550 Charged Particle and Photon Interactions with Matter
because these radical yields were not fully consistent with the nal induced biological effects. It has
been widely recognized that densely ionizing radiation, such as α-particles, induces cell killing more
efciently than sparsely ionizing radiation, such as γ- or x-rays. The relative biological effectiveness
(RBE) of the lethal effect on cells irradiated with α-particles when compared with γ-irradiation is
about two. Becker etal. (2003) have reported, however, that when hydrated DNA samples at 77K are
irradiated with high-LET argon ions (60 and 100MeV/nucleon), nucleobase ion radicals were induced
at a lower yield than that obtained with γ-irradiation, although the neutral deoxyribose radicals, which
are thought to accompany an SSB, were induced with a higher yield than with γ-irradiation.
Few studies have investigated the nucleobase lesions induced by direct energy deposition from
an ion track to a DNA molecule at ambient temperatures. Recent studies using hydrated DNA have
shown that the yield of DSBs induced by α-irradiation (Yokoya etal., 2003; LET = 140 keV/μm)
was twice that induced by γ-irradiation (Yokoya etal., 2002), indicating that dense ionization or
excitation events along the α-particle tracks are more effective at inducing clustered types of strand
breaks. Furthermore, irrespective of the hydration level, α-particle irradiation of DNA induced
more complex types of clusters of DNA damage, including nucleobase lesions, than photon irradia-
tions such as γ- or hard x-rays. Recently, the track size of high-LET argon ions has been experimen-
tally determined using pulsed electron double resonance spectroscopy (PELDOR) techniques by
Bowman etal. (2005). These authors reported that the number of clustered radicals within a 1 nm
length of DNA was 2.6, which is consistent with the distribution of lesions in a cluster damage site,
that
is, 4–10 lesions over several base pairs (Nikjoo etal., 2001).
In
order to focus on the clustered damage sites induced by irradiation with high-LET ion par-
ticles, the yields of nucleobases have been determined by enzymatic probes that convert nucleobase
lesions into readily detectable SSBs (as described previously). In these studies, plasmids or phage
DNA were used as models. The yields of damage were measured as a function of the ionization
density of the radiation using ion particles from accelerator facilities with LET values. The yields of
nucleobase lesions detected by the enzymatic treatments, as well as strand breaks, varied depending
on the experimental conditions. In dilute DNA solutions, the yields of SSBs and DSBs decreased
with increasing LET, although the ratio of DSBs to SSBs increased with increasing LET (Taucher-
Scholz and Kraft, 1999). Similarly, both the nucleobase cluster lesions revealed by Fpg or Nfo pro-
teins and the prompt DSBs induced in T7 DNA decreased with increasing LETs of the ion particles
(Hada and Sutherland, 2006). In the dilute DNA solutions, diffusible OH
•
produced by radiolysis of
water contributed primarily to the induction of DNA damage. It has been well understood that the
yield of OH
•
decreases with increasing LET because the higher density of the radicals in the track
leads to a higher probability of an intratrack recombination process between the radicals than that
for a low-LET radiation track. Recently, Yamashita etal. (2008) discussed the intratrack reactions
along the ion-particle tracks using a model experimental system for the formation of methyl violo-
gen cation radicals. On the other hand, when DNA was irradiated with helium ions under hydrated
conditions, the yield of prompt SSBs did not depend signicantly on the LET of the helium ions,
whereas the yield of DSBs increased with increasing LET. The yields of isolated nucleobase lesions
revealed by Nth and Fpg as additional SSBs decreased drastically with increasing LET (Figure
20.5A, Urushibara etal., 2008), and very few enzyme-sensitive sites were induced at 120keV/μm.
These results indicate that a cluster of nucleobase lesions induced at 120keV/μm is less readily
repaired by the BER proteins than that induced at a lower-LET region and, therefore, may show a
high RBE value for cell killing. The sum of the yields of DSBs and additional DSBs revealed by
Nth and Fpg increased with increasing LET. These studies concluded that the yields of clustered
damage, revealed as DSB and non-DSB clustered damage sites but not isolated lesions (i.e., SSBs),
increased with increasing ionization density of the He ions under 140keV/μm (Figure 20.5B).
Chang etal. (2005) observed no enhancement of cell killing after exposing an Fpg-overexpressing
E. coli strain to α-rays. These results may reect the greater complexity of clustered damage sites
generated by high-LET radiation, in which the lesions are processed sequentially to avoid the DSB
formation
as described in Section 20.4.