46-20 The Civil Engineering Handbook, Second Edition
For plastic torsion, the sand-heap analogy has been developed, and it has similar interpretations as
those in the membrane analogy [Nadai, 1950]. Dry sand is poured onto a raised flat surface having the
shape of the cross section of the member. The surface of the sand heap so formed assumes a constant
slope. The volume of the sand heap, hence its weight, is proportional to the fully plastic torque carried
by a section.
Warpage of Thin-Walled Open Sections
For a narrow rectangular bar, no shear stresses develop along a line bisecting its thickness. This means
that no in-plane deformation can take place along the entire width and length of the bar’s middle surface.
In this sense, an I section, shown in Fig. 46.19, consists of three flat bars, and during twisting, the three
middle surfaces of these bars do not develop in-plane deformations. By virtue of symmetry, this I section
twists around its centroidal axis, which in this case is also the center of twist. During twisting, as the
beam flanges displace laterally, the undeformed middle surface abcd rotates about point A, Fig. 46.19(a).
Similar behavior is exhibited by the middle surface of the other flange. In this manner, plane sections of
an I beam warp, i.e., cease to be plane, during twisting.
Cross-sectional warpage, or its restraint, may have an important effect on member strength, particu-
larly on its stiffness. Warpage of cross sections in torsion is restrained in many applications. For example,
by welding an end of a steel I beam to a rigid support, the attached cross section cannot warp. To maintain
required compatibility of deformations, in-plane flange moments M, shown in Fig. 46.19(b), must
develop. Such an enforced restraint effectively stiffens a beam and reduces its twist. This effect is local
in character and, at some distance from the support, becomes unimportant. Nevertheless, for short
beams, cutouts, etc., the warpage-restraint effect is dominant. For further details, refer to the reference
of Oden and Ripperger [1981].
Torsion of Thin-Walled Hollow Members
Unlike solid noncircular members, thin-walled tubes of any shape can be rather simply analyzed for the
magnitude of the shear stresses and the angle-of-twist caused by a torque applied to the tube. Thus,
consider a tube of an arbitrary shape with varying wall thickness, such as shown in Fig. 46.20(a), subjected
to torque T. Isolate an element from this tube, as shown enlarged in Fig. 46.20(b). This element must be
in equilibrium under the action of forces F
1
, F
2
, F
3
, and F
4
. These forces are equal to the shear stresses
acting on the cut planes multiplied by the respective areas. From summation of forces, and since the
longitudinal sections were taken an arbitrary distance apart, it follows that the product of the shear stress
and the wall thickness is the same, i.e., constant, on any such planes. This constant will be denoted by
q, which is measured in the units of force per unit distance along the perimeter, since shear stresses on
mutually perpendicular planes are equal at a corner of an element. Hence, at a corner such as A in
Fig. 46.20(b), t
2
= t
3
; similarly, t
1
= t
4
. Therefore, t
4
t
1
= t
3
t
2
, or, in general, q is constant in the plane of
a section perpendicular to the axis of a member. The quantity q has been termed the shear flow. Next
consider the cross section of the tube as shown in Fig. 46.20(c). The force per unit distance of the
FIGURE 46.19 Cross-sectional warpage due to applied torque.
(a)
f
e
a
b
T
T
c
A
d
a
a
(b)
f
e
a
M
M
b