
582 NATIONALIST CHINA, 1937-1945
sharply reduced;
and
civilian casualties
and
property damage were
enormous.
85
Despite
the
manifest deterioration
of
the Nationalist army
by
1944,
assessments
of
its achievements during the war have varied widely.
Ho
Ying-ch'in, long-time minister
of
war, for example, has claimed that his
forces fought
22
campaigns, 1,117 important engagements, and 38,931
small engagements against the Japanese. The Communists, he claimed, by
contrast' did not move a soldier against the enemy'. General Wedemeyer
similarly insisted that '
the
Nationalist Government
of
China,
far
from
being reluctant
to
fight as pictured
by
Stilwell and some
of
his friends
among the American correspondents, had shown ama2ing tenacity and
endurance
in
resisting Japan', whereas
'no
communist Chinese forces
fought
in
any of the major engagements of the Sino-Japanese war'.
86
It is assuredly true that, on a number of occasions, the Nationalist forces
fought heroically against the Japanese. Three times
at
Changsha (once
in 1939 and twice
in
1941) the forces
of
General Hsueh Yueh resisted
large-scale Japanese assaults.
At
Ch'ang-te, Hunan,
in
November-
December 1943,
the
57th Division
of
the Central Army fought with
extreme determination, suffering casualties
of
fully 90 per cent. And
in
western Hupei
in
1943, against
one of
Japan's so-called rice-bowl
campaigns,
the
Chinese lost some 70—80,000 men
as
against 3-4,000
casualties for the Japanese.
87
Critics
of
the Nationalists have tended
to
minimize these instances
of
heroism and combativeness. They claim,
for
example, that the brilliant
defence
of
Hengyang
in
June-August 1944 was undertaken
by a
non-
Central Army commander, Hsueh Yueh, despite obstructions
of the
Chungking government; and that, in the rare instances when the Nation-
alists took the offensive, it was because Chiang Kai-shek needed propaganda
to convince Allied leaders that the China theatre warranted more material
aid. The Communists, moreover, have ridiculed the Nationalist claims
to
belligerence against the Japanese, asserting that, until the Ichigo campaign,
fully
84 per
cent
of the
Japanese troops were concentrated against
Communist forces and only 16 per cent against the Nationalists.
88
Stilwell,
85
In
Kwangsi,
for
example, losses
in
the war
(most
of
which were sustained during
the
Ichigo
campaign) were reportedly 110,000 persons killed, 160,000 wounded, 300,000 houses destroyed,
80.000 head of ploughing oxen killed. Hsin-min-pao (New people's press), 20 Mar. 1946, in
Chinese
Press Review (Chungking), hereafter
CPR, 8
(21 Mar. 1946),
6.
86
Ho
Ying-ch'in, 'Chi-nien ch'i-ch'i k'ang-chan tsai
po
Chung-kung
ti
hsu-wei hsuan-ch'uan'
(Commemorating the Sino-Japanese War and again refuting the Communists' false propaganda),
T^u-ju
cbung
(Freedom's bell), 3.3 (20 Sept. 1972), 26; Wedemeyer, 279 and 284.
87
Israel Epstein, The
unfinished revolution
in China, 311; Gauss
to
State,
'
Observations by
a
Chinese
newspaper correspondent',
p. 1.
88
Warren
I.
Cohen, 'Who fought the Japanese
in
Hunan? Some views
of
China's war effort',
JAS
27.1 (Nov. 1967), in—15; Dorn, 321—2; Epstein,
Unfinished
revolution,
312;
Li
I-yeh, Cbung-kuo
Cambridge Histories Online © Cambridge University Press, 2008