
352 Refrigeration Systems and Applications
pump (GWHP) and then discharged to its original source or to another location. The piping for
such configuration is open at both ends and the water is utilized only once. Examples of such loops
include systems operating off wells wherein water is pumped from a supply well, through the unit
and discharged to a return well and open systems operating from such surface water sources as
ponds, lakes, streams, and so on, where the source water is pumped to the unit and returned to the
source. Open loops have the advantage of higher equipment performance since the source water is
used only once and then discharged, but have two significant disadvantages:
• Water quality needs to be carefully analyzed and treated if such corrosives as sulfur, iron, or
manganese are present, if pH is low, or if there are abrasives in it.
• The costs of pumping water through an open loop are usually somewhat higher than those
associated with circulating water through a closed loop.
6.28.3.2 The Closed-Loop Systems
Closed-loop systems circulate a heat-transfer fluid (usually a water/antifreeze solution) through a
system of buried plastic piping, arranged either horizontally or vertically. Horizontal loop systems
draw their heat from loops of piping buried 2–2.5 m deep in trenches or ponds. Vertical loop systems
use holes bored 45–60 m deep with U-shaped loops of piping. They work the same as horizontal
loop systems, but can be installed in locations where space is limited due to size, landscaping, or
other factors.
A closed loop (Figure 6.35b) is one in which both ends of the loop’s piping are closed. The
water or other fluid is recirculated over and over and no new water is introduced into the loop. The
heat is transferred through the walls of the piping to or from the source, which could be ground,
groundwater, or surface water. As heat is extracted from the water in the loop the temperature of the
loop falls and the heat from the source flows toward the loop. In closed-loop operation water quality
is not an issue because corrosives become rapidly spent or used up and corrosion caused by poor
water quality is quickly curtailed. The wire-to-water efficiencies of circulators used in closed-loop
operation are very high and the costs of pumping the water are lower as compared to open loops.
System efficiencies are somewhat lower in closed-loop operation, but given the lower pumping
costs associated with this method, economics sometimes, but not always, favors this approach.
Installed costs, however, are higher and need to be considered if the consumer already has a well
or other water source.
While there are several loop configurations used in closed-loop operation, generally two types
of closed loops are utilized by the industry (vertical and horizontal).
• In vertical loop installation, deep holes are bored into the ground and pipes with U-bends are
inserted into the holes, the holes are grouted, the piping loops are manifolded together, brought
into the structure, and closed. The argument for this type of ground-loop heat exchanger is that
because the piping is in the deeper ground (unaffected by surface temperatures) performance will
be higher. Generally, installed costs are higher than with a horizontal loop.
• In horizontal loop installation, trenches are dug, usually by a backhoe or other trenching device,
in some form of horizontal configuration. Various configurations of piping are installed in the
trenches. A larger number of horizontal loop designs have been tried and utilized successfully
by the industry. While installed costs have been lower, horizontial loops have been thought to
be less efficient than vertical loops because of the effect of air temperatures near the surface of
the ground.
Generally the payback period is 1–3 years on open loops, and 5–7 years on closed-loop systems.
Payback will also vary depending upon the insulation used and how well the delivery systems (duct
work) are designed.