
one, five (he pitched two innings of relief), 
and six. 
Game six was another tale of heart-
break for Giant fans. With no score in the 
fourth inning at New York’s Polo Grounds, 
Chicago’s Eddie Collins reached on an 
error. The next batter, “Shoeless” Joe Jack-
son, hit a pop-up that Giant rightfielder 
Dave Robertson dropped. Runners on 
first and third, no outs.
Happy Felsch then grounded back 
to the Giants pitcher, Rube Benton, who 
noticed that Collins had strayed too far 
off third base. Benton tossed the ball to 
Zimmerman, the third baseman. Collins 
sprinted home, past catcher Bill Rariden 
who had carelessly walked away from 
home plate. Zimmerman raced Collins 
home. Collins slid safely before Zimmer-
man could tag him. The White Sox won 
this game, and the Series, 4–2. 
The NHL Is Born
On November 26 a meeting took 
place inside Montreal’s Windsor 
Hotel. Earlier in the year the National 
Hockey Association (founded in 1909) had 
decided to reorganize. Five of those 
teams—the Ottawa Senators, Montreal 
Wanderers, Montreal Canadiens, Toronto 
Arenas, and Quebec Bulldogs—met to 
form a new hockey league. They called it 
the National Hockey League (NHL). 
Before the season even began, the 
Quebec Bulldogs opted not to field a team. 
Too many Bulldogs skaters had joined the 
armed forces. The new league cobbled to-
gether a short schedule of only 22 games 
per team. Finally, on December 19, the 
NHL opened play with a pair of games 
in Montreal that were played in front of 
only 700 fans.
The league champion would be 
awarded the Stanley Cup, which was 
already the goal for earlier pro hockey 
leagues in Canada. The first U.S.-based 
member of the NHL was Boston. The 
Bruins joined the league in 1924.
95
✔ On March 26 the Seattle Metropolitans of the Pacific Coast 
Hockey Association became the first U.S.-based team to win 
the Stanley Cup. The Metropolitans beat the Montreal Cana-
diens, three games to one.
✔  On May 2 at Chicago’s Weeghman Park, 3,500 fans wit-
nessed baseball’s first double nine-inning no-hitter. Righthander 
Fred Toney pitched for the visiting Cincinnati Reds while James 
“Hippo” Vaughn, a southpaw, was on the mound for the Cubs. 
Neither pitcher surrendered a hit through nine innings. The Reds 
won in the 10th inning as Jim Thorpe—yes, that Jim Thorpe—got 
the game-winning hit on a swinging bunt. Toney retired the Cubs 
in order in the bottom of the 10th to preserve his no-hitter.
✔ On May 28, lightweight Benny Leonard beat Freddie Welso 
to capture the world title. He retained the title for more than 
seven years. In all, he won 86 of his 92 fights and earned a 
reputation as one of the greatest ever in his weight division.
✔ On August 17, Gertrude Ederle, a 12-year-old swimmer, 
zipped through the women’s 880-yard freestyle event in 13 
minutes, 19 seconds at a meet in Indianapolis, Indiana, be-
coming the youngest person ever to set a world record. Nine 
years later, she attempted to swim the English Channel.
✔ Henry Hall ski jumped a U.S.-record 203 feet at Steamboat 
Springs, Colorado. Hall was the first to jump over 200 feet, 
breaking the previous mark by 11 feet.
Other Milestones 
of 1917