Physical Water and Wastewater Treatment Processes 9-49
Except for the Stokes, Newton, Allen, and Shepherd laws, the calculation of the terminal settling velocity
is iterative, because the drag coefficient is a polynomial function of the velocity. Graphical solutions are
presented by Camp (1936a), Fair, Geyer, and Morris (1954), and Anderson (1941).
Nonspherical particles can be characterized by the ratios of their diameters measured along their
principal axes of rotation. Spherical and nonspherical particles are said to be “equivalent,” if they have
the same volume and weight. If Re is less than 100 and the ratios are 1:1:1 (as in a cube), the nonspherical
particles settle at 90 to 100% of the velocity of the equivalent sphere (Task Committee, 1975). For ratios
of 4:1:1, 4:2:1, or 4:4:1, the velocity of the nonspherical particle is about two-thirds the velocity of the
equivalent sphere. If the ratios are increased to 8:1:1, 8:2:1, or 8:4:1, the settling velocity of the nonspherical
particles falls to a little more than half that of the equivalent sphere. The shape problem is lessened by
the fact that floc particles are formed by the drag force into roughly spherical or teardrop shapes.
In practice, Eqs. (9.138) through (9.150) are almost never used to calculate settling velocities. The
reason for this is the onerous experimental and computational work load their use requires. Floc particles
come in a wide range of sizes, and the determination of the size distribution would require an extensive
experimental program. Moreover, the specific gravity of each size class would be needed. In the face of
this projected effort, it is easier to measure settling velocities directly using a method like Seddon’s, which
is described below.
The settling velocity equations are useful when experimental data obtained under one set of conditions
must be extrapolated to another. For example, terminal settling velocities depend on water temperature,
because temperature strongly affects viscosity. The ratio of water viscosities for 0 to 30°C, which is the
typical range of raw water temperatures in the temperature zone, is about 2.24. This means that a settling
tank designed for winter conditions will be between 1.50 and 2.24 times as big as a tank designed for
summer conditions, depending on the Reynolds number.
The terminal velocity also varies with particle diameter and specific gravity. Because particle size and
density are inversely correlated, increases in diameter tend to be offset by decreases in specific gravity,
and some intermediate particle size will have the fastest settling velocity. This is the reason for the
traditional advice that “pinhead” flocs are best.
Settling Velocity Measurement
The distribution of particle settling velocities can be determined by the method first described by Seddon
(1889) and further developed by Camp (1945). Tests for the measurement of settling velocities must be
continued for at least as long as the intended settling zone detention time. Furthermore, samples must
be collected at several time intervals in order to determine whether the concentration trajectories are
linear or concave downwards.
A vertical tube is filled from the bottom with a representative sample of the water leaving the floccu-
lation tank, or any other suspension of interest. The depth of water in the tube should be at least equal
to the expected depth of the settling zone, and there should be several sampling ports at different depths.
The tube and the sample in it should be kept at a constant, uniform temperature to avoid the development
of convection currents. A tube diameter at least 100 times the diameter of the largest particle is needed
to avoid measurable “wall effects” (Dryden, Murnaghan, and Bateman, 1956). The effect of smaller
tube/particle diameter ratios can be estimated using McNown’s (Task Committee, 1975) formula:
(9.151)
where d
p
= the particle’s diameter (m or ft)
d
t
= the tube’s diameter (m or ft)
n
s
= the particle’s free terminal settling velocity (m/s or ft/sec)
n
t
= the particle’s settling velocity in the tube (m/s or ft/sec)
v
v
d
d
d
d
s
t
p
t
p
t
=+ +
Ê
Ë
Á
ˆ
¯
˜
1
9
4
9
4
2