
228  Fixed-domain methods 
to 
be 
determined by experiment. Meyer (1973) 
on 
the 
other 
hand 
claims 
his calculated values for 
the 
temperature record at one point in 
the 
region 
for a two-dimensional melting problem around a square duct are inde-
pendent  of 
B  in 
the 
range 
1O-6~B 
~0.5. 
Incidentally,  Meyer  (1973) 
mentions a precipitation problem (Cannon and Hill 1970) in which 
the 
enthalpy actually is  continuous and piecewise linear. 
Budak 
et 
al. 
(1965) and Moiseynko and Samarskii (1965) used higher-
order smoothings  in  which,  for  example, 
the 
H(u) 
function 
near 
the 
melting temperature is  approximated by a  parabola which  ensures con-
tinuity 
of 
the 
first  derivative 
of 
the 
approximating  smoothed enthalpy 
function 
as 
well as of 
the 
function itself. Brauner et al.  (1983) discuss 
the 
smoothing  function 
H(u)=!Lp{l+u/('7I+lul)}, 
where  '71>0  is  a  small 
parameter. 
6.2.4.  Other numerical schemes and multi-dimensional problems 
The 
discontinuous form of 
the 
enthalpy function expressed 
as 
u = 
u(H) 
was  used by 
Atthey 
(1974)  together with 
the 
one-dimensional explicit 
form (6.21) though 
he 
did 
not 
use 
the 
transformation (6.8). 
The 
scheme 
was extended 
to 
two-dimensional problems by Crowley (1978). 
She solved two problems 
of 
the 
inward solidification of a square cylinder 
of liquid  initially  at  its  freezing  temperature  for two  different surface 
conditions. This problem was described in §5.4.2(i). 
In 
the 
first case, 
the 
surface temperature is lowered 
at 
a constant rate, corresponding 
to 
the 
conditions under which Saitoh (1976) carried 
out 
his experiments. Crow-
ley's  (1978)  enthalpy  calculations  using  an  explicit  finite-difference 
scheme agree well with Saitoh's experimental results and with a perturba-
tion solution in inverse powers 
of 
the 
latent heat, 
L, 
until 
the 
freezing 
front has moved about halfway 
to 
the 
centre. 
In 
the second case, 
the 
surface temperature is dropped discontinuously 
at 
the 
initial instant. 
The 
solution obtained by 
Rathjen 
and 
Jiji (1971) for 
solidification in 
an 
infinite corner provides a  good approximation while 
the 
front remains parallel 
to 
the 
sides of 
the 
square cylinder away from its 
corners.  Crowley  also  compared 
her 
enthalpy  results  graphically  with 
those of Allan and Severn (1962), Lazaridis  (1970), 
Crank 
and 
Gupta 
(1975).  . 
Implicit finite-difference schemes with discontinuous enthalpy functions 
were described 
by 
Furzeland  (1974,  1977b), Federenko (1975),  Long-
worth (1975), and Shamsundar and Sparrow (1975). Wood, Ritchie, and 
Bell (1981)  used a  hopscotch finite-difference  scheme  (Gourlay,  1970). 
Ciavaldini  (1975) 'used  explicit  and  implicit  finite-element  schemes 
to 
solve a discretized weak form 
of 
an enthalpy formulation. Hodgkins and 
Waddington (1975) also introduced finite elements. 
Li 
(1983)  adopted 
the 
finite-element discretization used by Bonnerot