Цветков Е.В., Алябышева Т.М., Парфенов Л.Г. Оптимальные режимы гидроэлектростанций в энергетических системах
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
Prl
sHa,IeHfift Xiy'"r..np.
flyrelvr
aeportuocruol't
o6pa6orxn
fiocre,rl,H€ro
pfla,a
oilpeAenffrorcfl
6esyclonHue
SyHxuan
pacnpeAeneHun
aeponruocreft
.F(XN"r".on).
!,a,ree
c Hcronb3oBauuen
F(IN"r".op)
crpouTcfi
Ar{crrerqep-
cxuft rpaQux
f3C-xoMneHcaropa.
flpou3BeAfr
pacqerbr
perynr.rpoBaHnr
cro-
Ka no
nocneAHeMy
rpaQnxy
toro )Ke rr{ApororHqecKoro
pfiAa,
nofiyqaror
B
[onoJrHeHne
K MorrlHocrfiM
KoMneHcupyeMbrx
f3C
taxxe Mou{Hocrra
f3C-
KoMneHcaropa.
3areu nyreM
aeponruocrirofi
o6pa6orrn
pfilloB
Qpi,
XM"r"
u
Zeai
onpe,qenflIorcfl
Qynxunu
[epe.\oAa F(Xff.e"
/Qpn,
Zsai).
C
yvetou
nocneAHnx
crpouTcfi
HoBbtri
Aacnerqepcrufi
rpaQur<
f3C-xoMneH-
caropa,
3areM
yroqHrrcrca
$yHrulrH
nepexo4a
fi.
T.
g.
Taxofi
Hrepa[noH-
''' r'"' *^^''
nDrla
rrP\rr.{eLL
trHUAU.[..fiarul
AU
ltrA
rruP,
IruKa
AuuIle-l
gePgKnfl
IPaqJnK
I i7\--
KoMnegcaropa
or
HTeparIHH
K
HTepa[?rH He nepecraHer
H3MeuflTbcs.
Kax
Br,rAHO,
rvreTol nocTpoeHHrr
AEcneTqepcKoro
rpaQlrxa
Ins
f3C-KoMneHcaTo-
pa
noryqaercq
AocraroqHo
rpyroeMKuM.
3ra
rpyAoeMKocrb
eu{e 6onee
Bo3pacraer,
KorAa
yqHTblBaercfi
KacKaAHafi 83aHMocBfi3b
pexHMoB
fOC.
flycrl
AntI
Bcex
fDC
xacxaAa,
KpoMe
Hnxueli,
AucnerqepcKr,re
rpaSlr-
r{H
flocrpoeHbr
H rpe6yercr
onpeleJrHTb
.{,Hcnerr{epcxult
rpaSnr
Arq
HuxHefi
f3C. OnpeAenHB nocrynarcune
K suxseli
f3C
pacxoAbr
BoAbr
or
Bepxur.rx
f3C
n
nocrpouB
nx
Synxur,ru
rlepexoAa,
HecJrox(Ho nocrpouTb
rncnerqep-
cxnft rpa$HK
^lrfl.
sltxseti f3C-xax
AJrfi
or,IrnoqHoro
BoloxpaHrannrrla.
,[,ncneruepcxue
rpaSHKH
BepxHeft
fOC KacKaaa nplr
3aAaHHbrx
Arrcner-
r{epcKux
rpaQuxax npoqirx
f3C crponr no MeroArrKe
A/rfi
oAuuoqsofi fOC,
nph
groM
AonoJIHHTeJIbHo
AoJI)KeH
yqrrrbrBarbcfi
JrlIIrJb 3HeprerHqecrnfi
sQ$ert, Bbr3brBaeMufi npoxoxAeHneM
BoAbr
or
AaHHofr
f3C
qepe3
HnlK-
nne f3C.
[la
npovte]KyrotlHbrx
fOC
B
KacKaAe
Aucnerrrepcxue
rpacpuKr{
crporrr-
cff TaK )Ke, KaK
H
4ilfl.
nrrxHeft f3C,
uo c
yqeroM
aQrpercra
or npoxolKre-
HHfi BoAbr
qepe3
Hflx(Hlre fOC,
ec.nlr 3aAanbr rpa$axu npoqnx
f3C.
,I[Hcneruepcxue
rpaSnxu
g.nr
KacKaAa B
rrenoM
crpofiTcfi
nyreM no-
cJreAoBarerbHbrx
yrouHeuni.r:
cHaqafla
tlpoH3BoJrbHo
saAarorcfi rpa$lrxaurr
ecex f3C,
KpoMe
og,Hofi,
3areM
crporr
rpa$rir
erori oAuorl
f3C, sarer{
rpa$nxu
rarofi-ro
Apyrofi
f3C
s
r.
A.,
noKa
HTeparluoHumft npouecc
He
coli.{ercq.
Sror cnoco6
Tox(e
AocraroqHo
rpyAoervrxufi.
MeroAHry
Ann
oAnHoqHoro BoAoxpaHHJrHrrIa MoiKHo
raK>Ke
pacnpocTpaHHTb
Ha
cHcTeMy BoAoxpaHHJ{}ilq,
ecJrH 3aMeHHTb
TPYNNY
BOAOXP
AHHJIHuI
OAHH
M 3 KBIIBAJI CHTH bI
M
B O
A
O
x
p
a H H
Jr H uI
e u.
TaXan 3aMeHa
ueJrecoo6pa3Ha
LJrfl
nocTpoeHHfi
oTAeJrbHo ilrrHHft
fapaHTHpoBaHHofo
pe>KHMa
AHc-
nerrrepcKofo rpaQHKa, ec/IH
B
SHepfocHcreMe
Bo3Mo)KeH
cBo-
6oAuufi
BsaHMoo6ues
MorrlHocrffMH f3C,
rrro
o6uqso HMeer
Mecro. llprr
SKBHBa,'IeHTHpoBaHr{H Bce BoloxpaHHJI}IIIIa
cBo-
AfiTCfl
K OAHOMy
SKBHBaJTeHTHOMy
C SHepfOeMKOCTbrO,
paBHOrl
cyMMe 3HepnoeMKocrer:r
orAeJrbubix
BoAoxpaHHJrHur. fIpH
oroM
BMeCTO
paCXOAOB peKH
C,'reAyeT
paCCMaTpHBaTb
HX sHepfeTH-
qecKrie
3KBHBa"rreHrbr
(l,nn
cpeAHHX
HarropoB
H
KnA
nepecqeT
160
MolKHo
npoH3BoAHrb
no
QopMlrle
Srac
-?9-H
Lt)
' lluuvtrt'
ra-
'
paHr'poBaHHoi;-p*"rd
Oyayt
orpeAerlnrb
cyMMapHHe
ra'
pa'r'poBa*Hble
Mollr'ocru
e
ciyHKq;H
or
cyMMapHoft
j-lepro-
eMKOcTti
BOAOXpaHHJIHUI.
Aanee
3TH
JIHHHH
MoryT
yrIHTbIBaTb'
cfl
KaK
orpaHHr{eHHfi
npH
BeAeHHH
pex}lMoB
r3c
B
3OHe
H3'
6srroqutix
orAaq
Ha ocHoBe
AerepMHHHpoBaHHblx
pacqeroB
no
cflocooy
nocJreAoBareJrbHblx
ropperrHpoBoK.
Heroropue
no'
rpeulHocTH
B onpeAeJIeHHH
JIHHHfi
fapaHTHpoBaHHoro
pe}KI,IMa
3AecbAonycTHMbI'TaKKaKSTHJIHHHHHcnonb3yloTcflJIHIII'b
KaK
orpaHHrr.n"".
Taroft
n6axoA
oco6eHHo
UeJlecoo6pa3eH
r.a1- a,u1.\r.n narrrern nervJIHDoBaHHfl,
fAe
Ba)KHO
npH
Ha-
f,lT";;;
l';;i"';"
;;;y'*.in
.brv
BbrAepx(arb
orpaH'rreH*n
no o6ecneqeHHro
fapaFITHpOBaHHbIX
oTAaq
vr
B
nocJleAyrcuHe
roAbI.
-
llepexo4
K
eKBHBaJIeHTHoMy
BoAoxpaHufiHury
nepcneKTHBeH'
Ho
Tpe-
6yer
4OnoJrHHTeJrbHbtX
llCC,leAOeaHt'II:t.
B
r{aCTHOCTH,
rpe6yerCfi
yTOr{HeHUe
cnoco6a
npaBHJIbHoii
oUesrn
3HeproeMKocTll
Bg'u'oxpaHHJII{II'
Heo6xo[ulvtu
npHervrbr
6flHsxoro
K
orrHNraJtbHoMy
pacnpe.ne":IeHllff
cyMMapHbIX
orLdq
B
KaxAoNl
BpeMeHHOM
HHTepBaJIe
MelKAy
oTAenbHbll!{n
f3c,
qTo,
Hanpli}lep'
MOIKHO
Bbrno.;rHflrb
no
peFpeccgoHllbtM
3aBllcHMOcTflM'
nonyqeHHbIM
Ha
ocHoBe
o6o6qesafl
AeTepNlHHHpOBaHHblx
pacqeToB
no
cepllH
rn'u'porpason
n.nn
o6o6uteHafl
MarepHaJIoB
npounoii
3Kcnnyaraulrn
f3C'
HaocHoeeMeToAHI(HoAHHoqHoroBoAoxpaHHnlIU{aMox(HoonpeAeJlnTb
tr
HeKoTopble
!,pyr,e
,,IllHlIIl
A,cneTqepcxHx
rpaQIllicB'
A{ox<tto'
HanpllMep'
onpe.[eJrflro
onanatuepcKfle
rpasttxlt A,',Ifi
cyAoxoAHblx
no[ycKoB
B
Hrl)KHlle
6ueQor
f3c
no
BepOfTHocTHbIIvI
KpHTepHqM
Ha.q,elKHocTll'
T' e'
onpeAennTb
3aB'cr{Mocru
Q*or,,l,r
t:f
(2U(i,
xQp')
Axfi
KaxAoro
l-ro
I'IHrepBana'
cyr(-
MHpyfpacxoAblpeKI{lIeMKocTIIBoAoXpaHlI,lIIuBcexBblulepacnoJlojKeH.
nux
f3C.
c
HeKOTOpbryll
fonlEeFIHflMLi
ItoiKI{o
TaIO{e
onpeleJlnTb
|IIIIHI{H
fpa-
rpnra,
perJraMeHTHp.vloul6e
MaKcllMaJ'IbHble
pacxotbl
B
HlllKHlle
6oeQr'l
f3C
Infl
ue,lera
3aruuTbl
oT
HaeoAHeHI'{ft
1l
o6ecneqeHltq
6esonacHocilt
flllpo'
coopyxeHHir.
SxepreaJreHTHpoBaHHe
npH
3Tolvt
BblnoIHqeTcfi
Becblvla
npocTo'
TaK
KaK
3Aecb,
KaK
14.
B
npeAblAyuerl
cjlvl{ae, Ao,;I}I(HbI
cyMMIIpoBaTt,ci{
roJIbKo
pacxo.a.bl
peKl'l
H
o6levlt
BoAoxpaHHJIllur'
Aua,lorHqHO
rvlolKHO
Onpe.{,e.TfiTb
3,'IeMeHTbl
.llICIIeTqepcKoro
rpa$ltxa
f.[rr
]lppHraulloHHblx
oT'be]IOB
BOAbI
H
np'
IIIturnl.;lfi3oHbIlts6Hro.{uulxoTAaqf3CExarrBajIeHTIIpoBaHlIeNlo;+(e.|
I.aBarb
6O.nuU-rUe
nOrpeIUHOCTII,
TaK
KaI(
npH
3Torl
repflerCn
aSQeKT
OIITII-
:{u3ailHIIpe}l(HMoBfSC'floarouy'KaK]'ifieorlleqa'locbBbltue'Ha3HaI{e'
Hrre
pe}Kr.llros
f3C
s
eroft
3oHe
UeXeCOO6pasno
Bblno'iilfrb
Ha
ocHoBe
re'
Ir),u{rIX
peifirr}roB
f3C
c
Ilcno.qb3oBal-lHe\1
Cnoco6a
noc"le'['oBaTe'JlbHblx
KOp-
peKrHpoBOK,
HO
npH
yqeTe
orpaHHr{eHrtfi
no
}'l(a3aHHbl}l
xapaKrePHbll'l
JIH-
Hrrffivt,{,lrcneTqepa*oro
rpasutca,
o5ecneqllsarctullll
IipllTepHlI
HaAeiKHOCrll
BbrAaqu
fapaHr!rpoBaHHblx
oT,naq
nt6o
I(pHTeplrII
5e:OnacHoctlt
HlIiKHeio
6ueQa
II
trl.lPocooPYxeHltft'
n
-3433
l6i
B 3dK.,'Iro9€HHe Mo)KHo
orMerHTb,
qro
onpeAe,TeHHe
.[Hc-
EeTqepcKHX rpaQHKoB
AJrrr
cHcTeMbr
Bo,4,oxpaHHJrHrrl
Ha ocHoBe
HCnOJrb3OBaHHff
MeTOAa
trHHaMHr{eCKOfO
npofpaMMHpOBaHKfl,
H
QyHruur?
pacrpeAeJreHnfl
BepoflrHocreft peqHoro
croKa Bos-
MolhHo nu6o
L.,'It
qacTHblx
cfiyrlaeB
KacKaAoe f3C, na6o npn
BHeceHHH
B
pacr{er
Aonyurenwft
u
ynpoureHwir.
Haw6o"nee repc-
[eKTHBHbr 3AeCb
nOAXoAbr,
CBfl3aHHbre
C
sKBr4BaJreHT.HpOBaHHeM
BoAoxpaHHJIHIu.
BosltoxeH, Ho
6onee rpyAoeMoK
H
nyrb
pe-
rrreHuff,
ocsonanuotft
Ha
pa3AeJreHHH
f3C
Ha
KoMneHcupye-
MbIC
H KOMNCHCATOPbI.
fl nn nttn-o^t o^'-n vn4 xt, fifrttr 6n noa nannfi6rr6rt6rtlr id^^rrd
/t.+..JLAItvILlYl
ft\.rA\J/\yCrflrrdl'flr-q
rJ\.r/19\-
fl\Jy\-flgr\lrr.Crr!lrl
yALL'lYfCf-
TpHBaeMbie
HHX{e
peureHHs,
B
KoTopbrx HcnoJlb3yeTcg BepogT-
HocrHoe
onucaHne
peliHoro
croKa
eu6opxofi nnlporpaQoe
(ire-
qeHHft
cToxacrr.rqecxuft
noAxoA).
PeuresHe
Ha
ocnoBe
HclloJrb3oBaH[rfl rpaAHeHTHoro MeroAa
H
pacqerHofi
eHdopKH
rHAponpaQon.
llycrl
3aAaHa
pacqeruafi
nu6opxa
H3
v
rnAporpaQoe.
flo,q
oaHHM
rHAporpa-
Qoiur
noApasyMeBaervr
Ka/renAapHyro
noc",'reAoBareJrbHocrb
pac-
XoAoe
peKH
AJIfl
BceX
HHrepBaJIoB nepwol.a tr-ta+q.
Cria,iana
paccMarpHBaeM
BoAoxpaHHJrHuIa
fOC, HMerorrlne
ToJrbKo
gHeprerurrecKoe
Ha3Har{enne.
!,acfierqepcxue
rpaQnra
AJrft
Kax(Aoro raKoro BoAoxpaHHJrHx{a
B
"nro6orvr
i-l,r
BpeMeH-
HoM HHrepBaJre
6yaeu
onpeAeJrqrb B
BHAe
cJreAyroulux
ynpaB-
JiflForIrHX
QyHxqnft:
li?!l
'i
:
f lZ,a
t),
rAe
y'y'racij-cpeAHtff
MoulHocrb
i-ilt'
f3C B
i-u
HHrepBaae;
zeai-YpoBeHb
i-ro
BoAoxp
aH:j/^iluu\a
Ha Haqa.r'ro f-ro
r{Hrep-
BAJTA.
3aAaqa
saK/rroqaercfl
B
onpeAeJreHHH
no
KpnrepHrc
(5.1)
orrnMaJIbHbIX 3aBr.rolMocreit
(5.18)
Airfr
Bcex
f3C
(i:1
,
m)
Bo
Bcex BpeMeHHbIx HHrepBa/rax
ft-|,
2,
(d*q)1.
OyHxqrar
(5.18)
N{o}Ker
6stm
npeAcraBJeHa B BHAe cre-
neHHoro
noJrHHoMa HeKoropoft n-fi,
creneHn
/V:51
ii
:do
ti*
arilZv6
i
j-1...+
aniiZla
ii'
(5.19)
B
groM
cryqae
Hyx(Ho
onpeAeJIHTb
raKne 3HarIeHHfl &oij,
Qtij,
...,
Onij,
npH KOTOpbIX
AOCTII|
aeTCfl
MHHHMyM MaTeMaTH-
qecKoro
ox(HAaHHfl
cyMMapHblx
sKcnJIyaTauIIoFIHbIX 3aTpaT.
Buecro
(5.19)
Moifier oKa3arbcn
6o;ee
lAo6nrtra
B3flrb
oproroH
alru rrr? ilo;THHoM.
Oyuxunn
(5.18)
NIolKer
6urr
raKiKe sar\aHa s ra6arquofi
Qoprure.
HeHseecrHbrMH B
noc/'reAHeM
cryrlae
6.vlyr
3Har{eHHE
A fCnT
tv
racii
t62
(5.
18)
B
rrpHHflrbrx
y3Jrax
3 aAaHHs,
aror?
Qynrqrrur.
Ans
nro6oir
H3
rpex
paccMorpeHHbix
Qopu
saAaHHfl
3aBH'
cavroctefi
(5.18) saAaqa
cBoAnrcf
K
onpeAe"'rIeHHIo
AJIfl
KalK'
,11ott
fOC B
Ka)KAoM
HHrepBaJIe
HeKoropblx.HeH3BecrHbIx
BeJIII'
qr.rH,
AaFouIHX
*""*"y*
6y*ru"m
(5.1). O6osHa'Iur'r
o6o6llleH'
HO
gTH
HeHSBecTHbIe
BeJIHqHHbI
qepe3
OryE.,
IA€
k:0,
tL-'unCJlO
HeH3BecTHbIX
BeJIHqHH
B
nrc6Oru'i-ru
HHTepBaJIe Ailfr
arO6orO
i-ro
BoAoxpaHHJIHIqa.
B
3anl{cn
{5.19)
HeH3BecTHbIMI{
flBnfr''
IoTcs
ToeSSHUHeHTbI
doti,
afii,
..
-,
anii'
Hraw,-
ia1
a,aa
OnpeAeJIeHI{fl
o[THMaJIbHbIx
AgcneTr{epcKux
rpaQHKoB
Ann
m
BoAoxpaHHrIHIrr
f3C
B
(d*q) epenaelH{tx
HHTCDBAJIAX
N{ATCMATHqCCKI4
CB
uI{t4
(5.1)
cyNI}taPHbIX
sKcnryi
HeH3BeCTHbIM
O;ih.
LInclo
HeH3I
t{uclo
n o6trqso
AOcTaTOqHo
(
HanpHMeP,
Anx
ulecrH
f3c
et
.t
BaJroB o6uee
qucro
HeH3BeCTHb
Ans
peue'Hf
nocTaBJreHI{OIl
3aAar{H
peKoMeHAyeTCfi
Lrc'
noJrb3oBarb
rpaAnesrunft
MeroA,
npll
3roM
npoqeAypa
peue'
HHfl
6y4er
cneeyrouferl.
3aAarorcs
AncnerqepcKue
rpaQHKH
noloxpaHHJrHUI
I
3C
HaqarbHoro
npH6.rruxeHHfl,
T.
e.
HCXOA'
Hbre
3HaqeHgfl
a\1ln
nnn
BceX
i,
i,
k, nn6o
nocrpoel{Hble
oAHHM
H3
r4sBecrHblx
nfH6.nlrxeHHblx
MeroAoB
no
croKoBoMy
pflAy
Ha6nroAenvrfr,
au6o
no;yqeHHble
Ha
ocHoBe
HHlKeHepHbIX
co-
oSpaxenHrl.
flo
HcXoAHbIM
Agcnerr{epcKgM
rpaQHxau
onpe'
AeJrflercf
pacqerHar
elt6opxa
I{3
v
rl4AporpaQon'
Ha.{anrHHir AI,Icnerqepcrtnft
rpaQI4K,
xapaKrep143ylouuftcn
xoaQQraUHeHraNIH
{"!?,r},
lvlaTelvtaTnqecKn
IIo}KHo
noHYINIarb
KaK
HaqaflbHyrc
raivrn
il,|,o.
Tot{Ky
B
}IHOroN{epHOivl
npoCTpaHcTBe
c
KoopAHHs''
I,rn
uauaJlbFioro
BeKTOp-fpaAHeHT
OT
grad
(/Vl,l
,
!,HCnerqe
pcKoro
rpaQni<a
{.i,c:}}
Haxoar;rrcn
Qyuxunu:
rTln,
Tl Tl
(d+t4ta
)
,,,u,
(5.20)
UA
\
d'i,r
lo
j:l
k:0
r.4,e
t
tin
-
eAHHI4qHbIe
BeKTOpbI
B
npocTDaHCTBe
l(cspAliH-lT
, /
dMI4a-
t
L,
| ,
Ri
f -L I
- qacTHbLe
npoa3
BoIHbIe,
BblqllcJleHHble
A'nn
'
r'
\
dtr;',
l
'
uaqa,rssoii
rotIKH
{t}?D
r{e/reBori
d+q
d,Fl
-)o-
| I
u
i-l
Kax
HsnecrHo,
BeKrop-rpaAneHr
grad
(MH"t)
noKa3bIBaeT
HanpaBJreHHe
HaH6o,ilbulero
BO3pacraHIIn
QyurUHn
e roq*e
{oire}.
Ilosro-\1y
roc.'le
onpetreJeHHfl
rpaAHeHTa
1l*
MHI
npo'
i63
H3BOAHTCfi
ABHlrieHLIe
nO
HailpaBJIeHHIO,
npOTHBOnOeO)KHOMy
HanpaBJreHHro
rpa^(HeHTa
(nps
sroM coorBercrBylo[IluIvI
o6pa-
3OM
H3MeHrrOTCfl KOOpAHH
arbr
Aijh)
.
tr,eUXeHHe
'IIO
HanpaBJIe-
HHrO
BeKTOp-aHTHnpaALreHTa
npOH3BOAHTCfl
IrIafaMLI
AO
TeX
ffop, noKa ue 6yler
saftIen MLIHHMyM
QyHxqnn
MHdr
Ha
eroM
HanpaBJreHHH. 3ravr caMbIM 6yaer cAeJIaHa
oAHa
pacqerHafr
HTepar{Hfl,
B
pe3yJlbrare
xoropor:r
ottpeAeJIflercfl
roqra
{*','i,u)
B
grofi
TorIKe Bblr{Hc"rrfiercff
HoBoe 3HaqeF{He BeKTop-aHTHrpa-
AHeHTa,
3aTeM
npOH3BOALrrCfr,
ABH)KeHHe
nO
HanpaBJIeHHIO
3TO-
rrr F,pKTnne H T n flne.np r{eKornnoro uwe.nA urenafiufr rro-
--r-'- ----,r
CTPItaeTCf
O'nTLIMylvI H
pacr{eT
SaKaHr{HBaeTCf-OnpeAeJIflIOTCfi
GHaqennfi
{oniul',
coorBercTBylou{He
o.nrn}IaJIbHbIM
AHcnerrlep-
cKHM rpaQnicaM BoAoxpaHHaHuI.
C
qennio
yrpoueHl-ifi
BHAa
ynpaBJIflIotqnx
QyHxqul;t
qe,'te-
coo6paario
pe)KHMHbte
orpaHnqeHllr,
HanpLIMep,
no
npeAe/tb-
Hbrrvr
MaKcHMaJrbHbril{ H
MHHHMa.flbHblM
ypoBHflM
BOAoXpaHH-
fiHtll
fOC
He
yl{HrblBarb
B srHX
Qy"xqHqx.
Tor4a,
ec"{E
pe-
x(HM f3C,
AaBaeMbtft
ynpanrqloulnMu
QyHxt{Hr,Mw,
Hapyuaer
pexrrMHbre
of
paHHqeHHflr.-
To cJreAyeT orK.rl,oHHTbcfl or
AHc-
-
fleTqepcKHx fpaQHKoB H
Ha3HarrllTb
pexiHM
Ha
npeAeJle
ofpa-
snqesnft.
B
(5.19)
onrHMarlbHbie
Mou{Hocru f3C
//?5lri
i'Fr
f3C
B i-vr
npeueHH6tut
HHTepBaJIe craBflTcff B
3aBHcHMocrb
ro"rlbKo
or
ypoBHrr
BoAoxpat{HIHI{a
i-ft
f3C
B HaqaJIe f-ro
uH'repBa-
/ra,
r{To
e o6firevf cryqae
He orBer{aer
HaHJIyq[IeMy BuAy
AHc-
nerqepcKlrx
rpaQHxon. B
o6qeu
c"'Iyqae
HaIIJIyqulHe
Al{cner-
r{epcKpre
rpaQnxu BoAoxpaHHJrHru
f3C
Aaror
3aBHcHMocrH,
cBfl3brBaroulne
onrar!,taJIbHbIe
MotqHocrH
N?!I
ti
raxAotl
i-fr:
fOC
e rn6oilr
i-v
aurepBaJle
c
ypoBHfiMH
BoAoxpaHHJIHIIT
Bcex
coBMecruo
pa6orarournx f3C B HarIaJIe
i-ro HHrepBaJIa
H
c
pacxoAaMH
6Hroeorl
flpaTot{Hocrn
ilJrfr.
Bcex
f3C, Ha6nrc-
AaBrxHMricq
B HecKo"IIbKHX
IIpeAIUeCTBy]OU{HX
MOMeHTy
/;
BPe-
uesndrx
HHTepBaiIax
v npoFHo3HpyeMbtMn
Ha
i-ft
HHTepBaJI
B
peN{eHri.
VrasaHHbte
3aBHcHMocrrI
npeAcraBr'tfltor co6ofi
QyHxuian
or
6onrruoro
'urclla
nepeMeHHbIX,
aHaJIHTHqecKaR
annpoKcnil{arrnfl
KoTopbIX BecbMa c,'Io}KHa.
Kporure
roro,
npn
onpele"{eHzn
onTLL\,.{a"rtbHbIX
3aBHCHMOCreft
TaKOfO BHAa
npn-
H"rrocb
6rr u
HHHMH3HpoBarb
QyHxr{nrc
qpe3Bbttralino
6onruroro
qricJra
nepeMenHbrx.
Ariarug noKa3btBaer,
qro
Lts-3a
yxa3aH-
HbIX
TpyAHocrerl
TaKoe
nocrpoeHae onrHMaJlbnbtx
Allcflerr{ep-
cKHx
rpaQnxoe
D.,i-ifl,
6o"ryluoro
qucJra
f3C
npaKTHr{ecKIi He-
oc,v-uecrBrrNro.
llosrony npHXoAHrcfl
yrpoluarb
crpyKrypy
ynpaB,'tfltotIIHX
QyHxUltii,
r{To,
KoHerIHo, cBfl3aHo c
HeKoropbirl
cHHIKeHHeM
eQQexraBHocrn
Ancnerr{epcKux
rpaQuxon.
3rn
ynpou{eHnfi
Mo}I{Ho
ocyu{ecrB"IlflTb
no-pa3HoMy.
164
B
[68]
npeA/laraercn
coxpaHnrb
cBn3b
ffi5lti
c
yKa3aH-
HbrM
rgtire
6olstulttt
q6cfioM
napaMeTpoB,
oAHaKo
3Ty
cBfi3b
cJreAyer
annpoKcHMHpoBarb
HeKoropblMH
QYgxuunMH
npocrol'l
;;pi;;tp;i.
g
uu.tHocrl{,
npHHHMaercn'
uro
f
(xo,
xr
xn):
:
Ii
(x,), rAe
f-Qi''Hrqttr
o6utero
BHAa'
l:l
Bsrure
B
3aBIIcHIvlocrrI
(5.19)
yqreHa cBnsb
AR!|
roJIbKo
c
ze6ij,
oAHSKO
ST}I
3aBplcHMocrH
o6ulero
BHLA'
IIapaMeTpoB
MoAeJ'lH.
Mo;xso
npt{
OTotvl
MeroAe
npHMeHHrb
vr
paccMOTpeHHoe
paHee
pa3AeJIeHne
f3C
Ha
KOMfleHcgpyelvlbie
H
KoMneHcaTopbl'
KofAa
!^irn
KoMIeHcHpyeMbIX
f3C
-AacnerrlepcKl{e
rpaQuxn
6epyrcn
BHAa
(5.19),
a
Anfr
f3C-xotutneHcaropa-B
BHAe
,lr.rrruBaeT
aQcpexrnBHocrb
AHCreTr{epcKllx
rpaQuxon'
Ans
f3C
Kolrri.:reKcriofo
Ha3HaT-reHHff,
HanpHMep
npH
!Ip-
prrf aUHSHHoIvI
BSAO3a6ope
V3
BOAOXp
aHv1HUla,
B
AOnO"tHeHHe
k
(5.18)
norpe6y'ercn
nocrpoeHl,Ie
c"reAyrculHx
6IITHN{aJlbHbix
3 aB
t{cn}Ioc'reit:
(5
21)
165
Qffilr-l(Zusi),
rae
Ql[";1
-
orbeN{bi
BoAbt Ha Hppurauuro
r43
i-ro
BoAoxpaHr4lvr-
tlt.a
B i-tt usrepBaJle. I-lpn
etor
e Mklf*o
aon*Hbr
BKJrror{arbcfi
yqep6u
or
HeyAoBflerBopeHnfi
rrppuraunoHHbrx
notpe6ilocrer?
B
BOAe,
a
B
OCTajTbHOM nOpfiAOK
nOCTpOeHHff
OfiTHMaJIbHbIX
AHCnerqepcKHX
rpaQuroe
He HsMeHHTCfi,
yBe,TsrrHTCfi
JrI{Irrb
tIHC/:iO
OnpeAeJIfieMbIX
HeH3BeCTHbIX
BeJIHqItH
dtju,
TaK
KaK
B
aro
qacJro
nofiayT
rr xoeQQnqaeHrbr,
annpoKcr,rMupyrcrrrHe
saBr,icuMocru (5.21)
.
PaccuorpeHHbrM
MeroAoM
MoiKHo
onpeAe,TflTb
AncfleTr{ep-
cKHe
rpaQuxH
oAHoBpeMeHHo
AJrr
Bcex
3oH,
Ho npH HairHqHH
cronMocrHol:r
orleHKr,r
or
AeQHr{HroB
unn vtslbrrKoB
BoAbr.
BoeMoxHo
onpeAeJreHne
rpaQnron
w roJrbKo
AJTI
3oHbr
HS6tiro.rHbrx
orAarr
ro
KpHTepHro
MHHHMyMa paCXOAa
rO[JrHBa,
ec/rr4
AHcrrerqepcKHe
rpaQaxra
B
Apyrnx
3oHax
KaK-ro
nocrpo-
_eHbr.
B
[ocJreAHeM
Cryr{ae
B
pacrrerHyFo
nn6opry
cJreAyer
BKJrroqarb
JrHtrrb
ruaporpaQlr
c
noBbrrrreuHoft
npHTorlHocrbro.
OrAe.unuoe
riocrpoeur{e
Aucrrerr{epcKax
rpaQlaxoe
Ailfl
30-
HbI
rapaHTHpoBaHHoro
pe.)KHMa
MolKeT Bblno./TltflTbcff
no
KpH-
TepHro rroJryqeHHs
MaKcHMantUOrl
cyMMapHofi
rapaHrHpoBaH.
uort
orAaqu. Onpelenflrorcfl
(uanpauep,
B
BHAe
nonuHoruon)
ryr
_onpeAeJrffrbcfl
H
Apyrue
3oHbr
AHcnerrrepcKoro
rpaQHra.
PeuesHe
Ha
ocHoBe
o6o6rqenuq pe3yJrbraroB
AerepMHHH-
poeaHHbrx
pacqeroB
r{o rnAporpaQaru pacuernofi
nu6opru.
3ror
noAxoA
AJrfl
onpeAeJreHHs
ynpaBJrflrouIHX
Synxqnft
AHc-
nerqepcKnx
npaQHKoB
Hcc/reAoBan
B
[41]
3aAaqa
orpeAeJre-
HHff
onrprMairbHbrx
ynpaBJrflrorqax
Qynxuuft
craBHTcfl
H
perxa-
ercfl
KaK saAarra
lrAeHTHQwKag.HH:
rro
3aAaHHbrM
BXoAy
(pac-
qeruofi
eu6opxe rnAporpaQoe)
n Bbrxo^ty (onruvraJrbHbrM
pex(HM
aM
Anfl,
KaiKloro
ruAporpaQa)
onpeleflflercr
HeH3Becr-
Hrtfi
oneparop
cBrr3u, r. e.
ypaBHeHHe
ynpaBr'rflrou{efi
QyHxuuH.
crpyxrypa
oneparopa
3aAaercfl,
Ho
oneparop
3aBHcHr
raKixe
or HeKoTopbrx
anpr.ropH
HeHsBecTHbrX
H
no3TOMy
OnpeAeJr{e-
Mbrx
o6o6uenHbrx
napaMerpoB.
f]oc,reAoBareJrbHocrb
pacr{eroB
no
onpere,'refuurc
ynpaB.,'rfl-
IoIuHx
QyHrullr?
c",T€.ryrouraff
.
CHaqana
AerepMr{HHpoBaHHbrN{H
MeroAaMH
(cu.
r"rr. 4)
on-
peAeflflroTcs
onTr{Ma"rrbHbre
pe}KHMor
f3c
;.1.,'rf
Kzx(Aofo
fHApo-
rpaQa
H3
pacuerHoft
nu6opxn.
Aa"ree
Ha
ocHoBe
perreHHff
166
perpeccHoHHbIMH
MeToAaMH
3aAarIH
t4eutn$HKaqHLI
OnpeAeJIff-
nrcfi
ynpaB,'rstoqge
QyHxUun
3aAaHHoli
ctpyxrypbl
no
Kpure-
pnro cBeAeHHf
K
N'IHHHMyMy
-orKJIOHeHsft
pex?IMOB'
ilOflyqeH-
Hbrx
no
AgcneTrrepcKoMy
rpaQnrcy,
or
paccqllTaHHbix
AeTepMH'
HHpOBaHHbIM
MeTOAOM
__ ^a.,,,n n'vnpaBJrfrouue
Qy+rrunn
AHcreTqepcKoro
rpaQuxa
B
i-M
HHrepBaJre
AJrff
i-ft
f3c
orpeAeJlfftoTcfl
B
BHAe
IIOJIHHOMOB
U6ii:a1;iur;i*aziiuzti-ti*asiiI\(-.Di*a+iiu+(t-1)r;
(5'22);
. s 1.. \
ao;i:'1ii
\t'loii
)
,
(5.23)
rAe
dfij,
a2ij
KOSQQHI{HeHTbI
perpeccHl{;
ypaBHeHHe
(5.23)iypasHeHHe
HopM
ann3at\Hvr;
rls;i-HopMaJIH3oBaHHoe
3Haqegge
3aBgcgrurofi
nepeueHnoft
yoii
(ypoaeHl
Zsoii
HJII'I
BbI-
pa6orxa
f3C
Sraci:)
;
uriL-HopMa/IH3oBaHHbIe
3HaqeHHq
O)KH-
AaeMorO
perrHoro
cioxa
Qpiii
UzO-t)i-HOpMaJII{3OBaHHbIe
3Ha-
rreHHff
perrHofo cToKa
B
npeAlxecTByloqeM
HI{TepBaJIe;
uz(-r)i-
HopManrasoeaHHble
3HarieHHfi
Z
ed4-Dii
U+(-r)i-HOpMafiHSOBaH-
HbIe
3HarieHHff
Zs6(-2)i'
3alaqefr
nr4e"ia$irxaUnr,r
ffBJlflercq
orpeAerlegge
xoaQQr-
TIHeHT9B
a
B
(5.22)r
rITo
vig>Ker
6ltrn
BbInOJIHeHo
6AHHM
Hg
cneAyroglgx
MeToAoB:
MHolKecrBeHHoft
nuuefiHofi
KoppeJIflUH-
et-{,
MeToAoM
f.r'l&BHbIX
KOMnoHeHT'
HHTep[OJIflIIHOHHbIM
MeTo-
AoM
rrJr1 MeroAoM
rpynnoBoro
yqeTa apryMeHToB.
rIaule
nc-
noJrb3yeTcs
nepBblft
IvIeTo,n.
tI!4_3ToM
HTepaTHBHo
oqeHnBaior
vr
rrHcJIO
q,rteHoB
IioJIHHoMa
(5.22),
r.
e.
nocTefleHHo
HapaIUH-
BarcT
HX
rIflc"no,
Or6pacueaa
MaJIo3Ftrarlaulne
3Har{eHHfl
(Ha
ocHoBe
crarHcrHr{ecKHX
XparepHen).
PaccuorpeHHtrir
MeroA
ofrpeAeJreHHfl
]npaB",'IfiIOuIHx
QyIIR-
qHii
AncrerqepcKHx
rpaQHKoB
HMeer
npocrylo
crpyKrypy
afl'
rOpHTMa
H
O6stqHO
AaeT
yAOBJIeTBOppITeJIbHbIe
npaKTnr{ecKue
pe-Sy,rlraTbt.
Ba>xsstl,t
AOCTOHHCTBOM
MeTOAa
flBJIfleTCfl
Ha-
inqnHHIl
alailkr3
TexuoJloroM
AeTepMHHHpoBaHHblX
pacqeToB'
qro
npH6lnx<aer
3Tor
noAXoA
K
HMHTaUHoHHoMy'
Alerol
o6laAaer
v
HeAocrarKaMH,
ocHoBHble
I{s
KoropbIX
c.rreAylotUrle:
a)
no:6op
ynpaB,'IfflolrIHX
QynxUnft
npoH3BoAHT-
crr
no KpttTepttto
npH6nttxeHHq
IIo
pex(HMHbIM
napaMeTpaM'
a
He
no
ueresol?
QyHxuun;
6)
npH
o6o6ueHnu
pe3yJibraroB
AeTepMHHHpoBaHHbtX
pacqeTo.B
B
ynpaB,rqrcIlleit
QyHxUHn
IYIo-
fyT
HapyulaTbcfl
pei{illMHble
ofpaHHI{eHHfl,
KOTOpbIe
He
Hapy-
ua,,'rHcb
B Kax(Ao],I
IeTepMHHHpoBaHHOM
pacqeTe
no
fHApO-
rpaQaur.
Ans
ycTpaHeHHr
noci1eAHero,
HaHfloJIee
cyUeCTBeH-
Hono
HeAocTaTKa
seo6xOAnva
paspa6Orxa
Cfl€lII{da'IbHoro
a,rrropHTMa
NIHoN(ecrBeHHoft
roppeJIflUHH,
yrIHTbIBaroulero
orpa-
HLIqllBaIOIqHe
CBfl3H,
t{TO
nOKa
euie
He
cAe.llaHo-
t67
Onpe4erreHHe
onrnr{a,rrbHbrx
AucfierrrepcKr{x
rpaQnroB
Arfi
cHcreM
BoAoxpzHH.rrIHIrI
H
fOC
tBJlflercfl
BecbMa c.,,rolr(Holi
sa-
Aaqetl,
peuIeHHe
xoroport
HeJrb3r
cr{HTarb
3aKoFiqeHHbrM.
flo-
gTOMy
aKTyaJrbHbr
AaJrbHerluriae
HccJie,{oB
aHrfl, e arorl
o6nacrH,
oco6euHo
AJIn
rltApoy3,rloB
Kolln,'IeKcHofo
Ha3HaqeHHl'
.
5.4.
OE3OP 3ApyEEXHbtx
pA6oT
no
AHCnETqEpcKHM
rPAO
H
KAM
BOAOXPA
H HJI HITI
llpueoAnvuti
uuxe
o6sop ocHoBbrBaercfl
Ha
MarepnaJrax npoxoArrBrue-
ro B
IIae
1979 r. e nHP
ilre)KryHapoAHoro
coBer.ilaHprn
<<Vnpae,reHHe
cucre-
Maiuu
BoroxpaHH,'rHru>>,
opfaHH3oBaHHoro
i{e;xlyHapoAHbrrlt
aHcruTyro\{
ctr-
creMHoro
alarrq3a (HCA),
AxaAeuueft
Ha.vx v HscrvryroM
ruereopoJrornlr
w BOAHOTO
XOSqftCrea
nHP.
B rv1arepHa,'rax
coBe[IaHHfl coAepxarcfi
,no-
xna.lulor
CCCP,
CIIIA,
OPf,
r{CCP,
AHrrnrr,
KaHanu,
fAP,
BHP, OuH-
tfr.Hrrdw,
Hr.rlepnau
gon
172-841,
n
Koropbrx
.IaHbr
o6soplr
pa6or
no
ynpaB-
JIeHIIIO CIICTeMaMH
BOAOXpaHH,'rHUI.
B nocleAuHe
AecqrnJlerr{ff
sa
py6exoM
yre,'rfiercq
Bo3pacraroulee BH}r-
[raHHe
K HcnOnb3OBaHHiO
nI
ar_g-t\,I a rHqec
KII x
]lu
ItraI{ItoHHbt
x rr
onTultII3aUHoHHbtx
NIoAe;reit
.IJfi
.VnpaB.rreHHf
clrcre-
NIaMH
BOAOXpaHHJTHUI.
Eonuuroe
BHHIIaHLIe
yAeJrflercfl
Mo.{,e;'iffrr
}r rrauJrrHHbrM nporpailr}ra}.I
Ai'Ifl
cocTaBJIeHHt
AHcIIeTqepcI(Hx
rpaQnxoe,
a TaK).r{e
paspa6artrBatorcfi
rI
[lC[OJIb3ylOTCfi
I{OIe,'iH
H }taUiIIflHble npofpa}l]lbl,
nO KOTOpblt\,t
XaX4ttft
paS
BeAyTCfi
pacqeTbl
Arq
rIpuHfTlrfi
rroBofo
peueHirfl
no onpele,reHllro
oTJ.aqr{
BOAbI H3
CHCTeM BOAOXpaHlr"rrHru.
fipu
paspa6orxe
Allcnerr{epcxux
rpaQrrKoB
vqHTbrBaercx BepoflTnocrHoe
onncaHlre
peqHoro
croKa.
Kax
lr
B npaKTHKe
CCCP,
Hcnonb3ytorcr
gee
$op-
MbI Tar{oro
onlrcaHrra
-
QyHxrtnflilru
pacnpere.'reHHfi
eeponrHocreri
(nngtrfi
BepoffTHocrurrri noqxoa)
lr
pacverHoft
ntr6opxoli rulporpaQoe (uennHuir.
BeporrrHocrnur:i noaxol)
.
B
AHcnerrrepcKux
rpaSrrxax
Bbr.q,e.fiflror
xapaKTepHbre
3oHbr
(clr.
pIIc.
5.1)
-
nepe6oeo, rapaHTrrpoBaHHblx
or.r,aq, us6u'roqHtrx
orrlaq
Ir
.lp.
[r:a
nocrpoeHllff
lllcneTr{epcxlrx
rpaQIIKoB
3a
py6exolt
r{cnoJrb3yroTcrr
vrero.lbr
"'nruer?soro
nporpalrMrrpoBaHHr (;1fI)
]r
.u,trHaMrrqecKoro
nporparr-
lrItpoBaHHfi
(Ln).
Hau6olsirl€e
H]rc",-ro
onv6;uixoBaFrHbrx
pa6or
ornocrrrcfl
K OAHHOqHbINI
BO.U.OXp?HLI;1l'l[l?][, HO B nOCte]HIie
rOLbl B03pOC"{O
BHi{IIarllie
tl K
IIO.{,e,{f
}1
.1,i1fl
C}ICTeM
BOtrOXpaHlrJ-rIIu{.
Otr,gaXO
AO
Cef O Bper\teHrr
i{e
nor'Ivr{eHbr
crpor}re
}rero;r,br
nocrpoeHlrfi
J,ilcnerqepcKHX
rpaQltxor
l.ln
c}I-
crell
Bo.loxpaHn"[IIu,
Koropbte onpe]eJfl,rnr
6ur
orrrrr]raJrbH1.'ro orAaqv
tr3
I(a;xr,ofo BoAoxpaHII"Tnua KaK
Q.v*uxuuio
reKvrurx
oSrelioa HanojrHeHrrfl
Bcex BoAoxpaHilJrrru, a raKiKe
.leiicrnltreJbHbr\
rr,:Ir{
o)filt.r,aetltbrx
ecrecrBeir-
HbIx npIIToKoB. FIe.laeHIre
tlcc"Te.toBaHrrfl noKa3a.rir,
r{To
onrl{u}r3arr}IoHHbre
IIOAe,'IH IIltelOT llllrpoKYIO B03iltO;'r(HOCTb.I":rfl npii-\teHeHlIf
K cllcTeltalt Bo-
JOXpaHrialru.
168
Pa6oru
no
oAuHoqHbIill
BoAoxpaHHJIHIqaM'
flepnot:f
pa-
6oroir
no onpeAeJleHuro
onTllMaJIbHbIX AncneTqepcKux
rpa$nxoe
6sua
pa6o-
ra
A.
/Inrr,ra
(1955
r.)
*,
ocnoBaHHafi
Ha
,[,fl
U
reOpHH
M&Tepgsr-IbHo-
rexHHqecKIIx
3anacos.
3arel,t
MaHu,
To,vac
n Vorepvrefiep
(1960-1962
rr')
peuHJIH Ty )Ke
npo6;leu,v
c HcnOJIb3oBaHHelvI
IIn.
A.
,Ilutra
npelcTaBJlffn
cToK
npocTbllt
MapKoBCKH*'l
npoqeccoN'{,
a
ManH,
Tolrac
lr
VOrepueftep
-
HesaBHcrrMbrMH
HJrH
cepnfrHo
cBfl3aHHbtLIw
cnyuafiHiril'in
co6iirliflM?1.
Boctep
(1962
r.)
yconepuleHcrBoBarl
pelueH?Ie Ha
ocHoBe
AI-1,
a
@alxcott
(1965 r')
trcno,,rb3oBaJI
xou6uuaUuto
An
H
/ln
(ureparneHufi
noAXoA).
6ypac
(1963 r.) npHuesu.rr
trfl
ArIfi
cocraBrleH1fi
rpaQuxon
or4aq
xou6aunpoaaH-
uOfi
cltCteMbI
(BoAoHocsltli
ropH3oHT
-
BoAoXpdiiii;-ifiiii?>>.
Bce 3Tii
I'ioAe'IIIl
rrcnoJrb3ytot
nsHHft
BepOfiTHOCtttstf,t
noAXoA H
A'axe
AJtff
OAHHOqHbIX
BOAO-
xpaHttJIHUl
OKa3aJIHCb
Aoporocroqu{HillH
no
BpeMeHH
Cr{eTa
H
TpyAo3aTpaTal'vt
Ha
nporpaMillHpoBaHlte.
.IIayxc
n
OalxcoH
(1970
r.) cpaBHIIIH
npflNIeHeHIle
croxacrur{ecKoro
.[,n,
,|in
Lr MeroAoB
arepauHrt:
no
BpeMeHH
cl{era
npo-
r{fpbrBaror
MeroAbI
.IIfl, a
no rpyAo3arparaM
Ha
nporpaMMHpoBaHne
-
AII'
Cle.naH
BbtBoA,
qTo
XoTfi
Afl
n
MeToAbI
nrepaqlrit
TaKI(e
AoporocTofft{He
Arfl
peueHHn
Ha 3BNl,
Ho
oHH
HMercT
66auruyrc
nepcneKTuBy
AJIfi
IIpHtvIe'
HeHllfi
K CHCTeil{aM
BOAOXpaHH,'IHUI.
B
60-e
roAbr
pa3pa6arbrBaJrHcb
TaK>Ke
HeHBHble
CTOXaCTHqeCKUe
MO-
Ae.rfir,
opHeHrI4pOBaHHbIe
Ha llcnoJIb3oBaH?le
HenocpeAcTBeHHO
npotIIJIOro
croKoBoro
pnga Ha6lnAeurift.
flepnure
paspa6o'rxlt
s
sror't
o6lacrn
BblnoJI-
uuru
Xoa,t H
6ypac
(1961-1965
rr.),
Koropble
npLIMeHHrIer
All.
Hau6onee
no.,isoir
pa6orofi
3roro
n.rraga
flBlffercfl
pa6ora
fura
(1966
r-),
B xoropot?
pacclloTpeHbl
Boilpocbl
cIIHTesa
BoAoTOKa,
AeTepil{uHHcTHIIecKafl
onTHNtu3a'
ulrq
(ocHoBaHHafi
Ha
All)
lr
perpeccuosHstft
aHaJII{s.
fiocleAsnft
npltueHen
AJrfi
onpeAeneHlrfi
3aBnc]ntocrH
orAaq
or
ypoBHeft
noloxpaH]IJII'lua
H
Be-
ntrqllH
npeAbt4yulero
nplIToKa.
fl.Hr
paccMaTpllBaJI
JI[IIrIb
oAHHotlHble
BoAo'
XpaHHJ'rH1Ia.
OAsaXo
OrlleqaeTCq,
qTo
ero
II9AKSA
nepgneKTliBeg
H
Anfi
cl'l-
CTeilI
BOAoxpaHH,'IHU{.
Ho
npp1 STOM
nOAxoIe
He
peIXeH
pgA Ba}KHblX
Bo-
npocoB,
HanpHMep
KaKHe
nepeMeHHble
H
B
KaKoN{
BHAe BKJIroqaTb
B
pefpec-
CltoHHoe
ypaBHeHHe,
KaKHe
noTepH
aQQexrtreHoCTH
ynpaBJIeHHfr
HMel'oT
iliecTo
no CpaBHeHHn
C
flBHbIM
BepofiTHOCTHblM
IIOAXOAOM
(C nparrHuecxol't
Tor{Krr
3peHr{r
3rH
norepll
npeAcraBJlfitorcfi
HecyurecrBeuHsttun).
Pa6orur
nO
CHCTeMaM
eoAOXpaHI'lnHuI.
$ollUoe
BHHI!1a'
Hr{e
B
aHreparvpe
CIIIA
rr
Kasa[sr
yAerrffercfi H
Al'tcnerqepcKllM
rpaQnxalt
A,'rff
cprcreM
BoaoxpaHII.'IltuI.
Prr$c
(1963
r.)
noxasat,
qro
npnlleHeHue
AJIq
cilcreu
BoAOXpaHlti'il.r[u
flBHO|O
CTOXaCTHqeCKOTO
no!,xoAa
BeIeT
K
pe3KON{y
VBeJrHr{eHItto
3arpaT
IIatuHHHoro
Bpe}leHH
Ha
pacqeT. [Uealir
n Ko'rs
(1968
r.)
npHMeHH,'Itr
All
K cllcTeille
?13
ABy.{
BoAoxpaHHJIHu{
H
ycTaHoBH-
Jlrr,
r{ro
cToHnocrb
pacqeToB
oqeHb
BbICOKa
Aa}Ke
np!{
paccivtorpeHlll{
ynpo-
rrleHHoro
Bo.r,orol(a'
Taxtte
;'Ke
pe3y.Ilbrarbl
non-vqH'ut
fa6'nHH>rep
(1971 r')'
Xa1'rc
u
Kene
(1978 r.)'
x
flepeao.r
pa6or
!,.
ilutrta,
0,.
Iecc$op,la
rt
lly, orHocflurIIxcfi
K
oJ,tiHot{HblM
BoAoxparil'lJIllula,\'l'
C.
KapalrHa,
BY-t{aur'
coAepr(Hrcn
B
[51-|.
169
---...-F--
6o.nee flepcnexTuBett,{,Jrrr
cHcreM
BoAoxpaHrrl'rnilr
Heqsnrtft
croxacruq€-
cxuri noAxor.
Xo.nn lt
Parlc (1966 r.) onruMn3upoBaxu
Ha ocHoBe
eroio
noAxoAa
TpH
BoAoxpaHrrJrr{u{a,
Bxo.u,ffrrlnx B SHePfoKoMtIJIeKT
opOnu.ll
-
Tepua.rrnto a Cenepnofi
KanuQopnuu
(ruectn.nertruft ru,u,pofionaqecKl,Ifi
psA,
In).
flonxo.q oKa3aJrcff
ycneuHbrM,
Ho
Aoporocrofluturvr
AJIfi
pacqeroB
Ha
3BM.
flepax
(1966
r.)
npelno>KuJr MeroA, Ha3BaHHuft
Hn
<<.nuHeftuuM
AHHa-
MHrrecKr4M
pacuenneHHbrll npofpailrMnpoBanr'reMu.
AfI
npH 3ToNI
Hcllonb3yer-
cfi
.urr
onraMu3aurltl
npaBHn
orAeJIbHbIx
BoAoxpaHHJIIiuI, a
IIfl
-
rJfi
o6re4uueugrr
BoAoxpaHHnHrr1
B
cucrerry.
flpu
3Tor{
noAxoAe Ii3
petreHttfi Ha
ocnose
.IIII 6epyrcx
AsoricrseHHbre
repeMeHHbre
,rJrfi
orpaHnqeHnfi
peue-
Hnft,
natnoJlnfietvlblx c
noMotrtbto
All.
B
caoto oqepeAb,
peluenne
c
noMolllblo
nn
gaer
KoJToHKH erarpn(
,IIfl. OnrraMaJrr,Hoe
peueHr.re
Aocrnfaercx
!ITe-
paqunMrl
MelKAy
AII
n
,'Ifl.
fttero[
npoBepel{
Ha cllcreMax It3
AByx
lI
qe-
Tbrpex
BoAoxpaHtrnHru
npH 24- H 36-MecqrrHbrx
pacllerHbtx
HHTepB?r'I3x.
CxoAilttocrl
HTepaIrHoHHoro
npoqecca oKd3a;-Iacb
xoporuefi,
rITo
roBoplIT
o
nepcreKruBHoctr
luero.ta.
Ha ocHoBe sroro
MeroAa
Bypac
(1965
r.)
paspa6orair ynpoil{enHylo }toAeJIb
AiIfi
cncre}{bt
Bo.r,oxpanltJlltu CaxpaueH-
To
-
Be.nrru n Cenepnoft
KannQopuun
(verbrpe
BoAoxpaHunnlua,
Aecfirn.Iler-
uxa au6opKa
Fl4porpa$on).X9ltn
H
Ip.(1969
r.)
paeau.nPl
l{eroA fleplrxa:
BMecro
HcnoJrb3oBaHufi
rBoricrneHunx
nepeMeHHbrx
B
qacTn
MoAenH
c
Afl
oHtI
flnpeAnox(fi,IlH
onpeAeJ'IsTb H
3aAaB
aTb
Airfl
MoAeJII.l
c
An
HeKoTopble
orpaHHr{eHHfi,
r{To
oxa3aaocb 6olee
sQQertasuutvt
(yureuo,
r{To
BpeM.E
pe'
ureHufi
Ha ocHoBe
!,ll
yrrreubruaercn nprd cyx(eHult
o6,racrl{
onpeAeneHltr).
PuSc
n
Fonuu
(1970
r.)
cAeJIaJII{
roAxoA
flspura
6onee
rpaKrHrIHblM,
Ho
B TO )Ke
BpeMfi
OHH
npHIUJIIt
K
BbtBOAy,
qTO
3TOT
IIOAXOA
OqeHb
AOpOf
no
BbrrrHcneHHarvr.
HanpHMep,
pacqer
oAHofr
.{acrHofi
t{oAenH
norpe60aa.n
20
q
pa6oru
Ha
3Br!l
HEM 360/50.
B xosUe 60-x
rogoB
Bcne1crefie
6o.r1nuoti
rpy4oeMKocru
paccMoTpeH-
Hbrx Bbtrxe
noAxoAoB craJIH 4cKaTb
ynpo[IeHHble
pelxeHuq. Peeer.n,
Axe-
pec
H
Kep6er?
(1969
r.)
ilpeAno)Knnu HHrepecHoe
ynpoilIeHlie
noA
HasBa-
HHeM
<<npaBuno
JlHHet?soro
peIUeHHf)>.
3ro
npaafiJ'Io
paHee
(1958
r.)
6u.no
npeAnolKeno
9apnecou,
Kyneporlr
H Curuos.a,coll
AiIfi
onpe.(e,lenur
creneHn
orlHcTKH
MaceJr
npll
HafpeBe c
yqeroM
croxac'rlrqecxoft
3aBIICHMOCTII
OT
nO'
roAbr.
flpnlreuareJrbHo
K
BoroxpaHHnHIrIarI
3To
npaBHJIo 3aKfiIoqaercfl
B CneAyIO[IeM:
IIpeInOJIataeTCfi,
IITO
oTX,aqa H3
BOtrOxpaHIIJIHIIIa
fr
g
/-lt
HHTepBaJre
nsuefiHo
3aBtrcHT
or HanoJrHeHHfi
Bo,r,oxpaHLInHuIS
5r HZI HaqaJIo
STofo
HHTepBaJIa'
T.
e.
rt:st-bt, tAQ
bt
-onpeA€r'Iff€Mblft
napaMerp
IIo-
.qeJrn.
.[,rn
yxasaHHoro lssefiUoro
npaBnna
peIUeHHe MoXeT e$Qexrneuo
BHnoJrHflTbcfi
c
nououtrp
II[I.
B
cepun
pa6or
(Peeelaa,
Kep6er, ,[lxepeca,
JIu6uana, HaRxa,
Aopa
kr
Ap.)
OTOT
noAxo.{
6tt;t uO1ltQnUllpoBaH,
pacullpeH
II
npl'llvleHeH
AJtf
peueHufi npo6.nelt
yrpaBneHnq. OAHaxo
Bo
ltHofux
pa6orax (uanpnltep,
.Ilayrca,
.[opQuana,
1975
r.) 6u.no
noKa3aHo,
qto
,rHseftHoe
npaBHJIo
AaeT
6o.nnrulle
florepu
n a$Qerrr{BHocrrr
ynpaBneHllfi,
Iloro}Iy
qro
Ha
ynpaBneHlle
cucreuoft
grHil{
npaBunorr
HaKnaAbIBarorcfi
oqeHb
:fiecrI(IIe
orpaHflqeHIIfi.
flonOxeune
cyqecTBeHuo
He
y,TyquaeTcfr, ec;.:n
B
npaByrc
qacTb
ypaBHeHl'tx
170
aTofg
[paBHJIa
BBeCTI{
qJIeH,
3aBHcfiIIlHfi
Ot
paCXOIa
peKn'
CAe'naH
BbIBO]''
qTo
3TO
npaBHno
HenpHfoAHo Anfi
onpeAeneHHff
OnTI{MaJIbHblx
AHcfleTqep'
cKr.rx
fpaoHKoB
oAHHOqHbIX
fi
ClIcreM
BoAOxpaHHnI'IEI'
HulepecHoe
flccxeAoBaHHe
6ltno
BbInoJIHeHO
A
1970
r.
npHMeHflTeabi{o
x TexacCroli
Cucte,lte
BoAogga6xesns.
OnnOfi
H3
MHOTHX
rvtgge'netf,
Pa3pa-
6OTaUHUX .{Jr.fl
3TOft
CIICTeTVbI,
6utna
OSTHMH3aqHOHHaR
MOAeJIb,
Ha3BaHHafi
MoAenbro
pacnpeAeneHHrr
BOAbl.
B
gtoft
MoAenH
I',tclioJtb3yeTcE
anropltTM
<Dy.rrrepcona (onruuusauHfi
noroKoB
na
rpaQe)
I4
peulaeTcg
CneuHaJlbHafi
3anaqa
IIf[:
cnctelYla
BoAoxpaHHnHIII
npeAcraBneHa
KaK
cerb
c
eMKocrffMl'I'
COCpeAOTOqeHHbIMII
B
TOqKaX
nepegeqeHl'Ifi
,'tUttt'tfi
H
COeAHHnIOtrluX
Ayr'
peuresue
onpeAenfeTcfi
KpHTepueM
flonyqeFrHt
M-riiiliiviatbiiofi
ocuieil
croN-
MOCTI.{
noToKoB
rlepe3
Bce
AyrH.
V'IHtHealoTcfi
orpagl'IqeH}Ifi
tro
HenpepblB-
HOCTH
flOTOKOB
rr rIO
AO[yCTHMbrM
npeAenaM
noToKa
B
Ka]KAOft
Ayre'
Perue'
HHe
npotr3BoAfiTcs
nocJIeAoBaTeJIbHo
Ant
BpeMeHHbIx
I'IHTepBanoe'
A'nroputtrl
npHMeHeH
Anfl
cHcTeMbI
H3
18
no4oxpaHI{JIHIII
c
42
lyraukl
LJtfr
36-'netsero
fr{ApoJrorgqecKoto
pfrAa.
Bpervrn
cqeTa
na
3BM
oKa3anocb
6o'nlututvt,
xO
oKo
B 20
pas
MeHbrrre
(a
o6tem
naMfirH
n 35
pas ueHilue)
no
cpaBHeHnIO
c
BpeMeHeM
cqera
no
craHAaprHoMy
a'nropufi'ry
IIfl'
Ilayrc
(1976 r.)
paepa6orarr
!r
npHMeHHrI
AJIS
pfr^a 3a(aq
nnaHupo-
BaHHfi
pelKlIMoB
BoAoXpaHHnHuI
anropgTM
c
HcnoJIb3OBaHHeM
'}.IfI
Aag
onpe-
/LeneHHq
rapal{TrtpoBagHbl1
OTAaq
Anq
Bqero
peqHorg
6aCCefiga
(r'
e'
'4la
npeaBapflTeJrbHofo
onpeAefieHHrr
cooTBercTByIOilIHX
3OH
Ha
pHc.
5.1,
xoro-
pbre
3aTeM
IltOryT
6strn
yrOUHeHbt
Ha
OCHOBe
6O.nee
rot{HbIX
IIMHTaUHOI{HbIX
HccneaoBaHuft).
oAsaxo
ocHoBHoe
BHlrMaHrre
B
npaKrHKe
cillA
n
Kasalst
yAeJlflercfl
paapa6orxe H
npHMeHeHHro
LIM
HT
a
UHo
HH
bI
x
I{oAeneft.
Onrnusaa-
uttoHHble
MoAeJIH
Ha
npaKTHKe
nPnMeHstorcq
s
6oree
ofPaHHqeHHoNI
o6l'
eMe,
qefrt
HN{HTau}loHHble
MoAeJIH-
flpaan'na,
nonyqaeMble
Ha
ocHoBe
onrH-
IUr{3a(HOHHbrx
MoAeaer?,
ytouriff
roTcfi
Ha
fl
MHTaUHOHHbIK
IlIOAenfl
x.
B
uunta[HoHHblx
lvlor,e,'Ifix
AJIfi
IIoHcKa
peureuurl,
6lHgxHX
K onrHMaab'
Hbrlr,
HCnO,,rb3yeTCf
npotle.f,ypa
npo6
n
OtUU6On,
qTO,
KOFIeqnO,
rpe6yeT
npo'
Be1,eHHfl
6olnuiorO
qHcna
paCr{eToB
n
6onsruux
3aTpaT
BpeMeHH
na
3Br\1'
Ho nlruraqltoHHble
MOAeJIH
HMeloT
?I
pq,U,
npeg1{yqeCtn,
o6ycJIoBIIBuIuX
trx rrrHpoKoe
pacnpocTpaHeHHe.
Osu
ng3BoJlfllor
6o.ree
IeTaJibHO
IIoAeJIHpo-
BaTb
lrsyr{aeM_Vro
cHcTe}t,v.
Orin
rn6xu
np11 onpeAe1eHllg
npaBHJI
Axn
Bo-
.(oKpaHI[",'IHIII
*lHoro[e;1€Bolo
Ha3HaqeHIIfl,
KOfAa
HeKoTOpbIe
Uenpl
He
MOryT
6srru
OUeHeHbI
3ttoHOlIIlqeCKH
(nanplllrep, I{CnOJIb3OBaHHe
BOAOXpaHHT'IHIII
AirE
oTAbrxa,
yuer
Qaxropa
coxpaHeHHx
plt6nux
3anacoB
vt
xl'tsoiit
npll-
po.qbr
H
T.
n.).
L1,
HaKoHeu, ueHHO,
qTO
OHH
6Ortee
aKTI',IBHO
BOBIeKaI'oT
B npoUeCC
nnrpa6orXl
npaBH,'I
ynpaB;1eHI.Ift
TeXHO"1OpOB,
ynpaBnfIOIIlHX
pe-
x(filltolt,
qTo
no3BOJ,lfleT
HcnoJ'Ib3oBaTb
HHTyIIuHIO,
OIIbIT
H
3HaHHfl
nocJIeI-
Hltx rI
r€-\r
csrrbr:ir
co3J,aTb
y
Hlrx
66,rruiuylo
3aHHTepecoBaHHOCTb
B
npaKTH-
qeCKOlt
npIIlleHeHlitt
t'tOl,e,reft
.
B CIIIA
lt
Kauale
pa3pa6oraHbI
ll
llcno,''Ib3ytoTcff
Tblcflqil
pasuoo6pas-
Hbr.\
riltHTaUHoHHblX
rto.le;ieft.
OnU
B OCHoBHOIU
npe,{,Ha3I{aqeHbl
n.nfr
He-
guepreTnr{ecxi.tx
eOrlO\OSnftCTBeHHbix
CHCTeII1
[I iI]1el{CT
qaCTHbI}"I
XapaKTep'
t7r
Ho
uueercfl
Lr
pflA
lrore"cerl 6oree
o6urero Ha3HaqeHnq. Tax lroAerb HEC-3,
paspa6oraHHax
Kopnycolr
HH)KeHepoe
CLIJA
e
1970 f., Hiltlrrlrpyer orf,aqy
crrcreM BoAoxpaHHJrHur lrHoroqeneBofo Ha3HaqeHufi
H
npnfoAHa
A,'rfi
arc6oir
cucreMbr BoAoxpanHnfiu{ Lt KaHa,'roB.
Pacqer
orAaq Hr,er
or BepxHero
K
HH)KHeMy Bo.qoxpaglrngu{aNr KacKaAa
(o6uuno
rpH HTepauHr{
B Ka;K.ro}t
Bpel{eHHoM HHT€pBdJe) u
or
nepBoro
Ko
BTopo}ry,
TperbeNry
H
T.
r.
pac-
qerubrilr
ilrecfir{Hbnvt
HHTepBaJraM
c
iroBTopeH}re}r
urepaurrfi
(aHa,rorur \ro.r,e-
JLH
pacqera pexHilroB
f 3C
Ha
saraHHbre rtapaNreTpbr,
paccivrorpeHiioii
a
u. 9).
Pacqeru Be.{yrcfl
.{nfi
cepflH
rn.rporpaQcB
c
rroc.le.t.vtorrtu}r
c}'}r-
ITIIIpOBaHHeM OT,[aq.
B
oAuofi Hs t'togltQltxaqllti sroil lto,IeJu
paccMarpnBalorcfi
H
yror{HflIo
r-
cff
B
xoAe Hil{HTarrHH
TaKx(e
yKasanHbte
Ha
prrc.
5.
I soHsl
rr
Jrvtrytr,u,rlcner-
qepcKoro
rpaQuxa. A,aropHrlr
ArrcnerqepH3auHri
AJrfl
cncreMbl
BoAoxpaHrr-
,rraur
npeAyciwarplrBaer
pa6ory
ncex BonoxpaHHJrHuI
B HAeHTHT{Hbrx
3oHax
H.nH
nOA3OHaX,
tlTO
XOTfl
H
He OnTHlIafibHO, HO nO3BOJIger fn6XO MeHRTb H
yquTbrBaTb
xapaKTepHbre ./'rr4HHH r.r 3oHbr
.lHcnerqepcKoro
rpaQnxa.
Mo.qear
HEC-3
rxupoKo
pacnpocrpaHeHa
Ha
npaKTsKe
B
ToM
qncJe
H
nororlry,
rrro
MoAenb xoporxo
AoKyMeHrHpoBaHa.
Aan
cncreuur
<<ApxaH3ac>
gTa
MoAenb c,'ry)KHJra
Enn
HMrrrauHH
pa6ornr
18 no4oxpaHlrauur
u 8 f3C
no 2l-rerHBM! ruApoJrorlrqecKorvry
pffry.
C
nolroubro
HMurarrHH onpeAeirr{-
"IIHCb
ONTI,IN{AJIbHbIC NPABHJIA
YNPABJIEHI{fi.
B
uoAeru
SIMYLD-l[,
paspa6orauHorl
.rnq
Texaccxoft
cucreMbr
Bo.to-
cna6xegnq,
coAepxnTcfi H
onrnMHeaunossurr?
6.nox:
no
aJrroprrrMy @yr-
KepcoHa B Kax(,{,oM
HHTepBa,'re onpeJ,e,'tf
roTcfi
onTtrManbHble npaBrrxa
ynpaBJreHr{f
.
B
Mo.iteJrrr,
paspa6oraunofr
AJrfl Aenapra\{eHra
3aurHTbr oxpyxaroureir
cpe.nbl
r. Hlrc-PIopxa,
yr{HTbrBarcTcr
raKi.r{e
HHTepecbr 3ar.[nrbr Hrr;*(Hrrx
6reSon
or
HaBoAHesnfi
u
noryquJra
pa3BHTHe
uAeq
<<3oHlrpoBaHLrs>>
BoIo-
xpaHH.irHuI
(clr. pHc.
5.1
)
.
B
xoAe lrMHTarlur{ onpeAenflercfl
noJroixeH}re
oT,u,eJlbHbrx 3oH
v
ocyulecrBJrfieTcq
noA.xep;*(aHlre
Bcex BoAoxpaHlrJrrrq
B
ON,NHAKOBOM
3OHAJIbHOiVI IIOJIO}KCHHH.
B
il{or,eJrn
ACRES
onrlrrvrlr3aqnousltfi aJropnr]r
cD,v,rxepcona
HcnoJb-
Byercg
AJrfr
MrrHHNIu3auHH orr.toseuuft
or
coorBercrByrounx
,rlrHurt
Arrc-
nerqepcKoro rpaQnra, T.
e.
c
noN{ou{bro
3roro
a.irroprrrMa
peaarr3yercfi
no.r,-
Aepx(aHrre
Bcex
Bo^{,oxpaHn,rllu{
B
o,q,HHaKoBbIx
3oHax.
B
eroir MoAe,{!r }t}rrr-
Taurrfl
Har{HHaercfl
c
orpar(ennff
He.q,anHeir npaxruxu pa6orbi
clrcTeMu
(rarc
Ha3brBaetrran
xann6poBKa
clrcrelrlr).
!,a.nee
c
yqacrlre\t
nepconana
cncretrbr
H clrcreirlHbIX atantrilKoa o6c,u"xAarorcfi
rr rrrvrlrrtrpyrorcfi
ynyqueHrrfl
B
ynpaBneHun
cucrelroli.
Huxe npHBoARTcfl
MoAe.rrH, ricno.rrb3ye]rbre npn
ynpaBJreHrrrl
orAexbHbr-
IVIH
BOAOXOgqHCreeFIHbtil{H
CHCTeMaMII.
Cucretwa
BoAoxpaHl{,{nur
TVA
pafioHa
TenHeccn Bg"rr;rrr
Ha roro-Bocro-
xe CIIA npe,rHa3Haqena
.rnfi
3ar.qrrrbr or HaBoJ,Hernrft, npoH3BoAcrBa
r]r.rpo-
SHeprrlrr rr co3.{,aHrrrI
yc"roeafr
,4".'rfl
HaBHfaulrrr.
[onoaulrre.rrbHbre
ueJ]r
-
ynyqueHHe
KaqecrBa
Bolbr,
cosAaHlrfi
yc;loerrir
.1',rr
orAbrxa
Ha BoAoxpaHrr-
Jruru{ax. flpu HoplrarbHbIX
vc,'roBlrffx
(r.
e.
ttoc.ie
BbrrroJrHeHrrn
rpe6oeaulrfi
t72
flo3auHTeoTuasoAHeHHli)ocHosHofteaAaqeftcTaHoBHTcffgKoHoMHqHoe
npo?l3BOACTBO
rlr.(po3Heprtrfi.
Haqltsas
c
1972
f.
ocyuecTB'rfleTcfl
npoeKr
co3.u,aHrrfi
cr.rcrelrbr
lroAereii
no
ynpaBJreHHto
BoAoxpaHH,'IHIIIaME'
flpecle-
J,yroTcrl
uenH
y,lyqueHrrfi
nHsoplrauHOHHOlo
o6ecneqeHHfi'
noBbllIIeHHfl
one'
paTHBHOCTH
irpHHfiTHfi
peLueHHii
no
ynpaBr'l€Hl{io'
onT?iil{H3aUHfl
ynpaBneHHff'
MoAe:ru
B
rlaKcHtvlad,IbHo
BO3MOiKHOII
CreneHu
HC[Onb3yloT
KOJII4qecTBeHHble
OUeHKir
aQQextUnHOcTH
.[,,rlfl
ofipe,[,eileiilifi
OTHocitTeiibHblK
AOCTOHHCTB
aJIb'
TepHaTHBHbrX
peueHnri.
HUeroTCf
I{OAe.'Ifl
KaK
Aflq
nporHO3HpOBaH}Ifi
BXOA-
HOli
nHQOpilrauHH,
Tar(
LI
,u.,1fl
HMHTaulir',r
QynxlIHOHllpoBaHl{ff
cHcTeNlbl
BO'EO-
xpaHI4.rrHuI,
OueHKH
ue,leit
ynpaBneHIlfi
H
Hccile.x,osaHHft
IIO
Ontuvallrioit
CTpaTer-HH
ynpaBJIeHHfi.
ivioAe.rtr
iipe.LHasiiaqaiOTcg
I'1s
HCIIO'[h'3OBeHflfl
B
yc.IIoBHfX
3Kc[nyaTauHH,
a
TaK}Ke
npH
oueHKe
npoeKToB
pa3BI,ITHfi
cHcTe-
Irrr.
oun
peuaroT
3a,I,aqH
KaK
.u,oJlrocpoqHoro
nnaHHpoBaHHfl
pelKH!{oB
no
He,le.fifllvt,TaKHH€.[,€,',IbHoFOnnaH?IpOBaHHfinocyTKaMilcyTot{Horon.IIaHII'
poBaHHf
11o
r{acaM.
Hanpnuep, AoJlrocpoqHaq
N{o.q,eJlb
paspa6oraua
Anfr
18
BOAOxpaHHnr{u
Ha
nepHoA
25
npeAcTofiu{Hx
HeAeIb'
onrHnltsauHq
c
nolrlorrlbro
Atl
ocyuecTB,{fleTcfl
no
KpHTepHIo
nonyqeHHff
lvlHHHIlIyMa
TaK
Ha3brBaelf
ofo
HHAeKca
or.{,aq
-
3To
cno}KHafl
QyHxultr,
orpax{aoutafi
HHTe'
pecbInflTHyI{acTHHKoeBXK(noraI{TovtIHTbIBaIoTcRcToltMocTbf}IApo-
3HeprHH
r.r
yutep6n
oT HaBoAHeHnfi).
I,iUercrcs
KaK
AeTepMHHlIpOBaHHafl'
TaK
Ir
CToxaCTHr{ecKaH
NIoAe,'ill;
BrOpble
-
yMeHbtxeHgoro
O6leva'
BstnonHeHtte
peiKI.rrrHbrX
OnpaHnueHtlli
perJlalueHTHpyeTCfl
saAaHHblMI'I
IIpHopHTeTaDIlI'
B KpaTKOCpOqHbrx
rlronenf
x
yqHTblBaeTcfi
allHalvlHKa
BOAHOTo
iloroKa
c
ue"Ibto
KoHTpoJ'Ifl
noJloBoAbfl
H
yrytlileHiif
KaqecrBa
Bo'u'bl'
3aeepureHlie
paspa6orxrr
n
BHeApeHrre
sceir
ceplrlr
uoAeleli
3anJIaH?IpOBaHbI
K
1985
r'
Apyraq
crrcreMa
BOAOXpaHHJIIIII
(lleHrpa,'r
Ba.nlu
B
sanaAHOfi
r]acTu
cIIIA)
TaKiKe
npe.[,cTaBJfleT
C.;IOiKHylo
so,,LoxosqticTBeHHyro
cHcTe)vty
illHO-
fOUeJIeBOfO
Ha3Har{eaug.. D,ng'
ErOl't
CttCrel!bl
MaTel\IaTHqecIiHe
N{OAe'1H
pa3-
pa6aroleaprgfl
c
I970
r.
B
rpex
oCHoBHblX
HanpaBJ'IeHIIqx:
IIR
CttCteltsOir
3KcnIyaTaulltI,lJIfroueHKIIKaI{ecTBaBoI.bIIIrH.{po.r.IorHqecKIIe}ion.e.rli{'
OCO6Urft
I{HTepeC
ilpe,{,CTaB,'I5{IOT
MOAe,'IH
^{,;'Ifl
CtrCreUHOft
3KCn.nyaTaUII}I
6oriUurOrO
qliCJIa
BOAOXPaHHJIIIq
H
CBf3aHHblX
C
HHMH
KaHa'tIOB,
HaCOCHbIK
cranuHft
ri
f3C.
BaxHofr
uenbrc
ynpaBneHllfi
BOAOXpaHIIJIHUIaMII
qBrffercfi
yBe,lIiqeHIre
npoH3BoAcTBa
rptApo3HeprI{H,
A,'Ifi
qeFo
B
noN{ouIb
TexHoJory
paspa6oraHo
6
rroAe;rei'r:
AOnrOCpOqHble
Ha
nepHotr
l2
npeacroflglllx
llecf-
ueB,
tvrecflqrrne
ga
3l
npeAcTofu{I{e
cyTl(H,
CVTOqrlbIe
C
pacqeTatttlt
no
24
q'
.[,Orf
OCpOVUste
]1OAe.llI
BK;IIOr{3tOT
KaK
OnTUMII3aUIIOI{Hble,
TaK
II
II}11{Ta-
tIIioHrIbIe
}loAe,lII.
onrttrrllsauHoHHafi
Mo'u,e-,Ib
paccqIITbIBaeT
ontH\ta,'IoHltl"I
peiKI.tI{
qeTbtpe.\
ocHoBHblX
BoIoxpaHllJIiluI
cl{cTelvtbI
Ha
ocHoBe
IleTo'C'a 'n'[l
(Hcc,.rel)'ercfl
II
coqeraHge Afl
c
ilil).
CyrouHan
N{ol'enb
flBJ1fercfl
onrll-
nlrsaquoHHOfr;
OnTHMU3auIIf
ocyulecTB"IfleTcfi
llTepaullflv{Ii
Ha
ocHoBe
}te-
ro.X,oB
Atl
H
,IIII.
Taxaf
NIole,lb
noi!{r!Nlo
qacoBblx
Harpysolt
f3C
onpe-
J,eJrreT
rr
HarrBbrro.u,ueiiuufr
cocraB
pa6orarcruero
o6opylonaHHa
(nel1'rcr
pa6Orsr
nO
Onpe.Xe.leHlItO
IIHC"'Ia
Onpele,rlHeltblX
MOAe.qbIO
n,VCKOB
-
OCTaHO-
nox
o6op;-.foBaHtrq
B
cooTBercTBllu
c
rpe6onaHHff1r{ll
npanrirxlr).
l{Hrepecnal
Het(OrOpble
ltToril
BoCb]1i{JeTHero
nepllola
paspaSorxtt
}l
}{CnO"Ib3OBaHIlfi
| /J
-*.l-rJ----:
I
t
{
I
I
MoAeneft
B
Ueurpafl
B3nnrr.
Bupa6orxa
rrr,upo3Heprr4u
Ha eAr.rHuuy
BoAbl
3a
3TOT nepr{oA BO3pOCna
Ha l0
0/o
-
qacrb
srofo
yBenHrreHHr
nu6opxlr
cBfl3aHa
c HcnoJIb3oBaHueM
uo4ereft. flo.rlsy
lrpHHecno He
roJrbKo
He[o-
cpeAcTBeHHoe
Hcnonb3oBaHuo lro4e.neft,
Ho
n caM
npouecc
ux
paepa6orKrr,
noseornsturdfi
nyque no3Harb
cucreMy.
Moleau oco6enuo
rroJre3Hbr
upn
3aMeHe
sKcnnyaralrHoHHoro nepcoHana
HoBbrr[:
Arfi
6oree 6ucrporo
noJry-
qeHHfi
siiai{Hft
HoBbir}i
nepconanoM
B
iiacrn
npHHfiTHfi
peueunfi
no
ynpaB-
.tIeHHn. OqeHu
aQSexrueurrtvr
oKa3aJrocb
coqeraHfle Hiltprraqr.roHHbrx
MoAe-
neft
c onruMH3auHoHHbIMH.
OntxMusaq?IoHHbre
ruotreJll4 oco6eHuo rroJre3Hbr
Ha
HaqaJrbHoM 3Tane no.qroroBKn
peueHuft
no
ynpaBJreHnrc;
nocneAylorque
^c
Jr.u.rnsdflx
ernA'
PtrLutrnnn
utrJiecuuuPaJtlu
lruSilal-aIb Ha
nMfllaq?luftHbre
MoAenH.
[enecoo6pa3Hn
pa3pa6orxa
ceMeftcre lroAe,refi
-
or
naH6olee npo-
cTbIX
npaBI{JI
fl
MeTOIOB aHanH3a
AO
CJIOXHbIX H
AeTaflbHbIX.
OrMe,Iaercc- aKTyalrbHocrb
AanruefirueFo
pa3BHTHrI
MeroAos
fl
I,IoAereIi
,,Jrfr
ynyqrueHuff
ynpaBneHtrq
cflcre&raftrr{ BoroxpaHnnnur. Vnyurueure
Mo-
Aeaeft
Aon)KHo
nonHee orpa)Karb
H3ivleHffrorqnecg ru4poJlornqecKne,
3KoHo-
MfiqecKue
H co(HanbHble
ycnovun,
6aaupoBarbcr
ria 6oree roqHbrx ruApo-
npofHo3ax, oco6euHo npofno3ax MaJIoBoAHbrx
H
MHoroBoAHbrx
yc.rroairfi.
Vxasunaetcr,
qro
€Ue He
peuleHa
npo6reua
onrHManbHoro
ynpaBneHnrr
cncreMal{a
BoAoxpaHHnr.uq.
B"\actu
onrur!{Hsaunongbrx
ruoAelefi
6o.nee
aKTyanbHoft
cqnraercn
paspa6orKa
rBHoro
croxacruqecKoro noAXoAa,
o6ec-
requBalou{ero
6oree crporoe
perueHne.
floxa
qro
raKne [oAxoAbr
npHilre-
HHMbI Jrnrrrb
AJrfl
cr.rcreM c MaJrbIM
qHcJroM
BoAoxpaHHnHuI
(a.nr
TVA
paa-
pa6arunaercfl
onrnllu3arluonHafl MoAe,'Ib
Anfi
uecru
pery,'rHpytoulux
BoAo-
xpaHHJrHuI), n
4arsneftuelt
Bo3MoiKHocrH
onrHrvrr.r3aul{oHHbrx r{eroAoB
Bo:t-
pacryr.
Ho not<a
groro
Her,
Arff
ynpaBneHHff
cucreM 6o"nee
qelr
H3
rrfiTa-
urecru BoAoxpaHHJrrru
6olee nepcneKrHBHbr
HMHTaqHoHHbre MoAeJ'rH.
C
uenblo
coKparrleHrrfi
cronrtocrH
pacr{eroB
na
3BM
HMHTauHro
peKolreg-
Ayercff
BbInoJrHflTb
B
ocHoBHovI
IIo
ABylr-Tperr
rnaporpaQaivr,
a
He no
D,;l-r4H-
HoMy ruApononnqecKoilIy
pfiry.
OnruMptsaufioHHbre r{ojlenn
ul{pe
BHeApsror-
cfi
.[,rfi
cHcreM
f3C, r,{,e Bo3Mox{eH croulrocrsrrfi
xpr.rrepr,rft onrHruusauHH.
Anq
HesHepreruqecKax
yqacrHlrxoe
BXK
npHHflrfie
peureHrEir
ocHoBbrBaercn
NOTITH
HCKJIOTIUTEJIbHO
HA
ITITIHTAII}I}I.
HO
U
ANff
C}ICTCIT
C f3C
NYTCM
}INIH-
TaUHH
onpe.[enffror
xapaKrepHble
JHHr{H
r,Hcnerr{epcxax
rpaQHKoB,
pef.fia-
IueHTHpyIOUIue
B3aHIvIOoTHoueHHfi
pa3Hblx
yqacTHHKoB
BXK.
llplt
onruuu-
sautlu
3T?t
JIr.rHHrr
yqlrTblBaroTcfi
KaK orpaHuqeHirfi.
Orrvreqaercq
aKTya.lbHocrb
npo6"rerttt
.u,ocrHlr(eg?rfi
Jryqurero
B3atrrrc-
nor{llMaHHff cHCTer\rHbrx
aHa.:rlrr}rKoB
(paspa60nHKoB
Mo,Le.nefi
n
nporparrlr)
C
TCXHOJIOTAMH.
5.5. NPAKTHTIECKOE
NPHMEHEHHE METOAOB H
AJI IOPHTMOB PACII ETA OTITHMAJI
bHbIX
AHCNETqEPCKHX
TPAAHKOB
BOAOXPAH HJI
HIq
Paspa6orxa MarrrrrHHbrx
nporpallrr
pacqera
.[]rcnerqepcKlrx
rpa$uxoa
Bo
BHVIIAS
-BU
fTV
npoeolHr'r?cb
.r,.rs
.{Byx [e"'refi:
paspa6orxa
sxc-
ni,'ryararllroHHbrx
nporpalrlr
.rirfi
KoHxperHbtx
o6texros c
ue;bro
Hx Hcno,Tb-
174
soBaHlrfi
B
npaKTI4Ke
sKcnnyaTaUI4I{
f3C
n
paspa6otxa
ucCneAoBaTeJIbcKIlx
rrporpaMivt
AJrfi
BbIflBJIeHHfi
esQerta
oT
OITHMH3aUHH
AncneTqepcKll]c
rpa-
Qnxoo,
conocraBJlennr
rpaQHKoB
pa3ublx
BHAoB
II
T'
n'
Paepaooranu
pasnoo6pa3Hble
npOrpaIvIMbI AJfl
OAHHOKHX
BOLOxpaHII-
.quq,
ocHoBaHlrbre
Ha
AHHaMHqecKoM
nporpaMMHpOBaHflH
n
BePOfiTHOCTHOM
onucaflr{H
cToKa
QyHxUunuB
pacnPeAeJIeHHg
neponrHocreir'
K
atoft
}Ke
rpynne
oTHOCETCTi
14
IIpOfpaMIvIbt
AJrfr
cHcTelt
BOAOXpaHI'IfinIq'
HO
KOfAa
a
groir
CHcTeMe
I4lIeeTCfl
JiHIIlb
oAHo
BOAOXpaHHSIIUe
AJIUTeJIbHOT9
perynn-
poBaHHr.
B
TIIIcJIo
STHX
nporpaMM
BXoAHT
H
nporpaMMa'
HcnoJlb3yeillafl
AJtfr
conocTaBd,IeHHt
OIITHMaJIbHblx
H
npoeKTHblx AHCIieTqepcKHX
rpa'
q)nKUts.
!,,1n
clrcreM
BoAOXp
aHHnHuI
AIHTeJIbHOTO
peflr'IllPoBaHHfl
pasp
a6 arstsa
-
,,IIrCb
,,rnulb
3KC[epHIueHTa.i-IbHbIe
nporpalvfNlu.
3rn
npofpal{Mbl
OCHOBbIBa"IiHCb
KaK
Ha
Q-u*nxUnnX
pacnpele,'IeHHfl
BepoqrHOCtefi
peqHOrO
CTOKa,
TaK
II
Ha
pacqerHbtx
nuSoprax
rug,porpaQoa.
B
Apyrnx
opfaHH3aunffx
pa3pa6araBanucb
H
IIpllltei{flJlHcb
Ha
npaKTlI'
Ke
npofpaMr\rbr
rocrpoeHtrfi
onTHMaJrbHbIX
yfipaBnfpulHx
syHxunft
,u,]IcneI'
qepcKlrx
rpasuxoe,
ocHoBaHHble
Ha
pefpeccHousoli
o6pa6orxe
pe3yabTaToB
AeTepNIHHHpOBaHHbIX
paCqeToB
CepHH
rl',r.rporpason'
Ilpnrvrep
l.
conocraBJreHHe
OnTHMaJIbHbIX
H
npo€KTHblx
AHCneTqepcKHX
rpaonron
f3c
r.
conocraefiffJrHcb
AHcneTqepcrue
rpaQHKH,
OnpeAeJIeHHbIe
HaocHoBeMeToAaAHHaMHr{ecKotonporpaMMHpoBaHHfi,cAI4cneTIrepcKl{MH
rpaQnranaH,
nocTpoeHHbrMH
C
[OMOrrlbIo
[plIHtTbIx
B
npoexrnoft
[PaKTHKe
*iaroLou.
Pac,{etH
BeJIHcb
AJIS
AByx
cfiyqaeB
oAHHoqHbIx
fOC
c
BoAoxpa'
rrlrJ,rHulaMH
ce3oHHoro
(rOAoeoro)
peryalrpoBaHHfl'
pacnoflox(eHHblx
Ha
pe'
KaX
C npeHMyUIecTBeHHO
CHerOBbltvt
nHTaHHeM'
Paccuo'rpuM
cHaqarla
HeKoropyro
f3C-1.
flo
eroir
f3C
HMeJIcfi
.['Hc-
neTrlepcKltfi
rpaQltx,
paapa6oraHHlttlt
npoercrHoti
opfaHH3aUlreir'
flo
TelI
xte
rrCXOAHblilI
AaHHbtM,
qTo
H
y npoeKTHofi
oprauu3aUl{}l
(n
rOu
qHC'/'Ie
rI
npt,t
rex
i11e
OfpaHHqegunx),
6ara
npOu3BeAeH
pacr{eT OIITI'IMaJIbHOTO
AHCneTqep-
cKofo
rpaQuxa
f3c
no
KpHrepHro
onrl{MaJIbHOCTU
(uaxcHMylda
eupa6orxu
rgApoSHeprnn).
!,anee
no
o6otttvt
AgcreTqepcK?lM
rpaSn-xarrt
(Ontlrnra'rlHo'
Nry H
npoertHonry)
Ha3Har{a"rlHcb
pex(HMbI
f3C
npl'IMeHHTeJIbHo
K
rltgpc-
rpaQan
flpor.gJroro
pfi.[,a cToKoBblX
na6.nrcAeHnfi
(23-nernnli
pnA)'
Pesy'rl-
TaTbr
pacqeToB
cpaBHnBaJrHcb
no
ntrpa6oTKe
fH.[po3Heprflu.
Kpolre
Tofo,
no
BceMy
pflAy npoujnblx
ru,u.porpaQoa
npoH3BoAIl"MCb
pacr{eTbr
onrrl$iaJlbHbtx
pe)KHMOB
f3C
e
npeAnonoxeHllll
nOJIHOTO
npeABH-
.I,eHHfi
cToKa
(.1ereplvtltHHpOBaHHble
onTHMH3aUHoHHble
pacueru)'
floc'rel-
Hrre
pacqeTbr
HrPa.[II
pO,lb
3TaJIOHa
-
noKa3blBaiIH,
xaXOfi
BblHrpbllu
B
3Hep-
FrIrr
:!,tolKHo
nonyr{HTb
3a
cqer
nplt6,ruxeHtln
BepofrHocrHoro
xapaKTepa
rfl.{ponporHo3a
K
Aerep
IIIIH}lpoBaHHo}Iy'
XapaxrepucTlIKII
f3C-l
Cfie,4ylox1He:
VCTsHoB;1el{o
ceMb
o,[,HorplnHblx
arperaroB
o6rleft
IloulHgcrbro
400
MBr,
Hanopbl
6p1'rro
f3c
HslreHfllorcfl
B.
E.
KocoPoruronoti.
I/D
rP,acqeru
Bbtno.lHeHbl
Bo
BHVll4?
-
BU
fTy
8
AHana3oHe 12-20
l!I, Boroxpaullnpllue
o6ecneqneaer
ce3oHHoe
pef.v;rrrpo-
BaHUe
cToKa.
flpni
pacqere
onTHlrairbHoro
A[rcnerqepcKoro
rpaQuxa
AnH
BeceHHero
nepHola
6panw.ca
nflTHAHeBHbie
pacr{erHbre
prHTepBaJbr,
&
Anx
JrerHe-oceHHe-
3l{}IHero
nepHo.(a
-
}IecfiqHble
pacr{erHble
}rHTepBaJ,rbt.
crorc
oI]HCbrB?r,rcfi
npocrblM
MapKoBcKIIlt
nPoqeccolt.
B pacqere
yqnrbrBanncb
Bce
H[{erclu]re
NfecTo
DelKlIMHbIe
ofpaHuqeHl4'F',
B
Toilf
I{Hc.[e
sa,{rnxc-rrpoBaHHbre
B
AHcneT-
qepcKoM
rpaOlrxe
npoexruofr
opraHu3a(Ha
rapaHTlrrr
o6ecneqei{prfi
rpe6ye_
rvroro
SHeprocua6xeHHq.
onraMarbHbie
ynpaBnffrourHe
QynxqtrH
Ar-,crTerqep_
l#
:ir|"Kt
Anq
Kax(Aoro
pacqerHoro
HnrepBarra
HMe.rrH
BHA ZSlrtt+rl :
,
\-5Uzr
Ypl/.
B pesy,rurare
cpaBHlrre.flbHbrx
pacqeroB
no
23-aerueMy
pflAy
rr{Aporpa-
Ooe
nonyqeHbl
KpltBbte
nPoAonxlrreJrbHocra
pa3HHubr
roAoBori
eHpa6orxu
aneprur{
f3C
ontHMa"[bHoro
H npo_
eKTHoro
AucnerrrepcKHX
rpaelrxoe
a3r
rr
pa3HHubr
ro.toeor.l
eupa60r-
KH
oHeprHrr
f3C
AerepMrrHrrpoBaH_
Hbrx
pacqeToB
H
pacqeToB
Ha
OcHo-
BE
ONTHMAJIbHbIX
AHCNCTqCPCKIIX
rpaQuxoe
rA32
(perc.
b.b).
Bo
Bce
roIbI
onTHMaJIbHbIe
AHCneTrieDcKple
rpaQarlr
naJrw
6onr,ruyro
ro,pu6or-
Ky
3neprrtr
f3C
no
cDaBHeHrrio
npo
ao fiLu,,,
o,o,hou
;"i:XT':lTl#'"l';l'TffiT;Ji;
PHc.
5.5. I(purne
npoAo,txHretbHo-
llup:utj'
li3MeHflercn
B
l"unuton'
crn
A31 u-
A,32,
noAcr{HTaHHbre
flo
or
2,6
Ao
l,020lo'
cocraBJl.flfi
B
23-.nerneuy
croKoBoMy
pfiAy
B
cpe-(HeM
sa
23
roAa
1,8%.
Orn
r{HQpbr
noKa3brBaroT
cyrqecTBeHHyro
eKoHoMHrIecKyIo
aQ$exrnnHocrb
BeAeHHs
pell(HMoB
f3C
no
onrrrMaJrbHoMy
IncnerqepcKoMy rpaQnxy.
pacr{erH
Ha
3aAaHHbre
rH.nporpaQbr
p\anrr
B cpeAHeM
sa 23
foAa
noBblIUeHHe
aupa6orxn
no
cpaBHeH[{lo
c
onrrrManb-
HbrM
AHCrrerqepcKHM
rpasltKorvr
npn6,rnenrerbHo
Ha
0,5
%.
llocaelsHe
unQpu
xapaKTeprl3ylor
sxoHoMHqecrHrl
Bbrurpbrrrr,
xoropuli
Mo)Ker
6urr
noJryseH,
ecJrH
3a
cr{eT
coBepIxeHcTBOBaHrIfi
TeXHHKH
rHlponpofHo3HpoBa_
HLIfr.
CTAHCT
BO3MO)KHbIM
NP
KTHqCCKH
OAH03HAqHOC
NPCABHtrEHIIC
CTOKA.
flo
IauHofi
fOC
6lr,r
.{,onoJrHHTeJlbHo
npoBeAeH
ynpoqeHHbrH
pacr{er
rucnerqepcKoro rpaQuxa
B 3oHe
Hs6srroqHlrx
orAaq,
KorAa
Br\{ecro
yc",.roB_
Hbr.y
KprrBbrx
pacnpe.{,eJreHnfl
BeporrHocreli
pacxoloB
peKrr
6pancn
yc.nonultt.i
cpe.uHltri
pacxoA
peKII
(npuunlralocu
C,:Q).
Onrnlranuusrfr
lucneruepcxrrfi
rpaQnx
npH
3Tolrr
no'{Tn
He
r.i3NreHlrJicfl,
a rp.v-Ioe]rKocrb
pacqeroB
cHtr3tr_
racb noqra
B
1,5 pasa.
B
KaqecrBe
Ap,vroro
BapHaHTa
conocraB.rreHrfi
onrHrrarbHoro
.fi
npo-
eKrHoro
.[Hcnerl{epcxlrx rpa$lrxoe
pacc}tarprrBairacb
f3C-2
c
ycraHoBjreH-
Hoft
wtouruocrblo
600
MBr
c
Haropaillra
14-20
)r
rr
BoAoxpaHrrJrrrqen,
o6ec-
t76
A 2.o/
\\
AJr
a3z
I
_j
neqHBaloI]lHM
Ce3OHHOe
pefy'j'IHpoBaHlle
cToKa'
conocrasreHlle
AHCnerqep-
cxnxrpaQHKoBnpoH3BoAHJTocbTo,,IbKoAnflnoJIoBoAHo|onepHoAa-B3ToT
nepnoA .{,Hcnepcrlfl
xpnnoii
pacnpeAeneHnfl
nporHo3a
npH"T-^^i."-Trl-blrlar'
Onrunta,runltr't
.*ltcnervepcxnt't
rpaQnx
t'po'i'ot*
.inun
H
npoerrHuft)
no
KpriTepr{}o
MaKcHi\lylwa
nirpa6orKPr
rHApo3Hepl'Hll.
PeqHorl
croK
onl{CblBailcfi
IIpocTbl]1
*up*ouo"M
npoueccotvt.
oAsaxo
Bce
noJloBoAbfi
(xax u
B
IIpoeKT-
-.--=. --^.r.,,,ra\ 6rrnr.r
nr3[eJ-reHbI
Ha
Tpu
rpynnbl
-
AJIfi
]lanoBoAHblx'
cpeA'
ill
;t#;i;";;;;
,:";;,
;
;oeAnolrararocb,
qro
nepea
HaqarroM
KalKAo-
|onoJloBoAbffnofl|AponporHo3y}IoxHoonpeAe.ilHTb'BKaKytofpynnyno.
na.{,aeT3TOnoJ'IOBoAbe'cooreercrBeHHo14'u'HcnerqepcKHerpaQnxucrpoH-
"^
d dd vavtitnir rnvnnbl
noroeoAtift'
Oco6egHocTbro
nocrpoeHl{fl
ffi':;;=ffi
;;;;;;;'"-'
tpu'pn*o"
"'4aHHoM
cnvqae
nBrlnitcn
Yr{er
BepofTHocTHorootpaHHqeHHflnonpeAoTBpaUIeHlltoHaeoIHeFIHft:BepoflT.
Hocrb
HenpeBb.xe*Hq
pacxoO^
uoOoi
n
unxuuit
6seS
10500
Mr/s
o6ecn€-
qHBaxocb
c
Bepoflrrlot'oto
PT
:0'99'
Onrlttualsnbie'u'ncnerqepcKne
rpaQnxn
cTpoll,,IHcb
B
yc.jloBHoft
xaleulapuori,
oTcqnTblBaeuoli
oT
HaqaJla
noJloBo'4.bff
'
uKaJIeBpeMeHH,3aKoTopoenpHHHMa,lacbAaTanepexo,[.apacxoAapeKI4
qePe3
1000
,lt3ic.
Pacqelutpex(fiMoBf3CnoAllc[eTqepcxnlrrpaQHKaMHncAeTepMHHlr.
poeauHolr
illoAentr
A.rfi
npounoro
pflAa
rnaporpaQoB
Aa'nH
CneAylotltfle
pe-
3y.[bTaTbI.Han6o,roruannupa6o,*u,".prnlrf3CnoJlyqeHaBAeTepilIHHlI.
poBaHHbIx
Pacqerax
Ha
3aAaHHbte
tuaporpa4or'
Bupa6orxa
sHeprHI'{
f3C
no
onrflMa,'IbHbINl
Allcnerqepcl(IrNl
rpaQnxalt
oKa3aJIacb
HHIKe
artpa6orxu
3Heprtrr.r
npeAbrA-vudero
C;'IVqaR
Ha
2,4-4,2
of6
(pasHsre
unSplt
A"Ifl
pasHblx
rpynn
uoo"o.r"ri
no.rroeolttr'i).
flpoerrnute
AHCneTqepcKIIe
rpacl;i:-l't
lafiw
eu{e
}IeHbluyro
(Ha
1,2-4,08 %)
eulpa6orxy
sHeprIIii
r3C,
qeM
onTrIlttaJib-
Hbre
!,Hcnerr{epcKtte
rPaQuxli'
fIpune4euuuepacqeTbInoKa3bIBaIoTcyulecTBeHHyro3KoHoMHqecK.vlo
s$QexrHaUOCTb
npHNIeHeHll
fl onTI{lu
a!'IbHblx
Al{CneTqepcKfl
x
rp
aQHXOn'
llpnrvrep
2-
,ll'ucne'ruepcxue
rpa$nxn
Anc
KacKaAa
H3
Tpex
f3C
c
BepxHHM
BOAoxpaHHnHuleFl
MHOronerHero
perynHpoBaHHf
l'
Paccltarpn'
BaJIcf
KacI(aA
II3
TpeX
f3C,
B
KoTopoM
BepKHffl
r3C-1
nrueet
BoAoXpa.
Hrrr.l!{[Ie
r{HoroJreTHero
pet-YaHpoBaHHfl,
a
l?c-2
rl
f3C-3
-
BoAoxpaHI{JII{-
uacyToqHoroperynHpoBaHl'tfl.BcTBopaXllr2uttxgero6oeQaf3C.l
yrrHTbrBantrcb
3a.x,aHHble
otpaHllqeHHff
n
Qoprvre
HepaBeHCTBa
no
cpeLHeHH-
TepBa";rbHbrNl
pra*ooun,
peKll.
vcraHosneHHlte
]v{oulHocTlr
f3C
cooTBeTcT-
BeHHo6rtaupaBHbIlS,43ir84MBr,cpe.{.HHeHanopbl_cooTBeTcTBeHHo
10,9;10,5u22rr'BpacueraXyqfiTbIBa.flIlcbTaK}KeofpaHI.lqeHIIflnocpe.lHe-
trHropBs;lbHbrNr
pacxolalt
so.1,bl
B
HHiKHlle
6se$sr
f3c'
no
ypoBHflvt
Bo'u'o-
xpaHH.rrrlu,
no
.1'n,rtapnoii
rapaHTHpOeaHFIoit
MOrI(llocT?I
TpeK
f3c
e
xax-
AOM
trHrepBa"[e.
PeKa,
Ha
KOTOpoli
pacnolo;'I{eHbl
f3C'
I{}leeT
npel'{N{yilIecr-
BeHHo
cHero'oe
nHTaHHe.
Crox
pexll
npnlrepHo
nopoBHy
'r,eJIHTcfl
Ha
'vr{a-
croK
Bbrrue
f3C-l
u
l.uacro*
,'*.O.u
i-ac-r
fi
f3C-2.
kluercn
49-"'letrutit
IPacqetst
Bblno':IHeHm
e
BII'
fTy
IO'
f'
r{acrorttsoft'
t2-3433
177
Ta6rtnua
5.1
pfi.U
croKoBblx
ira6,rroAeuuli.
PeqHoft
croK onrrcbrBa.lcfi
npocrbrM
MapKoB-
CKHM npoqeccoM.
Pacqertt
AHc[erqepcKHX
rpaQr.rxon
npon3Borrr.;rucb
B ]texer{b
no
}re-
cflqHbltr't,
a
B [oJIoBoAbe
-
no
AeKaAHbrM
r.rHTepBa,Ta]r.
Vnpaanaoulile
Qynx-
IIHH
lllcnerr{epcKoro rpaQnxa
crporlnucb
ronbKo
.I.-rfi
Bo.4oxpaHnJrgrrla
Bepx-
uefi
f3C
H
HMeJTH
cneAyrorr{Hri
sHA:
Z?E'<,*l)
:
f
(Zua
r,
Qp),
fre
Qpr
-
cyMMa
rpflToqHocru
K crBopy
BepxHef{
f3c
lr 6oxosofi npnrorr-
Hocrn
Mexly
f3C-l
u
l3C-2.
Pac,{ertr
npoBor,rr,'rHcb
no
r(pHTeprito
MaKctrny},{a
alrpa6orxu
rrr.xpo-
3Hepfr.{H, pe)Krrilrbr
3HeprocHcTeMbr
yrrHTbrBa.{}rcb
3a.(aH}reilI
cooTBeTcTBVtO_
IrIHX
OrpaUnueunfi
Ha
cyrvrruapHyro
rapaHTlrpoBaHH.vro
Mou{Hocrb
KacKaf€
f3C.
',
Uerrom
pacrieroB
6rrna
oueHKa
eQ$exrnnHocru
pa3.JurqHbrX
npoBrr.,-r pe-
rynHpoBaHHfl
pelr(HMa
cpa6orxu
H HanorTHeHrrff
BoroxpaHHnHUI
f3c.
ConocrasrfiJIHcb
rpH
npaBlIJra
pery.irnpoBaHHfl
(nasnaueune
pex(rrIra
f3C): I)
no
KpHrepHIo
MaKcuMA,rrrnoli
eupa6orxlr
3Heprlrn
na f3C
B
yc.To-
BHfix
oAHoSHaI{Ho
sa,(aHHolf
rn.4ponoruqecxofr
nuQopuaunu (.aeteprvruHgpo-
BaHHbre pacverrr);
II)
no
AHcnerqepcxulr
rpaQrrKarr, peann3yrorlrdM
r,raKcu-
MyM
&lareMarHqecKoro
oxHAaHnfi
nnpa6orxu
Ha
f3C
3a usoro"nerulrft
fieplIOA
npH yCJ'IOBHII
nOJIHOfO
OTcyTcTBHff
eOsltOxtiOCteft
AOrrOCpOr{Horo
nperBHAeHur
crora;
IIi) no
Ancnerqepcl(I-rM
rpaQnxau,
peaJin3yrou{Hrvr
tvra-
KcllMyM
l{areMarnr{ecKoro
oiKu,u,aHlIfi
earpa6orxrr
Ha f3C
sa lrnoroneruurl
neplloA,
Ho
npH Hailwrtult
Bo3NIoxHocT
eri
nporHo3trpoBart
o6teu
croxa
Ha
6nuxaftururi pacuerHur:r
neproA (ce:ou,
rol).
flpaan.na peryJlnpoBaHnq
I
pilccqprrbrBaJrrcb
no
nporpaiuilre
onrulrrr3a-
utrlr
[JrHTeirbHbrx
pex(HMoB
f3c
B
AerepMnHirpoaauHorl
flocraHoBKe,
ii
-
Ha
ocHoBe
49-.nerHero
pfiAa
cror(oBbrx
Ha6,rueulrii
no
onrulvraJrbHbrM
,a,rrc-
nerqepcKHrw
rpaQuxau;
npaBuna
pefynHpoBaHrrfi
III npe.[craBnnrcr
co6or"l
ua6op
onruMaJrbHHx
AacrrerqepcKHx
rpaQlrxoa,
nocrpoeHHbrx
pa3AenbHo
A!,rfi
aeT
uanoft
H noBbllrlensoii
aolHocrl.I
no
rrpH3HaH)*
c,vt\{N{apHofi
npnrouuocrrr
3a
IOA.
Ilepear
cepur
cpaBHHTenbHbIX pacrreroB
npoBo.lrrxacb,(Jrfl
r{erbrpexJrer-
Hero
flepHoAa,
cocToflrqeto
H3 oAHOTO
]rHoroBo,]HOrO
rO.U,a,
foAa
cpelueir
BoLHocrrI
H
AByx
ManoBoAHbrx
.r'rer.
Peayluratbr pefyJ'rrrpoBaHprfl
no
npaBH-
,ra*t
I-lII npeacraB.rreHbr
n ta6.r.
5.1
Karc
H c!'Ie.{,oBano
o}KrrAarb,
salr6o,ruru}'ro
gHeproor.raqy
f3C
lnreev
npH
pefyJrHpoBaHHr.r
no npaBH,'ry
I,
galee
no npaBtr.lalr
III
H II.
Bnlrly
'OTCYTCTBHfi
AETCPM!IHHPOBAHHbIX
|PIIPONPO|HO3OB
PE3YJIbTATbI
PCI'YJIIIPOBA.
HHfl no
npaBHJIy
I e
npaxrHqecKHx pe3yxbrarar
He.f,ocrH)Krrivrbr,
Ho relr
He
IIeHee
trx
qelecoo6paeuo
Hrvrerb
,{,Jrfl
oueHKrr
esQexuraHocTrr
paspa6arsr-
BaelrbIX
npaBHn yqera
BepoflTHocrHoro
xapaKTepa
rrr.lpoJrofrrqecxofi
nH0op_
IrauI{fi.
178
i945-1946
(uHoroeoaHurft)
1946-
1947
(vanosoAHsril)
1
I
47
-
1948
(rraa.nooogurtri)
1948-1949
(cpeaunti)
z+Jz,
I IZ
,olo
6ce ro
Cpaawinan
pe3)'J'IbTaTbI
perynHpoBaHllg
no
npaBHJIau
I u
II, nolyuaetvt,
qTO
nOTepI.I
3HeprOOTIaqII
KaCKa.{,a,
O6ycaOnneHHble
BepOfiTHOCTHbIM
XapaK-
TepoM rg4ponoigqecxofi
HHQopMaqHH,
cocTaBJIflIoT
OKoJIo
4l
Mfin'
KBT'u'
unu
1,7
0/6
clMrvrapnor?
nupa6orxl4
KacKaAa.
BseAeHHe
B
MeTOAHKy
pacqeTa
yqera
AoflrocpoqHoro
[porHo3a
ToJIbKo
BoAHocrH
roAa
(npaen.rro
III)
IIos'
BoflfieT
sTH
IIorepH
CoKPaTHTb
na 60
|s,
uro
cocTaBJIfieT
I
0/0
cyl'ruapHofi
aupa6OrrU.
floentuIeHHe
3HeprooTAaqH
o6yc,roe.neHo
yMeHblxeHueM
XoJIo-
crsrx
c6pocoa
BoAbt B
NIHoFoBoAHoM
1945/46
r. 3a cqer
6olee
rny6oKoil
npeAnorloBo.qnofi
cpa6orxu
BoAoXpaHHJIHula,
a TaKxe
pa6oroft
fOC'1
sa
6oree
BbtcoKux
Hanopax
B rlocJleAylolune
roAbl-
Pac.{eru
A.nq
6orree
.I,JIHHHofo
pffAa TaK)Ke
noI(a3aJIH
6o.rrluyrO
aQQer-
rtrBnocrb
npaBnna
III.
floeltueHlle
nupa6orrcN
Ha f3C
EJrfl
49-nersero
nepnoAa
cocTaBH,,ro
10,8
lr.ts.
xBT.u,
qTo
cooTBeTcTByeT
0,3
0/0
CyurrrapHOft
nstpa6orxll
3HeprHH
3a
sTor
nepuoA.
fr'iABA
6
pAcrr
ETbr
H EyCTAHOB
H B
rUErOCfl
AB
H
N<EHHff
BOAbI
B
EbF
aAX
THAPOSJI
EKTPOCTAI{UH
p{
6.I.
TEO
PETHT{
ECKHE
OCHOBbI
METOAOB
PACI{ETA
Pexnrust
ypoBHefi v
pacxoAoB
BoAbl
B
6le4ax
rAC'
fn-
ApO3JIeKTpOCTaHUHH,
KaK
H3BeCTHO,
pa60TaIOT
B
OCHOBHOM
B rrnKoBoiir
n
nonynHKoBoft
3oHax
cyroqHblx
rpaQHKoB
Harpy3'
K?I
SHepfOCHCTelvl,
BC.TIeACTBHe
qefo
Hx
pex(HMbI
MOIqHOCTeII,
pacxoAoB H
ApyfHe
pelKHMHbIe
napaMerpbl
pe3Ko[epeMeHHbl
BO BpeMeHH.
Han6olee
3Har{HTe,'IbHa
BHyT
p
H CyTO
rIH
a ff
H
e
p
aB
H o-
MepHoCrb
peiKII].IoB
f3C:
MHorHe
f3C B
TeqeHHe
cyToK
N,rofyT
I.t3MeHfTb
cBotl
pex(i,IM
pa6oTbl oT no"rlHoit
ocraHOBKH
(nouHue
qacbt)
Ao
tIoJIHoti
MoIIrHocrH
(uaclt
nI{K)
3naqpITeJIbHo
pa3"THriaIoTCfl cpeAnecyTotlHbIe
Harpy3KH
f3C
nO
AHgM
HeAeJIll
Bc"leiT,CTBHe
HeAe'IIbHOTO
pery/IHpOBaHHf'
KO-
re*
179
Beipa6otxa
gHepFaH
na
I-3C,
u.nn.
rBr'r,
nprt
pa3 JInqHbIX
npaBlrnax
penynHpoBaHl{fi
I
II
II
-FP d-6
lDo,zt6
53
I
,935
436,887
7A8,612
nn | 4(|1
I'J1,l4L
614,273
417,435
628,098
J A A R,l'7
,
TT'L'T'
552,799
424,756
696,366
(1,4
r
o
(4.,
A'X
l1)
t
Qv2
c
I
!