Ващенко Ю.В. Банківське право
Подождите немного. Документ загружается.
201
2. !R!&" !D=*+, & #&!; <%@*, '!J*$A H*$ @!$"&+!&' $
H%D@!$"&+!&'.
3. K!$$ «!D=*+» $ «!D=*+!&" E&!&"!#» % I $!-
$!J'. H!&’D+!&' #*H’I+$!' !D=*+!&= E&!&"!# I H+
H! %H+"&#A+ "#!& *#$!&, $!H$! "#!&F E!#%%+, D
!E!'!@!; +!@! D"F#;;$A# C" !D=*+. "E!&"! !D=*+!-
&" E&!&"!# — C% &%@*?A!&" !'' E& &"!#, +" &-
+;$A * E!C%#" D"F#% H%D@!$"&+!&= !D=*+"&.
4. L!' H%D@!$"&+!&= !D=*+"& &?I #!H!; *%@*?A!&* !-
'' E& E"#$&" ECE"& H%D@!$"&+!&= !D=*+"& #*+*E"#$A
#E!#!H* E?$%J*, !' !D=*+!&= !+*'%$"& $ &"E!&"!@! ,'
!+*'%$!!H"@*, J%%? E?$%J*, $+!J E& $ !H!&’D+"& *<#+"&
H%D@!$"&+!&= !D=*+"&. !H$!, !' !D=*+"& !'*;$A# $
&""D;$A#
! &" !!, #'% E!I' (&"C"') "D!&"&
#+?!&= %?%'%$"&, &D<%= &"E!&"' E&!&' !''.
K CA!'* #E!#"H H%D@!$"&+!&= !D=*+"& I !' "D %?%'%$"& !-
' H%D@!$"&+!&= !D=*+"&.
5. + ';$A E&! &"+&$ #&!,' +?"I$' &+?" (%E!D$-
"), E!$!<" $ +!%#E!%$#A+" =*+.
6. K!!+ &"+$$ H+' =*+"& * C"!?A"F $ "!D%'"F &-
?;$=
, E!!+ &+!#$ +!R$"& C= =*+= $ E!!+ ,= D+$$
&D<%F #$*+C"I; E! E!!+ &"+$$, &+!#$ " D+$$ -
=*+"& * C"!?A"F $ "!D%'= &?;$=, D$&%J%!; K!#$!&!;
K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, - 492 &" 12.11.2003 .
7. K!!+ D"F#% H%D@!$"&+!&= !D=*+"& * C"!?A"F
&?;$" &D<%F, & E%R* <%@*, * T+!" +, «K!
E?$"J"
##$%' $ E%%+D @!R%F & +,"», $+!J & #$*+C", «K!
H%D@!$"&+!&" !D=*+ & C"!?A"F &?;$" +,», D$&%-
J%"F E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, &"
21.01.2004 . - 22.
$&$+, /!
1. #, ( , $! $
«0», «* 0» «-
0 $»?
2. # -$ *"-
'! $ *0 0-
<?
. .
202
3. # 0 &! % -
< "F? # -
% *"'F!?
4. $ 0 $"&0 -
'F! $ (?
5. L " *
" $"&0 ?
/!$ &$)'$%$( +&"&!
"+% " #/% " 16 $D 2003 . // >% %
#/%. — 2003. — E11. — ;. 462.
[%+% " #/% " 16 $D 2003 . E 435-IV // >%
% #/%. — 2003. — E 11. — ;. 461.
#/% «A % + "D+;+» " 7 "D 2000 .
E 2121-III // >% % #/%. — 2001. — E 1—2. — ;. 1.
#/% «A +% #/%» " 20 ;D 1999 .
E679-XIV //
>% % #/%. — 1999. — E 24 " 02.07.99.
#/% «A ;G %;'% ; ! \ #/»
" 5 ;D 2001 . E 2346-III // >% % #/%. — 2001. —
E 20. — ;. 828.
=;D «A !; !&% + @; #/-
%», !;"G ;@ AD + #/%
" 21.01.2004 . E 22.
=;D D" "%;;D, %%;D !%;;D &
+ ; !'%& @;&, !;"G A;@ AD
+ #/% E492 " 12.11.2003 .
* . . A @D "';%& "%;%.
// CG : % %& +. ?%"%$ ; ;%$ %.
— *.: =-; "G% '. . (. *+ #/%;
@%; #/%. — 2001. — %. 7. — . 312—319.
I .
. AD;;D ; %" % // CG :
% %& +. ?%"%$ ;%$ %. % 10. — *.: =;%-
;; "G% '. .(. *+ #/%, 2001. — 532 .
D. . A %% "%;-$;& ;-
\% "' &!D;. — *.: F \., 1988.
$% . =., 8" ;. :
. A%'% !";+;
"%;%% % $;&. — (.: ?%". %;., 1967.
! . P. *"%; % $; ;\%D '\-
;%. — (.: ?%". %;., 1975.
#. . *"%; ;\%D ;. — !". 2-, ". % -
. — (.: P'%, 1976.
)0 . . H!%D % I\% ). . «H$; % "%;-
;\%D» // ; "; % . — 1957. — E
12. — . 137.
203
10
85
8D D
§ 1. &%$% &4"+>% $%!= $/&B % "$%=
*%.
§ 2. &%!+ %' $%!= $/&B +@% *%.
) $%$( 4$%!.
§ 3. C$% %'/$%'+,, /&%$/$&"E %
#& 4$%$%!= &$&="%.
§ 1. %
" ( "
K!!+ " &'!@ M!! D"F#% H+', ,= "?"'
$ &""?%' +#!&= !E%C"F * C"!?A"F $ "!D%'"F &-
?;$=, E&!&" D# &DI'!&"!# H+"& D $%$!"?A'
*E&?"' C"!?A!@! H+*, "R' H+' $ +?"I$-
' D C= E$A &D<%" & #$*+C", «K! +#!&" !E%C", & H-
+= +,», D$&%J%"F K!#$!&!; K&?" C"!?A-
!@! H+* +, - 337 &" 14.08.2003 . (?" #$*+C").
T@"! D #$*+C"I; +#!&% !H#?*@!&*& — C% E!-
#?*@ D EF', &<" $ !H'"* @!$"&+.
#!&" !E%C", E!&!$A# H+' ?R% E"#? !%J
?"C%D", C"!?A!@! H+*.
! +#!&= !E%C"F, +" %@?'%$*;$A# #$*+C"I;, ?%-
J$A:
x EF' @!$"&+ C"!?A!, $ "!D%'!, &?;$ &"
+?"I$"& ? D=*&
&?#" =*+ $ =*+ "R=
;<= " "D<= !#"H H! &"E!&"F =*!+ H+*;
x &< @!$"&+ C"!?A!, $ "!D%'!, &?;$ +?"I$' D
,= =*+"& D &$+!&' +#!&' !+*'%$' <%%D +#* H-
+* H! "D D#$!#*&' E?$"J= +$!+ D ,= =*+"& < &"-
E!&"!@! =*+* H+* <%%D F!@! +#* H! H+!'$;
x EF' &" "D<= $ ;<= !#"H @!$"&+ C"!-
?A!, $ "!D%'!, &?;$ ? E%%+D* " &E?$ !$'*&<* #*-
' E%%+D* & @!$"&+!&"F !'";
. .
204
x &?*<% D !H"@* #*'"&= H+!$ ('!%$) $ #?
,= !#?"J%;
x !H'" +?"I$' %E$= ! !H"@* H+!$ ('!%$) C"!-
?A!, &?;$ E$".
'!@ #$*+C", M!! !!'?% +#!&= !+*'%$"& $
!H!H?%, !'*& " E+*& H+!$ ('!%$), $+!J
E!+* D"F#% !E%C"F D @!$"&+!; '"J $%$!"?A'
*E&?"' $ H+' E!R;;$A# $%$!"?A" *E&-
?" $ %$?A% #=!&M% C"!?A!@! H+*.
+ D"F#;;$A +#!&% !H#?*@!&*& +?"I$"& !@!&"-
= D#=. #!&% !H#?*@!&*& H+!' +?"I$"& $ !H!H-
?% @!$"&+ 'I D"F#;&$# & !E%C"F"F +#". $*+$**
!E%C"F!, +# $ <#%?A"#$A +#!&= EC"&+"&, $+!J E!-
$%H* &#$!&?% H+!'$"& H+ &D<I #'!#$"F!.
+ #'!#$"F! &D<I E%%?"+ +#!&= !E%C"F $ "R=
E!#?*@, +" E!E!*;$A# +?"I$', +M! "R% % %@?'%$*I$A-
# D+!!&<' +$'.
K" <# D"F#% +#!&= !E%C"F H+ ';$A DH%DE%<*-
&$:
i &D<% #E&J!#$" $ E?$"J!#$" H+!$ ('!%$);
i !H!&’D+!&% EF' @!$"&+ &'!@* +?"I$;
i #&!I<#% E!&% !EH*$+*& @!$"&+ C"!?A!, $
"!D%'!, &?;$, M!
"FR? ! +# H+*, $ D=*& ,,
DD<%" +?"I$' =*+ D@"! D &'!@' !'$&!-
E&!&= +$"&;
i #&!I<#* &<* +?"I$' E$= ! !H"@* H+!$ ('!-
%$) C"!?A!, $ "!D%'!, &?;$;
i !H'" +?"I$' % E$= ! !H"@* H+!$ ('!%$) C"-
!?A!, &?;$ E$" ! !H"@* H+!$ ('!%$) $ &?*-
<% #*'"&= H+!$ ('!%$) !#?"J%, $+!J !H'"
'!%$ H+!$, H+!$ '!%$, H+!$ ('!%$) !!@!
!'"?* H+!$ ('!%$) "R!@! !'"?*;
i !+*'%$?A% !!'?% *=* @!$"&+ C"!?A!, $
"!D%'!, &?;$ & !E%C"F"F +#";
i #&!I<#% &"!HJ% +#!&= !E%C"F * H*=@?$%#A+!-
'* !H?"+*;
i ?%JF &*$"R"F +!$!?A D
+#!&' !E%C"';
i D& @!$"&+ C"!?A!, &?;$ ! $%$!"?A=
*E&?"A D@"! "D &#$!&?%' &"E!&"' !@!&!!' *'!-
&';
i #$&!% H%DE%<= *'!& !H!$ D @!$"&+!; $ ,, DH%"@;
i D!&!?% E!$%H +?"I$"& * @!$"&C";
205
i ##$%'$<F ?"D #$* =!J%A " &<" @!$"&+ &
C"!?A"F &?;$";
i "%$"+C"; +?"I$"&, +" D"F#;;$A !E%C", D @!$"&+!;
H%D &"+$$ =*+* #*'*, M! E%%&M*I 50 000 @&%A H!
%+&"&?%$ C"I, #*' & "!D%'"F &?;$".
+ E"#$&" #$*+C", $ D *=*&' E%%?"+* !E%-
C"F, M! E!&!$A#, ';$A !D!H$ " D$&%$ &*$"R"
E!?!J% ("#$*+C",) E! !@"DC"; !H!$ M!! D"F#%
+#!&= !E%C"F, * += #?" &D<$ E!!+:
x !H!$ !E%C"F!, +# & !E%C"FF $ & E"#?!E%C"F-
F <#;
x E%%'"M% $ E%%& @!$"&+ " C"!#$%F E" &"-
E!&"?A"#$A EC"&+"& H+*, D"F#% EC"&+' H-
+* +#!&= !E%C"F D EF' $ &<" @!$"&+, * $!'*
<#?" "D D#$!#*&' E?$"J= +$!+ <%%D +#* H+* H!
H+!'$;
x !H!$ D H+!'$', +!$!?; D +#!&' !E%C"';
x E"+"E?% @!$"&+!; "?"F (&""?%A) $ EF' &"
= @!$"&+;
x D&%% !E%C"F!, +#;
x & !%* $ DH%"@ C"!#$%F +?"I$"& H+* &
"&"*?A= #%F=, EF' &" +?"I$"& C"!#$%F DH%-
"@
; !@"DC", !H!$ &"E!&"?A= !#"H * #=!&M" C"!-
#$%F, ,= +"?A+"#$A $ E!#;
x EF', &<" $ DH%"@ @!$"&+ !E%C"F!, +# $
"R= C"!#$%F;
x &"+& " D+& #=!&M C"!#$%F;
x !H!$ %E!D$!, ##$%', D& E" !=!!* $ EF-
$$ D-E" !=!! #=!&M C"!#$%F " %E!D$= ##$%', $-
+!J DH%"@ +?;<"& (*H?"+$"& +?;<"&) ! = $ %&"D", C"-
!#$%F $!M!.
#!&" !E%C",, &D<%" #$*+C"I;, D"F#;;$A# E"#-
$&" $+= +#!&= !+*'%$"&:
i D& E%%+D @!$"&+;
i EH*$+!&!-&$+!&F +#!&F !%;
i D& &<* @!$"&+;
i EH*$+!&F +#!&F !%;
i &$+!&F +#!&F !%;
i @!R!&F <%+;
i =*+
#E?$* E?$%J"& $ !+*'%$, *#$!&?%" &"-
E!&"!; E?$"J!; ##$%'!; ? &"E&?% E%%+D* @!$"&-
+ $ !$' F!@! & @!$"&+!&"F !'".
. .
206
#$*+C"I; &D<%" DD+ +#!&= !+*'%$"&, E"#$&"
+= D"F#;;$A# EF' " &< @!$"&+. ?+ +#!&=
!+*'%$"& &@!$!&?;$A# D@"! D ,= DD+' *+#A+'
#E!#!H!' H! D &+!#$' +!'E’;$%!, $%="+ D &"!H-
J%' !H!&’D+!&= %+&"D$"&, E%%H<%= #$*+C"I;, +"'
@!R!&= <%+"&, +" &@!$!&?;$A# ?R% *+#A+' #E!#!H!'.
L!' !+*'%$"&, +" D#$!#!&*;$A# E" <# EF' E%-
%+D* @!$"&+ $ &E?$ ,, #*' !$'*&<* & @!$"&+!&"F !'",
&D<;$A# &"E!&"!; E?$"J!; ##$%'!; " ';$A '"#$$
$+" !H!&’D+!&" %+&"D$:
x $ D"F#% !E%C",;
x DD<% E?$+ $ !$'*&<;
x " E#E!$ !#!H-!$'*&< H! !+*'%$, M! F!@! D-
'";I;
x #*' +#!&!, !E%C",;
x E"E# E?$+ H! !$'*&< $ EC"&+"& H+*, *E!-
&!&J%= D"F#;&$ +#!&* !E%C";.
! !H!&’D+!&= %+&"D$"& +#!&= !+*'%$"&, +" !!'-
?;;$A# ? D=*& #*' @!$"&+ &"E!&"" =*+
(+"' E%%?"<%= &M%), $+!J ?%J$A: !'% =*+* !$-
'*&< $ D& H+* !$'*&<. #" %+&"D$ & +#!&= !+*-
'%$= ';$A H*$ DE!&%" D@"! D E&?', DD<%' &
!$+* ! #$*+C",. "' !H!&’D+!&=, +#!&" !+*'%$ '!-
J*$A '"#$$ F "R" %+&"D$, E!$"H" ? D"F#% !+%'=
!E%C"F D @!$"&+!;. !$+!&" %+&"D$ '!J*$A H*$ !E#" &
+#!&!'* !+*'%$" &" *+ *<+!;.
TE!&;I +#!&" !+*'%$ +?"I$ &" *+ *<+!; < D !-
E!'!@!; $%="<= D#!H"& H! EC"&+ H+* D D@!!; +?"I-
$ "D D#$!#*&' $%="<= D#!H"& H! ##$%' &$!'$DC",
H+* (?" — ).
KH*$+!&", &$+!&" $ EH*$+!&!-&$+!&" +#!&" !%,
D& &<* @!$"&+ !!'?;$A# H+!' D !E!'!@!; $%-
="<= D#!H"& "D DD<%' !'% E'"+ & E&!'*
&%=A!'* "J+* H! &E#*;$A# D &+!#$' +!E";&?A-
!@! < #'!+!E";&?A!@! EE%*.
D" &+!#$ ? !!'?% +#!&= !+*'%$"&
$ &"E!&"! ! E!+* &*$"RA!@! +!$!?; H+ &D<I
+"?A+"#$A E"E#"& EC"&+"& H+*, +" !!'?;$A, +!$!-
?;;$A $ &+!*;$A +#!&* !E%C";.
+ &D<I &"E!&"?A= EC"&+"&, +' I$A#
E&! E"E#*&$ +#!&" !+*'%$ D +#!&' !E%C"', $
&D<I ##$%'* +!$!?; D ,= D"F#%'.
207
E#*I$A# $+ +"?A+"#$A E'"+"& +#!&= !+*'%$"&,
+"' @!R!&!@! <%+, + E!$"H ? *<#+"& !D=*+"&.
@!R!&= <%+=, D&= &<* @!$"&+, E"#$&" +=
&I$A# +?"I$' @!$"&+ %D?%J! &" #*', D &$+!' %-
?"DC", ;&"?%F=, E'’$= $ "&%#$C"F= '!%$, ';$A D-
D<$# " E#E!$ !#!H-!$'*&< H! !+*'%$, M! F!-
@! D'";I, F'%*& !+*'%$, #%", !'% " $ F!@!
&<", F'%*& *#$!&, M! F!@! &?.
!R!&" <%+ "F#" E!$@!' 10 +?%= "& D ,=
&E#+, % &=!&*;< %A &E#+. $ <%+* DD<I$A#
$+: $ $ "+ C', '"#CA #?!&!'. !R!&F <%+ 'I '"#-
$$ &"H$!+ E%<$+ $ E"E# (E"E#) *E!&!&J%= !#"H
(!#!H) +?"I$ D@"! D +$+!; DD+"& E"E#"&. +!#$
+#'"?% % !E*#+I$A#.
KH*$+!&!-&$+!&" +#!&" !% D#$!#!&*;$A# ? !!-
'?% +#!&= !E%C"F D EF' $ &<" @!$"&+ $%$!-
"?A' *E&?"', H+', ,= "?"' (&""?%') D !E#!'
C"!#$%F * C"!?A"F &?;$", M! E%%&!D$A#, D&$J%
" !D&$J% H+!'$"&, &<" $ EF' @!$"&+ E" D&"$
+#!&' EC"&+' E" <# &%% ?"$<!@! !H?"+*, E%%-
'"M% @!$"&+ D =*+* «+!$ $ '!%$, "+#!&" !
E%%=*&» =*!+ «+!$ $ '!%$ & +#" H+*»,
$+!J ? !!'?% D@?A!, #*' E!&%%= !E%C"F
(EF' E?$%J"& D =*+', !E%C",, &+!" "D D#$!#*-
&' E?$"J= +$!+ <%%D +#* H+* $ H+!'$, $!M!).
EH*$+!&=, &$+!&= $ EH*$+!&!-&$+!&= +#!-
&= !%= &<* @!$"&+ EC"&+' H+*, $+!J "+-
#$!' $%$!"?A= *E&?"A DD<;$A# E"D&M%, "'’,
E! H$A+!&" !$'*&<, D& !+*'%$ (E!#&"<%, E%%E*#$-
+) $ F!@! !'% (+"' !E%C"F D &<" $ EF' @!$"&+
'"J +#!&' EC"&+').
D&= E%%+D @!$"&+ ? =*& E!$+"&, DH!-
"& $ "R= E?$%J"& ! H;J%$* " C"?A!&= !"& * !$-
+!&= %+&"D$= DD<I$A# +! H;J%$!, +?#"+C",,
"%$"+C"FF !'% (+"' $= &E+"&, D += "D<
!#!H <%%D #&!, %?"@"F" E%%+! &"'!&?# &" EF-
$$ "%$"+C"F!@! !'% " & E#E!$" +!, D!H?%! &"-
E!&"* &"'"$+*).
+ '!J% EF'$ E?$%J" @!$"&+!; D =*+' #E?$*
E?$%J"& (+&$E?$ $ +!'*?A" E!#?*@, $%?%!F D&’D!+,
+H%?A% $%?%H<%, %?%+$!%%@", @D $!M!), !D*+!&-
' ;<!; !#!H!; — !$'*&<%' E?$%J"&. +F !+*-
. .
208
'%$ 'I '"#$$ &#" !H!&’D+!&" %+&"D$, +" E%%H<%" ?
&+! C= !E%C"F.
#" !E%C", D EF' E?$%J"& @!$"&+!; D &"E!&"'
=*+' ';$A "+#*&$# & E!$!+!?" H! %I#$" * !-
'", + % !E*#+I D'" F!@! D'"#$* " I !+*'%$!', M! E"$&%-
J*I &+! DD<%= +#!&= !E%C"F.
D" D"F#% +#!&= !E%C"F E!$@!' !E%C"F!@!
<#* &"E!&"?AF EC"&+ H+* +#!&= !+*'%$=
E!#$&?I $* D"F#% +#!&!, !E%C",, & E"#?!E%C"F-
F <# — E!$!<* $* " <# EF' !+*'%$"& H! E#
< R$'E «&%<"» H! «E"#?!E%C"FF <#».
+!" E!$@!' !E%C"F!@! <#* +#!&" !E%C", &"!-
HJ;$A# & H*=@?$%#A+!'* !H?"+* & C%F #'F %A, & E"#-
?!E%C"FF <# — % E"D"R% #$*E!@! !E%C"F!@! .
E&?% & +#!&= !+*'%$= %+&"D$"&, #'%: !'%
=*+"&, F'%*& +?"I$, #*', E"D&M, "'%", E! H$A-
+!&" !$'*&< (E?$+) % !E*#+;$A#.
[+M! EH*$+!&F !+*'%$ % DE!&%! H! DE!&%! D
E!*R%' &'!@, M! &#$!&?%" #$*+C"I;, H! +M! #*'
&= +!R$"& '%R, "J #*' E?$%J*, $! +?"I$ !I E!$"-
H* #*'* @!$"&+ H! !E%C" % &+!*I$A#, !+*'%$ " @!$"&-
+ E!&%$;$A# E?$+*. K!!+ *?;& !E%C", $ E!-
&%% E?$%J* &D<;$A# D?%J! &" &*$"RA!@!
E!+* H+*.
?"I$ 'I E&! DD<$ & D&" E%%+D @!$"&+ $* &-
?;$*&, + % '!J% E%%&M*&$ 10 +?%= "& E"#?
#+? +#!&!@! !+*'%$ (%A #+? % &=!&*I$A#).
[+M! $ &?;$*& E%%&M*I 10 +?%= "&, $! H+
% EF'I +#!&F !+*'%$ ! &+!.
E?$* !$'*&<' #*' E%%+D"& @!$"&+!; H+ D"F#;I
E!<;< D &D<%!, $ &?;$*&. [+M! $ &?;$*-
& EEI %!H!<F %A, $! H+ D"F#;I &E?$* E%-
%+D* E!<;< D E%R!@! !H!<!@! , #$*E!@! D %',
+F &D<%F $!; &?;$*&.
! #$ $ &?;$*& +?"I$ '!J% &"+?+$ +!-
R$, * D&’D+* D <' E!I &"E!&"!'* H+* ?#$ (? ;-
<= !#"H) H! D&* (? "D<= !#"H) E! &"+?+
+!R$"&.
[+M! !$'*&< E%%+D* E!$@!' $C$ !H!<= "& D
$ &?;$*& % !$'& #*'* E%%+D*, $! H+ !$'*&<
D!H!&’DF E!$@!' $A!= !H!<= "& E!&%*$ #*'* E%%-
+D* H+* E?$+.
209
E?$ &"+?+= (E!&%*$=) +!R$"& @!$"&+!; D"F#;I$A-
# "D<' !#!H' $ "D<' !#!H' — #*H’I+$' E"EI'-
CA+!, "?A!#$" + &E?$ E%%+D* H%D &"+$$ =*+, ;-
<' !#!H' — R?=!' D=*& ,= E!$!<" =*+.
§ 2. " (
/ . <
K!!+ D"F#% +#!&= !E%C"F +?"I$"& H+"&
%@?'%$*I$A# K!?!J%' E! &%% +#!&= !E%C"F *
C"!?A"F &?;$" & +,", D$&%J%' E!#$!&!; K&-
?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, &" 15 @* 2004 . - 637
(?" K!?!J%).
K"EI'#$& (E"EI'C"), +" &"+? E!$!<" =*+ &
H+= " DH%"@;$A C= =*+= #&!, +!R$, D"F#;;$A !D-
=*+ D #&!,' @!R!&' D!H!&’D', M! &+;$A *
@!#E!#A+= &"!#=, E"!$%$! & H%D@!$"&+!&"F !'",
$+!J * @!$"&+!&"F !'" (D !$'' <= !H'%J%A) *
E!+*, &#$!&?%!'* D+!!&#$&!' +,.
K"EI'#$& (E"EI'C") D"F#;;$A !D=*+ @!$"&+!; '"J
#!H!; " D "D<' !#!H' (@!'' +,, "!D%'C',
!#!H' H%D @!'#$&, +" % D"F#;;$A E"EI'CA+!, "-
?A!#$") <%%D +#* + D =*!+ @!$"&+!&!, &*<+, $+ " D =*!+
+!R$"&, !%J= "D H+"&. TD<%" !D=*+ E!&!$A# $-
+!J R?=!' E%%+D* @!$"&+ ? #E?$ &"E!&"= E?$%J"&.
K"EI'#$& (E"EI'C") D"F#;;$A !H?"+ !E%C"F D @!-
$"&+!; * &"E!&"= +@= !H?"+*.
< #*' @!$"&+!&!@! !D=*+* !!@! E"EI'#$& (E"-
EI'C) D "R' E"EI'#$&!' (E"EI'C%') E!$@!' !!@!
D !' H! +"?A+!' E?$"J' !+*'%$' &#$!&?;I$A-
# &"E!&"!; E!#$!&!; K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +,-
. K?$%J" E! DD<%* @<* #*'* E!&!$A# &+?;<!
& H%D@!$"&+!&"F !'". "?A+"#$A E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C"&), D +'
D"F#;;$A# !D=*+, E!$@!' % !H'%J*I$A#. $%E%
@< #*' @!$"&+!&!@! !D=*+*, &#$!&?% E!#$!&!;
K&?" C"!?A!@! H+* +, &" 09.02.2005 . - 32,
#$!&$A 10 000 (%#$A $#<) @&%A.
TD<%" !H'%J% #$!#*;$A# $+!J !D=*+"& @!$"&+!;
'"J E"EI'#$&' & !E?$* D $!&, M! EH" &!H-
. .
210
<" (@!#E!#A+") E!$%H D =*!+ +!R$"&, !%J= D +!-
E!$&' +$+'.
TD<%" !H'%J% % E!R;;$A# :
) !D=*+ E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C"&) D "D<' !#!H-
', H;J%$' $ %J&' C"?A!&' !';
H) !H!&"?A" E!J%$&*& $ H?@!"F* !E!'!@*;
&) !D=*+ E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C"&) D #E!J$* '
%?%+$!%%@";;
@) &+!#$ +!R$"&, &= &"J%;
_) !D=*+ E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C"&) '"J #!H!; E" <#
D+*E"&?" #"?A#A+!@!#E!#A+!, E!*+C",. K%%?"+ $!&"&, M!
?%J$A ! C"I, E!*+C",, &D<%F T+!!' +, «K!
%J&* E"$'+* #"?A#A+!@! @!#E!#$& +,».
D" D"F#% E"EI'#$&' @!$"&+!&= !D=*+"& D
"R' E"EI'#$&' (E"EI'C') E! *#$!&?%* @-
<* #*'* +!R$ & !D'"" E%%&M% &#$!&?%!, #*' !D-
=*+!&! !;$A# ! +$<= D?R+"& @!$"&+ & +#" +"-
%CA E?$+ @!$"&+ !!D!&! & %A D"F#% C"I,
!E%C",, D E!?AR' E!"&' !%J!, !D=*+!&!, #*-
' "D D$&%J%' ?"'"$!' +#.
C"!?AF H+ +, 'I E&! &#$!&?;&$ !H'%-
J% D &<" @!$"&+ D E?$"J' +$+'.
H'%J% D &<" @!$"&+ D E?$"J' +$+' '!J*$A
&#$!&?;&$# E?$"J!; !@"DC"I; &"E!&"!, E?$"J!,
##$%' $ H+' — <?%' C"I, ##$%'.
[+M! E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C") $ "D<" !#!H D"F#;;$A
@!$"&+!&" !D=*+ H%D &"+$$ E!$!<!@! =*+* R?=!'
*%#% ! H+"& @!$"&+ ? E!?AR!@! ,, E%%=*&
=*+ "R= E"EI'#$& (E"EI'C"&) H! "D<= !#"H, $!
$+" !D=*+ ? E?$+"& +!R$"& I @!$"&+!&', ? !$-
'*&<"& +!R$"& H%D@!$"&+!&'.
# @!$"&+, M! =!$A ! +#, 'I #&!I<#! (* %A !%-
J @!$"&+!&= +!R$"&) $ & E!&"F #*'" !EH*$+!&*&$#.
EH*$+*&' @!$"&+ & +#= E"EI'#$&, +" E!&!$A
@!$"&+!&" !D=*+ D !!'?%' ,= +#!&' !%' " &%-
%' +#!&!, +@ &"E!&"! ! &'!@ @?& 4 K!?!J%, I
D"F#% !H?"+* @!$"&+ & E!&"F #*'" ,, +$<= =!J%A
* +#!&"F +D" E"#$&" EH*$+!&= +#!&= !%"&.
D" E!&%% @!$"&+!&= !D=*+"& "D D#$!#*&'
(%I#$$! !D=*+!&= !E%C"F) H! &+!#$'
(!D=*+!& +J+) !EH*$+*&' @!$"&+ I D"F#%
!H?"+* DD<%= @!$"&+!&= +!R$"& * E!&"F #*'" ,= +$<=