
CAUSE-RELATED PERIODONTAL THERAPY • 439
in order to make subgingival instrumentation a pre-
cise and efficient procedure. A curette with a blunt
cutting edge
must be pressed
against the root surface
with a larger force than is required when a sharp
instrument is used. Scaling with instruments with
blunt cutting edges often results in an incomplete
removal of calculus but in the establishment of a
"
smoothened" root surface. Remaining calculus on
such a "smoothened" root surface is difficult to detect
with a periodontal probe. The cutting edge of the hand
instrument, therefore, must be controlled repeatedly
during scaling. This can be done by planing a plastic
stick (Fig. 20-11).
The sharpening of hand instruments can be per-
formed by the use of either "rotating" (cylindrical or
cone-shaped) or "plain" stones (India or Arkansas
stones). Curettes and sickles are sharpened by grind-
ing the lateral surfaces and/or the face of the blade. It
is important that the original geometry of the instru-
ment is not changed by the sharpening procedure (Fig.
20-12).
Ultrasonic and sonic instruments
For many years ultrasonic scalers (e.g. Cavitro
n
®
, Am
-
dent
®
, Odontosonl have been used for the removal
of
plaque, calculus and stain. Scaling with ultrasonic
instruments often results in the establishment of an
uneven root surface. It has been suggested, therefore,
that ultrasonic scaling should be supplemented with
hand instrumentation to establish a smooth root sur-
face (Bjorn & Lindhe 1962). Clinical studies have
evaluated the effect of scaling using ultrasonic or hand
instruments (Torafson et al. 1979, Badersten et al.
1981). The authors found that debridement of 4-7 mm
pockets with ultrasonic instrumentation was as suc-
cessful for healing diseased periodontal sites as was
scaling with hand instruments (curettes). It has also
been questioned whether indeed
a
smooth
root surface
after treatment is important for successful healing
(
Rosenberg & Ash 1974). Waerhaug (1956) found that
a
junctional epithelium readapted and a normal "epi-
thelial cuff" also formed to uneven root surfaces. Prop
-
erly used, therefore, ultrasonic instrumentation must
be regarded as a valuable substitute for conventional
scaling with hand instruments and may even be the
best instrument for scaling at furcation areas (Leon &
Vogel 1987).
Recently a new type of instrument for tooth de-
bridement was introduced —
the sonic scaler (e.g.
Titan
-
s
®
,
Micro-Mega Air Scaler
®
). This instrument is air-
driven and produces vibrations in the sonic range
(
2300-6300 cycles per second). In an
in vitro
study (Lie
& Leknes 1985) and in clinical studies (Loos et al. 1987,
Baehni et al. 1992) it was shown that the sonic scaler
was as effective for calculus removal as the ultrasonic
instrument and, besides, the sonic scaler caused less
root surface roughness than the ultrasonic device.
The removal of plaque and calculus by ultrasonic
and sonic instrumentation is accomplished by (1) the
vibration of the tip of the instrument, and (2) the
Fig. 20-13. The tip of the ultrasonic instrument. Note
the spraying and cavitation of the fluid used for cool
ing.
spraying and cavitation effect of the fluid coolant. The
vibrations (amplitude ranging from 0.006-0.1 mm) in
the ultrasonic instruments are produced by a metal
core which can change its dimension in an electromag
netic field with an operating frequency between 25
000
and 42 000 cycles per second. In the sonic
instruments,
the vibrations are generated
mechanically. During the
generation of the ultrasonic
vibrations heat is pro
duced, which is why the tip
during instrumentation
always has to be irrigated
with a coolant.
Before use, the ultrasonic instrument must be ad-
justed regarding the power (tuning) and cooling ac-
cording to the manual (Fig. 20-13). The tip should be
applied to the tooth surface with very light pressure
and be moved back and forth over the surface in
sweeping movements and in such a way that its pat-
tern of vibration is orientated parallel to the tooth
surface. This will prevent damage to the root. A peri-
odontal probe should always be used to check the root
surface characteristics after instrumentation.
A novel, diamond-coated,
sonic scaler insert was
introduced by Kocher & Plagmann (1997) The authors
claimed that this type of insert facilitated scaling and
root planing in furcation areas.
Rotating instruments
Root furrows, furcation areas and root surfaces in
deep, narrow, infrabony pockets are difficult to prop-
erly debride with the use of hand instruments. At such
sites, therefore, rotating instruments such as fine-
grained diamonds (or sonic scalers with diamond-
Fig. 20-14. A fine-grained diamond for mechanical de
bridement. Magnification x 1.5.