Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
41
!'$&!-E&!&" +$ C"!?A!@! H+* '!J*$A H*$
!#+J%" &"E!&"! ! D+!!&#$& +,.
%% !'$&!-E&!&= +$"& &"?;$A !'$&-
!-E&!&" +$ D" #E%C"?A' #$$*#!' — "#
'" # . %@*?$!" !'$&!-E&!&"
+$ EF';$A# C"!?A' H+!' +, &"E!&"! !
T+!* +, «K! D# %J&!, %@*?$!!, E!?"$+ *
#%" @!#E!#A+!, "?A!#$"» $ T+!* +, «K! C"!-
?AF H+ +,». T@"! D" #$$$%; 1 T+!* +, «K!
D# %J&!, %@*?$!!, E!?"$+ * #%" @!#E!#A+!,
"?A!#$"» E" %@*?$!' !'$&!-E&!&' +$!' !D*-
'"I$A# EF$F *E!&!&J%' %@*?$!' !@!' !-
'$&!-E&!&F +$, +F H! !+%'" E!?!J% +!@! #E'!-
&" E&!&% %@*?;& @!#E!#A+= &"!#, $+!J
'""#$$&= &"!# '"J %@*?$!' !@' H! "-
R' !@' %J&!, &? $ #*H’I+$' @!#E!;&.
T&%$I'! *&@* $%, M! &"E!&"! ! #$$$" 3 &+D!@! T+!-
* F!@! &'!@ E!R;;$A# ?R% $" +$ , +" #E'!-
&" &+! ' *+C"F, &D<%= E*+$' 4, 6, 7, 9,
11 " 17 #$$$" 7 T+!* +, «K! C"!?AF H+ +,-
», " ';$A !D+ %@*?$!= +$"&.
%!H="! &=!&*&$, M! &+D' T+!!' &#$!&?%!
!#!H?&!#$" E"@!$!&+, EF$$ $ !E?;% E&!&=
+$"& , +" ';$A !D+ %@*?$!=. +, D@"! D" #$$$%;
12 %@*?$!" +$, EF$" C"!?A' H+!' +, $
F!@! E!#!&' !#!H', !"C"F! !E?;;;$A# & «"-
C"F!'* &"#+*» $ * @D%$" «!&F +*’I» % E"D"R + *
%#$%F #$!+ E"#? ,= %J&!, %I#$C", H! EF$$
$ E"E# * &E+*, +M! C" %@*?$!" +$ % E"?@;$A
%J&"F %I#$C",.
K!#$!&!; H"%$* ""#$"& +, $ C"!?A' H-
+!' +, &" 14 +&"$ 2004 . - 471 D$&%J%! '%$!+
E!&%% ?"D* &E?&* $ &"#$%J% %D*?A$$&!#$" %-
@*?$!!@! +$ C"!?A!@! H+* +,.
K+?' %@*?$!= +$"& I, D!+%', K!?!J%
E! E!!+ &<" H+' H+"&#A+= ?"C%D"F, E#A'!&= !-
D&!?"& $ ?"C%D"F &+! !+%'= !E%C"F, D$&%J%%
E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, &" 17 ?E-
2001 !+* - 275, K!?!J% E! E!!+ &<" ?"C%D",
D"F#% !+%'= H+"&#A+= !E%C"F %H+"&#A+' "-
#!&' *#$!&', D$&%J%% E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!-
?A!@! H+* +, &" 16 #%E 2001 . - 344, K!?!J%
. .
42
E! E!!+ &<" "&"*?A= ?"C%D"F E%%+D*&
"!D%'!, &?;$ D '%J" +, ? !E?$ H+"&#A+= '%$-
?"& $ E!&%% !+%'= &?;$= !E%C"F, D$&%J%% E!#-
$!&!; K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, &" 17 <%&
2004 . - 266.
%!H="! D&%*$ *&@*, M! E+$C" ';$A '"#C% &E-
+ EF$$ #E"?A= +$"& D E$A H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$" -
H"%$!' ""#$"& +, $ C"!?A' H+!' +,. [+
E+? '!J &%#$ E!#$!&* H"%$* ""#$"& +, "
C"!?A!@! H+* +, &" 14 +&"$ 2004 . -471 «K!
D$&%J% '%$!+ E!&%% ?"D* &E?&* $ &"#$%J%
%D*?A$$&!#$" %@*?$!!@! +$ C"!?A!@! H+* +-
,». *'+* .!$;+, !'$&!-E&!&" +$ D E$A, M!
#$!&?$A &DI'F "$%%# " ?%J$A ! +!'E%$%C", H"%$*
""#$"& +,, '""#$%#$&, "R= !@"& &+!&<!, &?
$ C%$?A!@! H+*, E!&" !D!H?$# D"$%%#!&'
!@!' " E!@!J*&$#A D C"!?A' H+!' +, H%D
EF$$ #E"?A!@! D ' !'$&!-E&!&!@! +$
44
.
5
1. +"&#A+% E&! — C% +!'E?%+#F '"J@?*D%&F E&!&F "-
#$$*$, +F &+?;<I E&!&" !', M! %@*?;;$A &"!#, +" &-
+;$A * E!C%#" D"F#% H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$".
2. +"&#A+% D+!!&#$&! — C% +!'E?%+# @?*DA D+!!&#$&,
+ &+?;<I #*+*E"#$A !'$&!-E&!&= +$"&, M! %@?'%$*;$A
&"!#, +" &+;$A * E!C%#" D"F#% H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$".
3. K%'%$!' H+"&#A+!@! E&
I H+"&#A+" E&!&"!# — &%-
@*?A!&" !'' E& &"!#, +" &+;$A * #%" H+"&#A+!,
"?A!#$", #'% * E!C%#" *E&?" H+"&#A+!; ##$%'!;, D"F#%-
$+= !E%C"F, + EF' &+?"& (%E!D$"&) &" ;<= $
"D<= !#"H, &"+$$ $ &%% E!$!<= =*+"& +?"I$"& " H+"&-
+!%#E!%$"&, * $!'* <#?" E%%+D @!R!&= +!R$"& D
C= =*+"& D
!E!'!@!; E?$"J= "#$*'%$"& $ D=*& +!R$"& =, !D-
'"M% D?*<%= +!R$"& &" #&!@! "'%", &?#= *'!&= $ &?#-
F D+, $+!J D"F#% "R= !E%C"F E"#$&" &!, C"!-
?A' H+!' +, ?"C%D", H! !+%'!@! !D&!?*.
4. ! #E"?A= !D+ H+"&#A+= E&!&"!# '!J &"%#$:
x
+% ,= * #%" H+"&#A+!, "?A!#$";
44
=' . $. C"!?AF H+ — C%$ H+"&#A+!, ##$%' +,. @"-
DC"F!-E&!&F ?"D. — .: &<F "' « N%». — . 63.
43
x "I; #$!!!; H+"&#A+= E&!&"!# D&J I "#!-
&F E!#%%+ — C%$?AF H+ %J& < "RF H+ H! %H-
+"&#A+ "#!& *#$!&.
H!&’D+!&' #*H’I+$' H+"&#A+= E&!&"!# I:
x C"!?AF H+ +,;
x "R" H+;
x %H+"&#A+" "#!&" *#$!&, +" E"#$&" !D&!?* '-
;$A E&! D"F#;&$ E%&" H+"&#A+" !E%C",
.
5. ? H+"&#A+!@! E& I =+$%' +!'E?%+#F '%$! E&!-
&!@! %@*?;&, +F E!I*I & #!H" "'E%$&F '%$! ('%$! &?-
= EE#"&) $ #E!D$&F '%$! ('%$! "&!#$" #$!").
6. ! J%%? H+"&#A+!@! E& +, &"!#$A#:
1) !#$$*C" +,;
2) "R% !#$$*C"F!@! ** +,;
3) '"J!" !@!&! +,;
4) D+! +,:
x
D@?A" D+!;
x #E%C"?A" D+!.
5) E"D+!" !'$&!-E&!&" +$:
x E!#$!& %=!&!, +,;
x *+D K%D%$ +,;
x %+%$ H"%$* ""#$"& +,;
x E!#$!& H"%$* ""#$"& +,;
x E!#$!& K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +,.
6. !+?A" +$ H+"& $ %H+"&#A+= "#!&= *#$!&.
7. "J!!-E&!&" D&<,.
$&$+, /!
1. # $"! "'! $
!* $?
2. < $"*'! " -
!* $?
3. ="' !* $.
4. # % , *"'! !-
"!!, $ <?
5. $ «! $-
».
6. # !0 $ &
? $ 0
?
7. # % < '!
! "! <?
8. ! "%' &" !*
$.
. .
44
9. # % &" !* $-
'! -$ %-
"!* <?
/!$ &$)'$%$( +&"&!
" =. =. ;; ; . — (.: ?%". %;., 1975. —
264 .
: 7. =. $% ; . — ., 1952.
D. :. . #$ % ;%$ %. —
(.: !"- )*, 1994. — 360 .
/0 5. 6. + : A% "D ;". @%". ; .
. %F. $. !". — .: ;DD, 2002. — 222 .
+ ;D "G% : $. . / *" .(., *K-
$% . ., % . . ; . / ". . . *K$%. — ;.
%". — *.: ?%' =;, 1999. — 320 .
E. .+ #/%: $+% %. —
L: *, 2000. — 464 .
. . + : $. . — *.: M, 2004. — 320
.
' . . + : $. . — 2- %"., -
. ". — *.: (#A, 2000. — 240 .
' . D. +% — ; +/ %;'% #/-
%. !-% !. — *.: %"%$% C' «= ?». —
248 .
F% . :., 6( +. +., & . ., )( 7. .
: #$
. % / H;. . N. %. — H;
C, 2003.
FD ;%D % ";: #$% / A" ". . . -
!. — 2- %!"., . % ". — (.: ?%;J, 1996. — 472 .
FD ;%D : #$% "D @%"%$%& ! / C'%;%-
C. ., *!+'% . I., ! . . % ".; A" F. ".
.. A%%-
. — 2- %!"., %. % ". — (.: !"- (# %'. . P. ', 1995.
— 384 .
"' . 8. + %;' #/%. A !"% !/.
— *.: ?' =;, 2003. — 240 .
"' . 8. ;%$ %;D + + !-
";. — *.: ?' =;, 2003. — 104 .
%D "; %
. * % / A" ". . . (;! %
. . (+. — (.: ?%;J, 1997. — 672 .
%D "; % : #$% "D @%"%$%& ! % >-
+;; / A" ". . (. *+ % . C. A. — (.: !"-
;+D IH-(-H(, 1997. — 570 .
9 :. ., " . ., ;" .
+. H-
% I"%%. FD $;+: #$% / A" F. ". ". ..
%. — (.: ?%;J, 1999. — 448 .
Gavalda C., Stoufflet J. Droit de la banque. Paris, 1974. — P. 6.
45
3
6
§ 1. $&!? $$%! *%,$( !)!.
§ 2. $&!? /! *%,$( !)! &(!.
§ 3. $ +' *%,$( !)! &(!.
§ 4. $ %!'! *%,!= $*’@',.
§ 1. &'
+"&#A+ ##$%' H*A-+!, %J& — C% #*+*E"#$A
H+"&#A+= *#$!&, +" #$&!%" $ ";$A $%$!", &"E!&"-
!, %J& D@"! D ,, D+!!&#$&!' * #%" D?*<% @!R!-
&= +!R$"& #%?% $ ;<= !#"H, +%$"& $ &%-
% =*+"& +?"I$"&.
KF$! !D"D$ !!- $ &!"&%&* H+"&#A+" ##$%'.
!"&%& H+"&#A+ ##$%' E%%H<I E%%&J! @!D!-
$?A" D&’D+ '"J H+', *"&%#?"DC"; ,= !E%C"F " *+-
C"F. '%J= $+!, ##$%' &#" +%$" *#$!&, * $!'* <#?"
C%$?AF H+, D=!$A# !!'* "I="<!'* "&", &-
+!*;< ?!@"<" *+C", * +%$!-!D=*+!&!'* !H#?*-
@!&*&" +?"I$"&. %F ECE E!H*!& =+$%F, @!?!&'
<!', ? +, D %!D&*$!; %+!!'"+!;, $+!J ? +, D
'""#$$&!-+!'!; E!H*!&!; E$* *E&?"
45
.
[#+&' E+?!' H+"&#A+!, ##$%' CA!@! $E* H*? H-
+"&#A+ ##$%' #A+!@! !;D*.
&!"&%& H+"&#A+ ##$%' H**I$A# &DI'!&"!R%=
'"J H+' * &!= E?!M= — E! &%$+?" $ E! @!D!$?". K!
&%$+?" — &"!# E"?%@?!#$" '"J C%$?A' H+!' + +%-
"&', +%*;<' $ D!&' ?+' — +!'%C"F' H+';
E! @!D!$?" — &"!# "&!@! E$%#$& '"J H*A-+'
D!&' ?+'. !DE!"? '""#$$&= *+C"F " !E%C"F,
45
+!&#+!% %?! / K! %. N.. H<%&!F. — .: w+!!'+, 1994. — 397 #.
. .
46
E!&’D= D !H#?*@!&*&' C%$?A' H+!' @!R!&!@! !H"-
@*, I '!J?&"#$A &=*&$ "$%%# &!= +$%@!"F +?"I$"& —
+!'%C"F= H+"& " *!&= #$*+$*, E<!'* E%%&@ &"-
I$A# *+C"' «H+ H+"&» $ *E&?"; "?A"#$; H+"&#A-
+= *#$!& D '%$!; %@*?;& F +!$!?; D *+C"!*&'
+* +%$!-"#!&= E!#?*@. &!"&%&"F #$*+$*" H+"&-
#A+!, ##$%' E!&" <"$+! !D"D$# !'$&!-%@*?;;<" $
+!$!?A" *+C", C%$?A!@! H+*, D !!@! H!+*, " *+C",
+!'%C"F= H+"& D "R!@!
46
. &!"&%& H+"&#A+ ##$%' E-
$' +,' D !D&*$!; +!&!; %+!!'"+!;.
?"D*;< !@"DC"; H+"&#A+= ##$%' D="= %J& D
!D&*$!; %+!!'"+!;, ="&C" "FR? &#!&+* M!! $A!= !#-
!&= E'"& !D&$+* $+= ##$%' $ ,= #+?!&=:
1) H+"&#A+" ##$%' D &%?+!; +"?A+"#$; H+"& D %H@$A' &"-
"?%' (unit banking); 2) H+"&#A+" ##$%' D %&%?+!; +"?A+"#-
$; H+"& "D H@$A' &""?%' (branch banking); 3) H+"&#A+"
##$%' D H@$A' H+', E!&’D' *<#$; (chain banking)
47
.
%!H="! DD<$, M! & *C" "#*I #+*#" M!! #E"&&"-
!R% E!$A «H+"&#A+ ##$%'» $ «"#!&!-+%$
##$%'». %+" &$! &+?;<;$A ! H+"&#A+!, ##$%' $+!J
" "R" "#!&!-+%$" *#$!& (+%$" #E"?+, "&%#$C"F-
" !, !&"<" $!&#$&, ?!'H $ ".)
48
. K!$%, R*
*'+*, H"?AR !H_*$!&!; I E!DC" $= ="&C"&, +" &&J-
;$A, M! DD<%" ##$%' % I #!"''
49
. L"#!&!-
+%$ ##$%' $ H+"&#A+ ##$%' #E"&&"!#$A# + D@-
?A% $ <#$+!&%, $!H$! !#$ I <#$!; E%R!,.
§ 2. '
$
$
%((
46
< <. %=+ H+!&#+!@! %?. — .: 1994. — . 15—16.
47
#!&` D+!!$%?A#$& +E$?#$<%#+= #$ ! H+!&#+!F ##$%'%. — .:
#$$*$ D+!!$%?A#$& #&$%?A!@! E&!&%% E L, 1992. — . 4.
48
%. . !''%<%#+F H+ & #!&%'%!F !##: $%! E+$+. —
., 1996. — . 29.
49
&' &. ". +"&#A+ ##$%' +,. K&!&" D# !@"DC",. — .: N"-
+!' $%, 2003. — . 33.
47
+," H+"&#A+ "?A"#$A !DE!<?# & #%%"
UVIII #$., ,, !D&$!+ &"H*&&# &!!<# "D #$!&?%' H-
+"&#A+!, ##$%' !#",. !@"&? &%?# D @!$"&+*, E!'#?!-
&"#$A !D&&?#A E%%&J! D =*!+ %J&. +," E!-
R% +!'%C"F!@! +%$* #*$$I&! DE"D;&?!# E!"&!
"D T="!; V&!E!;. K%R' E!D<?A+' H*? * $
D%'?%&?#+, !?A +%$!"& &""@&? !!!#!H!&" E"E-
I'C"-?=&". *'!&= $*?A!@! E!'"MCA+!@! @!#E!-
#$& $+ "?A"#$A &? '!J?&"#$A H%D+!$!?A! E""'$
&"#!$!+ D +%$. "' $!@!, *E!!&J 1769—1774 . !#" &-
E*#$? & !H"@ EE%!&" @!R" — #@C", #*'* 20 '? *H.
#% C% #E?! #$&!%; +D%= H+"& $ H+"&#A+= +!$!
* E!&"C",, +" '? '" &!#+!?$ @!R!&F !H"@ & "'E%",
$ &? E!D+.
1754 . H*? D#!&" E%R" &!#A+" H+ & K%$%H*D"
$ !#+&". +!R$ @!'#A+!#$" $ E!J%$&*& E&$=
!#"H #$&!;&?# '"#A+" H+. 1781 . & "J", U+!&"
D’&?#A E%R" H+"&#A+" +!$!
50
.
E+"C" XVIII #$. * I&" H*?! #$&!%! !'#A+* +!-
'"#";, +!$ E&= H+* EF'? &+? $ D"F#;&?
+%$*&. T 1810 . & +," E!<? D’&?$# H+, D-
#!&" !@' '"#C%&!@! #'!&*& H! '%C%$'.
K%R" E&$" +%$" *#$!& &+;$A $*$ * 30-= .
UU #$. = D#!&+ — &"!'" +*EC" $ E!'#?!&C": E!?+
@*R+, CA+", !H#A+", *+,C" [=%+ $ '-
%+. K!& $+= H+"& E!#;&?# %#E!'!J"#$;
%J&= *#$!& D!&!?A$ E!$%H &#"= HJ;<= &
!$'" E!D+. " *#$!& '? %&%?+" D !D'"!' +E"-
$?, $!" + !D&$!+ +E"$?"#$<= &"!# E!$%H*&&
D<= +!R$"& ? @!#E!;& E!-!&!'*. "$+ E!-
@%#&" @!#E!" DE!<$+!&*;$A * #&!,= 'I$+= &?#" +%-
$" D+?
51
. $"', E!R% &! H*? ?R% E"#? E-
F$$ * ?;$!'* 1862 . «K!?!J% E! '"#A+" @!'#A+"
H+». $&!;&?# $+" H+ D !D&!?* ""#$%#$& "-
#"& E '"#A+= *'=. ;< +%$ '"#A+' " D%'#A-
50
=' &. %. +"&#A+% E&!: &<. E!#"H. — 2-@% &., E%%!H. " !E. —
.: K, 2000. — . 22.
51
) . $&!% $ "?A"#$A H+"&#A+= *#$!& K&!H%%J"F
+," * *@"F E!?!&" UU #$. — ., 1997. — . 11.
. .
48
+' *E&', $+!J '"#C%&' +*EC', C" H+ D!H? &-
@!'F &%#!+ * !D&$!+ %+!!'"+
52
.
24 $& 1839 . *+D!' "'E%$! +!? * I&" D#!-
&*I$A# '"#C%& +!$! +!'%C"F!@! H+*. +D!' &" 31 $&-
1860 . H*& #$&!%F %J&F H+ !#",, +F DF'&#
%'"#"I; +%$= H"?%$"& " +!'%C"F' !E%C"'. CA!'* J
!C" %J&F H+ !#"F#A+!, "'E%", D#*&& #&!, +!$! *
I&", U+!&" $ %#", $+!J &""?% * K!?$&". 1862 .
+%*;<' ,&#A+!; +!$!!; #$& +!? *@%, +F D@!!'
H& H%DE!#%%; *<#$A * D#*&" & I&" H"J", E%R!@!
E&$!@! +!'%C"F!@! H+* " $!&#$& &DI'!@! +%$*,
+!$% !<!?& 1868 .
53
.
1862 . H*?! &! E%RF !'$&!-E&!&F +$, +F
D+!!&<! &%@*?;&& "?A"#$A H+"&#A+= *#$!&. T@"! D
C' !+*'%$!' H+ '& E&!:
x EF'$ &+? E" &"#!$+;
x &$ E!D+ E" D#$&* C"= EE%"&;
x &&$ %E!D$" +&$C", E%&" #*';
x D"F#;&$ !E%C", D !H?"+* &%+#%?"& $ C"= EE%"&.
T#" E&?" H+* &"H*&?!# ! D $J%A *
#+?" +%*;<!@!, F!@! D#$*E+"&, R%#$ %+$!"&, $A!= %-
E*$$"& &" %J&= +%$= *#$!&. E&?" &#"'
#E&', !E%C"' $ +!$!?A D ,= &+!' E!+??#
E&?" H+*
54
.
60—70-= . UU #$. & +," #$&!;I$A# D+ &%?+= +!-
'%C"F= H+"& (&!#A+F, %?#A+F) $ ?@!J*I$A# '%-
%J !M= *#$!&, M! +*'*?;&? D!MJ% #%?%.
T’&?# +C"!%" $!&#$&, +" D"F#;&? ?!'H" !E%C",.
18 <%& 1868 . D$&%J%! #$$*$ ,&#A+!@! E&$!@! +!-
'%C"F!@! H+*. !@! D#!&+' H*? 50 !#"H, * $!'* <#?" +-
D" . @*R+!, . *H%CA+!F, @ . K!$!CA+, . %%M%+!
$ "R". + D"F#;&& R!+F #E%+$ !E%C"F, * $!'* <#?":
x !H?"+ $!@!&= &%+#%?"&;
x E!D+ $%'"!' ! 9 '"#C"&;
x !$' E?$%J"& D &%+#%?' $ "R' $%'"!&'
!+*'%$';
52
. ., *’ ;. ;., ;. ., ". ., !. ;. L"#!&!-
+%$ ##$%' +, — !#", (XVIII — XX #$.). — *': ?!H!JM, 2000. —
. 131.
53
= A. K&!&% %@*?;& "?A!#$" %+= H+"&#A+= *#$!& I-
& (UU — E!<. UU #$!?"$$) // "#+ . — #$!E 2004 . — . 51.
54
! &. %., < %. <. K&!&% %@*?;& "?A!#$" %J&!@! H+*
* UU #$. // "#+ +,#A+!, +%'", H+"&#A+!, #E&. — 2001. — . 13.
49
x E!&%% E?$%J"& * !#", $ D +!!!', % H+ '&
&?#" +!$!;
x +*E"&? $ E!J "D!'"$= %J&= " E&$=
E!C%$= EE%"&;
x &"+$$ E"E#+ %J&" $ @!'#A+" E!D+, +C",,
!H?"@C",;
x EF' #*' (% '%R= 100 *H?"&) %$%'"!&" &+?-
, E%&" $%'" " E!$!<" =*+;
x E!D+ E" #!?!-&%+#%?"
55
.
T 1866 . & *#"= @*H%"= I&!E%F#A+!, <#$ !#", (I&",
U+!&", U%#!", %"@!&", K!?$&" F $%!#?&") H*?! #$&!-
%! $!&#$& &DI'!@! E!D%'%?A!@! +%$*
56
. !" J D-
#!&*;$A# D%'%?A" H+. 28 <%& 1872 . & I&" H*?! #$&!-
%! T%'%?AF H+, D#!&+' +!@! H*? D%'?%&?#+
. !<*H%F, K. %?;CA+F, . *R%&, [. !&#A+F, . -
!@#A+F. %"&C$&! H+* #+??!# D @!?!& E&?"-
, ! #+?* +!@! #=!?! <!$ !#!H, +!$= !H? $%-
'"!' $ !+. %$!; D#*& H+* H*?!
E!D+ E" D#$&* %*=!'!, &?#!#$" * ,&#A+"F, %"@"&#A-
+"F, K!"?A#A+"F $ !?#A+"F @*H%"=. F!, &$"#$A +!-
@! D !C"+!; H+* H*? '%R!; 500 *H?"&, * D#$&* %
EF'?!#
57
.
1882 . D '%$!; +%$"& #%?' ? +*E"&?" D%'?"
#$&!%! %J&F %?#A+F E!D%'%?AF H+. #!&' F!@!
D&' H*?! !'*& +?#* "H= D%'?%&?#+"&. T 1883 .
&"+&;$A# &""?% H+* * !?#A+"F, $%!#?&#A+"F,
,&#A+"F, K!"?A#A+"F, K!?$&#A+"F, %"@"&#A+"F, U%#!#A+"F $
"R= @*H%"=. E&?? &""?%' * #+?" +%*;<!@! $
E’$ <?%"&, +" ED<?# '""#$!' "#"&.
%?#A+F E!D%'%?AF H+ &+!*&& $+" *+C",:
x EF!' " !D@? D& M!! +%$"& ? EH
D%'?";
x ?"D !+*'%$"&, E"#$&" += D"F#;&?!# +%$*&;
x +%$"& &"E!&"! ! !%J= !D&!?"&;
x @!#E!#A+% *E&?" D%'%?A' '#&', M! ?%J-
? H+*;
55
#$&d %&#+!@! #$!@! !''%<%#+!@! H+*. — %&d, 1899. — . 7—8.
56
* $. $= ! "#$!", !D&$+* +%$!, ##$%' !#"F#A+!, "'E%", //
"#+ . — 2001. — 8. — . 51.
57
E&!< +@ ? D%'M+!& ,&#A+!@! T%'%?A!@! H+, #!#$&?%
!#!& *#$& E!#$!&?%F !HM= #!HF +C!%!& H+. — %&, 1913. —
. 7—8.
. .
50
x E"@!$!&+ D%'%?A= '#&"& ! %?"DC",;
x +!$!?A D =!J%' +!R$"&, !%J*&= D -
' +%$';
x DH%DE%<% E!@R% E!#$!<%!, DH!@!&!#$";
x &+! !*<%A H+* M!! *+?% *@!
58
.
K%"! 80—90-= . UU #$. =+$%D*I$A# E%&!; #$H"?"-
DC"I; H+"&#A+!, ##$%', EF$$' * D+!!&<= +$"&,
#E'!&= ,, D'"C%, M! #E?! !'*&; * #%-
?% !&" ! H+"& $ "R= +%$= *#$!&. +, 5 +&"$
1883 . '""#$!' "#"& +!?!; *@% H*& &&%%F * ";
T+! «K! D'" $ !E!&% "#*;<= E&? &"!#! &"+-
$$ !&= +C"!%= +!'%C"F= H+"&», D 1884 . H*&
<!#$" D+! M!! *+C"!*&, E!+* #$&!% $ ?"+-
&"C", H+"&#A+= *#$!&. E"#$&" CA!@! D+!* H*?! &D-
<%! #$*+$** H+"&#A+!, ##$%', +* #+??:
x %J&" H+ (%J&F H+, D%'%?A" H+ (&!#A-
+F, #%?#A+F);
x E&$" H+"&#A+" *#$!& (+C"!%" +!'%C"F" H+,
+%$" #E"?+);
x @!'#A+" H+"&#A+" *#$!& ('"#C%&" H+, '"#C%&" ?!'-
H)
59
.
E!<$+* UU #$. ,& DF'& E!'"$% '"#C% * +%$!-
H+"&#A+"F ##$%'" !#"F#A+!, "'E%",. *$ ?"<*&?!# 10 "?"F
&%?+= D@?A!"'E%#A+= H+"&, 10 H+"&#A+= +!$! " 5
&?#% +,&#A+= H+"&. E%%!" K%R!, #&"$!&!, &"F +-
,&#A+" H+ E!&? 30 % @!?!&= !E%C"F &" D"F#;&=
*#"' H+' $!@!<#!, +,
60
.
+' <!', #$"'+F !D&$!+ %+!!'"+ " @!'J%
+E"$?"& * +," E+"C" UU #$. DH%DE%<*&? *'!& !D&-
$+* H+"&#A+!, ##$%' !#", & C"?!'* $ & +," D!+%'
61
. [+
#E&%?&! DD<I T! !'#A+, 'FJ% &#" H+, +"
"? K&!H%%JJ" * C%F E%"!, H*? "?"' !#"F#A+= "-
#!&= *#$!& ", &?#$&!, E%%H*&? * E'"F D?%J!#$" &"
!D&$+* D+!!&<!, HD, #$&!;&!, "'E%#A+!; &?!; —
'""#$%#$&!' "#"& $ "R' "#$$*C"'
62
.
58
H %., < #. %?#A+F E!D%'%?AF H+ !#"F#A+!, "'E%", // "#+
. — 2002. — - 4. — . 60.
59
* $. $= ! "#$!", !D&$+* +%$!, ##$%' !#"F#A+!, "'E%", //
"#+ . — 2001. — - 8. — . 51—52.
60
I . %&#+% H+ 100 ?%$ D… // %%@. — 2002. — -2. — . 66.
61
=' &. %. +D EC. — . 22.
62
= A. +D EC. — .53.