
650 CHAPTER 14 Substitution Reactions of Aromatic Compounds
+
CuCl
–
+
HCl H CuCl
2
Dichlorocuprate
ion
FIGURE 14.56 Formation of the
dichlorocuprate ion from CuCl
and HCl.
+
–
CuCl
2
+
.
CuCl
2
+
N
2
+
CuCl
2
+
CuCl
.
.
.
N
2
N
2
Cl
Dichlorocuprate
ion
Benzenediazonium
ion
Phenyl
radical
Chlorobenzene
FIGURE 14.57 The mechanism of chlorobenzene formation.
PROBLEM 14.16 We reject out of hand the notion that any of these net displace-
ment reactions could go by something as simple as an S
N
2 reaction. Why?
+
S
N
1
BF
4
–
N
2
N
2
+
F
Phenyl
cation
Fluorobenzene
FIGURE 14.58 Some reactions of
benzenediazonium chloride involve
a phenyl cation.
Some Sandmeyer reactions apparently involve a phenyl cation formed by the irre-
versible S
N
1 ionization of benzenediazonium chloride (Fig. 14.58).
In the Sandmeyer reactions involving copper, electron-transfer-mediated radi-
cal reactions are certainly involved. In HCl, cuprous chloride (CuCl) is in equilib-
rium with the dichlorocuprate ion
CuCl
2
(Fig.14.56).The dichlorocuprate ion can
transfer an electron to the diazonium ion, which can then lose molecular nitrogen
to give a phenyl radical. In turn, the phenyl radical can pluck a chlorine atom from
a copper chloride molecule to give the chlorobenzene and a molecule of cuprous
chloride.The mechanism for the formation of chlorobenzene in the Sandmeyer reac-
tion is shown in Figure 14.57.
Of course,you are now clamoring for the mechanisms for all these changes. Sadly,
only the outlines of the mechanisms are known, and much remains to be filled in.
The details of many reactions are imperfectly understood,and there remains a delight-
ful (to some) atmosphere of magic about parts of organic chemistry. What are we to
make of the admonition in one procedure for the Sandmeyer reaction to “stir the mix-
ture with a lead rod.”What happens if we use a glass rod? Although one would think
that the reaction might still succeed, there are examples to the contrary, and perhaps
microscopic pieces of lead do affect the success of the reaction. We’d use lead.
3
3
Speaking of lead and magic, two of MJ’s chemical relatives, Milton Farber (b.1925) and Adnan Abdul-rida
Sayigh (~1922–1980), once discovered a useful reaction of lead dioxide, and the work was duly published as
an effective way to make alkenes from 1,2-diacids. However, the reaction only worked when one particular
bottle of lead oxide was used, and once that bottle was used up no one could reproduce the yields achieved
earlier. All other sources of lead dioxide failed! Apparently, the particle size of the lead dioxide was critical.
(What’s a “chemical relation”? That’s someone who did his or her graduate work with the same professor as
you. Farber and Sayigh both worked with the same person as MJ and hence are his chemical brothers.)