
366 Refrigeration Systems and Applications
or power. The following six facts should be considered when any heat supply system is designed
(IEA-HPC, 2001):
• Direct combustion to generate heat is never the most efficient use of fuel.
• Heat pumps are more efficient because they use renewable energy in the form of low-temperature
heat.
• If the fuel used by conventional boilers is redirected to supply power for electric heat pumps,
about 35−50% less fuel will be needed, resulting in 35−50% less emissions.
• Around 50% savings are made when electric heat pumps are driven by CHP (or cogeneration)
systems.
• Whether fossil fuels, nuclear energy, or renewable power is used to generate electricity, electric
heat pumps make far better use of these resources than do resistance heaters.
• The fuel consumption, and consequently the emissions rate, of an absorption or gas engine heat
pump is about 35−50% less than that of a conventional boiler.
In the past, most heat pumps were of the air-to-air or air source type. Air source heat pumps rely
on outdoor air for their heat source. Although cold outdoor air contains some heat, as temperatures
drop, the heat pump must work harder and efficiency decreases. In very cold weather, the air source
heat pump alone will not be able to provide enough heat, and supplemental or backup heat must be
provided. This can significantly increase heating costs. GSHPs extract heat from the ground or from
water below the surface. Because ground and groundwater temperatures are a constant 10−13
◦
C
year round, this type of system is much more efficient.
This varies with the cost of electricity, oil, and propane in your area. Generally, a GSHP can
produce heat with average savings of 10−15% over natural gas, 40% savings over fuel oil, and
50% savings over propane; air-conditioning savings average 40−60% over conventional systems
(EESC, 2001).
Heat pump water heaters extract heat from surrounding air to heat water in a storage tank
and can be fueled by electricity or gas. These heaters have essentially the same performance as
electric resistance storage water heaters, except that efficiencies are typically 2−2.5 times higher.
The energy factor for heat pump water heaters ranges from 1.8 to 2.5, compared to 0.88−0.96 for
electric resistance systems. Heat pump water heaters cool and dehumidify the air surrounding the
evaporator coil. This can be an advantage where cooling is desirable, and a disadvantage when
cooling is undesirable. Some heat pump water heaters are designed to recover waste heat from
whole house ventilation systems.
Heat pump water heaters are commercially available, with payback typically ranging from 2 to 6
years, depending on the hot water use and the efficiency of the water heater system being replaced.
When purchasing a new heat pump, the buyer should check the efficiency rating of the pro-
posed unit. A higher efficiency rating will result in lower operating costs. Heat pump efficiency
is designated by the SEER, particularly ranging from 10.0 to over 15.0. For split systems with an
outdoor unit and an indoor coil, the efficiency varies with the match between the indoor cooling
coil and outdoor condensing unit. The manufacturer should be consulted to determine the com-
bined efficiency. The American Refrigeration Institute publishes an annual directory listing various
combinations of outdoor units and indoor coils with their SEER rating. Most major manufacturers’
product lines are included in this directory.
Over the past several years, the SEER for the highest efficiency heat pumps has increased from
12.0 to over 15.0 because of the incorporation of the following improvements (JEMC, 2001):
• Variable speed blowers, compressors, and motors. This equipment provides variable speeds of
operation to optimize performance and efficiency. Heat pumps utilizing multispeed components
will typically start in the first stage or at low speed. If comfort levels or control settings cannot