The Binomial Theorem, which gives the expansion of , was known to Chinese mathe-
maticians many centuries before the time of Newton for the case where the exponent k is a
positive integer. In 1665, when he was 22, Newton was the first to discover the infinite series
expansion of when k is a fractional exponent (positive or negative). He didn’t publish
his discovery, but he stated it and gave examples of how to use it in a letter (now called the
epistola prior) dated June 13, 1676, that he sent to Henry Oldenburg, secretary of the Royal
Society of London, to transmit to Leibniz. When Leibniz replied, he asked how Newton had
discovered the binomial series. Newton wrote a second letter, the epistola posterior of Octo-
ber 24, 1676, in which he explained in great detail how he arrived at his discovery by a very
indirect route. He was investigating the areas under the curves from 0 to x for
, 1, 2, 3, 4, . . . . These are easy to calculate if n is even. By observing patterns and inter-
polating, Newton was able to guess the answers for odd values of n. Then he realized he could
get the same answers by expressing as an infinite series.
Write a report on Newton’s discovery of the binomial series. Start by giving the statement of
the binomial series in Newton’s notation (see the epistola prior on page 285 of [4] or page 402
of [2]). Explain why Newton’s version is equivalent to Theorem 17 on page 778. Then read
Newton’s epistola posterior (page 287 in [4] or page 404 in [2]) and explain the patterns that
Newton discovered in the areas under the curves . Show how he was able to
guess the areas under the remaining curves and how he verified his answers. Finally, explain how
these discoveries led to the binomial series. The books by Edwards [1] and Katz [3] contain
commentaries on Newton’s letters.
1. C. H. Edwards, The Historical Development of the Calculus (New York: Springer-Verlag,
1979), pp. 178–187.
2. John Fauvel and Jeremy Gray, eds., The History of Mathematics: A Reader (London:
MacMillan Press, 1987).
3. Victor Katz, A History of Mathematics: An Introduction (New York: HarperCollins, 1993),
pp. 463–466.
4. D. J. Struik, ed., A Sourcebook in Mathematics, 1200–1800 (Princeton, NJ: Princeton
University Press, 1969).
y ! &1 # x
2
'
n,2
&1 # x
2
'
n,2
n ! 0
y ! &1 # x
2
'
n,2
&a ! b'
k
&a ! b'
k
HOW NEWTON DISCOVERED THE BINOMIAL SERIES
W R I T I N G
P R O J E C T
784
|| ||
CHAPTER 12 INFINITE SEQUENCES AND SERIES
This project deals with the function
1. Use your computer algebra system to evaluate for and .
Does it appear that has a limit as ?
2. Use the CAS to graph near . Does it appear that has a limit as ?
3. Try to evaluate with l’Hospital’s Rule, using the CAS to find derivatives of the
numerator and denominator. What do you discover? How many applications of l’Hospital’s
Rule are required?
4. Evaluate by using the CAS to find sufficiently many terms in the Taylor series
of the numerator and denominator. (Use the command
taylor in Maple or Series in
Mathematica.)
5. Use the limit command on your CAS to find directly. (Most computer algebra
systems use the method of Problem 4 to compute limits.)
6.
In view of the answers to Problems 4 and 5, how do you explain the results of Problems 1 and 2?
lim
x
l
0
f &x'
lim
x
l
0
f &x'
lim
x
l
0
f &x'
x l 0fx ! 0f
x l 0f
0.0001x ! 1, 0.1, 0.01, 0.001,f &x'
f &x' !
sin&tan x' # tan&sin x'
arcsin&arctan x' # arctan&arcsin x'
AN ELUSIVE LIMIT
CAS
L A B O R A T O R Y
P R O J E C T