<
"''''''.::0
__
IIPEJUiC
j
IOBlIE
B
HaCIOJUll~
apeWlI
~
lIO!fC:lBlJOi'iIfK
-=e
__
....
-
'IHBCC
~
B
o6;iacn,
COIIHa..ThaO--~
BZJIL
H ;]!C.1IO
:Eecb
CO]!Ce1ol
He
B
Wli,
'flO
~q
liEalIC:lCl
CIpI>-
rocIK
llIDI
BCS!J[oIi
lJ3iDl..
Bawo·alNCib
IIEIiO.Jh3OB2!D
lIGlicw:m
=-
CKoro
loW.lCliBpOD2HiIll
CBlDilHa
C
C}i!if£tiI033
H
HCOi
jCluQqajg,D
-rm--
~
KOiOpYC
laf'3JiepB3)"'Ui
.IIBOOIe
amaa~?CiJ&i...u:.
'C
JIpO.nc:ocH.. B
mm:6o."1YIIcA
CICIKH..H
f'
2P8++"-
0'
..
•
Mica
K
Ai
......
JCeli
me
~eaate
MCI1l.JH
aCIMdHO
~Hji"IUI.
C
3Ha'leHHe
y.n~UIII'JOR?1Jf11'51
"I2X
~
prrl'CWRHB4
OIlIP_c:reJC~
ell
-rew,
'ItO
Mo:re.Th
!JPe-1~
coiioA:
~
IIIICIP'JI«HJ".
opuetllHPO!!:!HHJ.rii
u:a
aHa.lJD
1l3)'"
"¥HT
iipO!ltiXXI3 • JIX
I1POl1EIIJlKIPI>-
BaHRC_ HMetmo
JI«Jro
•
Hl!IIpID6Cp.
B
COspev!HH!B
..
,peal[
IJO
3KO-
H6llH'iecJWA
TeOpHH
(
!a
'I-
OmflOlWHl";!·
• • •
~3x.OHOMDC")
8al'\I
IJ C
CO.l~
Hll=
eTO.l
~u::xnru
HaJO
CklDalb,
'ItO
CIIX
IlDp
3JO'I
IlC1JQ.'U030BaIlCII B
CCICCUlfHHYX
IDJ
IDJXD
H _ • fi03'1'OW}I' a
COOlBEiC
.....
c
.wro
BHcmero
061''''&808,
B
roa:mr-
11)'301!
mo.mr
talCIe
H
I»lJC
-
~::::::~eCleCi.i
•
HU"'. B
mrnpo
\I3)"t!JliiUi
IIpID«PY
~
Ba:HHlI
II
,
DOODI
•
i'iItolIonIJI..
C:
oyer,
0 •
IDe1b
B ,
'llO
JalH'Iu::xnru
liIO,lempollaJ!D
DpB
3EUIDe
6
llpeaUC/108Ue
-
nnr"nf
D~rpa
","nheIPa MCCTIiOCTII n
Til
.
),
TO
B COl1.HlUIbHO 3
y~~'"
~
•
y-'
-
KOHO_
MH'ICCKOit
o6./Iacnl
'lJICIIO IPaKTOPOB,
RIlHRJOJ..l.{HX
Ha
OTKiIOHeHne
Te
1lI'ICCKID. BbIBOllOB
OT
peanbHOCTII,
He
TOJIbKO
cmID1KOM
Be.nJ.fK
°Pe_
.h
IT
0,
lio
MHome
HJ HIIX B
rtplfHlllme
Hc'!'opMamf3yeMbl.
03TOMy,
rOBOPIi 0
rrpei1c,1ax
rtpHMeIDlXfOCTIf
MeW"'
Ua.'reMlI:nfllecKor.{)
-MOIlCJIllpo8aJ.uu!
I npu 060cHOB3HIDI ynpaBnCHQeCJ(I!X pCl.I.IeHlfit.
BCrrOMIDIM
e.nOBa
T.
Ca_
ani
CK333Rlllero
06
HCCllelloaamrn
orrcp8I1.Hi.t,
'ITO
3TO HCKyCCTBo
•
lIa-
BaTb
rrno:rnc
OTBeThi
Ha
re
npa.t<Tlf'leCKHe
BonpocbI,
Ha
KOTOpble
ll
a
lOTcl!
ewe
601Iec rrnoXHC
OTBCTbl
IlpyrnMH
cnOC06aMH
.
nOll'lCpKHCM,'ITO He06xoilHMOCTb OCBOeHHR 3KOHOMHCTaMH H Me-
HClIlICCPaMH
MareMaTH'IeCKoro MOIle.ID!POBaHHR COl.\HaJIbHO-3KOHOMH_
'ICCKHX
npoucccOB
KaK
MCTO,lIa
aHaJIlf3a
He
OrpaHJfllllilaeTCIi
'IHCTQ
rtpaKlWlCCKHMH
norpc6HOCTlIMll:
RIlallCHHC
3THM
MCTOIlOM cnOC06CTBy_
eT
4JopMHPOBaHHlO He.nIDfCitHOro
MbIwnCHHJI,
CHHCPreTINCCKoro
nOll-
xO.!Ia
K nOHHMaIDfJO rtpHHIIHIIOB
PaJBHnflI.
TaKHM
06PaJOM,
nOM
HMo
peWCHHlI
cyry60
npa.t<Tlf'lCCKHX 3a1la'l HCnOJfbJOBaIDlC
3TOro
MCTO,lIa
HMCeT
6onbinoe
MHPOB033PCH'lCCKOC 3Ha'lCHHC.
K
coxancIDfJO,
60Jfbwal!
'IaCTb JfHTCpaTYPbI
no
MOlleJrnposaHIDQ
COUHaJIbHO-3KOHOMH'leCKHX npOUCCCOB ]fJ.f6o ncpCYCJfO)I(HCHa <P0pMa-
JIH30BaHHbIMJI
~H3lIl.I.IHhIMH"
nOCTpoeHHJIMH, Tpc6YJOlI.IHMH
OT
'UlTaTe.nll
DOCTaTO'IlfO
my60Koi.t
MareMarn'leCKoi.t
nOArOTOBKH,
JfH60
'Ipe3McpHo
ynpomCHa
(B
JroM
CJJY'Iae
H3JlOlKCHHe MO,llcnci.t,
KaK
npaBHnO,
conpo-
BOlKlIaeTCli rpaIPHKaMH,
Ha
KOTOPbIX
paccMaTpHBalOTCli
.1IHl.IIb
pasHOBCC-
IWC
peWCHHlI). TaKOC nonOlKCHHC nOpOlK,llacT y
MHornx
'UlTaTe.nC~
secbNa nosepXHOCTIfoe npC,lICTasneHHC 0 MCTO,llC
MareMaTIfllCCKOrO
MO-
DCJfHPOBaHHll H Bhlpa6aThlBaeT
Y HHX
CTOl.tKOC
CKCIITIflICCKOC OTIfOWC-
IDfC
K
cro
B03MOlKHOCTlIM.
Uem.1O IIpeilJfaraCMoi.t
BawcMy
BHlfM3HHlO
KH:Hm
lIBJflICTCli H3JlO-
XCIDfC H aHaJfH3 6aJOBblX MOllenci.t
MHKPO-
H
MaKP03KOHOMHKH
a TaK-
xc
HCKOTOpblX
npHMCpOB
npHMCHCHlfli
MCTO,lla
6HonoflfllecKoi.t'
aHMO-
fHH
npH
HCCllClIOBaHIDf
COUHMbHO-3KOHOMlfllCCKHX
np0l.\CCcOB.
no-
CKOJlbKY
06naCTb npHMCH
CHHR
MareMarn'lCCKHX
MCTO,llOB B COl.\MMbHO-
3KOHOM]NCCKHX
Havv
J
~ax
BeCbMa
WMpoKa
OCHOBHOC BHHMaHHC
3,lICCb
y.aenCHO
3KOH91",IIS~K
'
-~4M-MO.IlCJlllM,
-
xO'I'Opbie
--o-rpalK3rar
nnO.l.lCJlypbl
9PHHK'WP
P""",,'Q
----r
3KOHOM]N , IIIl'Il4IIaUHIO Jl.lO,llei.t H T. ,lI. - MO,llenH
reXHHKO-
CCKOro ypOBHlI Hrp3JOT
BcnOMorarenbHvtn
ponb
3ro
oTpaJKC-
HO
B HaJBaHl4H T K " J .- •
'IaJOwciI
.ac
'"
3KOHOMHKa
lIMlieTCli
COl.\HaJIbHOl.t
HaYKoi.t,
H3Y-
"'"'"
(3
M lITe.nbHOCTb nJOlIci.t, lKHByWHX B
opraHH30BaHHbIX
KonnCKTH-
.....
. MCHBO).
KHHra
HanHcaHa Ha
oc
I
lOIn",
KOTOPhlli
aBTO
HOBe
cncUKypca
'
MaTCMaTIl'leCKal!
3KOHO-
HlIlI
IiMCHH
Cepro
0 p 'IHTaJI B
rOCYllapCTBeHHoA
aKa,lICMlIH
ynpallJl
c
-
TIl
HaWlOHaJIbHoi.t
/:OIDfKHi13e
B
1990-1996
IT. \:1Y,lICHTaM
HHCTlITY-
MCHCJlXNCHTa 0 HpoBOi.t 3KOHOMHKII H
HHCTInyra
Ij>HHaHcoBoro
• Ha
COCTOIIT
H3 BBe,llCHHR H TpCX
'Iacrei.t.
npeaUC/106Ue
7
Bo
BBellCHHH
llaH
KpaTKHil
0630p
OCHOBHblX
np06ncM,
B03HH-
KaJOUlHX
nplf
HCnOJJb30BaHlfH MCTOlla MareMaTH'lCCKOrO Mo.aenHpoBaHlfli
ilJfll
aHanH3a
cOUlfanbHo-3KOHOMH'lCCKHX
npOl\cCcoB
.
B
nepBoli
'1aCTII
KHHTII
paccMaTplfBalOTCli
MOllenlf
MlIKp03KOHOMll-
'1ecKMX npou.ccCOB.
3lleCb
06CYlKlIaJOTCli MOllenb OilHonpo.aYKTOBOIi
IPHPMbI,
aHMH3
KOTOpoli n03BOJ\HJI BhlBeCTII
ypasHcHHc
IPYHKIDUI
rrpeilJfOlKCHlflI; MOIle.nH rrOTpe6nCHHlI, n03BOnllJOl.I.IHC
nony'lHTb
ypasHC-
HHC
1j>}'HKl(HH
cnpoca;
PaJJfM'IHhlC sapHaHThl
nayrnHoo6paJHoli
MO.aenH
H MO,lle.nH
o6mero
pasHoBeCHR, KOTopble OIlHChIBalOT ,llHHaMHKY 113a-
HMOllei.tCTBHR nOKYIIaTe.nei.t H
TosaponpOH3BOilHTencli
Ha
pbIHKC.
Oco-
60e
BHlfM3HHe
B 3T0i.t '1aCTII y.acnCHO lfCe.nCIlOsaHHJO YCToli'lHBOCTII
pasHoBecHbIX
pCl.I.IeHlll! IlHHaMH'ICCKHX MOlle.ncA.
Bo
BTOpOi.t '1aCTIf 06CYlKlIaJOTCli TaKHe MaKPOOKOHOMH'lCCKHC
1040-
,lICJflI,
KaK
KnaCCHlJCCKal! MOllCJfb BJaHMoilcliCTBHlI phIHKa
pa60'lcli
CH-
JIhI,
IPHHaHCOBOro
pbIHKa
H
pbIHKa
TosaPOB,
paJiIH'lHblC
sapHaHThl
KCl.tIiCHaHCKOi.t MaKPOMOllCJfll, O,IIHOCCKTOPHal!
H .u;sYXCCKTOpHal! MOllenH
.D.OJITocpO'IHoro
nporn03HpOBaHlfll,
0606meHHal!
MOllem.
KclIHca-
<l>PHAMCHa.
311CCb,
B '1aCTIiOCTIf, nOKaJaHO, 'ITO
ynpoweIDfal!
MO.D.enb
Kcl.tIica
06nallaCT
CBOi.tCTBOM
lIHKJIH'IHOCTII, 'ITO KcitHCHaHCK.Id\ H
M0-
HeTaPHCTCKHi.t no.nxo.D.bl K OIIHCaHHJO MaKP03KOHOMH'lCCKHX npoUCCCOB
JIBJUIlOTCli npC,lICJfbHbIMH CJJY'IalIMH O.!lllOi.t H
ToA
lKC Mo.aenH BJaHMO-
BJlHJIHHJI
TOBapHoro
If
llCHClKHoro
pbIHKOB.
B TpeTbci.t 'JaCTII
KHHrlI
npHBellcHhI
IIpHMCphl
MOllencli
• .acMOH-
CTpHpYJOU\HC npHMCHCHHC
Merolla
6HonolWlccKoi.t
aHMOrHH
IIpH
aHa-
IDf3C COll,HanbHO-3KOHOMll'lCCKHX npoueCCOB.
nOKaJaHO,
HartpHMCP,
'ITO MO,llCJfb
THrra
MQllCJTH
~IIHl\CMIDI
60nce
aIleKBaTIfO OTpaJKaeT
,llHHa-
MHKy
H3MCHCHHR CTpYKTYPbI HauHOHanbHOi.t 3KOHOMHKH,
'1CM
paCCMOT-
PCHHal!
BO
BTOpoi.t '1aCTII KHHfH
MOllenb
CaMy::!JfbCoHa-XHKca,
nOCTpO-
CHHal!
Ha
OCHOse KOHl.\CIIl.\HH aKce.nepaTOpa.
60nbl.l.lHHCTBO PHCyHKOB, conpOBOlKl\aJOWHX H3JlOlKeHHC
reopCTH-
'1CCKOro
MarepHMa,
nonY'lCHO
C
3KpaHa
KOMIIblOTCpa C nOMoWbJO
OPHfHHaJIbHhlX
lleMOHCTpall,HOHHo-o6yqaJOWHX
nporpaMM.
nOMOrruo-
J..l.{HX
rnyGlKC
nOHllTb
CBOi.tCTBa
MOlleneA
.
3TH
nporpaMMbI
C03,l\a.H1>I
K.B.JIc6cllCBblM,
KOTOpbI:l\
npHHHMM
aKTHBHOC
yqaCTIfc
TaKlKe H B
pa-
60re
Ha,lI
nepBbIMH
IIlITbJO
rnasaMH.
ITPH
HaIIHCaHHH
KHHTII aBTOp CTpCMHnCli
nOKaJaTb,
'ITO
MareMa-
TH'ICCKHC MO,lle.nH e.nYlKaT
BOBCC
HC
AJflI
YKpaweHHJI
3KOHOMH'ICCKOi.t
reopHH
H
nonY'ICHHR
yGCIlHTeJIbHhIX
.D.OKaJaTe.nbCTB
O'lCBH,IIHhlX BblBO-
1l0B,
KaK
3TO
'1aCTO
6b1saeT, a lIRIllIJOTCli 0,l\HHM
1t3
cpellCTB
aHMHJa
CO-
U.HMbHO-3KOHOMH'ICCKHX
npoueccOB,
n03BOJ1l1lO1UHX
nony'llfTh
HOBYJO
HHIPopMawuo.
n03TOMY
npH
H3JIOlKCHHH MO,lle.nelt
npelKl\e
scero
no,ll-
P06HO
06cYJK,llaJOTCli KnJO'ICBblC
rnn0TC3b1,
nCJKJllUlIC B
OCHOBe
CQOTBCT-
CTBYJOUlci.t
KOHUcmyMbHOA
MOlle.nH
If
OTpaJKaJOl.I.IHe
RIlHllHlle
paJJfll'l-
HbiX
<paKTOpOB
Ha
H3MCHCHHC COCTOIIHHlI
paccMaTpHBaCMoro
npou.ccca.
•
-
• ,
Ii'
'1111
'1I1lt ,
I'
'I,
\
~~
01"'11 1
Ill'
1I\'I~Il'lt
_
I!IIII
to!
',1,
II
I1J
ru"
II
Ill'lIlNIII
r'llI(1II111
II
4"H
:UI~
~~'
HlU
"'UIIl'it
1Il"r
,',
"Mft'
I-H,'
liN
I,'>l II
'll
,It~
n~JI
I \ 'UIII
,al
l'-It'I'II"j\
3'1
'111"111\
'-Hili'
11"
I,ll'\"
1,1,
\'
,n \
.. ..
II
'
~
11'11,
~\.o.1\
\lal'\"\t,lnt
1
111111-
1(,1
'\ll~",
n,
..
\.
l
N'I(
......
dI
1
I""
1\.\1
1~II'".
H,I
1IJ"t.I~
I\l\,'
111'0(\'1(\11.
111'
-
'1\
1\ 1U1.
8~'IIR1~\lNC
It
"'1I11ft'
'1,II'\"\I,tnlll
1·
...
11~
1"'1 II
l'lt,
1I~
\l"
,0
(11;
UlC'"
t
'II"IIIIN
lit
1lt'1I"11I11 III ",11'\"'1.1
111"'11
"
TIlIl.!
qtmlft'
•
~
( "1"11
1\1
IN
"M'HO'nt~CI""1\
II'
"II
.,
~(I\It(
(
'II""IIN
'
Ill"r
1(\1
",
'1('\lt1"'Il;LHIt'l
HI
npl'l'I
«\lIII,
,
'Ii
'\Ill
1\
II
1l,\\IClUl\.\tI
111'111
11>;11'11,11"
1:"1'1'
\t('UUNt'
Il\
_
nrn
C \
"'~t
.
,tUbI
...
IlH
1m'
I
~II"I\('\.·IIN'
1'(\UCHIlit
IIIH1MIIII~(
"11\
Ill'
'II(C,·""
1111
''1M
'1'1>.
~
'(
'III'
C ''''11''111
1'\""1'1111
I'
Inl
11
*'
111'111'
HUN(
,pa
'I'\"
llfIO'(l'hI
""Slm'l(
•
...
11
~1I~.I"II'I(,
...
1t
'I,
l"~cl1
It
It \11'111 -
!II
:l1II111
n'lI>(
ILl\I 1I:1t
110
II
It
~1I1,\"lhIlO
111""1
\IOll,'l1'IIP"II,ITh
IlIlUllmlllAhlllll'
pc;
1b
alf3.l11 I IIUtI'ol"!81\1I1I II
'UO,l;\Hlllll
1 1M
Hl'\I
>tm'.Ilpc;
(\:\HIl~
nrll
npllU!lTIlI!
mr
1I\1(,H'I(' •
...
11
r
IlI~HIII'
n('l
.JaIl
'.
B
~al'11il
:111.
'IT<l I
'm
1\
II
...
'"
l';IltUOI'
1111
11.1
I'NH'"
IlJ'Q = B
"'('III(~H
I
Im'l'\"
HC
,'\lOn
n\;lMlt q.1'H"'Ultil
'nl"
'"
II
nre111
tllll~.
"K
1\'
{ b1qllO OOl'IlI'IIHItMB(1
',.
'1lrntTl"JlII
til
III
'n(
_1I11
IIlll'3
C
C,
'l1'Crrrel'll'UIl\MIt
toJle~HMIl
""'OH'\\tllKII
I'
HIC
'H'
~t'\:~,'A
nl
'taIIOR)'C. B
p~a"'ult(<<
.......
t'HO\tll'l('
"11\
al'('lm'""
('10.1'110-
1oCl\'Ice
II 1'1.
cnul
...
OR
- R
JlnHHOM
CIt
'Ia~
1'\>1
al'onpoltJ\l
\Il"l'\"JlCj\ II
no-q>e6IrI'\".,dtl
1I11
II
MeUCHII(
CI!l)lIUIlIt
H
phlH
...
e.
J{
H''''peHII(
6"U1ro..~a~H
l'l'e~1
'1011'1
KO'll~I1IM.
111>11
\lIlH 1:lIll1C.
BOO
e~aTe..'~1I1U1
"plmlK
I\.!\pI
en:
UI
110.lJ,.1~P
l(n 1l1'1Ul.U11,1.1H
Y\l~
~lIl1o<'"1'I>
B
11(06\
1t\l,....,,1 pa.l('l160ThH
...
pc
I
"M,lfeM,I1WlrcKwl
' ....
).
HOM"K
•
~
TO"
Rlue, l(al(
'1\)
6h1.10
DNl\lVlIl~1l1l
n
r"
WI
K.Iq.rJ\I'~
N po
IoOHONII
...
H.
1I
HblHe
qlrmrn:M
\13
K.Itj>CJll'r
nNellleil
~""'\"MU
1111"1
•
.II
npHlHaTe..'CU TIll( (
CT)l1tlflll\l.
0'1
~Jt\l(
C ....
lTOI'I~
til
MIlOIH'
a!icrpaJmu,(\
'TtOf'C'TK'lt'\:l\1I
oonJX
"'8
IlpenI'3LUnJI,'
llC""l'OI'N(,
1''1~b
HhlC
3l/tI1lIJl B H3c:roMLUlt( TlIOp'l( ·
...
'11"
CC""ll1lPI~,
HR
,;
k6<'tJ
l.U\
\tl
II~'""'I
tt"l
\;
tut"lttlru:~
, '\('1 H
1111
n
11.\'H' p \
lUll
fUll'
U."'Ttl
it'U
II
11'1
1I11t'I ,
t'tl1~11
It
elm'
IDI"III1"n
1\1'
"<'Hlh"1
tl"l
l!t"'"""llI"
II
111>!"
11.11'
...
11.
Ill'
1'111
111M
)
(lll"'lIr
'Ct'lI)
HI"
'I '1"Il.HUIII
13
"11'1
III "tI HI)
npHllC
:1'11
1'\"""1'
\(~ll'leC:I:"'11O
Itll'\
IlIrllllNn
lilt
,
1"I'Il~b
1
"llll
Mlli\
Tlh
H
,)
1
UIH~
'·lIollelll,l
. 1'\'
""
II
III l\.IOT
11'111
<,,,,,I
11.1
OClltl\I;IUUII
-II ' Ul,OlIllIUUI
CIlIQ~lC
IlI'II
\Illlir
""11
\
Ihllll'lIM
p.
" (
'11'1t'1I1
I""
(l\IlllI
1.11" \
HI"'II\'llIIt'
,
t'\
III
('
111""111,'
"ltp
I 1
lilli'll>,
"I"lHlI'I
1111
UU
10
IUl
II
IIHblC
cro
OTllC1lbHblC
cBolk-rBa
~''''aJOUlee
TC
.h
eTC
(~B.,elUlII).
0.,......·
).:aK
GIIc,,"a
n
bID'lO ..,OPMY KO)1I1POBa-
'\O.le..'lb
YO
HO
pJcc'larpllB3Tb
'-"Tb
'ITO MonC1lb
cOllCPlIOlT
B
ce6e
,,
'
Mo)tJIO
c..........
•
HI~
IUf4loPIoI3IlHH. •
KOTOPOC
'IeJlOBCK.
IICCJlClJ,YSI
ce.
MOlKCT
nplI-
nOTCHUllanbHoe 3HaHHe,
liJ
3TOro
CJIeJlYCT.
'ITO
np"McHcHlIC
MCTO-
06pecTIl"
(H
HMollceeB)
;mpo!IIlIIlUI6Y.l1
eT
3<\>cJ>eICTlIBHblM n11UIb
TOr-
ila
!d8TCWlITH'IeCKoro
~:~
"3a);OBHPOsaH3"
II 1'3
llHcjJopMaullSl.
KOTO-
n
a
1'01113
B IdOlle.'lII •
, 0
3TOro
HC
3HaJDI.
P
\1O
HCC.lle.lOB8TC11.I1
II
J(}I
B COUllaRbHO-3KOHOMII'ICCKIIX HaYKllX
-
. IIIIl1
ldaTCld3T11
npJUlo~e
pa3BJlTIICM caJ>loii
MaTeManlIQI,
a
ncpBblC
palBHB3.'IIICb napa'L1eI1bHO
aCn~ec)(}IX
MOllC1lci! B
06WCCTBCHHbIX
Hay-
~III~
1d3TCId"
.
o[lblTbl
n~·
1"'-
B8IDICM
cjJI13H'1CCKIIX
aHanomit
npil
1I3yqCHlIlI
Kll
cBlIJaHhi c IIcno..1b3O B
XVI'
1-)(\ 1JI
seKllX,
KOTOPblC 3aJI0lKHJDI
UHlI.'Ib/IbIX npoueCCOB
co
."
aJIl>Hoil
<j>H3l1J(}\
".
nplI
3TOM.
onllpaSlCb,
HanplIMep.
Ha
OCHO~
COUH
'OH
rpaBI!T3UIUI
p:13ml'lHblC
yqcHbic
nplIXOlIHllll
K
O.lIIH H
TOT
)l(C
JaK
•
14
coUHll.,bHbIId
MOlle..1lIloI
TaK, r
rpoUl1ii
nOJlaran,
'ITO
JIJO)111
no
= npHPOil
e
DllurelOT
apyr
K
llPyry,
a
o.CnIlHOJa
C'Il!TaJI,
'ITO
OHII
;tpyr
apyra
OTT3J!KIIBaJOT
MHome
cospeldCHHblC
no~1lI
3KOHOMIIKH TaJOKe IIMCIOT
60J1b-
WYID
HCTOplllD
HanplIMcp,
nonbITKH
onpellC1lllTb
cjJym<IIKIO DOJIC3HO-
m
H3
OCHOse Ha6.1JOllCIIIISI
33
peaKUlICII IlHIDIBI1JlYYMOB
Ha
BepoSIT-
HOCTHbIC
cH1)'3UHH
BOCXOJISIT
K CTaTbC il5epHyJIJJII (1738
r.)
0
CaHJcr-
nerep6vprclCoM
napalloKce.
B KOTOpoil
6b1J1
060cHOBaH
npKHIUlI1
"C~UlcilCli
npelle..1bHOil nO.1C3HOCTH"
(M5JJayr).
npHHlITO C'OITaTb, 'ITO MaTCldaTII'lCCKOC MOllC1lIlPOBaHliC K3K MC-
to.:! aHaTH33 ldaKpo3KOHOMJI'lCCKHX
npoucccoB
6b1J1o
BncpBble
npllMe-
HeHO
IIcA6-MCllHKOM KOpoilll JIlDllOBHKa
XV
llOKTOPOM C1>paHcya
KCH3,
Karophlll
B
1758
r. ony6J!IIKOB3." pa60ty "3KOHOMII'ICCKl\JI
1'36.mH.la"
B
3TOA
pa60re
6h1na
C)1e..1aHa
ncpB3S1
nonblTKa
KOml'lCCTBCHHO
oml-
can. IWUIOHaJJbH}'lO
3KOHOloOl
KY.
OIDIO HJ ncpBhIX JlOrH'lCCKK noc.1Cll0B3TC1IbHblX 113110lKCHII1I
Ma-
reMaTH'lCCKOil MOlleJIH 3KOHOMHIQI 6b1J1o BblnOJlHCHO B KHlf!"C
o
KYPHO
"I1CCJ1CllOBaHHC MaTCMaTH'lCCKH)(
nplIHUllnoB
TCOplIlI
60-
f3ICIBa".
ony6JJIIKOB3HHoft
BO
<1lpaHUIIII B 1838 r. B
3TOil
pa60Tc
KOJIII'lCCTBCHHhlC
MCTOllbi
6b1J111
BncpBhlC
IICnOJlbJOBaHhI
JlJlII
aHaRII3a
KOm:ypeHUHH Ha PhlHKC TOBapa
npH
P33ll1l'lHbIX
PblHO'lHblX
CIrry3-
UIUIX
. B 'laCTHOCTH,
6h1na
nocrpoeHa
II
IICCJlCllOBaHa
llIlHaMII'ICCKl\JI
I(OJlCllb .u;yonOJlIIH
o
BKI13J1e
O.KypHO
B
palBIITlle
M3TCM3T11'1CCKOro MOllC1lIlPOBaHlIR
KOIIOMHqCClOlX
npoUCCCOB, a
TaKlKC
0 npenRTCTBH.SIX,
orpaHII'III-
:~lIUIX
pacnpocTpaHCHllc
noro
MCTOlla. 33MC'laTC1IbHO
CKaJaJI
apW3JIII B nPCllHc.10BHH CBoeR KKllfII
"nplIHUllnbl
3KOHOMII-
qCCKOA
H3""u~
"
J~'
KOma
npHXOlllITCIi IICnOJlbJOBaTb CJII1WKOM
MHOro
CHMBOIIOB,
paJ6l1paTb
HX
CTaHOBIITCSI
TpYllHO
BeeM,
KPOMC
caMoru
aB-
11
Topa
.
npaBlla
,
!"cHili!
KYPHO
Jl
OJIlKCIi
Dpll.!laTb
HOBbi
CTHMYJI)'M
-
CTBCHHOi! llCSlTeJlbHOCTlI
BceX
. KYO
IIcnhlTbrBaCT
lIa
ce6e
BlIlllUUlC era
TpYllOB, a
PaBHhlC
CM)'
no
ypoBHIO
laTCM:rn!KH
B COCTORHIIH
HCllo.'Ib-
30BaTb
CBOC
11311J06JTCHIIOC OPYlKIIC, 'IT06y
np06HTb
ce6e
JlOPOI)'
K
caMoil
CyTII TeX
TpYllHcilwlIX
npo6neM
3KOIIOMJ{tJccxoii
TeOPIIII
. KOTO-
PblC
110 CIIX
nop
33TpamBamlCb
seChMa
nosepXHocTIlO
"
B
nocncJ1YIOUllIc
rollbl
npolICXOJlJuta
H!1TeHCIIBH3JI
M:lTCMaTlIJa
-
UIIJ! 3KOHOMJIKH.
HanpIIMCp
, B KHII!"C Y •
.lbcCBOHC3
"
Kp:!TKOC
OnllC3
-
HIIC
06weii
MaTeMaTlI'ICCKoi!
TCOPlIlI
nammAccxoR
KOHOMHII
",
ony
-
6J1lfKOBaHHoi!
B 1862 r
.,
6b1J1a 113110lKCHa
0JIH3
H3
nepBbIX
sePClli!
TeO-
plIlI
nOJlC3HOCTII. 0
JHa'ietfllll
MC'fOlill-Ma'RllzmyecKom
yoncnRpaB:l
-
HIISI
npn
IICCJ1CJlOB311HH. 3.K.OHOMI!.'it.c;KHX
npoUCCCOB
DO
BTOpa
nO
.
10-
BIIHC
XIX
seKa
JIY'lWC
Beero
roBOPHT
CJIcll)'JOUlHR
$u-'T
CpeJtII
Bb/-
)1aJOIUllXCSI
3KOHOMllcroB
3TOro
ncpRoaa
U .TO.'IbKO
Knap
II Ee -
naBepK
C)'MC1IlI
BHcenl
cjJYHllaMCHTaJ1hHblR
BKJI3.11
B 3KOIIOMH.'ICCK)'lO
TeOpll1O
6C3
lICD0JIh30BaHIISI
H.1JH
3HallllSl
MaTCMllTlIIQI
"(
M
Ii.'IlIYT)
MCTOllOJlOfllll
MaTCManl'lCCKoro
NOlleJJllPOB3HllJ!
0((()1f'IllTe.1bHO
yrscp)1llJ1aCh
B 3KOHOMJIKC K
Ha'lany
XX
BCKa,
Koma
YCHIIHlIMH
JI.BaJIhpaca,
S.ITapero,
C1>
.
3lllKYoprn
II
IIp
. KilaCCll'lCCKl\Jl
JKOHOMH'lC-
CKl\JI
HaYKa
6b1J1a
ncpesellcH3
Ha
llocralO'lIiO
CTpOnfll
IdaTCM:rn!'lC-
CKHH S13b1K.
rOBOpSi
0
KJlacclI'IccKoR
SKOHOMllKC,
06Y'D10
nOlIpal)'MC-
BaJOT
pa60Tb1
yqclIhIX-3KOHOMlIcroB.
KOTOPblC B COOl
selCIBRlI
C
Tp3-
llIlUIICi!,
lIJlYIIIcA OT
.ll.PlIKlIPllO.
RCCJlCllOB3JllI
BOnpocbl
06UlCro
3
0-
HOMIl'lCCKOro
paBHoseclISI
.
OrMeTlIM.
'ITO
,
HeJaBHClL\lO
OT
ypoBHll
HC-
nOJlbJOBaHH.Sl
M3TCMaTIl'lCCKoro
annapa1'3.
3
OHOllIICTbl-KJl3CClIKH
(B.
ITem,
.ll
.
PIIKapllo
II
)1p
.) II IIX
nocncllOIl3Teilll
DpH
060cIlOB3HHII
TeOpeTIl'lCCKIIX
BbiBOllOB npIIMCHSlJlII clICTCMHbIlI
no.x<OJl
, 'lCTKO
BbI-
paJKaSI CBOII
npellCTall1leHlIJ!
0 nplI'llIHHO-c.nCllCTBCHllbL1( CBJlllIX MeJIU\Y
p3.3llll'lHhlMlI
3J1CMCtrraMlI
olD,:ypeHTIloR
CIICTCMhI B
uenoM.
PacurnpeHllc
IIcnOJIh3OBaHl1Jl MaTC!IIaTH'leCKHX eTOlIOB
npH
HC-
CJICllOBaHHII 3KOHOMlf'lCCKlIX
npoucccoB
cnoco6crBoBaJlo
palBKTHIO
C~HOI'Q
.DOJl.l(Olla.
HanpHMcp,
J]
Ba.'Ibp3C
C'lHT3JI,
'ITO
see
COUII-
anbHblC
RB1ICHIIJ! -
peJJllnlJ!,
nOJllmn
..
"3,
3KOHOMllKa
II lJY1(OBHalI CII3Hb
- TCCHO CBlI33HbI MelKllY
co6oi!
(0
Ce.1HrMCH)
.
9ro
COOTBeTCTB}'eT
co-
BpeMCHHOM}'
nOHIIM3HIIIO
lOro.
'ITO S OHO)'(}IKll
JlB,'lSIeTOI
nQllCllCTC-
Moll
UCJlOCTHoli CIICTCMbI COUllaJtbHo-SKOHOMJI'IeCJQL'I(
OTIfomcHlIA
,
BCIICllCTBIIC
'lcru
113yqcHlle
Co6cTBeKHO
3KOHOMlIIQI H
npellCKlI33HHC
TpacKTOp1l1l
cc
P33BIITIIJ!
H3
nepcnct..'THBY
Jla:
HO
onllpaTbCll
H3
aHa-
Jllll
06bCKTa
60JJce
06weli
npllpollbl
- COUII:lJIbHO-S 'OHOMlI'ICCKOil
CIICTeMbi.
YcncwHble
npIIJIOlKt'HIISI M3TCMaTIlKH B SKOHOMHKC CTHM}'1IIIPOB:l-
JIll
nplIMeHeHlIc
MeT01l3
MaTCMOTH'It'CKOro
MOlleJJllPOBaHllJl
II B
liP
'fHX
06weCTseHHbIX
HaYKox.
HanplIMep.
C1>
3.1lK}OpTOM
6bLla
0lly6JtH
OBa-
Bl1eiJelllle
12
nlll"
a B
napero
6bIJIM
paapa-
..
MaTeMaTll'leCKaJI
nCIlXOJlO ,
H3
KHllra
.
lIT
60taHbI
OCHORbi
-reOpllll
3JI OCbl
06oeKTIIDHOro
aHaJlIl3a
COUl1aJ1bHO-
Hallo
C((aJ3Tb. 'ITO
Bonp
ccr)!a
6wTII
D
uetrrpe
DHIIMaHlill
HaY'HlolI
3((OHOMH'IeCKIiX
npoue~~;e:
CTPaHe.
HecMOTPR
Ha
113BeCTHble
TPY.l\-
06wcCTDeHHOCTII
II
B
((oro
nepl!o)!a,
3KOHOMII'IeCKaR
HaYKa
0
POCCIII!
HoeTlI
nOClleoJ(11!6pbC
Cb
a
~IHOnte
ee
pe3YJlbTaTbl
CTaJlIl
.l\OCTOllmleM
nOCTORHHO
~aJOl!oan::c
:nIM,
npelK.lle
Dcero,
CJle)!yeT
OTHecnl
aHMIl3
Mllposoll
I"Jlbrypbl
. nOT
61rreJJJ1
E.Ci!yUK11M;
OTKpblTlle
.l\JIllHHbIX
Moneill!
nOBClleHWI H
K~HJlPaTbCBblM'
paapa60TK)'
nepooro
6MaHca
BOnH
B
3KOHOM~:Ke
CCCP
33
1923~
1924
IT.,
Ha
OCHOBe
KOTOPOro
H3ponHoro
X03R
n
CTaB
BJI
6b1J1a
nOCTpoCHa
WHpoKO
H3BeCTHaJI
HblHe
MO.l\CJI; K
eOHTbeOa;
paa-
BHTHe
MeTOnOB
HCCJle)!ooaHWl
JUfHellHbIX
CIICTeM . aHTOPOBll'IpeM.
H
B nOC1leuocHHble
ro)!bI
B ueJlYl1llfX
HayqHbIX
uetrrpax
OCCIlIl
(U3MH
PAH
,
HID',
BHHHCH,
BU
PAH,
HMM
PAH,
H30rm
CO
PAH.
HJ13H
npH
rOCDJlaHe
CCCP
H
)!p.)
6J1aro)!apR
npllMeHe-
HllIO MeTO)!a
M3TeMaTll'leCKoro
MO)!CJIllpooaHllR
6b!J111
nOJlY'leHbl
3Ha-
'1l1TenbHble pe3YJlbTBTbI 0
06naCTII
IlCCJlellooaHIIR
COUllaJlbH~-3KOHO
MH'IeCKHX
npoueccoB
HanpKMep,
BblBOIl 0
B03MOlKHOCTIl
RIlepHoII
3HMbI", nOJl}"leHHbII! 0
BU
PAH
no)!
PYKOoollCTBOM
H.H.Mollceeoa
Ha
OCHOBC
BbI'IlIClIIITCJIbHbIX 3KCnepKMeHTOB.
3roT
pe3YJlbTaT
IlCCJIellooa-
mill
COOTBCTCTBYJOweli
M3TCMaTll'lCCKOA MO)!eJlII 0!GI33JI 0
cooe
OpeMR
6oJ!bwoc
BlJIlRHIle
Ha
MHOillX
nOJIKTIIKOO
so
aceM
M11pe.
K coJKaJlelfllJO, MCTOIl
MaTeMaTll'leCKoro
MOlleJlllpOOaHIIR
COUll-
aJlbHG-3KOHOMII'IeCKHX"
npoueccoB
110
ClfX
nop
npllMeHRJICR
0
HaIlIell
CTp3He
npellMYWeCToeHHo
B
HayqHblx
paapa60TKax,
a
peKOMeHJlBUIlH
3KOHOMH'ICCKOfi HayKH Ja'laCTYIQ
nonpocry
HrHopllpouanllCb
(Il
HrHO-
PIIPYIOTCR) Ha
octx
ypoBHRX
ynpaoneHHR.
3T0
0
60JlbwoA
CTeneHll
CDR33HO
C
TCM,
'ITO )!O
He)!aBHero
opeMeHH
npifMeHeHHC....KOJlH'Ie-
CTBe"UWX
ueJ))nOB B ynpaaDeKHM H3yqanocb B D}'33X POCe"H ,nOCTa-
TO'lHO 4>oPM3JlbHO, a MCTO)lbI
oblcwell
MaTCMaTHKIl
0
3KOHOMIl'IeCKHX
)!IICUHnilHHaX
uoo6we
np3KTH'IeCKH
He
IlcnOJlbJOBaJlIlCb,
nOCKOJlbK}'
3KOHOMH'ICCKOC
06p330oaHlle
6b1J1o
cDClleHO,
no
cYweCTBY,
K
1l0I'Ma-
TH'ICCKOMY
TOnKODaHHIO KJlaCCHKOB
MapKCH3Ma,
a
onbiT
aHMIl3a
CO-
WI3JlbHO-3KOHOMH'IeCKHX
npoueccoo
Ha
OCHooe
IlPyntX
nO)lXOIlOO
npBKTH'IeCKIi
He p3CCMaTPHDanCR.
HanpHMep,
BnilOTb )!O KOHUa
80-x
rollOO
JlJIl1HHble OOJlHbI 0
3KO-
HOMHKe
6b1J1H
B
Hawel!
CTpaHe
3anpeTHoA
TeMoA,
T.K.
3TO
He
onll-
CblDanOCb 8 KOHuenUHIO
"HeYKilOHHOro
poem
Hapo)!Horo
x03RIICT-
83"
(
nOKaJaTenbHO, 'ITO nepDaR
MOHorpa$HR
Ha
PYCCKOM R3b1Ke
~~
M.MeHbwIIKOB
H
JI.A.KnHMeHKO),
nOCBRweHH311
3TOMY
Bonpocy,
Ulna
B
CBCT
nHWb
B
1989
r.).
npH
3TOM
nOnblTKII
(BecbMa
pellKHe)
ny6nHKaUHH
pe3ynbTBTOB,
nonyqeHHblX
Jan3)lHblMH
yqeHblMH
Ha
OCHoae HCnOnb30DaHHR MaTeMaTH'leCKHX MeTOIlOD,
06R33TCJlbHO
npe.l\-
8tIeiJel/ue
OapRnHCb
KllconorWtCCKHMH
KJlHwe
TaKora
po.zxa
•• CT3p3S1Cb l3T)'l1IC'"
naTh
3KCIIII)'3TaTOPCK}'1O
npHpo.ny
JalnHTaJlIlCTlI'lCCKOro
cnoc06a
npo-
H3DoIlCToa",
...
TeopHII
paDHooeCIIJI
,
8p3lKJle6I1aR
MapKcHlldy-neHH-
HH3MY
...
",
" .
Ifa
3KOHOMCTpHK}'
6h1J13
D03JIO;tCeHa J:l.IU\'13
nO.l\HRTb
npeCTHlK
6YPlK}'aaHolI
nOJlHTH'leCKOIi
JKOHOIdHIl'
H T n
npll'IHHbI
npeHe6pelKIITCJlbHOrO
OTHOWCHIIJI K
H3yqHOM}'
aHanll-
3y
nOCJIC.llCTBHii
ynQ3W1cH'ICC.KlIlLpemcHIIIl
em
my6olOte
KOPHH,
B
conpOTHMcHHC
t
KOTopoe
BCTpelJaCT
Me-TOA-
U;lTCUa
Vft
lcCK0r.:2.
0
t1
pODaHl111
npll
aH3JI113e
COUHMbHO-:lKOHOMlI'IeCKHX
np06i1eM
, - 60JJee
'1eM oeKOOYIO HCTOpHIO.
HanpllMep
,
npolllD
H3MepeHIIR
JI
Banbpaca
D
1890-x
ro)!ax
DDeCTH 0
K}'PC
nonHTH'lecKoli
lKOHOMll1l
MaTCMaTH'Ie-
clOte
Merollbl
BblcrynMO
nOllaBJIRlOlUee
6oJJbWIIHCTBO
ero
KOJlJIer
no
JI03aHHcKoM}'
}'HHBepcHTery
OIlHIlM
113
OCHOOHblX
1l0001l0D,
KOTOPbll!
cnyJKHT
npenRTCTBlleld
Jl)!R
IlCnOJlb300aHIIJI
MeTO)!a
MaTeMaTH'IeCKoro
1d0.lCJl11pooamiR
npll
aHaIDl3e
KOHKpeTHbIX
COUHMbHO-3KOHOIdH'IeCKHX
npoueccoo,
IIBlIJICT-
CR
CJlOlfCH.oc<T~fu.e
_
Kn..
MQJlCIDlPOB3HIlIl,
nocKo..1bK}'
npIIMeHlleM3JI
TeopeTH'IeCKaR
MOIlCJIb MOlKeT
oKaJaTbCR
Cl!HllUCP1ol
yupomeHHo
I
no
cpaDHeHllIO
C
ofu.eKTOM-OPllfllHaJlOM
OllliaxO
peKoMeH)lllllHlI
II
DY-
BOllbl,
nOJl}"leHHble
Ha
OCHODe
aHMH33
a.neKBBTHol!
IlMllTaUHOHHOA
MOlleJlIl,
Ta/OKe
MOryl
OKaJaTbCll
HeooCTpC60naHHYMH,
nocKonbK}'
ynp3B1!e~u
~lKe:L
nll!:JlnO'!l;CTh
Qnepc::rhQI..
Ha
IIHT)'HUIl/o
Il
Jl3lI(e
HMCTb
HepeweHHyIO
npo6neM}',
'1eM
HCnOJlb30B3Tb
MOlleJlH,
D KOTOPbIX
OH
Hll'Iero
He
nOHHMaeT
, H CTaTb,
T3KIIM
06pa30M.
:l3.IIOlKHHKOM
pa.3-
pa60T'1IlXa-MaTeMaTHKa.
,
~
-
Co
C-
~".
6-
HellooueHKe
M~a~IOllen
_
HPOB:U!1lR
lll?1I
!lPIIHRTHII
pewelUll!
CJ!yJKHT
Ta/OKe
H
('npeHe6peliceHHe
aKaJleMH'ICCKolt
3KOHOMII'IeCKol!
HaYKolI
ynOPHblM.
CHCTeMaTll'IeCKHM,
9Mnllpll'leCKIIM
3HamooM
H
YBJlC'IeHHe
1l3RlUHblMH,
HO
nYCTblMH,
$OpMMbHblMH,
rnaoHblM
06pa-
30M
MaTCMaTH'IeCKIIMIl,
TCOpeTII'ICCKHMJ{
"ynpalKHeHHllMII
~
(B.JIeoHTbeo.
1972
r.).
nORHOCTblO
npllHHMaR
KBK
He06xOIlIIMOCTb
paaBlITHll
BKCHOW3-
TII'IecKoII
TCopeTH'IeCKOil
MaTcMant'leCKOII
9KOHOMHKIl.
TaK
II
6oJJb-
woe
3Ha'leHHe
npllKJI3JlHblX
COUHaJlbIlO-~KOHOMII'IeCKlIJ(
HCc.1CJlOna-
lillA,
oTMeTHM,
'ITO
D OCHODe
9THX
nOilRPHbIX
HanpaB1leHll1i
MaTeMam-
'1eCKOrO
MO)!eJlHponaHHR
1l0JIlKHO
JlClKllTb
rny6oKoc
nOHIlMBHHe
6a:lo-
DbiX
TeOpeTH'IeCKlIX
"OlleJleil
H,
npell<Jle
Bcero,
1l0nyweHIlI!,
Hcnonh-
3yeMblx
npH
nOCTpoeHKH
3THX
Mo)!eneil,
KOTOpyC
II
OnpelleJlRlOT
npe-
IlCJIbi
IlX
npllMeHHMOCTl1.
KaK
BHJlHM,
HapRllY
C
cym,eKTIIBHYMII
TPY)!HOCTIlMII
cymeCTByIOT
H
BnORHe
060eKTHDHble
npo6J1eMbI,
orpaHH'IJIB3IOWIlC
3IjKjleKTHDHOCTb
npHMeHeH1l1I
MeTO)!a
MaTeMaTH'IeCKOrO
MOlleJIllponaHllR
npH
aHMHlC
COUHaJlbHO-3KOHOMIl4CCKHX
npoueCCOD.
K
HHM,
npelKJlC
Dcero,
CJle.ny-
eT
OTHCCTH
HCKJlI04HTeJlbliOe
P33Hoo6p33He
H
PalHOPOIlHOCTb
OOoeK-
14
_~",,""lI
nOCKl),1b:Y B
::noR
06naCIll
HMCIOT MCCTO :3.1c-
TO
~~---'
II
CT1\XHllHOCnl,
lleTCpMHlmponaHHOCTIf
H
c;y-
eHTH
ynpu.'DIC
OCTII
OCTII
co'leT3HHC
npoueccoB
TCXHH'ICCICOro
JllCCT1ICHHoR
lleD)lllOJua'l1l
,.
' . J
H
cowu..
1hHoro
xapaxrepa
~""bl
CTOIlWlle
H3
nym
p:l3BHTHR
!j>op-
• OCHOBllblC
npe,
y-
,
04JW'0
COUH:L1bHO-3KOIlOMH'ICCKHX
HayICax,
HO-
,~
wctoll
OB
B 0 K
)UlIIOOBaJIlI..,.
y6beKniBllblli
xapaKTCP
·
rn3BIIOn
H3
HHl(
arT,
no-BJl.III{)Coldj', C
McXllYH3pollH
OM
cHMn03HYMc
no
T1J13HHPO-
cJ:J33!l
n
JI
K~~
~;59
r PaJMbll1l1UlJl 0
p:l3BHTHH
06WCCTBCHHbll(
saHlIJO
H3)'KJ1
cm
B3JI
auanomlO
c nOJlO;f'CHHCM CCTCCTBCHHbIX HayIC
uayx.
OH
IICDOJIb30
n
•
..
.UCpKOBb
6pana
113
ce6J1
MOHOrrOJIHIO
CXO-
"""'''''HC
seKa,
Kor_
"
B
..,.-.
OnlaTl!'1eCKoro
TO!lKOnaHHR
BceX
JlBJlCHHn
rrpHpOllbl,
Jl3CTI!'ICCIOl-ll
C1aJI
see
'ITO XOTb B
ManeAwcA
MCpe
npOTHBOpe-
peWHTCIIb~=KIDI
rrH~KJUI
.
..
CeA'I3C
CymCCTByeT
60JlbUIOC
'fH.'10:
IIC rocynapCTBCHHhIX CTpYKTYP, KOTOPblC
npH3H31OT
3a
~
~KO
TO
B
06meCTIICHHblX
HayKaX,
'ITO
1l0K:l3b1BaCT
nCJle-
coo6paJ
oCTb:rrHX
CTpYKTYP
EcieCTIICHHO,
'ITO
npH
TaICKX YCJIOBHj!l(
p33lIHTH: 06mcCTBCHHblX
H3yK
CHJlbHO
CTCCI/CHO"
(n
11
KanHua)
. K
co;aJlCHHlO,
33
COPOK 6eJ
loIanoro
,TCT
3TH
CJI0Ba HC
yrpaTKJIH
cBocA
aJ<:JYIllhHoCTH
Cna60e
npellCTaBJIeHHC 0 c;ymeCTBc IoICTolla
MOllCJlHpOBaHKlI
K
ero
BOlWOXHOCTlIX
npHBOllHT
K TOMY,
'ITO
Ja'laCTYlO
pcaKUHcA
Ha
HcCOOTBCTCTBHC
o;«H)laHHli
H
KOHKpeTHblX
pe3YJlbTaToB
COUH3JlbHO-
,)KOHOWH'ICCKOK nOJlKTIIKH,
ocHonaHHoli
H3
HCnOJlb30BaHHH
HC3)1CK-
B3TfIbiX MOlleJJeA, CJIYlI(aT 3MOUHOH3JlbHblC
BblBO)lbl
0
TOM,
'ITO
"3KOHOWH'ICCKHC '33KOHLI B POCCHH
HC
JIcACTByJOT",
'ITO
"YWOM
POC-
CHJO
HC
nOHJlTb",
'ITO "IoIOJICJlllpoBaHHC B
HaWHX
YCllOBKlIX
6cc-
CWliCJICHHO" H T.
ll.
Ho
BCllb
310
Bee
paBHO,
'!'TO
paCC'IKTblBaTb
Tpa-
CKTOPHIO
llBHXCHHJI
Toli
lICC
63JIJJHCnI'ICCIC01i
paKCTbI
no
<POPMYJlC
H3
Kl8CCTHOA WKOJlbHOA
'l3llll'lH
0 JlBH;KCHHH
TClla,
6POWCHHOro
nOll
yrlIOM
K
roPH30HlY,
a nOTOM
B03wywaTbCli
paCXOJlCllCHHCM
TCOpHH
H
npaKTIIKK'
CKaJaHHDe BWlBHraCT
BOnpoc
06
IOY'lCHHH
CnCUH3JlHCTaMH-
ynp3ll1lCHWlMK. }lCIOJIDB IJ;9PIlIi.
npl1HJlTHll
peUICHHA,
apceH3JI
K01'O-
pYX
BICJIIOII3CT
MO;ICJlHPOB3HHC COllH3JlbHO-3KOHOMH'ICCICHX
npoucc-
COD.
He06xoI!HWDeTb
3Toro
onpeJICnJlCTCJI TCM,
'ITO
npoHHKHonCHHC
KO,1H'ICCTBeHHbIX
MCTOIlOB
B COUH3JlbHO-:"KOHOMH'lCCKHC
HaYKH
-
mOJlHC 33KOIfOMCPI!aJI pe3JIbHOCTb,
nOCKonbKY
PU3UHTHC
Beex
HaYK
npoHCXOIlHT
¢JaKTH~CCKH
no
eJIlmoli
cxeMC.
3rd
CXCMa
IlKJIIO'laCT
:~~OJlbKO
nCpHOJlOO'
OnHC3TCJlblfbiK
neplIOD;
nepHOll
ynopIUIO'ICHIIJI
CTeW3TH13UHH
H3KOIlJleHHoA
HIl<PoPM3UHH'
nepHOll
DLlJlMCHH$!
H
YCTaHOBJICHHII
CBlI1CA
H COO'TIfOweHHII'
"TO~IfLl'A"
nCpHOJl
D K01'OPOM
WI!POKO
I!CnOJlb""
' ,
-JCTCR
MCTOI! MarCMaTH'ICCKOIO MOJICJIHpoll3HHJI Jl}I$!
aJlaJJl!13 p3.l1!iI'lHblX o61.eKTOB "noli KaYKH
IS
CnO;KKBWHMHCJI
TO'lHl.DlJI
HlI)'KIDlJ1
RBJlJlIOTCJI
cel!'i3C
KaTCM3TII-
1(3 H
HlIYJOI
«pH3H'ICCKOTO
ItHllJla
(
c:xamuca,
TCpIolOJ1}U{3.)(1{JOl,
S,1C
-
JpOllH
HaMH
KlI
, KnaHTOB3JI exaHlUCll,
XH
K'lecxaJI
«pH3K1Cll H
lip)
Bee
OCTIlJIbHblC H3yKH B
601lbwcA
HIIII
CHbWC
creneHK
no
'ITO
OTHD-
CRTCR
K
KJlaccy
OnHC3TCJTbHbIX, X011I
MHornc
K.J
HHX
, B TOM
'IHenC
6HonOrKll
,
3KOHOMH1(3
H COUHOJIOrKll,
1l0CTaT0'lHO
WHPO
0 HenO-'Il>-
3YJOT
MaTCMaTH'lCCKHC
MCTOllbi
aH:L'IHJa
(H3ITPHMCP, B D()(;,,1e.1lHl1C lIe-
CJlTHJlCTHIi B
rywaHHTaPHbIX
H3}'KllX
nOJlBH1DlCh
3TCloIllTH'Iccmc
Teo-
PKH
paJnHTH$!
KYJlbT)'pbl
,
nocrpoeHbl
H HCCJlCJlOB3Hbl aTCM3TH'ICCIOtC
MOllCllH
M06K.flH3allHH
, UHKJlH'fCCXOTO pa3BH1l1J1 COItHOK)'JUoT)'pHbIX
npoueccon,
MOllCJlb
83llHMODcI!CTBHJI
HaPOllll
H
np:1B~TbCrB3,
O.aC:.!Ih
roHKH
nooPyxcHHIl
H
llP
.) /
B
C3MbIX
06WKX
'1cprax
npouecc
MaTCMal'H'ICCKOTO
1oI0llem!pona-
HKlI
ycnoBHO
MO;KHO
nOllpa3l1CllHTb
Ha
'1CTb1pe
::rrana::
C
- !j>OPMYJIHPOBKlI
CHcreMbI
rHUOTCl
H
pa3pa6arKa
KOHUcmyanb-
HoA
MOllem!
;
-
paJpa60TKa
IoIaTCMaTH'lccxoA
MOllem!,
-
aHaJlK3
pe3YllbTaTOB
MOJICJlbHbIX
pac'lCTOB,
KOTOpbl
BJC1IIO'IaeT
cpaBHcHHc
HX
C
np3JCTHKoll
;
i I - Ij>oPM)'JIHPOBKlI HOBbIX
rnnOTCl
H
yro'lHCHHe
01le.1H B
c:nyqac
HecoOTBCTCTBHJI pe:JyllbTaTOB p3C'iCTOB H
npaiCTlNecxHX
llllHHbIX.
OTMCTKIoI,
'ITO,
KlIX
npaBHJlO,
.JIPOI.ICCIl M3TCMaTII'ICCKOTO MOlle..1H-
ponaHHJI
HOCHT
rWICl!!f'lrcKHll
xapa=p,
nocKOllbKY
.aaxc
npl!
Hcc,,1C-
llOB3HHH
CpaBHHTCJIbHO
npocnv<
nponeccoB
peJIKo
ynaCTCJI
c
ncp80TO
wara
nOCTpOHTb
3)1CKnarnyJO
MaTelolaTK'IecxyIO
1oI0.llCJlb H
nOll06p;rr&
TO'lHblC
CC
napaMCTpbl
.
Bonpoc
0
crencHH
3)1CKB311fOCTH
HcnOJlb3YcWbIX
1d0llCJIcli
RB-
JlRCTCIi UCHTPaJIbHblloI
npH
npHloIeHcHKH
MCTOlI3 MOJII:J1HpoB3HKl1
1llllI
nocrpoeHH.lI
3)1cKnaTHoli
MaTCMaTK'ICCKol!
MOlleJIH
TpC6yJOTCJI
WHPO-
mc
3HaHHJI
«p3XTOB, O1'HOCJIWHXCJI K
H3}"IacMoM)'
npouecc;y,
rny6oKOC
npoHHKHoncHKc
D
ero
TCOpHIO.
n03TOMY
H3
ncpBOM
3T3IIC
HCCJle.l10-
BaHKlI,
Koma
CTpOHTCIi
KOHUCmyanbHaJI
1oI0.llCJIb,
JL1JI
ec
pa3pa6ancH
06b1'1HO npHB1ICKBIOTCIi CnCnH3JlHCTbI PaJ.]IK'1HbIX
H3ITpaBllcHKA,
CBlI-
3aHHblX
C
06oeKTOM
HccnClIOnaH11JI
He06xOllHMOCTb
T3Koro
COTpYJIHH'leCTBa
06ycnoMeHa
TCM,
'ITO
crencHb
UIlCKB311fOCTH
pa3pa6aTblB3CMOIl
MOlle.'lH 33BHCHT npellCJlc
sceTO
01'
:noro
3T3na'
HMCHHO
;mecb
npoHClloJUIT
~
'MO.lIem!,
YCT'J.HaB1lHnaIOTCJI
83llHMOCBlllli.
MClKUY
«.
3llCMeHT3M1l,
33K]la)1h1B3J01'Cl1
OCHOBbi
MaTCManl'lCCKOil
33,Ila'lH.
nOJ1'lepKIICM,
'ITO
ypoBCHb
8,;lCKB3T-
HOCTH MaTCMaTH'ICCKOA MODeJIH
H3Y'J3CMoro
00beKT3
(npouecca)
B
6011bwoll
crencHH
onpeJIeJlllCTCR
llOnyWCHHJIMH,
HcnOJlb3YcMblMH
npH
nOCTpOCHHH COOTIICTCTBYlOwcil
KOHuemyaJlbHOIlIdODem!
K CO)l(3JICHHIO, npHXO)1HTCJl KOHCT'J.THPOBaTb
eneDYIOWcc:
xapaK-
TCPHblM
HCllOCTaTKOM HlIIOllCCHHII MaTCMaTH'IeCKHX 1oI0llCJIcA B
HaY'l-
/J8eiJeHlle
16
Ii
}IIfrepaTYPC
no
3KOHOMIIKC,
KOTOPbl1l
HOII
II
Y'lefiHO-MeTOJlII'leCKO '1nTare.nCM
lIMlICTClI
HC'ICTKOC
06c)')K-
npenRTCTUYCT
It).
uocnpIIIITI~:T
UCHTP3llb'Hi>Iil
npll
nOCTpOCHllH
MO.D,C-
JlCHIIC
.:nIO'ICBbI~
nmo~~Oil
nllTCpa1)'PC
11311araCTClI
3a'lacTYIO
BCCbMa
neil
BonpoC
JI:lJKe B
y'le
1I0ueP\HOCTHO.
6HIIKe
n
CaMpnbCOHa
"3KOHOMHKa",
lIBJUIIO-
HanpIIMCP,
B
}"IC
'oil
KJlaCCI1KOii
H3
crpaHlluax,
nocBlIw.CHHbIX
WCldCR
3KOHOldll'lCCK ' • "
..
JlCJ1H
pblHKa
TOB3pa,
'1IITaCM.
..
KOHKYPCHTHM
naVTlIHOofipaJHOI!
MO
6 P
•
lIJlaraeTClI
Ha
pblliKe
0
bI'IHblM
nyreM,
KOr.D,a
npoJIYKUlIlI
npe
6 II
MO)KHO
nOJly'!IITb,
npoacJllI
BCPTlIK3J1bbn"JII~HIO
OT?
n;;
~
TO'lIGl,
ofi03liaQaIOlllCH
Q,
.D,O
KPllBOil
cnpoca
. TO
3TO.
C PC)l(HOCTb
pa
Hnll
IICK:lJKeHlfe
nplf
ncpeBOJlC?
KTO
If
r.D,C
npc.D,J1araJ\
npo.D,yK-
auB1l) ,'?
UUlO,
~
.npoBCJlli
BcpTHK3J1bHYlO
JIIIHIlIO
.
npoUIITllpoB3HHOC
BblCKaJblBaHIfC -
lIpKHIl
npHMCp
HcfipC)l(Horo
omicaHIIR
MOJlCJ1I1,
IIMeIOlllell,
KaK
Idbl
YUH,D,HM
HIDKe,
npHHUHnH3J1b-
HOC
3H3'1eHIfC lIJllI
nO}l}!MaHIIlI
JleilCTBIIJI
PblHO'lHblX
McxaJrn3MOB.
OT-
MenlM,
'ITO npIIBCJleHH3lI
llnTaTa
BblPaJKllCT
Bcero
nKlllb
anropHTM
onpeLlCJ1CHIIlI
MaKCIIManbHOro
3Ha'ieHIIlI
UCHbI,
npH
KOTopoll
BCCb
TO-
sap
MOlKCT
fiblTb
npoJlaH
Ha
PblHKC, a BOBce
HC
nmOTe3Y
0 npe.D,J1ollCe-
Hlfll
TOsapa (CM. HlIJI(e,
maubl
2
II
3).
HCJlOOUCHKa
npouecca
MO.D,eJ1HPOBaHIIlI
CBlIJaHa,
no
MHCJrnIO
AA)loPOJlHIIUblHa,
npelKJle
ocero
C
nCIfXOnOrll'lCCKHM
3<p<p
e
KTOM,
TllJ(
IGIJ(
TeXHII'IeCKHe
II
nporpaMMHble
CpeJlCTBa B aHrJ101l3b1'1HOIl
JIltTcpa-
"h
d "
"ftw
"
TYPC
IIMCIOT cneUlf3J1bHblC
TepMIfHbl
-
ar
ware
If
so
are
COOT-
BCTCTBCHHO,
a
CnCUllanbHoro
TepMHHa
.D,J1JI
MO.D,encll .H. 3!I
ro
PHTMQ!I
(HanplIMcp,
"brainwarc")
HCT
.
npeHcfipelKllTCnbHoe
0Tl10111CHIlC K MOJlCJ1HPOBaHlflO
npHBo.D,HT
K
:rolY,
'ITO
'1aCTO
lIJlR 3H3J1H3a COUII3J1bHO-3KOHOMII'ICCKHX
npol\eCCOB
II
/IP"HqTHH
OTBeICTBeHHJ,lll
"CYDbfioHOCHblx!'
pellleHHIl
IfCnOnb3YIOTclI
MOJlM"
(uonenhHble
.!!£CJlcraI0CHIIH),
HC3)leKB3THO
01J!ruKllKl1lI.He
3TH
'IIflJO"CCCh!
3r0
npolfcxoLlIIT,
HanplIMCp,
TOrJla,
KOrJla
CJlHHCTBeHHblM
KPIITCPIICM 3LlCKsaTHOCTII OKaJblBaeTClI
"npaBJlono.D,ofiHOC"
nOBC.D,eHHe
MOJlCJ1I1.
TaKoe
lKC
"060CHOBaHIfC"
BblBOJlOO MOllCHO
OfiHap)')KIfTb
II
0
nllICp3TYpe
no
3KOHOMII'ICCKOii
TCOplfll.
HanplIMCp,
nllWb
H3 OCHOBaHll1f
KoncfiaHHII
paC'IeTHblX
3Ha'lC-
HIlIi
HaUIIOH3J1bHOro LlOXOJla
npll
onpe.D,CnCHHblX
3Ha'leHHlIX
napa-
MCTpoB
MOJlCJ111
JlCnoBOro UIfKJ1a
CaMpnbCOHa-XIIKca,
KOTOP3ll
pac-
cMar~lIsaeTCR
H"JKC
(maua
7),
O'lCHb
'1aCTO JlCJ1aCTClI
BblBO.D,
0
TOM,
'ITO 3T01
cnyqall
Hall60nce
finll30K
pe3J1bHOIi
.D,ClicTBIfTenbHoCTH"
(M
Ky60Hllua)
Ocofio
OTMCT"M
npofincMY
nocTpoeHIfH
3)leKBaTHi>IX
MO.D,CJleli
npll
IIccnCIlOBaHll1l
COUII3J1bHO-3KOHOMII'IeCKIfX
npoucccOB
no-
cKonbKy
nOllaBnRIOWCC
fionbWIfHCTDO
113
HIIX
113MCHReTCR
BO
~peMe
HII
II
nonOMY
COOTD~CT
~,
0YIOWIIC MOJlCnll RBnRIOTCH B
npHHllHne
Boedel/lle
17
.D,HIIBMII'1CCKlIMH
.
HeCMOTpli
lIa
fionce
'lCM
BCKOBYIO HCTOPHIO
npH-
MeHeHHII
MaTeMaTll'1eCKOrO
MOllcnHpooBIIHlI
0
)Toil
ofinaCTII,
MCTO-
.D,HKB
H3YQCHHII
llHHaMH'lCCKIIX
npoueCCOD
npaKTH'IeCKH
IIC
113MCHH-
naCb.
KaK
II
CTO
neT
Ha33)l,
OJlIIHM
113
fJ1aBHblX
MCTOlllI'ICCKHX
npHC-
MOD
HccncnoBaHHR
llllHaMHKII
MIIKpO-
H
laKpo'JKOIiOMII'ICCKHX
npo-
UCCCOO
lIBJUIeTClI
HCnOnb300aHHC
rna.D,KHX
HenpepblOHblX
<PYHKUHli
II
a
II
an
113
CMemCHHlI
paBHOOCClloro
PCWCHIIII,
Bbl30amloro
113MCIICIIII-
CM
BHCWHHX
ycnooHII.
OfiOCHOBblB3lI
B03MOllCIIOCTb
npHMCHCHHC
rilJ.llIUIX
<pymrulill
npH
113Y'le1lHH
3KOHOMH'ICCKHX
npoUCCCOB,
AMaplll3J1n
0 npenHCJJOOlI1I K
BOCbMOMY H3.D,aHHIO
cooei!
KHHrII
"npHHUHllbl
3KOHOMH'lCCKOIl
Hay-
KH"
nHweT,
'ITO
3nHrpa<p
"npHpoJla
He
nenaeT
CKa'lKOB"
OC06eIlHO
nO.D,XO.D,HT
K
pafiOTe
ofi
OCHOBax
3KOHOMH'ICCKOIi
HayKH
CBolICTBo
rJ13)lKOCTH
HcnpepblBHblX
<PYHKl\HIi
o6ecnC'IHBaer
OOJ-
MOllCHOCTb
HCnOnbJOBBHHlI
annapaTa
nH<P<t>epeHUHanblloro
HC'IHCJJC-
HHlI
.D,J1JI
aHanH33
COUH3J1bHO-3KOHOMH'lCCKHX
npoucccoB
.
nocneJIllce
npHoMo
K <pOPMHPOBaHHIO B
3KOHOMHKC
MeTO.D,OJIOnl'leCKoro
Ha-
npauncHHlI,
nOny'lHBlllcro
HaJBaHHC
"MBPlKHH3J1H3M"
. B
OCHooe
noro
nO.D,Xo.D,a
nellCHT
aH3J1HJ .D,H<p<pepeHUHanbHblX
xapaKTepHCTHK
3KOHO-
MH'leCKlIX
nOKaJareneli
npenenbHblx
BCJ1H'IHH
(npenenbHoR
npoH3BO-
nHTenbHOCTH,
npe.D,MbHblX
H3.D,epJKCK,
npenenbHoro
.D,OXOD.3,
npe.nenb-
Holl
nonC3HOCTH
H
T.n.),
C
nOMOlll.blO
KOTOPblX
JlcnalOTCiI
OUCHKH
npH-
paw.cHHII
cOOTBeTCTBYlQw.HX
3KOHOMIr'lCCIUIX
nOKaJaTcncil
H
onpe.D,c-
nlllOTClI
OnTHMaJlbHble
peweHHR
.
ITo
cyw.eCTBY,
TaKoli
nO)lXOn
K
aH3J1113Y
JlHII3MH'IeCKHX
npoueccoB
onHpaCTCII
Ha
ofiw.ec
nOJlOllCeHlle,
comaCHO
KOTOpoMY
p33BlI1lIe
mo6011
CJJOJKHoll
CIICTeMbi
MO)J(}lO
paCCMaTpIlBaTb
KaK
CMCHY
onHoro
YCTOR'lH-
BOro,
rapMOHH'IHOro
COCTOlIHHlI
JlpynlM
C
KpaTKlIM
nepHOIiOM
ncpexo.aa
OT O.D,HOro K .D,pyroMY.
OnHaKO
aHaJJII3 3KOHOMH'ICCKOIi
.iUlHllMHKH
.13
OCHOBe
IlccncnOBaH11JI
OnTHM3J1bHbIX
paBHOueCHblX
KBa3HCTaTH'ICCIOIX
MO.D,CJ1cA
MOJKeT OKaJaTbCJI
OWII60'lllblM,
nOCKOJIbK)'
nepHOJl
HCpaBHa-
BecHoro
PaJ8I1T11J1
MHOnIX
3KOHOMII'IeCKHX
npoueCCOB
'1aCTO
fiLlBaer
CJJIIWKOM .D,J1l1renbHblM, '1TOfibl
11M
MOJI{HO fiblJ10
npeHe6pe'lb.
npCKpBCHO
nOHHMaR
3H3'1eHlle
IICCJJenOBaHHlI
3KOHOMII'leCKHX
npOUeCCOB
B
niIHaMIIKe,
A
Mapwann
onpaDIILluaJl
HCnOnbJOBaIlHC
Koa3HCTaTH'ICCIGIX
MonMcli
TeM,
'ITO
"H311I
aHaJJHl
uce
ClllC
npefiLl-
BaeT
0
Mn3)leH'ICCKOM
B03paCTC".
BaJKHOe
3tJa'ICHIIC
H3Y'lCHHIO
COUH3J1bHO-3KOHOMH'ICCKHX
npo-
ueccoo
B .D,HHBMHKC
npHna03J1
H
H.KoHJlpaTbCB,
OTKPblBlllHlIlIJIHHHblC
OOJlHbl B
3KOHOMIIKC.
nplI
3TOM OH
ocofio
Bbl)lCJIJIJI
nporn03bl
TCH-
.D,cHuHII
COUH3J1bIl0-3KOHOMU'ICCKHX
npoueccoo,
KOTOPblC
xapaKTepH-
3YlOTClI
npHHUlmH3J1bHOil
HpperynllptlOCTblO,
T.e.
npoTCKalOT
"6e3
BCIIKol!
onpenenclIHoA
npaBllJlbHOCTH".
B ::lTOM CJIY4ae
.....
caMoe
fiOJlbllICC,
'ITO
MOJKCT
.D,BTb
IIMCIOIllCCCR
3HaHIIC
COuHanbHO-
,--
,
&tdtHUI'
18
J81(OHOMepHocrell
npH
HpperyJlIlPHOCTH
caMoro
:JICOHOIolJl'/CCICllX
co6
L
---A
-:no
yCTBHoBlleHHe TeH.lleHUHII, 6J1aro_
IIII:MOro
..
,n,
nptJlCIWY
H-~poT
He 6J1aronpHIITCTlIYIOIUHX OOJIfHKIfO_
_............,WHX
MM,
IIUUV
,
Ul"""'-··'~~
Ho
OHO
He
MOlleT
.QlITb
OCHOB3HHII
f!RA
JlOKaJlHJaIlHH
IICHJIIO
co6WTMA
paHCTBC"
TeM
He
MeHee
npe.llCllbi
3T1f
lie
ero
JO
IIICMCHH
H
n':'~IIWHM'
OHH
paCWHpAlOTCA
no
Mepe
po_
npr.ac:tUIUIKrTCa
tfIHeM
NA
-"
TeM
caMbI~
H.KOH.llpaTbCB
npe.llBoeXHlUan
CTI
......
HOro
3M
.
II
-I
.ocn.
HCCJleJlOIl8HHA
KatfeCTBCHHOro nOllC.lleHHA IoI0.llClle ,
KO-
IJCIYUWI
06--"""
HCOlllIJIaHHble cBOIICToa H3y'faelolOro
npo-
TIJIIIoIe
MOfY1'
..... 1-···
III'CI2
nOClle,lHJle
roAM
nOJl)"lHJJH
HOllbill
HMnyJlbC
pa6arbl
no
8H3-
B
ecItJIX
(nepexo.llH
bIX
)
npoucccoB
3KOHOlolHKH Ha
OCHOBe
=-
3trHr1JacIIOM
3THX
pa60T
BnOJlHe
MOllHO
6b111o
6b1
an
CIIQYIDIIIJIe
CIIOII3:
")Kx:nn,
- :no nOCTOllHHOC pa3BHTHe, BCtfH3A
~,
a ncpHOJllol CTB6I1JJ108UHH -
JlHWb
Kp8TIOIe
OCTaIlOB-
D
HI
3TOM
nyTH".
npl!
IlHIIIIHlC pa3BHB3IOWHXCA COUH8JJbHO-3KO-
lIOIOI'IecDX
nponcccoll
6oJn.DJ0A
npaKTHtfccKHA
HHTepec
npe.llCT8B-
MeT
IDJ'ICIfHC
nOllCACHHA nepeMeHHbIX MO.llCIIH B 38BHCHMOCTH
OT
jMMii4HbIX BHeWHHlI
BO:IoIICIICTBHA
H CBA38HHblA C 3THM
BOnpoc
ycNl,HIIOCTII
pIIIHOlICCIfbIX
peweHHA
no
OTHoweHHIO
K
COOTBCT-
Cii)lOiiUDll103MJlllCHlUill,
H,
CJJeAOlllTCllbHO,
no
OTHoweHHIO
K HCJa-
n'RllPiII8HHIDI
Jl3llelteHHAII
II
pelIHIIe
ynpaBlieHHA
Pe3yJi&'JIIJ'OI(
TIXiIX
JICCIIe4OIJ8HHA
IIB1iAIOTCJI
pupa60TKa
CDoe-
4
11
iIiiiIX
peKDiIICIWIOIA
no
npeAOTllpaWCHHiO
B03HHKaiOwero
He-
WOi."i
...
II
CiPJICTYPC
pacaaI1'pHiIICMoA
CRCTeMbI,
onpellClleHHe
MOIICIIia IIOIII.aHIIJI
CIIcn:_
B
lCpH1'H'Iec:JCyJO
06JJacn..
HccneAOII8-
- 3ICDH01OI'IecKHX CllCTeM
Ha
ycroAtfHiIOCTb
no-
•
lIer
apoIIlIIPWpOIIarb,
HallpllMep,
MOMCHT
38MeHbl
crapoA
'mOIO-
....
-IIOIYiO,
CIIOCol6::'.,.ib
iI03HHJCJIOIeHHIO
HONX
TeXHOJIorMA
I,..
HiM
c:npMI,
IIiiIn.
JIll"
~CCJCOro
nporpecca.
Ka
==.=I11III,
.,. H
4J0pMuwt0-1flII'CMaTH'ICCKHA
aHBliH3
•
iU
CWiiW
IIOUT
11m. JJpOIJIe,UH I TejJMIIJI8X
CHHCPreTJOOi
-
W •
P""'*iiipiiUllIIJDI.
..........
cpuHII'I'UWIO
He.uBHO H
..
wut......
upw""......
....,...H
H c:8MOOPI'IJIII3
,.
n AI
__
CJaI«* • -HItHbIx areaarrJI'Iec:KIIX
MOJIMel.
Ca
*fiII-
".,
OCIIOIIDIM K8'ICC1IIeJlJllOl
no-
f.
niiiwu, JUII MifOI'IIX IIpOIUICCOI pIi3IHTHlI.
4' i I
....
m •
...
a c
~
n04-
• -
II
........
ITIM.
lIOI'"ilnlCtOl
c
_lima
CHHiDpCiJl1le-
-ttw
Ie
_WiCA
cIoVo4.,......
..............
VniOl
1M
';"HU
~
--
19
(nO)lCHCTeM) OIC8JblB8eTtIl, 'fTO )lilJl
pa
B1f1lB1O
/Jf)(
Ii
IfCTeM
u~
HhI, C OJl/IOA CTOPOllbl, YCToA'lHIIOCTI. r:-rpyIOyp'" a e.:Ipyrotl IJOTqM
YCTolI"HIIOCTH,
paJpylIJelOle
oMolI
C"TpyKrypW H
HMC
JIpyroI
YCTolI'lHIIOIi CTJlYKTYpbl R
pe
symmrre
npoll
PIOlII!THJf
1fCTe
....
NO-
lICeT
IiblTh
npe.llCTaMeH
KaJC
nocne
~
HOCTb
'110
IOUJlotfHOf'O
ID-
MeHellHA
ec
COCTOIIHHII fllfYTJ!H
IlH
co
IKoofipaJHY"
IIepelIO,!Iow
cHCTelol'" II KOHue
IlHlCJJa
Ha
Hon",11 K
'I
HHYI!
)'poIJeH.
0ltI8'aIJi)-
II1HII
Ha'/ano
HOOOTO
/tHlCJJa.
CYUICCTBellHO, 'ITO
"mepyc-r
A,M
•
CH
CTeMa
JC
palBHTHIO
lie
cnoco6l1a,
noclCO
rcy
OHa
racHT"
IlI06we
0T1UI0-
IIeHHA
OT
CBOero
YCTolI"HlIOro
COCTOIIHKJI
nrnrowy
4IIIi
pe:JIStnIJI
nepexo.na B lC8'/CCTBellIlO IIOBOe
COCTOIIIIH
CHCTCMa
roota
III
IteJCO-
TDpoe BpeMA nOTepATb )'CToA'lHBOCTb C
CTBHe
..
WSICJJ~
..,.
BHTHlI
(c
nepccKOKOIoI B KOHite
ws""a
IIa
KB'lCCTBeHHO
HOlY.
ypua
...
,
IIBIIAeTCA
lle06pa
I
HMOCTb,
ICDTOpaA
JaX.iYlO'IaeTClI
II
He~
nepexo.na
OT
HOooo6paJoBaHHOA CTp)'JC1)'pW K
crapoA
pcipJ'WClSJIOI
CTp)'lC1}'pe. TBKHM
06paJOw,
"Heo6pa.HMOCTb,
1U
&e
Dk
"ycroIt'lHIIOCTb"
H "nOTepA YCToA'lHIIOCTH"
ABllAc:TCII
X3pIJC1qJIIc:no
JlJ060A pa3B1fll8lOwcllCII CHCTt:W",
K KOHuenUHH CTJlYKTYPHoA YCToli'lHBOCTH 6
IIJU
1COpU
iii!
$YPKBUHIt,
a TaJGl(e
ee
COBpeMeHIWI nonY1IJIpIWI
8epeNA
1WpidI
1ClIT8CTJlOCI>.
~
TCOpHA paccW3Tp1fll8eT IIOnpoc 06 YCJiOIIID
DpII
sco-
TopblX
H3MeHeHHe napaMeTpOB IIeJJHHeAHOA
CHCTe_
/IIoI3WIae1' ncpe-
MeLUeHHe TO'IKH
II
cjJa:JollOM
npoc,paHCTIC,
xapaJCTepJiJ~.
coc
....
-
IIHe
CHCTeMbI, H3
06J1l1CTH
nplSTlDl:eHHA K Ha'SlnbHOMy
~
paBHOIICCHA II
06JJaCTb
npsu
IIDtu:HHA K
JiPYI'OMY
nOJlOlleHlOO
,.
ID_
CHA.
nOCJJellHec
oqem
II8lIHO
He
TOJDoKO
4IIIi
_
IfiHa.
'a'
CRCTeM,
HO
H
.IIJilI
DOHHMIUIJIJI
ycrol'llnloc:ns
C01lJSUWSO-__
Ie
KHX
nponeccoll
.
B :noR
CiIII3H
Dpe.llCTllIllWOJ
tone,..
."W1",
B
M.Avrm.
0
3Ha'leHHH
HCCIICAOIIUIJIJI HeJUlHeIbaa MQIICJieI
.....
ynpel.
B
XHHJ'C
"TeopHA
U1'IC'I'JJ04I",
~
11990 r
011,
I
'lIB-
HOCTH,
nHmer.
" HbIJIeWJWI
ncpecipoltD
10
_011
01+
I"
TeM,
'ITO
H8'IBIiH
Mlci.,..J.
lIDJlI
6w
HelWiq_
-.-...
..
._
HoA
CIIII3H
(1Ioatu. JIII'lHOJ'O
ytIII'mIlICHU)
npH
310M TpyllHOCTH apo6rJcM
ncpeclpoba
B M ••• _
...
~
3JiI
.....
C
oe
IfCllIIHelHOc:IWO,
IC.IIqI:iIIIC
.1'0
npamiIJ'IIIIII
......
ynpaJllCJlU,
IJPM
KOropYll
pc3)'JDoTUY
~
ewy,.
'MH,
1YI'
nepoclam
.IIdenoaan,
H
JJOmIMy
IIyaJIO
-.peI5
I-F'.
CIII-
I.lB4IH'IOCIaI ~1HyJO HHr)'JUUUO,
0CH0IIHJIyiD
III
lIOII
III
.....
40KCIJJWDIX
"'GO"
HCIDIJIeIHoa
NOpIfII
'XIs
II
_ iii.'."
...
iCDrOpMC
IIpOCIeIwllc
U'IecneJIJIWe
........
JetljiliM
.....
ii
II
n~
it
1fUJIJIdHo.
caeie..
_
'C
..
'H.'''",
'clol
......
COCI08Dfll.
lIP"
'+W
....
''"''.
l1l:I
• •
..,
......
"..,.MD
1M
·'seCIa...,
....
DIMI'
H,.,8=
•
,,'AD>
_
ceeNiiiHD
c:JWi
....
8m
MIl
......