
9.5 Problems 279
Other operations defined on uniformly convergent series are addition, sub-
traction, and multiplication by a continuous function: If
∞
i=1
u
i
(x)and
∞
i=1
v
i
(x) are uniformly convergent for a ≤ x ≤ b and h(x) is continuous
in the same interval, then the series
∞
i=1
[u
i
(x) ±v
i
(x)] ,
∞
i=1
h(x)u
i
(x),
are also uniformly convergent for a ≤ x ≤ b.
Historical Notes
The mathematicians of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries used series indis-
criminately. By the beginning of the nineteenth century some absurd results from
manipulating infinite series stirred up some interest in questioning the validity of
operations performed on them. Around 1810 a number of mathematicians began
the exact handling of infinite series.
In his 1811 paper and his Analytical Theory of Heat, Fourier gave a satisfactory
definition of convergence, though in general he worked freely with divergent series.
His definition of convergence was essentially in terms of the sequence of partial sums.
Moreover, he recognized that the convergence of a series of functions of the variable
x maybeachievedonlyinanintervalofx values. Although Fourier stressed that
a necessary condition for convergence is that the terms of the series approach zero,
he was fooled by the series
∞
k=0
(−1)
k
, and thought that its sum was
1
2
[substitute
t = 1 on both sides of (9.14)].
The first important and strictly rigorous investigation of convergence was made
by Gauss in his 1812 paper Disquisitiones Generales Circa Seriem Infinitam wherein
he studied the hypergeometric series (see Section 11.2.1). Though Gauss is often
mentioned as one of the first to recognize the need for restricting the series to their
interval of convergence, he avoided any decisive position. He was so much concerned
to solve concrete problems by numerical calculations that he used a divergent ex-
pansion of the gamma function. When he did investigate the convergence of the
hypergeometric series, he remarked that he did so to please those who favored the
rigor of the ancient geometers.
Cauchy’s work on the convergence of series is the first extensive treatment of
the subject. In his Cours d´Analyse Cauchy clearly defines the sequence of partial
sums and gives a rigorous definition of the convergence and divergence of the series
in terms of this sequence. It is also in this work that he gives what is now called
the Cauchy criterion for convergence of a sequence (see Box 9.1.1). He proves this
to be a necessary condition, but merely remarks that if the condition holds, the
convergence of the series is assured. He lacked the knowledge of the properties of
real numbers to provide a proof. Cauchy then goes on to state and prove many of
the results that we have outlined in our discussion of the tests for convergence.
9.5 Problems
9.1. Show that
(a)
n
k=1
kz
k−1
=
n−1
k=0
(k +1)z
k
. (b) x
2
n
k=0
a
k
x
k
=
n+2
k=2
a
k−2
x
k
.