
418 Part C Materials Properties Measurement
the temperature of fracture test, z is distance of the notch
opening gage location above the surface of the speci-
men and V
p
is the plastic component of critical notch
opening displacement, as defined by Fig. 7.89.
CTOD Testing of Welds
Fracture toughness evaluation of welds is more compli-
cated than that of base metal because the welds have
heterogeneities in terms of microstructure and tough-
ness. Therefore, toughness values of welds inherently
show large scatter. The existence of local brittle zones
(LBZ) in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) sometimes gives
extremely low toughness values. From this viewpoint,
special attention should be paid to CTOD testing for
welds.
Figure 7.90 shows the variation of critical CTOD
values of high-strength-steel weld HAZ as a fraction of
the coarse-grained (CG) HAZ along the fatigue precrack
front in the thickness direction [7.245]. This result indi-
cates that at least 15% of the CG HAZ should be sampled
by the fatigue precrack to assess the lower-bound CTOD
value; see below for the definition of %CG HAZ.Most
of the CTOD testing standards of weld HAZ specify
the %CG HAZ for this reason. Typical standards of for
CTOD testing method for welds are specified in [7.246,
247]. Among these, API RP 2Z [7.246] was the first to
specify a CTOD testing method for weld HAZ.Other
standards follow the same concept. The API RP 2Z stan-
dard is intended for preparing and certifying fabrication
welding procedures and assuring that the steel to be sup-
plied is inherently suitable for welding.
Critical CTOD (mm)
10
1
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
0.1
0.01
% CG regions
Fig. 7.90 Critical CTOD values versus % CG regions for steels
showing some LBZ behavior (after [7.245])
API RP 2Z refers to BSI 7448 part 1 [7.238]and
ASTM E 1290-02 [7.243]fortheCTOD testing method.
Additional requirements are specified regarding the
notch positioning in the weld and post-test examinations
for sampling the CG HAZ regions, which is thought
to have lower-bound toughness. Figure 7.91 shows the
HAZ regions in a multipass weld. Because of the multi-
thermal cycles induced by multipass welding, the HAZ
has an extremely complex microstructure distribution.
It is intended that the fatigue precrack certainly sam-
ples the CG HAZ. For this purpose, the fatigue precrack
should be carefully introduced. Welding should be made
carefully so that the fusion line of the weld is straight
enough to sample as much CG HAZ as possible. It
should be noted that proper welding consumables and
welding procedures should be adopted to maintain a cer-
tain level of critical CTOD value for the weld metal. In
addition, welding residual stress may be relieved prior to
fatigue precracking to promote crack-front straightness.
This is done by lateral compression (Fig. 7.92)[7.248].
API RP 2Z requires three levels of weld heat inputs.
At least five or eight, depending on the heat input, CTOD
tests should be conducted for each welding condition. At
least three specimens aim to sample the CG HAZ regions
close to the fusion line and at least two specimens aim to
sample the boundary region between the HAZ and base
metal.
Post-test metallographic examinations are specified.
Figure 7.93 shows the sectioning method for this pur-
pose. The broken half of the specimen is sectioned at the
fatigue precrack front, etched and its microstructure is
revealed. The CG HAZ regions sampled by the fatigue
precrack tip is measured (Fig. 7.94), and the %CG is cal-
culated as
%CG =
100
n
i
L
i
B
, (7.115)
where L
i
is length of the i-th CG region sampled by the
crack front and B is the plate thickness. The CG regions
need not be continuous. The value of %CG should be
at least 15% for the three specimens. For the other two
specimens, the crack front should sample at least 50%
of the boundary region between the HAZ and the base
metal.
The CTOD toughness values are influenced by many
other factors than the local brittle zones. One is the de-
gree of strength matching, i. e. the ratio of yield strength
of the weld metal to that of base metal. An overmatch
may cause excessive constraint in the HAZ,whichmay
cause unexpectedly low critical CTOD values.
Part C 7.5