
236 • THE ROAD TO VICTORY: From Pearl Harbor to Okinawa 
landing craft veered away to the west, ending 
up at the extremity of Red 1 where they were 
recruited by Major Ryan. 
At around ii3ohrs Shoup ordered Major 
Ruud's 3rd Battalion, 8th Marines, to land on 
Red 3 in support of "Jim" Crowe. There were no 
amtracs available at the line of departure, and 
Ruud and his men were left to come ashore 
the hard way, by Higgins boat. The Japanese 
gunners had now worked out the range to 
perfection, and the first salvos arrived just as the 
boats reached the reef. As the ramps came down 
the Marines - most of them laden with heavy 
equipment - leaped into the water amid a 
furious barrage from the artillery at the eastern 
end of
 Betio.
 From the shore, Crowe's men could 
only watch in horror as the figures struggled 
forward amid exploding landing craft and 
spouts of artillery fire. Seeing his men facing 
annihilation, Major Ruud took the courageous 
decision to order the fourth wave back. 
Julian Smith was now left with only 
one reserve unit, Major Lawrence Hays' 1st 
Battalion, 8th Marines, and they were ordered 
to the line of departure in readiness. At i33ohrs 
Julian Smith radioed Holland Smith asking V 
Corps of the 6th Marines to be returned to his 
command. Permission was granted at i43ohrs, 
and he now felt confident enough to ask 
Shoup where he wanted the 1st Battalion to 
land. His message never got through, so he 
instructed Hays to land at the extreme eastern 
end of Betio and work his way northwest to 
link up with Shoup on Red 2. Yet again the 
communications foul-up persisted, and this 
message went missing, with the result that the 
batallion spent the remainder of D-Day and 
the following night embarked in their landing 
craft awaiting instructions. 
Admiral Spruance aboard the Indianapolis 
was short of information, and could see that 
the operation was faltering. His staff were of 
the opinion that he should step in and take 
control, but he declined; he had selected his 
team and they must be allowed to conduct the 
battle as they saw fit. 
RED BEACH 1 - AFTERNOON 
Major Ryan found himself in charge of a 
bewildering mixture of men on Red 1. He had 
the remains of three rifle companies, one 
machine gun platoon, plus the remnants of 
Major Kyle's 1st Battalion, 2nd Marines. Over the 
course of the morning he had also acquired 
various amtrac drivers, heavy weapons men, 
engineers, signalers, and corpsmen. On the 
eastern side of the cove the formidable cluster 
of Japanese defenses that had caused such 
havoc that morning were still intact, and Ryan 
realized that his best chances lay in attacking 
south along Green Beach. He got a message to 
Shoup at i/
(
i5hrs informing him of his situation, 
and proceeded to carve out a beachhead by 
overrunning several enemy pill-boxes. However, 
he had nothing but infantry weapons available 
to him, and he decided that his best option was 
to consolidate his position for the night. 
RED BEACHES 2 AND 3 -
AFTERNOON 
By late afternoon of D-Day the Marines had 
a toehold on parts of Red Beaches 2 and 3. 
The battleships and cruisers continued to 
pound the eastern end of the island to prevent 
reinforcements from moving westward, and 
the fighters and dive-bombers from the carrier 
support group strafed and bombed anything 
that moved outside the Marines' perimeter. 
Sherman M4-A2 medium tanks had been 
specially prepared for the landings:
 6—8ft
 long 
extensions were attached to the exhausts and 
air intakes, to be discarded when they got