Юридические дисциплины
  • формат pdf
  • размер 601.26 КБ
  • добавлен 03 ноября 2011 г.
Lindquist Stefanie, Cross Frank. Empirically Testing Dworkin’s Chain Novel Theory: Studying the Path of Precedent
New York University Law Review, Vol. 80, p. 1156, 2005

Abstract:
This article provides an empirical study of the effect of precedent on judicial decisionmaking. Precedent is much analyzed as a controlling factor for judicial decisions but rarely tested for its effect. Some have argued that reliance on precedent creates a system of path dependence of the law, which may yield undesirable herd behavior. As a framework for the study of precedent, we use Dworkin's metaphor of a chain novel, in which each deciding judge writes upon a background to which he or she must adhere, thereby influencing his decisions. This yields testable hypotheses about judicial decisionmaking. Given the considerable data on the ideological component of judicial decisionmaking, it provides a means to study the effect of precedent, as a constraint on judicial ideology. First, we examine cases of first impression, for which there is no controlling precedent, like the very first chapter of a chain novel. The hypothesis is that the absence of precedent in these cases frees judges to use their ideology to a greater degree than in other cases with precedents, and this hypothesis is confirmed. Judges render more ideological opinions in cases of first impression. The second study considers the growth of precedent over time in the context of 42 U.S.C. Section 1983 litigation. The hypothesis is that as precedents accumulate, they steadily narrow the range of judicial discretion, so the effect of ideology should dwindle over time, as might be expected from a chain novel. The data falsify this hypothesis, as ideology seems to increase somewhat as a determinant as more precedents build up. The results suggest that precedent acts as only a limited constraint on judicial decisionmaking and the path dependence of a system of stare decisis is exaggerated.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 64
Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: February 17, 2006
Похожие разделы
Смотрите также

Dworkin R. Hart and the Concepts of Law

  • формат pdf
  • размер 88.06 КБ
  • добавлен 06 ноября 2011 г.
Harvard Law Review Forum. - Vol .119. - Р. 95-104. Replying to Frederick Schauer, (Re)taking Hart, 119 Harv. L. Rev. 852 (2006) (reviewing Nicola Lacey, A Life of H.L.A. Hart: The Nightmare and the Noble Dream (2004)). Philosophy and the Social Sciences. Adjudication and the Theory of Law. Can a Doctrinal Theory be Only Descriptive?

Dworkin R. Interpretation, Morality and Truth

  • формат pdf
  • размер 275.98 КБ
  • добавлен 05 ноября 2011 г.
Dworkin R. Interpretation, Morality and Truth. - Manuscript (unpublished essay). Note to the Colloquium: This essay is intended to supply one or two chapters to a book I am writing that will tie together topics I have discussed independently in a general interpretive account of value. The essay therefore covers a good deal of material that I have discussed elsewhere, some of it in past presentations to the Colloquium over several years. I apolog...

Dworkin R. Justice in robes

  • формат pdf
  • размер 202.75 КБ
  • добавлен 06 ноября 2011 г.
Cambridge, Massachusetts, London, England: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2006. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-674-02167-3 (alk. paper) Judicial process—Philosophy. Law—Interpretation and construction. Law and ethics. Justice. Jurisprudence. How should a judge’s moral convictions bear on his judgments about what the law is? Lawyers, sociologists, philosophers, politicians, and judges all have answers to...

Gonzalez Ana Marta. Contemporary Perspectives on Natural Law

  • формат pdf
  • размер 1.04 МБ
  • добавлен 06 апреля 2011 г.
Ashgate, 2008. 334 р. ISBN:0754660540 Resort to natural law is one way of conveying the philosophical conviction that moral norms are not merely conventional rules. Accordingly, the notion of natural law has a clear metaphysical dimension, since it involves the recognition that human beings do not conceive themselves as sheer products of society and history. And yet, if natural law is to be considered the fundamental law of practical reason, it m...

Wacks Raymond. The Philosophy of Law: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

  • формат pdf
  • размер 1.41 МБ
  • добавлен 06 апреля 2011 г.
Oxford University Press, USA, 2006. 144 р. ISBN:0192806912 This lively and accessible introduction to the social, moral, and cultural foundations of law takes a broad scope-- spanning philosophy, law, politics, and economics, and discussing a range of topics including women's rights, racism, the environment, and recent international issues such as the war in Iraq and the treatment of terror suspects. Revealing the intriguing and challenging natur...