
with his heavy cavalry into the gap that opened between Eumenes' left and center as
his phalanx advanced, routing the light cavalry on Eumenes' left and forcing Eumenes'
victorious phalanx to halt and about-face. Antigonos then sent orders to his phalanx
and light cavalry to form a new line of battle along the foothills.
Though the sun had already set, the two armies thus reformed about 125 yards
apart, a little less than four miles from the site of the original battle. By the time all
was ready to renew battle, however, it was nearly midnight, and both sides were too
exhausted, after a night of marching and a day of fighting, to fight again. Accordingly,
Eumenes decided to march back to the original site of battle and occupy it, taking up
the dead; but once they were moving back, his troops insisted on returning right to
their baggage, some distance away, and camping there for the night. Antigonos, who
had his troops better in hand, marched his army forward to occupy the battle site,
and encamped there for the night, claiming the victory as being in possession of the
field of battle and the enemy dead. However, his casualties were far more numerous
than those of Eumenes (Diod. XIX 30, 1–31, 5).
[23]
Antigonos wished to conceal this disparity in losses from Eumenes, and he also
wished to fulfill his original purpose of marching away from Eumenes into unplundered
country. He therefore began rapidly to dispose of his own dead at dawn the next day,
and when a herald arrived from Eumenes to ask for his dead to be handed over,
Antigonos detained him. That day he buried his dead, rested and fed his men, and
then sent Eumenes' herald back to him with the announcement that he would hand
over the dead next day. When darkness fell, however, he broke camp and marched
his entire army away, making a forced march in order to put a long distance between
himself and Eumenes (Diod. XIX 32, 1–2; Polyainos IV 6, 10). Antigonos took his
army to southern Media, and since the year was nearing its end, he there went into
winter quarters; Eumenes buried his own dead magnificently, and marched his army
to Gabiene, where he established his winter quarters (Diod. XIX 32,3; 34,7–8). But
Antigonos had still not given up hope of ending the war quickly, and when he learned
that Eumenes had divided his army for wintering into many small detachments, which
were scattered widely around Gabiene, he formed a plan to make a surprise attack
and mop up
[23]
― 99 ―
Eumenes' army before it could be gathered together (Diod. XIX 37, 1; Polyainos IV 6,
11).
The winter quarters of the two armies were separated from each other by a
distance of twenty-five days' march by the road, which led through well-peopled
countryside, but only by a distance of nine days' march as the crow flies (Diod, XIX
34,8). The march would be across waterless, treeless desert, but it was this route
which Antigonos proposed to take. He ordered his troops to prepare food and water
for ten days' march, giving it out publicly that he intended to invade Armenia. When
all was ready, he led his army into the desert, setting out towards the end of
December 316, at about the time of the winter solstice (Diod. XIX 37,3). Since the
desert was an open plain surrounded by highlands, he gave orders that no fires were
to be lit at night lest they should be observed from the bordering highlands and
reported to Eumenes. During this march occurred the famous incident when some
soldiers, not realizing he was present, stood outside Antigonos's tent cursing him,
until he called out, "You'll be sorry if you don't go farther off to curse me!" rather than
coming out to discipline them (Plut. Apophth. Ant. 10; Mor. 457e; Seneca De ira III
22,2), the sort of story that gets passed around the camp and wins a commander his
soldiers' affection. However, some soldiers went beyond complaints, for the nights
were so cold that on the fifth night they disobeyed his orders and lit fires. What
Antigonos had feared then happened: the fires were observed, and the presence of a
great camp in the desert was reported by the locals to Peukestas and Eumenes (Diod.
XIX 37,2–6; Plut. Eum. 15,3–4; Polyainos IV 6,11 and 8, 4).
[24]
Eumenes and Peukestas were now in an awkward position, for while the most
distant of their winter camps were six days' march away (Diod. XIX 39, 1), the enemy
were only some four days' march distant. Peukestas wished to retire to the further
reaches of Gabiene and there gather the army, but Eumenes rose to the occasion with