
Note that 30 molecules of ATP are consumed per hexose molecule formed when the C
4
pathway delivers CO
2
to the
Calvin cycle, in contrast with 18 molecules of ATP per hexose molecule in the absence of the C
4
pathway. The high
concentration of CO
2
in the bundle-sheath cells of C
4
plants, which is due to the expenditure of the additional 12
molecules of ATP, is critical for their rapid photosynthetic rate, because CO
2
is limiting when light is abundant. A high
CO
2
concentration also minimizes the energy loss caused by photorespiration.
Tropical plants with a C
4
pathway do little photorespiration because the high concentration of CO
2
in their bundle-
sheath cells accelerates the carboxylase reaction relative to the oxygenase reaction. This effect is especially important at
higher temperatures. The geographic distribution of plants having this pathway (C
4
plants) and those lacking it (C
3
plants) can now be understood in molecular terms. C
4
plants have the advantage in a hot environment and under high
illumination, which accounts for their prevalence in the tropics. C
3
plants, which consume only 18 molecules of ATP per
hexose molecule formed in the absence of photorespiration (compared with 30 molecules of ATP for C
4
plants), are
more efficient at temperatures of less than about 28°C, and so they predominate in temperate environments.
Rubisco is found in bacteria, eukaryotes, and even archaea, though other photosynthetic components have not
been found in archaea. Thus, rubisco emerged early in evolution, when the atmosphere was rich in CO
2
and
almost devoid of O
2
. The enzyme was not originally selected to operate in an environment like the present one, which is
almost devoid of CO
2
and rich in O
2
. Photorespiration became significant about 60 million years ago, when the CO
2
concentration fell to present levels. The C
4
pathway is thought to have evolved in response to this selective pressure no
more than 30 million years ago and possibly as recently as 7 million years ago. It is interesting to note that none of the
enzymes are unique to C
4
plants, suggesting that this pathway was created using existing enzymes.
20.2.4. Crassulacean Acid Metabolism Permits Growth in Arid Ecosystems
Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) is yet another adaptation to increase the efficiency of the Calvin cycle.
Crassulacean acid metabolism, named after the genus Crassulacea (the succulents), is a response to drought as well as
warm conditions. In CAM plants, the stomata of the leaves are closed in the heat of the day to prevent water loss (Figure
20.18). As a consequence, CO
2
cannot be absorbed during the daylight hours when it is needed for glucose synthesis.
When the stomata open at the cooler temperatures of night, CO
2
is fixed by the C
4
pathway into malate, which is stored
in vacuoles. During the day, malate is decarboxylated and the CO
2
becomes available to the Calvin cycle. In contrast
with C
4
plants, CO
2
accumulation is separated from CO
2
utilization temporally in CAM plants rather than spatially.
II. Transducing and Storing Energy 20. The Calvin Cycle and the Pentose Phosphate Pathway 20.2. The Activity of the Calvin Cycle Depends on Environmental Conditions