
148 | The American Revolutionary War and the War of 1812: People, Politics, and Power
through the colonies; it was even felt in 
England,  where  in  the  House  of 
Commons  Edmund  Burke  denounced 
the use of Indian allies. In America the 
deed  galvanized  patriotic  sentiment, 
swung waverers against the British, and 
encouraged  a  tide  of  enlistments  that 
helped  end  Burgoyne’s  invasion  three 
months  later.  The  tale  of  Jane  McCrea 
became  a  favourite  and  was  much 
romanticized  in  popular  versions  by 
such  authors  as  Philip  Freneau,  Joel 
Barlow, and Delia S. Bacon.
Arthur Middleton
(b. June 26, 1742, near Charleston, 
S.C.—d. Jan. 1, 1787, Goose Creek, S.C.) 
Arthur Middleton, a signer of the Decla-
ration of Independence, spent time as a 
prisoner of war during the Revolution. 
After  completing  his  education  in 
England,  Middleton  returned  to  South 
Carolina  in  1763  and was  elected  to  the 
colonial legislature. In  1775–76 he was a 
member of the Council of Safety, a com-
mittee  that  directed  leadership  for  the 
colony’s  preparations  for  revolution.  He 
served on the legislative committee that 
drafted the South Carolina state constitu-
tion and was a delegate to the Continental 
Congress (1776–78).
At the Siege of Charleston (1780) he 
served in the militia, was taken prisoner 
when the city fell to the British, and was 
sent to St. Augustine, Fla., as a prisoner 
of  war.  After  being  exchanged  in  July 
1781, he was a member of the Continental 
of the  death  of American  colonist  Jane 
McCrea,  which  aroused  anti-British 
feeling  and  helped  sway  opinion  and 
stir  action  in  the  colonies  toward 
independence.
McCrea, a tall, attractive woman, was 
courted  by  David  Jones.  In  1776  Jones 
was one of several Tories in the area to 
join the British army.  In  the summer of 
1777 the approach of a large British force 
under  Gen.  John  Burgoyne  down  Lake 
Champlain and the Hudson River valley 
and the consequent abandonment of Fort 
Ticonderoga  and  Fort  Edward  by  colo-
nial defenders caused a panic among the 
remaining settlers, who quickly began to 
evacuate  southward.  McCrea  declined 
to  leave,  however,  because  she  had 
received  a  letter  from  Jones,  by  then  a 
lieutenant with Burgoyne, saying that he 
hoped  soon  to  see  her  at  Fort  Edward. 
Later legend has it that they were to be 
married at that time.
On  the  morning  of  July  27,  1777, 
McCrea visited  a  friend, Sarah McNeil, 
who was preparing to leave Fort Edward 
for  safety.  About  noon  the  two  women 
were captured by some Native American 
scouts  whom  Burgoyne  had  employed 
as an advance force. McNeil was deliv-
ered safely to British hands, but McCrea 
was later discovered dead, several bullet 
wounds  in  her  body,  and  scalped.  Her 
captors claimed she had been killed by a 
stray bullet from a colonial detachment, 
but it was generally accepted that one of 
the  scouts  had  killed  her.  The  murder 
and  scalping  sent  a  shock  of  horror