Дизайн на западе (сборник)

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.

BnegeHHblMl4

3acTblBtlltlMx

HopMaM[

14 cTaHAaplaM[,

ychrnnan ee

yHblnblM HayKOO6pa3[eM,

npenFTcTByB

HenocpeacTBeHHoMy

KOHTaKTy

peanl4aMr xt4Bot

xr43H!4

(OT

npo[3BOACTBeHHbIX

l,4

SKOHOMI4'{eCKUX AO

coqr4oKyrlbrypHbtx)

nennercs,

MHeHn$

JlxaepoB

,,lMeMdhca"

,,HoBoro

AV3ahHa",

rnaBHblM

nocraBull.r'

KOM 3nI4TOHCKOTO

aKa,4eMH3Ma

B npoeKTHol4

KynbTy'

oe. CoorEercrBeBHo,

atbrepHarhBoi

eroi

cxeue

6yaer

aKueHTupoBaHHo

nrqHocTHoe,

a6corloTHo

cBo6oaHoe

KaKl4x-rq6o

anfiuopHblx

HopMaTHBHhlX

npeanlca'

Hl4i,

He noAAaoueecF

cxeMaru3aq[u

Aa)Ke'

B npeAe-

ne,

paq!4oHanu3aL{}11, 14

$opManu3al]u14'

peanhcrl,qecKoe

npoeKTtapoBaHre.

[4 xar

pas

era

anurepHart,tBa,

HecMor-

pfl

Ha cBoK)

BHeuHK,lo

caMoo'{eBhaHocTb

sopManb-

nyrc 6eeynpe,ttocrb,

oKa3aracb

HblHe

noA c,lnbHetu|,M

noao3peHxeM

KaK HOC[TeJlb

noTaeHHblx

cMblcJloBblx

a6eppaq!4i.

llpexae

ecero,

cpa3y

cneayer

yKa3arb Ha cBoero

poaa

rexHu'{ecKyto

a6eppaqhrc.

Koropyrc

nperepneno

peaflIcTt4'{ecKoe

npoeKTl4poBaH,le

yxe

E npaKTvKe

rpynnur

,,Mer,aSuc":

uaen

toaoro

Meroaa oKa3arlacb

cpa3v

xe Bonnou.leHHoi

+opMe

crHnF,

ro ecrb

HeKot

cucrevur

6optransHo-nnacrtri{ecKux

npueMoB

v o6pa3-

Hhtx xoaoB,

FBrteHHblx

raKoi

npo3paqHocrbto,

Bbl-

nyKnocTblo.

yaapHocrblo I

o6naaapulrx,

3Ha9uTerlh'

Hoi creneH!4

6naroaapF

neqarh

reHrarbHoro

aBTopcKo-

)Kecra Corrcacca,

raroi

6ecnpexocnoet'roi

y6e-

[urerbHocrblo,

'{To

pe3ynbrare 3Tr npueMbl

l.l

xoabl

6brnla

BocnpuHarbt

crper"rau]eficn

K o6HoBneHhto

Mo'

roAexhrc,

oco3HaHHo

unv

Her. B

Ka'{ecrBe

HoBoro

hM_

neparl,Ba, HoBoro,

BnollHe

Haar!14'{Horo

3aKoHa.

[lapa-

aoKc

3aecb

3aKrllo'{anca

ToM,

qTO

B 3TOi

pOnU

,,HO-

Boi aKaaeMuh"

oKa3arlucb

npxeMbl

paa

KanbHoi

Ae_

KoHcrpyKql414

KaKux

6bt ro

Hla 6blno

SopMarbHblx

yHti'

OHurpoBaHHbtx

cl4creM

3aKoHoB

npl,lHq!4nvanbHbli

3KreKrri3M,

6puKonax,

a6cypa143M,

Bl43yaflbHaF

napa'

IoKcanrcrhKa,

o6fl 3arenhHocrb

caMo6blrHoro,

ocrpof

xecra u

r. n. 3ro

rnusri

pa3

npoAeMoHcrpl4poBano.

rtro

oprtr[HanbHocrh

KaK nprHtlhn

Hl4'lyrh

He 6otlbue

3acroaxoBaHa

6aHarr3aqrr

l,l

Ktlh LlJl4

poBaH

,lF

qeM

aHoHlrMHhri MaccoBbti craHAapr.

BnpoqeM,

ecr6

Bce ocHoBaHtln

npeanonoxhrb'

qro

npor3otleAuiaa

noaMeHa

Meroaa cr4neM

npeKpac'

Ho co3HaBanacb

JrraepaMu

,,lMeM$tlca"

aaxe

6btj]a

coBepueHa

qeneHanpaBneHBo.

nocKorlbKy,

He Haao

3a'

6urearu,

poxaesre

HoBofr

npoeKrHoi

l.laeororxtl

npo'

l,icxoal4Jlo B

npoqecce xecToqaiulet

nolreM'lK9l

c oKoc-

TeHeBuJl4Mr,r uAeonoreMaMh

14 npaKT!4Koi

o+xqho3Horo

,,xopouJero

Ai3ahla",

a e

rarcoi crrya\t

t co3aaqre

Bbrpa3rrenbHoi,

yaapHoi.

cyrrecr!aBHoi,qecrpyKTl4B-

xoi uronorpa$uv

Morno oKa3arbcg

peuJapulrM

SaK-

TopoM

ycnexa

xKoHo6op'lecKoro

ABhxeHt'lF

AH3a14He'

apyroi

cropoHbl,

nrAepbr

MeM(Du3Ma

Bep[rl4'

']eM

cBraererbcrByor,

qacrHocrl4,

BblcKa3hlaaHrla

Corr-

cacca,

qfo

6yM

noApaxarenbHocr,|

orpaHu'{lrrca

Kpar'

KXM HaqarbHbrM

nephoaoM

ycBoeH[a HoBoTo a3blKa

unr xe

6yaer

orrecHeH

060q14Hy

npoeKTHot

Kynbry-

pbt, ynoBaF

B 3Toi cBoei

yBepeHHocTl4

Ha nocreneHHylo

aKTyarh3aul/|Kr

14 caMoaBl4xeH

asyx

Krlloi{eBblx

coaep-

xaTenbHbrx

nocTyflaToB, cToFul'tx

3a crrtll4c1H'{ecKoi

$opvynoi,,l\4eM6rca"

aonxeHcrBytoulttx

npeaor-

BpaTuTb

aa[xeH{e

npoeKTtlpoBaHxa

no KaHaraM

KaHOHtl3aqU!1:

nOCTyraTa a6cOmoruoi

ceo6odbl

feop'

qecRo?o

caMoebtpaKeHuR

v1 locrYnara

npoeKTHozo

pea'

nusua,

Karc noKa3att14

AarbHeiLuxe

co6blrl,lE,

TaKhe

ynoBaHxF

re 6utnq auulexut ocHoBaHui,

pa3Be

qro

pe-

3vnbrat

nonyquncF

aaneKo

oaHo3HaqHblM:

BMecro

roro

qTo6bt

KoMneHctlpoBaTh

B KoHeqHoM

c'{ere

BnoJT'

He ecTecrBeHHbli

npouecc

KnHull,lpoBaH4F

cTl4nA,

O6a

co.qepxaTenbHblx

nocTynaTa oKa3anuch

aene,

MHeHU|o KphTl4KOB,

He npOCTO

AeTOHaTOpaM[

,,aeKa-

aaHca"

r.r, coorBercrBeHHo,,,ceMhoTl4qecKoro

uJyMa"

{3HaKoBoi l,{36brroqHocrtl

nph cMblcnoBoi

Heaocraro'{-

nocrlr)

onu

coo6ul nh

3ThM

SeHoMeHaM

nplaHqunllalrb-

Hoe 3Ha!eHL4e

cneqhdH,tecKyto

coAepxarenbHocrb.

flapaaoxcansrocru,

noreHuranbHo

3aKfltoqeHHyKt

B nepBoM

nocrytare,

MoxHo 6btno

6bl cBecTh

K cneay'

loU.leMy:

Hen

perKHoBeH

Hoe,

6ecnpeaenbHoe

caMoBblpa-

xeHl4e

paHo

tuq no3aH9 nphBoal.lT

K hCTOUIeHl,llo

CaMO'

cTh,

a anonorhF

tlHAHBHAyanhHo

n/qHocTHoro

Haqara

(opurhHanuHocrq)

K H3MenbqaHhrcl

nu'lHocrl4ta

6a'

HanA3awA

ee caMoo6pa3a.

C 6onuuoi

BEroa3rrenbHocrblo

nqluer o6

stou

P03aHoB

yxe

uHrfipoBaaureicF

crarbe

,,,qeKaaeH-

Tbr":,,BentiKoe

caltoorpaHH'{eHre

L]enoBeKa,

npeaBa'

phrerbHo

rFHyBureecF

Aecarb

BeKoB,

aano

Mexay

XIV h XVI BeKaMH

HauJei

3pbt Becb

qBef

raK Ha3bl-

BaeMoro

(Bo3poxaeHlra

<...>

CpeaHle

BeKa 6blnh

BerxKxM Knaaoxpe

H;an

!.lef,l

chn

'{eroBeqecKrx;

B l4x

acKeTh3Me, B

HX orp:::HHH

'lenoBeKa

oT ce6n,

e npe_

3oeHH!,r

eTo

K KOaCOTe C-Oet,

CrnaM

cBol,4M,

yMy

cBoeMy

3rH cnnbl,

3;c cepAue, 3Tor

6blnl4

cbepe'

xeHbt

Bperte,+,.

3aoxa

So3poxaeHHF

6blna

3noxoro

orKphrrla

3roio

K-.a.ta.

<...>

XIV r

XIX

eeKa

Mbt rorlbKo

.ipaTrra

Hgc\leiHble coKpoBhula,

Tofaa or'

KphrBUJlecA.

pacxc:"

er1 33nac

cqn,

K 3IOMy BpeMeHX

co6paHHbri.

<... >

q:-:cia<

{9 xo'{er

ytaeer

6onee

ce6e

Mo,rqa-E: =cFK€

\,a.,reiL!ee

qyBcTBo,

BcFKylo

HOAyrc

L!eBei5fi!3-!_f,Ci

\r!lcnh oH

Topon[TcF

BblcKa-

3arb

apYaHM,

c339r:c43ts a€ a

KpacKax,

pacuBeT[B

3ByKaX,

Henpe\!-:r''ia 3a<a:n,1Tb

ne'laTHblM

CTaHKOM.

craFoBFTCa 6C_.-_-,,E.

f-a iOJ'tbKO

MyApoe, He

TOIrhKo

6naropoAHoe,

Hc r c\'a-Litoe,

ruynoe,

HaKoHeq,

Aaxe

ypoAnHBoe

6 ca* cr c5--eK3ei

crHxl4 x npo3y,

Kna-

Aer

Ha My3!i<,

c:a-r

xtt?-r 5br,

Ho ronbKo

yMeer,

Bbrpa3hlb

r.,c:\,:c€

,1-:,' 33ne'laTneTb

apxl4TeKTyp-

Hhtx

nHHrlax.

<...

.i3x,,:9<rypa

cnHlllKoM

6ecroput'

crHbri

Br'a

/:<1):-a: :

\,Ex,qy reM

HoBbli

qeroBeK

pe[JJhrenbHo

-a -'.\a:..-

<a<... oH

Mof 6st

novyecteo-

Barb ce6A

53:<:a= :-i:

,.,.

ece 6onee

x 6onee

pa3-

yqaercF f,to:r:!c.--. :-3

;\'uja

06paulaercH

TonbKo

x ce6e. Bce,

!-c

g:-:.,\':::

erc,

TecHhr.

qro

Meuaer

He-

3aBhcl,lMo\ty cai-aa

!-_<;.ir''o

caoero

(F).,.

ArlF

Hero cra'

HoBHrcF

He3!,i3.,.wc- q-..

):'On

AeKnaphpyer

npaBa

3TOTO

(A"

-::-,'3,':.:r

i.:y6,rHhr 3Toro

(F);

ro'

BOpLT,

sTO

I 345

\ttA

aci5

TOtl6KO OTpaXeHtle

3TOrO

(A),

3TO

(ar,

--3:3r:ceHHoe,

H3yKpauleHHoe'

or'

paxaeHHoe

3a<cY.ia:a:::bci3aM!a

pa3BaJlvHax Ecex

CBF3ytOUlrx

"tca/::"ia3-.

:eOKEl4,

OTeqeCTBa,

CeMhl4.'.

Penrrzt

csc;_c

rr), dlnnoco+laa

roro xe

(a),

npoy3Beag oi

lc:i<,,3 r O;rnensdo

EaipoHa

f-dTe

pFA

H3y\r,rr:-:5-1::x

io r.ny6HHe h apKocrl4

co3Aa'

HHi,

xcqepnar,.!,

Ha<ei:-!. eac coaepxaHue;

(no3-

3tAA),

da:adeice'a

\r!

8,.:rr!

clpeMrrenhHoe

H43Bepxe-

HMe nycroi

olc:al<t

3:c.o

{F,)"

[9,

c.438-440]

3ra o6u,r.o,ia"

r-i,1:aia 736aBtFer

Hac

nepero'

xeHha MHoxeci-

acca3,!,o

sotee

aHeMvlHbtx

coBpe-

MeHHhtX BblCKa3bl-€l1./r'

?1Or C'leT,

nOCKOtlbKy

CIO-

Po3aHoaa

Aa:<a;::ae,

oTAeneHHbte

or Hac corHei

neT, nopa3hTenbHo

-o-.iJ

,.oxaTcF

,,AeKaAaHC"

Hbl-

neruxri. Torsxo

io. !io,

He 6e3 onr6Mh3Ma,

nonaran

Poranoe

nocreaxav :F:ercM,

o6Hapyxhno

3a [creK-

uMi aeK

HeMarbr,.-'. roreH,{,1an

pazeutua,

Pertnrna

"F",

arrecTyeMan H5rHe KaK

,,naronofvgecKt

3f3tA6u'

r.ll4oH143M", 3aXBar[Jra X,,6eCKOpbrCTHyrO',l apx,|TeKly-

x Tupax[pyercF

yxe

npocTo

ManoMou.lHbrM ne-

gaTHbrM

CTaHKOM, HO nnaHeTapHoi l4H+OpMaqqOHHOi

clcTeMo;. fl[qHocTh

{ ceMbF,

KoTopbre, KaK nonafan

PogaHoe,

,,naaator

nocleaHrMt4", c 6onbuJr4M

TpyAoM

yAepxqBarcrcF

Haa

nponacrblo Bech XX BeK. 3a

sro

cloneTHe

eu.le 14 eqe

pa3

ncqepnbtBa,lhcb

ao aHa

Benl4-

rcre

SurocoQcrcue

crcreMhr

or,qeKapra

Terena,

no3l4T!4a,lcroB,

Hrqure, rro6ur npxiT!4 K KoHqy BeKa

+hnoco$cKyM

,,MoAaM",

orubr Koropbrx c aaBxAHoi

pefyJlFpHocrhrc

caM14 noxhparcT cBorix

Aeret.

Taruv

o6pasovr,

MeMSx3M, so3HxKLUhri Ha rcxo-

nocneaHero cToneTqa BToporo T6rcFqenerr,rF, npea-

craer

3Toi

nepcneKTrBe

x B cBoei vqeonofuu 14 B

npaKTxKe

KaK KBl4HTSCCeHqrlA HeCKOIbKOBeKOBOTO

npoqecca 3MaHchnaulq'{enoBeKa

rl. cooTBeTcTBeHHo,

rlcqepnaHt4a

v{Au1nqyanu3Ma, 14 B oroM cMbtcle

oH,

KOHeqHO,

He npoBoKaqfiF, HO

BhrpaxeH[e,

aeMoHcTpa-

tllrf,, 6oree roro,

o6HaxeHhe

MexaHhsMa

06u.{eKyflhryp-

Horo

AeKaAaHca.

Xaparcrepno,

.rro,

6yAyer4

peaKLl[ei

na roraaurapruri,

o6e3fl14geHHbri BapAaHl,,penurvq

venoeera",

BonnouleHHbri B MoAepHu3Me,,,Mervt$|c",

roqHee,

poAl4Brlutca

Hero MaccoBl4AHbti MeM-

Ox3M,

BcKpbrBaer HeKylo

SaranbHylo

Her36exHocrb,

c Koropoi

SunocoohB

gMaHclanaqlah

r14qHocru

nphBo-

At4T

o6e3n[,{eHHocrr4, TaK

qro

B KoHei{HoM

tlTore

pa3-

Ht4qd Mexay rorarurapHbrM

{aeropnrapHsr[a)

treMo-

Kpar!.qecKhM

Bbr6opoM

oKa3brBaercF

TpyAHo

ynoBh-

Moi.

O6 oroM MHoro

nucaJtu B cBa3y c 3K3ftcreHqya-

rucrcKot tuonoAexnoi

peBorroqhei

ronqa 60-x ro-

AoB.

80-e

ToAbr 3ror napaAoKc

aa+uKcl4poBan

oAHH

l43 nxAepoB

,,|\4eMSHca"

A. SpaHqx,

orMerrB,

liro

gnoxy

nocrMoaepH[3Ma

Ha cMeHy

o6ulecrey

,,ceporo

60rbLu14HcrBa"

nptrxoAxr

o6ulecreo,,cepbtx

MeHb-

uJrlHcrB", Koropoe.

np!4 Bcei caoei necrpore, a Bep-

Hee,

[MeHHo B ctlny friraHTcKoi, MaHuaKanhHo

yr-

BepxAaeMoi

coq!4oKynbrypHoi apr[KynFqhx

x crpa-

T[SxKaqlah

Hex36exHoi

flpl4 3ToM MenKoTpaBqaTo-

cr'T n'l.f HocrHoi

nle1rutvKaqva,

BocnpuHuMaercF

KaK

HeKOe

MaCCOBllAHOe MapeBO.

Bnpovev,

3ro KynhrypS!anoco$cKoe rcrorKoBa-

Hl,e

,,nopogHocrh"

nocrynara

6ecnpeAenbHoro

!4 He-

nperKHoBeHHofo

caMoBbtpaxeH{a, npr ecei ero nony-

napHocTr,l ,i aBTopxTeTHocTl,r ero cropoHHlrKoB,

aaneKo

He BceMt,t

BocnprHrvaetca

<arc

6eccnopHoe r aBraerca

oTHroab He eauHcTBeHHbrM, xoTa 14 cvulecTBeHHbtM, ap-

ryMeHToM Kpr,4Tr4KOB MeMsU3Ma.

Fopaa4o

neruure

pa3HorolKoB

Bbr3brBaer

apy-

roi,6onee

qacrHbri.

Ho, TaK cKa3arb,,,6onee HayqHbri';

apfyMeHT,

cyTb KoTopofo 3aKnloqaeTcF B cteay|oueM:

anoflorfia H[qeM

He cTecHfeMoro 14 HnqeM

KoHTpo-

nhpyeMoro

caMoB!poKeH!4a. !a Boo6qe Bhrpa>KeHuF

KaK

TaKoBoto,

nopoxAaer HeKVrc 313r6rql4oHl4cr.

cKyto

+lanoco+xro

caMoAocraroqHoro o6pa3a, Koro-

paa,

rrneprpo$npya

acneKT shrpa3hrenbHocrx,

cyrrec.

TI4BHOCTI4

XyAOXeCTBeHHOTO

Xecfa, BnnOTb

AO,,06-

pa3Hoi,

t clepvA",

oaHoi

cTopoHbl, npoBoqxpyeT

rlcKyccrBeHHoe

ycrapeBaHue

SopM,

nopoxAaa reM ca-

MblM

ceMqoT14qecKylo

ae3optieHTaqxto

KaK

(paKTop

nocroFHHoro

HapacTaHrF

Br43yaabHo-3HaKoBofo

ury-

Ma', c

gpyroi

nptaBoAxr K Toranrl3allllx crpeMllTeJrb-

,,Ver,,r

6onhrxe craBKa

AenaercF

Ha Bbrpa3qrenbHocrb 06-

pa3a,

reM

Kopoqe

qvKn

ero norpe6neHuF. CoepeMeHHaF apxu.

TeKTypa

KaK

pa3

aenaeT

cTasKy Ha SKcnpeccuE KaK Ha rnaB-

Hoe

cpeAcTBo ao3AeicrBhH, a noIoMy HyxAaeTca B

nocToaH-

Hoi

cMeBe 3crerrqecxhx

ycraHoeoK"

[27,

c. 58] .

HO[O h 6ecnnoTHoro

noToKa Bl3varlbHocTl4,

nocTeneH-

BbrTeCHflrOUle;

U 3aMeUlarculei

peanbHocTh.

B uAeonorfih

MeM+u3Ma E. u|,pe,,.Hoaoro

A143at1'

Ha" rapaHToM npeoaoneHrF

rrrl[, no KpaiHei

Mepe.

KOMneHCaq 14 OxapaKrepn3oBaHHhrx Bblue

u3aepxeK

aKqeHTrpoaaHHofo aBTopcKofo

xecTa

(KaK

npaBx'

no, npeKpacHo

co3HaBaeMbrx nl4AepaMu

aBuxeHl,|F],

TaKXe ero

sopManx3aqur,

Heo6F3aTenbHocTt4

14 cyry-

60i npo143aonbHocr]1,

KoMneHcaulu ceMaHThqecKoTo

llcToHbuJeHtlF

Bbrpa3hTenbHoro

F3blKa L ero ToTan!43a'

ut4x

yulep6 pearbHocTl4

BblcTynafl nocrynar

npoeKT'

HOrO

peanu3Ma,

cuny KoToporo aBTopcKtil,

xecT

OKa3blBatlCF

rlHTerpfipoBaHHblM B

xl,|Byio Xl.13Hb, CTa'

HOBI4TCF HenOCpeACTBeHHOt

peaKq,lei

Ha ee nynbca-

Lll4lo. [lpeacTaBnaeTcf,,

r'lTo

uMeHHo

3To l,lMen B B!4ay

Corrcacc,

KorAa HeoAHoKparHo

yrBepxAan

Heo6xoah-

MOCTb npeaenbHoi

nracruqHocTh

ah3aiHepa,

ero

He_

npecTaHHoro

peaKTriBHol'o

l43MeHeHuF:

.,lMbl

He MO-

xeM l, He

aonxHbt

uenrFTbca

KaKre.nrl6o npeaycra-

HOBJ|eHHhre LrKOHOrpa614qecKxe cxeMbt,

Ho, HanpoTrlB.

aorxHbl

t4 BbtHyxaeHhr

peanbHocTb

3acraBrlFer

nocroFHHo

o6BoBnsTbcn"

[20,

c. 49].

To, vlo, no MHeBxK) Kpl,irl4Koa,

TaKaF KoMneH-

caufiF He

cpa6orana. Moxer

o3Haqarb

aBe

Bequ.

Bo-

nepBbtx,

'{To

peaflx3M

B MeM+h3Me ocrancF

'{l.lcroi

aeKnapaul4et,

rrnoTe3a, nonYqlrBuaa B

paae

cnyqa-

eB cBoe noATBepxaeHr!e,

Ho B To xe BpeMf ocTaBJlalo-

ulaa 6e3 o6rFcHeHHF

cn14L!KoM MHofo BaxHbtx

SaKToB

coBpeMeHHoro

npoeKrHofo npouecca. Bo-BTopbrx,,tro

caMa KynbTypHaF

peanbHocTb

o6leKT

cBoeao

poaa

MhSonor43aqu||

B uTanhFHcKoM aHTr.rMoAepHh3Me

KaK HelcqepnaeMbri l4cToqH,1K

cnoHTaHSblx,

a noToMy

opTaH[qHbrx x

aonoanxHHbrx

TBopqecKxx [MnynbcoB

t4 xr43HeHHbtx 3Heprxt4

Ha caMoM

ae-ne.

Bo BcFKoM

cnYqae

HbrHeLlHeM cBoeM

,,nocTlrHAycTp

anbHoM"

KaqecTBe, BbtcTynaeT

B KoMneHcaTopHoi

ponr,

Ho a

ponx

cTt4Mynnropa u

npoBoKaropa,,ceMt4oT14qecKoro

3acopeHl,|F", 14, cneaoBaTenbHo, Bce

saKTopbr

nocnea'

Hero,

,,o6pa3Hoi

vcrepvu"

Ao ,.6enoro

L!yMa".

FB.

IFIoTCF HenpeMeHHhtM CteacTBueM

paa

KanbHor4

pea-

nr4cr

,{ecKoi

na6hnbHocrrl

[

3afiHa, KoTopaa, B cl4uv

HeKplTr4qecKo;

der[uiusaq

,,>KuBoi,

>Kvt3{t^" vt

,,)Kn-

Boi Kynhrypbr", o6opaquBaercF cyry66rM

KoH$opMr43-

MOM,

CnOCO6H6TM

nXlllh Ha naCCMAHylo aAanTaLlUrO 14

Aa-

pa6cKyro

3aBl,lc14MocTb

peanbHocTl4,

HaTypal|[cTl4-

qecKoe

Bocnpo|43BeaeH!1e/oTo6paxeHIe

aaneKo

6e3ynpe,rHofi r,

Aaxe

He 6esonacxoii c rogKr4 3peHua

,,noar14HHbrx ueHHocTei

KynbTypbr" |,1,,ceMuoTr4'{ecKoi

3KOnOT14'l" MeXaH14K14 CeMh03hca nOCTI4HAyCTpUaI|bHOi

cpeabt.

3Ta

nocneaHFF r[noTe3a

npeacraBnfleT

AnF

Hac

Hax6orblirxli l4HTepec 14 BnIloTHyro

noaBoarlT

Ko BTopo-

oHTOnOTUqeCKOMy

I4CTOJTKOBaH!1K|

paCCMaTpl4-

BaeMoi cLlTVaq4h.

O4uaro

npex4e, reM

nepeiTr K oqepeAHoi rpyn-

ne apfyMeHToB, Heo6xoat4Mo

noaqepKHyTh,

qTo

onpe-

AereHue,,oHTonoru,{ecKxi"

6oneeqeM

ycnoBHo,

no-

cKonbKy

pe'{b

|,aer

aoBo'lbHo

cneqh+[qecKoM

oHTo-

oHTOCe

l,tCKyCCTBeHHbtX CVUIHOCTei. 3AeCb

,,peaflb-

Hocrb",

,,x143Hb",

.,cyulee"

3To coBceM He To,

'iTo

peHeccaHcHbri

qenoBeK

BkaeII B

oKHo,

Ho cBoero

poaa

co6cTBeHHoe

oTpaxeHHe B

3epKane,

3KcTpanorl,|poBaH-

Hbtfi.

o6teKT!,tBtlpoBaHHbri,

oHTonof

143rpoear nsr fi r ca.

MOABT4)KyUI|I4CF.

KaK

nOUOXeHO CyUleMy, MeHTl4C,

Sonee

roro,

Konb cKopo

peqb

[aer o npoeKTtapoBaH{t1,

cneayeT

roaoplrTb

aa)Ke

3epKaler

a o HenpoHhqae-

MoM 3KpaHe,

Ha Koropbri cnpoeuqpoBaH

o6pa3

yxe

3aBeaoMo cnpoeKTltpoBaHHoi

pearbHocrh.

EcflLr B

50-e roaur 3a Heopearr3MoM B

HTanbFHcKoi apxrreK-

lype

au3ahHe

croFr nph3hlB orBecr[ B3TnFA or

He-

xfi3HeHHbfx ror

'{ecKrx

cxeM

peanbHocrx

o6parvrt-

ero

rpy6yro, xeo6pa6orannyro, neorpe+ne<crpo-

BaHHylo, noqT, He oKynbTypeHHyp, a noToMy eule

non-

Hyro

crr4x[fiHoi opraHuKr4

,,xl4Byrc

Kyrbrypy". To B

80-e

noAo6nan npoqeAypa

aaer

yxe

coBepuJeHHo

l4Hoi

3+QeKr. nocKonbKy B3rflFA

Ar,13al4Hepa

naAaer He Ha

HeKyE

AeBCTBeHHyTO.

pa3BpaueHHyrc

npoeKrHbr Mr.1

MaHUnyrFql4aM14 KynbTypHyro

ael4cTBvTerhHocrb.

ynrpaeTcF

a 3anyraHHyK,,

MHorocJloiHylo

cerh ee npo-

eKTHbtx

Moaerei,

raeonoTfiqecKrx

orpaxeH4i

h T. n.

O6pautaacu c BonpocoM

peanbHocrH,

atagaiHep

eirec-

OTBeTa

nOnyqaeT MHOTOKpaTHO

yMHOXeHHbli

CO6Cr-

BeHHbri Bonpoc.

14 nporcxoArr

ero ne noroMy.

qro

Ati.

3aiHep cMorpl4T He

ryaa

1nv

He raK,

noroMy,

tlro

TaKOB

AeiCTBhTenbHOCT|4

OHTOC nOCrrHAyCTpranbHOt

3noxl4,

npoayKT caMoBbtpaxeHl,lF

HaKoHeq-To oKoHqa-

lenbHo 3MaHchn14poBaBtllerocF

qeroBeKa,

BceoxBar'

HaF

l, BCenOTflOulaloU]aF,,ChCTeMa-CnpyT

KOMMyHl,iKa-

qri.

roeapoe

v\eonorqi", no

BhrpaxeHxto

SpaHqy3-

c<oro

drnocoda

X.-Q.

flrorapa, <oropaF

,,noaMtlHaer

l,| MOAepHrl3M U nOCrMOAepHtl3M,

Cn4paF

MeXAy

Hl4Mtl

BcnKyro

pa3Hxuy"

[15.

c. 134] .

B coorBercrBhu

aByMF

ocHoBHbtM

noacl4cre.

MaMh 3TOi MeraChCTeMbr

rexHonorn'lecxrv cy6-

cTpaToM 1,4 co6crBeHHo

KoMMyHhKau[oHHoli, KpoBe-

HOCHO', Cerhto

OHTOnOtLlileCKOe I,CTOIIKOBaHUe OCO-

6eHHocrei, B ToM

ql4cre

,,nopoKoB".

nocrr4HAycrpl4-

aJthHoTo ceMh03uca

pacnaaaercF

aBa

pycfla.

rextoqetrpltctcroi

tov<r eperrn

peL!atou.l14M

cpeAoo6pa3yrcuthM

$aKTopoM

B 3noxy

nocr,4HAycr-

pvant

3Ma,

onpeaenFtou]rM

KaK

su3[qecKhe,

TaK

u ce-

Ml,lOT14qeCKrle

napaMeTpbl

cpeAbl, lr, COOTBeTCTBeHHO,

.,KOpHeM

3fla" FBnFtoTCF Ka'IeCTBeHHO

HOBbte XapaKTe-

pl.4crt4K14

nocrhHAycrpranhHoi TexBonofl,l.,t, o6ecneqt4-

Bapulhe nonHyto 6e3oroBopoqHylo

Torarr3aq4rcTex-

Hocdepbr.

CroooHHhK TaKo; To,rK 3peHfiF Bt4aHbri

fiTanh-

aHcKr4i Kynbryponor

Manqunr nrurer B 3Toi cBa3h:

.,3a

nocneatne

aecarb

neT npon3ouJen

pe3Khfi

TexHo-

noTxgecK14t cKaqoK: HeBepo8THoe

pacurrpeHue

Bo3-

MoxHocrefr

MaHlnynauh!1 c 6ecKoHe,{Ho

MarbrM 146ec.

KoHe,rHo

6brcrpbrM. B

pe3ynbrare

dyHKuxoHxpoBaHl4e

TexH[Kl4

OKa3arOC6

HeAOCTynHbrM

HaLleMy

qyBCTBeH-

HOMy

AOCnpriATrto

Mbt

yTpaT[nu

cnoco6Hocrb

l,iaeH-

rxS!4qrpoBarb MarephanbHbri,

$l,,|3hqecKhi

cy6crpar

ee norre3Hbrx 3sseKroB. c

apyroi

cropoHbr,

caMh Ma-

Teptanbr,

KoTopbrMr4

nphxoal,iTcF

pa6oraru

greaine-

paM,

TaKxe

yTpag[

Barc T

claTxq H ocTb h cybcraHuuo-

HaJIhHOCTb

Xapa KTepfiCTl,l K t4

TBepAOTO Tena

l,| CTa'

HOBFTCA

(TeKyq[MX).

HaKOHeq, He CyUleCTByer

HbrHe

onpeAeneHHoro, orHochreflbHo

ycroi,r14Boro

Ha6opa

BO3MOXHbtX rl

AOnyCTltMbtX

TeXHOJtOt4qeCKtlx

peue-

H14i, HanporrB, TexHonoruF

npeAnaraer orpoMH6ri

cneKTo B03Mo>KHbrx anbrepHar

o6ecne.rheaer

orpoMHoe

pagHoo6pasue

aocrh)KrMbrx

pe3ynhraroB.

grov

Hoeov npoa3BoacrBeHHoM r rexHonorq-

'{ecKoM

KoHTeKCTe

MaTepl4an TepFeT

CBOTO

14HepTHoCTh,

Tpaa[Llt4oHHo n

poTk

BocToF u.lyto

ar.t

Ha Mr,t 3My M btcJ|l,l 14

x3MeHeHui.

Cpeaa

HaeoaHaercn

+opMaMu,

pa3MHoxa-

lorJtnMr.lca

c HeBepoflTHoi 6urcrporoi, ee BpeMeHHbre

napaMerphr np

o6peraFor caMoAoB'epuee

3HaqeHue.

'{To

BhrpaxaercF

ycKopeHHoM

TpaHc$opM143Me.

B03-

HrlKaer

SeHoMeH

(AeMarephan|43aq!4l4)

onbrra,

AaHHoro

B ou-lyuleHyEx.

(oBHeuiHeH[F)

orHoueH t c BeulaMu,

nocKonbKV

arux

oSevepnurx Beulax-rpaHcSopMepax

HeBO3MO)KHO

vKOpeHITb,

(OCaAUTb)

H14

OnbtT,

H14

nanaaru"

[25.

c. 18] .

t13

oco6eHHocrei

nocrl,rHAycrpuanbHoi TexHono-

Tl4U C nerKOCTbtO MOryT 6btTb BbtBeAeHbt npaKTlqecKh

BCe COCTaBrAtoUlre CeMl4OTt4qeCKOi CneUl4dUKl, nOCT-

MoAepHycrcKoro

cpeAoo6pa3oBaHrF.

caMbre,

Koro-

pbre

cropoHHl,rKx lr4eeqenrprcrcroi ToqKh 3peHxF

cKroHHbr

BhrBoAl4Tb t13

hAeonoruy

fi flpaKTl4Kt4

.,MeM-

Sl,lca",

CpeAu Hhx 14,,r4creqeHxe" Marepl4u, n roraJ]l43a-

uua

3$eMepHoro 3HaKoBoro MapeBa. h 6eueHbri Ka-

neiAocKon

SopM

o6pa3oB

BpeMeHx r B npocrpaH-

crBe, fi,

rJtaBHoe, Tor

6ecnpeAen Bo3MoxHocrel;. Koro-

pbri,

l4cKyujaa 11 3acacbraaF e ceorc eoponry,qusaine-

pa,

oaHoBpeMeHHo aKTyanr3t4pyeT

a,lF

co3HaHua

npe-

ae,lbHocTb

BocnphFTrF: Bce,

pacnofiafatoqeeca

3a 3TuM

npeAenoM, BHe 3aBqcqMocrl,

or cBoero o6beKTrBHofo

KaqecrBa H

Aaxe

ceMaHTrLlecKoi nnorHocr14, Heu36ex-

HO BOCnpHH14MaeTCF KaK HeqTO

pa3ApaxarcUlee

!r Hepa3-

6opvreoe

KaK

,,ceM

rorr4

qecK

ui4 wyl.r'.".

CxoAHas Kapr[Ha

p[cyercF

H npH B3rrFAe Ha

nocTl,.+raycrp|,anbHyro

cl4cTeMy-cnpyr noa MeArlyMhqe-

CKHM, To

ecrb

co6crBeHHo KoMMyHuKauuoHHbtM,

yr-

roM 3peHhF. Kpurrra

eroi opheHTaqn[ craB[T

Bo fna-

yrj|a

nocrMol4epHrcrcKoro

cpeAoo6pa3oaaHyF tl

Bcero

KynbTypHoro

npoqecca caMy MexaHhKy KoMMy-

HxKaqul,, npl4Hq[nbr

caMoAeicrBl,,tF

qenoi

cerh ee Ka-

HaJloa,

c noMoulbro KoTopol4

cl,rcreMa ocyulecTBIlaeT

l,HTerpaTuBHyro

h, clleaoBaTeIbHo, ToTanl/t3npyloulyro

dyHKl{xto

pbrHKa,

peKflaMbt,

npeccbt, sbtcraBoK, ap-

MapoK. uroy-npe3eHTaqlai,

MHoroo6pa3Hbrx Bl/3yanb-

Hbrx MeAha r.

flp/9eM

necyuqei

onopoi

3Aecb no-

nafaeTcF

pbtHoK,

BepHee, npxHuln

,,Bce

Ha npoaaxy",

npeBpaluarculhi

ocrarbHbre

KaHanbt

B cBoro uHdpa-

cTpyKTypy la rpaHc$opMhpyrouj,l4

Bce,

qTo

nonaAaer

B 3ry cerb, B 6|,3Hec,

,,t4cKyccrBo

npo4axa". Cpaene-

HUe

BhrcTaBoK

coBpeMeHHoTo

LICKyCCTBa,

He TOBOpF

yxe

o BbrcTaBKax

Ah3aiHa,

c cynepMapKeToM

yxe

AaBHo

crano o6uhM MecroM.

He Hosocru fi caMaa He-

nocpeacTBeHHaF

cpHHaHcOEaa 3aBhCr4MOcTb npeccbr

peKnaMHo;

o,rcrevur.

O4naro B Haut,l

AHLr

3Tu

SaKro-

pbr

KoMMepqlanrl3aq'lh

KynbTypbr,

B cnyqae

al43aiHa

He TOITbKO HeU36eXHbre,

HO h

ecTecTBeHHbre

o6F3a-

TenbHbte,

npho6perarcT

noucrhHe vera$rarvecrui

cMbrcn, cTaTyc,,Be3aecyulero

KoMMep'{ecKoro

3Ko-

HoMtt'{ecKoro

daKTopa,

Toro

(!lcKyccrBa

npoAaBarb),

KOTOpOe BCeM

ABr.4>KeT

ynpa8n8eT,

BCe

npOAaeT |4 BCe

noKynaer,

Bce cMeurhBaer"

[16.

c.99] , flcHo,qro B

3TOM

BaBT4nOHCKOM CTOTnOTBOpeHUI

BCerO

Ha CBeTe,

npeBpauleHHoro

B ToBap, KaKre.nH6o oUeHo,{Hbre 14

pa3nx'{4TenhHbre

Kpt4Tep[14

ecrrl 14 He hcqe3arcT, To no-

naAaloT

B Mrcopy6Ky ToranbHoi

Kynnh.npoAaxla, np|,l.

BreqeH[a,3a3brBaHVF', Ha6vBa{wl

ueHbt

np.

OcroeHoi npreM

3roro

,,HcKyccraa

npoAaxl4"

yxe

ynoM[HaBuJaaca

.,o6pa3Has

Acrepup,",

r neprpo-

$npoaantaa,

napanh3ytoulaF

3penhulHocrh

SaHTacru-

qecKafl

ta3MeHqrBocrh

KaK B npocrpaHcrBe

(MaHt,laKanb-

Ho-Luta3o+peH

qecKoe

pasnoo6pasue)

TaK h Bo BpeMe-

(6eLUeHaF

ToHKa cMeHFlou.l4x

Apyr

Apyra

MoA x

crtanei) .

O6o3peBarenb xypHana

,,l4HrepHla"

Ax.

5o-

30Hl,1, HanOMuHaF

qcrop14rO

B03BhlUleHrF l,

BceM4pHOrO

TptayMOa,,MeMSrca"

{utrpovairuan

ny6rhKar]t,lB

daK-

T[qecKy yHrKanbHbrx,

M14KpocepniH6tx

pa6or

l,3 nep.

Bbrx KorreKqhi

,,|\4ev$rca",

coa4aHue Ha 3Tr1x. B npn-

MOM CMhrCIe

Cq14TaHHbtX, 3K3eMnIIApax

CFeHOMeHa TeH-

AeHquh,

Koropaa,

B cBoro

oqepeAb, oKa3ana o6parHoe

anl4FHhe Ha npovutrunennoctu]

orMegaer,

.rro

raKoi

Trn npeanoxeHrlE

npoayKTa-ToBapa uMeeT npl,Ht{rnh-

poe

3a'racTyro npoBolll4poBano

eTo

onnoHeHToB

yn-

peKl4

paaHoayLrJ4t4

aa)xe

qtiHl.13Me,

qacTHocTl4

KOrAa

pet!

TenhHo He xerrar

ApaMarh3r4poBarb

ceroaHa Bo3Hr4Kujylo npo6fleMy

MaHbepx3Ma, 3n[roH-

cTBa, noaq!tHeHttF

[h3aiHa

TeMnaM xl,|3H14 MoaHblX

qrKnos,

.,OpueHTauxF

(xopour,ri

A[3aiH)

KaK Ha

HeKt4fi cepr[6uKar KaqecrBa,

orMeeaer Corrcacc,

cKpbrBaeT

co6oi nnaToHoBcKr4i

B3rflFA Ha cuTya-

tI4lo, To ecTb l4cxoa!.ll h3

y6exaeHlia,

qTo

rae-Io

cy-

qecTByeT

xpaHxn4qe.

pe3epByap

(xopouJero

a,|3a14.

Ha). []o MHe xe, Hao6opor. npo6neMa

cocrohr He B

TOM,

qTO6br

CUnl/|TbCA

AOTFHyTbCF

(XOpOUerO

Ah-

3aiHaD, Ho B

roM,

qro6br

npocro

aenarb a[3aiH,

clpeMscb MaKcrManbHo npx6lu3t4TbcF

K HblHeuHeMy

aHTpononorxqecKoMV

cocToFH!,ro,

KoTopoe,

a cBolo

oqepeab,

aorxHo

MaKcuMarl6Ho np,16nhxaTbca

K ToMy

caMoo6pa3v,

qro

norpe6eH o6qecrBy.

Ecnh Mbl, KaK

vTBepxaaloT,

aeicrBfiTenbHo

xhBeM B o6ulecTBe,

Ko-

TOpOe nporpaMMupyer x nnaH!1pyeT

crpeMtlrellbHoe

ycrapeBaH|/|e

npeaMelHo;

cpeabr,

aonroBeqHbtM

6yaer

xcKnlo'{uTenbHo Tol

au3aiH,

Koropbt;

aeicTByer

B co-

oTBeTCTBhrl

C 3Tl4M!1 3aKOHaMh

yCTapeBaHrlF.

KOlOphli

K HeMy

aaanT[pyeTcB.

6yah

To nyTeM HHreHor+uKa.

Llx[,

npoBoKaquh

YcKopeHua,

6yab To

nyreM npoTl4Bo.

Aei.clBy.A

v ero TpaBecT!,rpoBaH4a, 6yAb To

ny1eM non-

Horo ta a6conprHoro

c Hl4M cornacun, [,1, cooraercreen.

Ho, caMbtM

HeaolroBegHhrM

raKoM

o6ulecrBe 6vAer

KaK

pa3

Tor

Ah3aiH,

Koropbti oprleHT!4pyerca Ha Mera-

+u3ugecKoe,a6conprHoe

BeqHoe. BnpoqeM, F He no-

HhMalo.

nogeMy

AorroaeqHbti A143aiH

ny'{ule

cKo-

poreeHoro..."

[15,

c. 134]

Herpy4tro 3aMer[rb,

ero

Bce

rpta Totr Kr,4 3peHxF.

TaK ,|'It4 rHale cooTHeceHbr

c npo6teMoi

peatlu3Ma

KaK

npoeKTHoro MeToaa,

oaHaKo

Bce Tpoe

rpaKlypT ero

nopa3HoMy.

.qnE

N4apx

peanu3M

ecrb

,,AereHeparrBHbri

pea-

n!,r3M", KoH+opMr,r3M.

ae3epr4pcrBo

14 npeaarenbcrBo

Ytonuu,

to ecrh

lraeana

Maplr e

Ka'{ecrBe [aeara

BHcrynael

coquar

3M, Ho, no cyr4

aena.

peqb

3aecb

l4Aer He

KaKoM-To KoHKperHoM haeane, a 06

[Aeane

rax

raKoeov)

,Koropbti

oAkH

cnoco6eH

coo6ulhrb xla'

Boi xr-13Hx x

peanbHof pearlbHocrx/

araKXe

npo-

eKThoMy TBOpgeCTBy nOAnl4HHO

qenOBeqeCKOe

AOCTO-

hHcTBO,

Aarb

{HTeHqhto

caMocoBepL!eHCTBoBaHl,|F

14 no-

Meuarb

norpa3Hyrb

B x14BorHo-6uortoT14qecK14x

llH-

CTI,IHKIAX,

ArE

6paHu[

pearr[3M

3anot Bo3poxAeHrn

re-

por4

poMaHTrqec

Koro

ayxa

nhoHepcKoro

A[3atHa

(reaapov

peqb

xaer o

,.BTopoM

[aoaepHlsr',re")

ecTb

Au3aiHa,

o6naAarculero

crparer['{ecK[M xr13He-

rBopqecKHM

noTeHuuaroM,

a 3Haqrr, aKT[BHo

+opMx.

pytoqero

caMoe

pearbHocrb,

oaHaKo

xe nyreu o6py6a-

Ht4F

,,KOCHOi

Malepn\" BO

'lMF H3Bre'{eH4F,,nporpec-

cnatoh cytu", KaK 9To

aenafl ,,nepeuri

uoAeprlsv",

HO nyTeM O3HalieHl4A

'1 CrlMBonh3aLltiH

l,lHKynhTypa-

ul,1h

cnoHTaHHbrx npoqeccoB

+opM

ee caMoABt4xe-

uun,

roi e Macce cBoei HeMorcrByrou.lei

xnBoi

xr43'

Hl4 KOTfleKTUBHO|.O

6eCCO3HaTenbHOfO,

rcOrOpaa 6la-

roAapF

Ak3aiHy

o6peraer

pevu,

o6paa

r xynurypruti

cMbtcn.

Ara

Corrcacca, Koropbri Boo6ule

He cKroHeH

npeyBefl

hq14BaTb KynbTypoTBopqecKoe

M14cc14oHepcTBo

ausahp.a,

peanusl,l.

ecrb

cKopee arpx6yr

3apaBoro cMbt'

cfla x 3ApaBoro noBeaeHhF, no3BonF|oulix

Ax3atHepy

ocBo6oAxrbcr

or np[cyu.lero

eMy. no onpeAeneHrp,

aeM[yprhqecKofo

Hapu[cch3Ma

h npuo6u.lxTbcF

op-

raHUiKe CaMOCTpOeHl/|F

xl43HeHHOl,i

peanbBocTl,l,

KO-

Topoi nplr.racrHbr Bce

aope$reKcuBHbre

+opMbt

xx3-

Be- !4 KyJrbrypocrpoeH

a H Ha

SoHe

Koropbrx

Ax3aiH,

6e3 KoHqa

pe$neKcxpyrou.llai

,1 BbrBepFpult4i cBo|4

3a-

aaqu,

ueflH,

qeHHocTl4

x cMbrcnbr,

KaxeTca 9eM-To

Ha-

nbtqeHHo-pt4Topl4'{ecKr'lM,

cxotacTrqecK14M

14 aHeM14q

HbIM.

6osoru oqeH!4eaer

no3uur4io

Corrcacca,

6e3yc'

noBHoro

aBTophreTa

B Bonpocax npoeKTHoTo

peantl3-

Ma, KaK

prMecc[Bxyrc

(noxopryo)

To ecrb nacctaB-

HO-KOH+OpM!4CrCKyrO

l,{ nol

ycTl.lTenbcKylo,

vnv, Ha xy-

Aoi

KoHeq,

orpeLreHHyto

aaHHocrei

HhtHeuiHei

cl4'

Tyaqla[, BMecTe c TeM oH He

MoxeT He

oTMer[Tb

Bblpa.

3t4TeIbHOi

MOU.lh, C KaKO; 3Ta

prMeCCl4BHaE,

a MOXer

6urru,

yuyapennaa,

no3rq[F nperBopaercn

TBopqe'

crae Cotrcacca:

,.K

coxaneHhto, npoeKTHoro

co3HaHt,ra

|,r npoeKTHoi oTBeTcrBeHBocv

TaKoro MacLllTa6a

Mbl

He Haxoal4M

noanxHHbtx

vnfi caMo3BaHHblx

y'{eHti-

KOB fi nOCneAOBaTerei

cOrrCaCCA.

A noToMY B

KOHe'l-

HoM 14ToTe

80.x

roaoe HaM

ocraeTca

nl,L!h crnbHei'

uJa8 o6pa3Haa

SopManhHaa

3aLuyMreHHocrb,

6ecHo-

BaHl,le

Meaka, KoTophre nocreaoBaTenbHo

AesopMt4-

pylor

cKa|(alor noaflhHHyro

norpe6[TerbcKyto

qeH-

Hocrb Beqef, npoBoufipypr Bc€ 6ofiee

cnoxHoe I aprtl

Kyn!.ipoBaHHoe norpe6neHhe, ocB06oarisureecF

or cBo-

elo

TpaahtlHoHHoro KoMnr]eKca nepBopoaHoro

fpexa,

Koropbre Bce

(ynorpe6nnpT)

14 BceM

(TopryrcT)"

[15,

c. 1341 .

Oataro npexle,

qeM

cortachrbcn

l4rlti He

corna.

c[rbcfl c HeyTeulqTenhHblM

BhlBoaoM Eosoxu,

nonstta.

eMca npoFcHhlb, no Bo3MoxHocrl4 orBneKLll14cb oT

p14To.

pvqecKxx

ceroBaHri no noBoay Bceo6ulero

3n[ToHcT-

Ba h

aerpalallhH,

B KaKoi

Mepe

06038a,{eHHble

BbluJe

no3xr.lh[ Tpex KpynHblx

al43ahHepoB

coBpeMeHHocTl4

oTpaxapT

aKTYanbHyro npoeKTHylo npaKT[Ky

u B Ka-

KOM Ka'reCTBe OHh A Het npeAcTaBtleHbl,

HaKOHeU, B

KaKOt CTeneHh

OHh

nOMOTapT

yACHUTb

CyTb npOrlCXO-

aFUlero.

B nepeyro

o,repeAb.

nonpo6yeM

pa3o6parbcn,

06-

naaael rA

npkHqHne nocTl4HAycTpranbHaa

cuTyalll4F

avxoBHbtM,

B ToM

q14cue

no3ThqecKhM

{ScTeruqecK4Ml ,

noTeHur4ajtoM, a cneaoBaTeI6Ho, BbrFcH14Tb,

HacKotbKo

o6ocxogar onrl,,lMracrla!ecKrli

egrnnA 6paHqu

peanb'

HOCTb h nepcneKThBbt nposeccul,| B

ycJroBhax

nocTMo-

aepHfic-lcKoro

cronnorBopeHra x 6ecnpeaena.

14 3Aecb

np[xoar4TcF np 3HaTb.

qTo

aaxe

npx

caMoM noBepx-

HOCTHOM B3rnEAe Ha nOCTt4HAyCTpUanhHyto

Cl4Tyaqhp

BHe 3aBtICXMOCTH OT TOrO,

qTO

Mbt notaTaeM

B Ka9e-

crBe ee

rBuxHTenF

KoMMep'{ecKhi

r,lHTepec, Hayq-

Ho-textrqec<ri

nporpecc l4Ih rlaeiHo-3crerl4qecKyro

ycTaHoBKy

onpeaeneHHoro

poaa,

oHa,

HecoMHeHHo,

Mo-

xer 6btrb h aBrFerc8 hcroqHt4KoM enorue 6ecr<opstcr-

Horo

npoeKTHo-xyaoxecrBeHHofo

BAoxHoBeHt,rF.

3TOM CMhrCne

OTHTOAb

He CnyqaiHbt MHOrO'rr,lCrleHHble

nocreaHhe

roabt

ccbrnKu Ha [TaJrbnHcKhi

+yrypx3M

HecKpbrBaeMhri

!,lHtepec hra'IbFHcKoro,,HoBoTo

At4-

3aiHa" K

SyryprcTl4qecKoi

3crer[Ke,

pexAe

ecero,

ecru

paccMarpuBarb

nocrr4 HAycr-

phanbHyto

cl4Tyaqfito c To9Kr4 3peH14a ee

KocMofoHlqec-

Koro noreHqvana, To ecrb B

ypoBHe

SyHAaMeHTanbHbrx

npeacraBneH14i v crpeunerri Knaccl4'{ecKoro aBaHrap-

aa,

la Boo6qe np6oro [cKyccrBa, npereHAytoqero

,,6onbLUoi

crrnb", To HaAo np!13Harb,

qro

aKTyanbHoe

HhrHe nepexrBaH[e cKopocflr,

eceo6qero

rpaHc4op-

M|,|3Ma,

060porHr,r,{ecrBa o6HapyxxBaer

oqesuAHyto

npe.

eMcrBeHHocrb c

oaHof

x3 BaxHeiLU14x'TeM

xyaoxecrBeH-

Hot.o

no[cKa B np!4Hqhne,

He roBopE

yxe

06 [cKyccrBe

eera,

reuoi Bpeuenr. 3ra rsae'lfiaa reMa o6pe-

TaeT

ceroAHF

caMoaoBIre|ou.{1,1t4 xapaKrep,

npa3aHyer

no6eAy

Ha,q npocrpaHcrBoM

rt/,arepuev,

nepentaBnFa

x a Mou.lHbri 3Heprer

qecKui

noroK,h,TaKrM

06pa-

3oM, o6ecneqrBaer

BbrxoA 3Toi rnyboKoh

xYAoxecr'

BeHHOi

TpaArUhrl Ha KaqeclaeHHo HoBblt

vpoBeHb,

or_

KpbrBaF

,.He

3BecTHbre 17| BonHytoulhe

ropx3oHTbl .

B eroi cassri

MoxHo

yKa3arb

xota 6st ta Hoaoe

AbrxaH4e,

Koropoe o6pen B Hau!4

AHl,1

Ml,1Hr,1Maru3M,

a BMecTe c nqu r tav6olee

cTporaff, KnaccuqecKaa

TpaA14qqa xyAoxecrBeHHoTo KocMh3Ma

{HanpHMep,

nocneaHhe

pa6orsr

Mr.r<eratl4xeno

[lqcronerro) . C

Apyroi

cropoHbt,

h HeKnacchqecKaF, ToqHee.

KoHTp_

KnacchqecKaa

rpaahLll4F

(oT

6apo,lHoro opraHr3Ml,l-

'recKoro

naHTeh3Ma

pa3HoTo poaa poMaHThro'r/1po,

HUqecKrx 4rp c noafl14HHbtM-Henoan14HHbrM,

nory-

croporixr.ru-nooocropoHH14M.

BeqHbrM-cKoporeq-

Hutv n np.) HaxoAhT 3Aecb

crl4Mynhr

Ana

6t'lrt4iP'o'

N4eradragl,l.]ecK!ax h aHTpononor14qecKhx

npo3peHt4t.

Yxaxev

xorn 6sr Ha oxronorh,{ecKtai,

KocMr,t,{ecKtat

Macuira6

noHntri,,noBepxHocrb",,r,rcKyccrBeHHocrb',

,,Mafvst','",,,o6oporlrvecreo"

(ecero

'1 ecgl e

reop'

qecTBe

Toto xe

3. Corrcacca, F. fleu.Le.

K. Kacrennh,

Aan',1sv,

lvleHAhHh,

!,.

Canraxunput.

Aalee,

ecnu B3FTb

HbrHeLuHroro cr4Tyaqho

B ee

TexHonor/LrecKoM cpe3e,

ro B

3aecb

MoxHo

o6Hapy-

xhTb HeMaflbre no3Tr4qecKhe oe3eoBhr

1,1 Bo3MoxHocTl,l.

O6uler-r:eecrHo,

'fro

Ha nporFxeHfi4

Bceh

vcropw 9e-

noBe'recTBa TexhonoThF hr

pana

BaxHetLUyro

Kynbrypo-

o5pa:yroulyro

polb,

Bo'nepabtx, B KaqecrBe onpeaeneH-

HOiO nOnA npaKrqqecK,x Bo3voxHocTei,

B ToM

cte

4 npeaenbHbrx,

ecrb ofpaH14qeHui,

eo-eroputx,

KaqecrBe HeKoi fiaeanhHoi cyulHocrri,

l1eHHocrr,. C

]e-

qeHfieM

BpeMeHh 3Ta

ponb

Bo3pacTarla, xoTF

ao-

BonbHo npr4,ryAnrBoi

rpae<ropru,

qro6br

B XX

BeKe

BbrpBaTbcF Ha n

atlpyroulr4e

no3fillr414,

qTo

oTpa3hnocb

B TeX HOqeHTpr.l 3Me MOAepH'4CrC

KO; V

AeOnOf

VV. n

AeO

no-h.recKht

ahKrar

npoMbruneHHot

rexHonorhh

11 To'r-

Horo 3HaHrF

(rsxenepnoi

uayrr,r)

aer:ean

vou.luyto

peaKqhrc

oTTop)keHuF: aHT!4TexHr.1tlt13M

cTan o[HhM

r,13

SyHAaMeHTanbHbrx

nocrynaroB

nocrMoAepHhcrcKoro

MeHTanrrera

MoMeHT

eTo

haeiHoro

o$opMneHrF.

Oana<o nocrvoaepHrlcrcK14i

aHr/TexHruta3M

napaaoK'

caleH: oTBepaaa

HaytlHo-TexHlLlecKrlil

derhui[sv,

Ha npaKlhKe

T/nepTcxHotofr/qeH.

aaxe

6oneP,

qeM

MoaepHrl3M..Ecr!,r

Kop6rosse hnr1, K npr,rMepy,

aBTo'

M0614nbHbre crh'lqcrbt npeaBoeHHo,

nopbr, noKnoHFFcb

npoMbtrll,leHBoi

TexHonorl411, KaK 6oxecrBy, Ha npaK-

ThKe npoaonxan,4

pa6otatu

peMecfleHHo;

aotlHAycl.

pv,an5qov

rpa[,vt!t4a h, nbITaFcb

t Ml4rv,poBarb npoMbluJ.

reHHy|o TexHonoTVto,

aoBoavtnv

pyKoTBopHocTt'

BepLl]hH h3outpeHHocTrl,

To nocrMoaepHr4cTsr,

TeopeTh_

gecKtl

Hl,lCnpoBepraF

TeXHOnOT|4lO BO

14MF

TyMaHl4Tap_

Hbrx

qeHHocTei,

nonb3yrorcF

ana

tix

BonnouleHhF ca'

MOHOBeitrlhMX TeXHOnOrhFMt4-.

tlcro,{Hl4K 3;oro napaloKca

B KaqecrBeHHoM

TexHonorhqecKoM

cKa'lKe

noc1h

HAycrp14 an

ro 3py,

B npeBpaueHhrl

TexHono14h

t'13 opyaha

h cpeacTBa

FcHo,

qro

,,HoBoe

peMecfo",

,,6eaH5ti

au3ah9 . ,,npa'

KiaaH,rqecrBo"

h npoqtae HAeiHbte

onopSl

aHirrexHxqH3Ma

chn6Hei|.jl6M o6pa30M

onocpeAoBaHhr

coapeMeHHblM

TexHotlo-

rrrqecKuM

ypoBHeM KaK npsMo

(xanpr,ruep,'repe:

rncnonssye-

r"rsre r,rareoaansr)

raK 6 KocBeHHO

(raneonorr,rqectcu)

-Xapax-

TepHo,

qto

l4aeiHoe HenpxFT

e xat-TeKa ocyulecrBnFercF

3aecb

qepe3

runocra3xpoBaHue

,,Hl,l3Koi"

TexHonorHx,

ecrb

6srBa uAei

hAer

cyryoo

rexHonor4'lecKoM

VpoBHe,

nuurHee

cBtlAerenbcrso

Bbrco,taiLjleto,,AyxoBHoro"

c'?'yca

rexuonorr,rr,r an

sich e Hau.r,a

axr.

Heero

BpoAe reMoacKoli

OaHloMonorh|,l

cpeAy

o6uraHVA,

npx6n

xalou.lyrocF

roranbHoi nonHore

oxBaTa He

ronbKo MarephanbHoro,

14 uaeanbHoro

Mt1pa,

B caMoe arvoc$epy. Bo3ayx,

KoropbrM BbrHyx-

AeH AbtrlaTb

xaxauri, eHe 3aBhcr4Mocrr,l oT

Toro,

Tex-

Ht4Uf4CT OH

6nU

aHlVfeXHVUUCl.

nosroMy, BbrFcHaF Kynbrypo06pa3ytou.lhi

no-

TeHqnan TexHonorr4h B HbrHeuHloto 3noxy

fyMaH/Tap4-

3aq!414 co3HaHha, Heo6xoanMo

vqhrbtBaTb

cBoeTo

poaa

Be3AeCyU.lHOCTb ee CnOHTaHHOi CaM OpeatX

3aU11h, nOM|4-

MO l4JtU

AaXe

BOnpeK!4 CO3HarenbHoi

KyflbTypHot hnl

SCTeThqecKo; Bore, Ty TexHororh3aq|,1rc

KynbTypbl,

Ko-

ropaa nopoxaaeT TeM 6onee

SaHTacrh,{ecKhe

h HeBe-

aoMbte

KynhTypHbre

QopMbr

cMbtcnbt,

qTo

uaer oHa

cKpbtrbtM oT co3HaHqa h Bon

KaHanaM. no He

MeHee

+aHracrhqecKyp

KaprrHy FBnFer fi c+epa

oco3-

HaHHOt4

TeXHOIIOT!43aqhh KVIrbTypbt r,4

rAOp9eCTBa

pacrvu.lt4x,

KaK rp[6h', HoB6rx, TexHo-nor

'{ecKrlx

Br,r-

AOB

14cKyccTBa,

AnF

Bo3Hl.4KHOBeHxF

MHoTl,lx lr3 KoTo

pbtx

TexHojrorl.4F

EBnFercF

eal4HcTBeHHbrM

1.1 caMoaoc_

TaroqHbrM c1,1My|oM 14 raison

d'ctre,

qefl14KoM

noKpbr-

BaF 14 11c'repn6tBaF tx

ayxoersrri

l,1

SopManbHo-3creru.

qecKhq

rop[3oHT,

HeorexHonoThqecKoro

av3a;Ha.

K nocneaHeMy npex<ae Bcefo

cne4yer

orxecrr

o6urtzp_

Hyro u crpeMqrenbHo

pa3pacratou.lyrocn

c$epy

a!43aiHa

MarepranoB

HeMarepllaJtbHbtx cpe4oBbrx

3QQeKToB

(xai-raq)

o Koropoi HaM

yxe

np!4xoal4lrocb

nhcarh

[4,5]-

CpeA|4 MHoroqxcneHHbtx nhKoB HeorexHonor

gecKoTo

aq3aiHa,

Koropbri K

KoHqy 80-x

ToaoB Bbr-

ulen

113 HaqaflbHor o lrana

aeKtapau4il

r.1

oTAenhHhrx

yHhKanbHhtx

3KcnepqMeHToB '1 npeBpaqaercF,

npq

ecei ceoei

$atracrrlrocrr,

B FBreHtte notrr[ o6brAeH-

Hoe, cneuu$hqecKtli4

t4, ll'o>Rer

6urt,

uau6onvwuil

uu'

Tepec

npeacTaB,'taeT

cBoefo

poaa,,naneoTexHonoTt43M

(,,rexnororuvecrri

varr:v")

Koropbri,

pa6oraa

npocTo c aBaHrapaHbrMt4, Ho c

dyryponoflaqecKhMh

TexHoJloT14FMtl, OKpVXaeT Ce6F,

6e:

OCHOBanrn,

napaAoKcanbHoi, apxa

pyroqei

aypoi' anxhMuu,

MeraMopO/3Ma, eonuJe6ctea l,

qapoAe;crBa.

qlo

Ka-

caelcF anxuMuv, To 3aecb Har6onee BneqarnFto-

ulue nphMepsr cBoero

poaa

Ka6an crr,l,recKoro

B5l-

pau-[rBaHhF

MaTeptanoa

Beu]ei

nocraBnFer TeK-

crfinbHhri

ahsaix

(Hanphvep,

pa6orur

9. Pyaxepta

coBceM MonoAoTo

ar.i3aiHepa

nacKap

[32]).

{1ro

KacaelcF MeTaMopsl,43Ma,

3aech

eatlHon!4qHblt

npeTeHAeHT Ha 3BaHrle

rnaBHOTO Vnnrct3vo\t4cla

u 9a'

poAee"

HenoApaxaeMbri

Carra<uepa,

Ko BceMy

npoqeMy

e|J]e v opt4fvHanb+\lfi MbrclrhTenb.

fnaenurfi npeAver npoeKTHoro hHTepeca

CaH'

TaKbFpr,r

MeraMopdhqecKhi

noreHqhan

HoBbrx,

l,1MMareprlanbHbrx MaTep[afloB, |4nh,

KaKonpeaerrn-

er oH caM,

'1x

nep$opMarr4BHocrs

cnoco6aoctr

npeA-

craBrFTb

cBol,

dr3!4qecKhe

napaMerpbr

$opue

co6ut.

F B npocrpaHcrBe

BpeMeHr4:,,Cneu/Su,{ecKaF

xapaKTephcl/Ka nepdopMaHca

xar co6srtun cocrour

B aKThBHOM

/CnOnb3OBaHU!1 BpeMeHHOTO

43MepeHnF,

TOrO l,1MMaTephaJtbHoro

143MepeHrF, KoTopoe, noao6Ho

KI4HO

1,1

Mynb1t4nnhKaqvtl,

AenaeT

BO3MOXHbIM

pa3Btl-

rqe

v Bt3yatv3awto

co6brniF.

4...

1,4 eror

nepSop-

MaHC HOBhTX

(XMMaTepnarOB',

AOCTynH6ri

HenOCpeACT-

BeHHoMy BocnprFrhto,

noao6Ho Kl.lHorproKy.

npotlc'

xoaET npFMo

Hac Ha

rra3ax".

nep$opMarl4BHbre

Ma-

Tep[anbr,

yTBepxaaeT

aanee

canraxunpa,

no3BonFK)T

npeBpaT4Tb

BpeMF

,,8

KOMnOHeHT

TBOp'IeCKOTO npo

uecca,

B HoByFo nepeMennyrc

au:aiHepcKoro

$opMoob

pa3oBaH

F, obnaaatoqvlo

iieBhaaHH6rM no3Tl4'tecKl,M

noTeHU!4aJloM

r,1 co6cTBeHHo; 3cTeTrKon"

[33,

100] .

anbHoe

KoHcThTyxpytoulee

3Ha,.teHI4e

B nOCTtlHAyCTptt-

anbHoi

c14TyaLlxl,l:

,,8o-nepeutx,

3To

anodeo3

Btl3yanb-

roro

$ororpa$[qecKoro

peKnaMHoro

o6pa3a

npoAyKTa

KaK TnaBHot.

a nopoi

l,l eA[HcrBeHHoi

(peanbHocl4)

ToBapa;

Bo-Bropbtx, ycraHoBKa

npoeK.

TUpOBUII4KOB

!1 npoMbtL!J|eHHI,KOB

Ha TITaHTCKOe pa3-

Hoo6pa3he

$opM

x MoAener.

qro.

c oAnori

croooHbt...

orBeqaeT

pacTyuleMy

pa3Hoo6pa3[rc

h r43oqpeHHocTl,l

norpe6uocrei

v xenaauh

ny6lrrt,

4pyroi

pacLlH-

pFer

roBapHyro

cxcreMy,

o6ecne'thean

pasnoo6pasre,

Heo6xoAr,4Moe

AnF

ycKopeHxa

pa6()rur

rlrAycrpraluloi

MaurHbt,

KoTopyto

oTHbtHe TaKXe

MOXHO

Ha3btBaTb

nocrhHAycrpxan

on"

115, c.

1341

Ka< xaxerca,

npoAonxaer

Kpl4Tl4K,

npaB[na

3Toi

xrpbt

,,Ha

ycKope-

Hue ycBoeHbr

B npoeKT[poBaH]1t4

nonHofi

Mepe

,,Hr4'tyr6

o6ecKypax[BarcT

Aq3aiHepoB

aoxrreK-

TOpOB,

Koropbte

BHocFT

cBoi

BKIaA

pOCT

3TOrO

nepe-

,ruBalouleToca

qepe3

Kpai, r36blTortHoao

vgo6t

nl/,a

SopM

o6pa3oB,

npeAnaraa

Bce HoBbte

h Bce

6onee

FpKhe,

uyMHbte

4 3naT!4pyroulxe

Bapuaql,lt.

TaK,

Te_

qenre

80-x roaoB

nepea

HaMH, KaK MeTeopbt,

npoHec.

Jrucb

nocTMoaepHx3M,

fhnepMoaepHrl3M,

HeoMoaep_

H!|3M,

(BTopot

MoAepH!i3M

TpaHcaBaHTapa.

M l4Hl.1Ma_

nt 3M,

6onvay,3M,

Heonpl4Ml,1Tl4Bt43M,

Xati-TeK,

aeKoHcT-

pyKTrBr43M

A.,

r. n,

reHAeHq

h 6onee

hn, Me.

Hee

3HaqrTenbHbte

4 fiHtepecHhre.

oaHaKo

noTpe6nFB_

uJreca

c rot4

)l<e cKopocTbro,

'.tTo

l,1 npoMbtuneHHaa

npoAyKUl4F".

KpoMe

Bcero

npovero,

orneraer

Eoao-

Hl,l,

3TO

no6yxaano

h Kpt4Tl.lKOB

npeBpauaTbcF

B cBOe-

ro poAa

peKnaMHhtx

areHToB

tanx

6poKepoB

,,BbtAa_

Barh

6ecnpepbtBHylo

qepeAy

cyxAeH[i

oueHoK, B

6oflr,LU14HcrBe

caoeM

Heo6ocHoBarnurx

r tenyxoalrx,,.

03a6oqeHH6tx

TIlaBHbtM

c|6pa3oM

x306peTeHraeM

3+.

QeKTHOTO

3anoMuHaoulefocn,.TOBapHOTO

FpnbtKa,,

,,xopouJei

ynaKoBKt4"

A.ftF

cBot4x

cKopoTeqHbtx

r,rAei,

tl3OUlpFrOUlhXCF

OCTpOyMl4l4

np4ayMbtBaHl4|o

mot

(xoanqt,tx

cnoaeqer)

4evotcrprpyrcu.llrx reM

caMbrM

cBoro

KoHKypeHTocnoco6Hocr6

KaK Ha

pbtHKe

Au3aiHa,

TaKta

phrHKe

<purlrxr_r

(Tar,l

xe) .

Kov|uepvecrn.ue4vyM4yecKui

cpe3 nocrl4HAycr_

puarsnoi

c4ryaqh!4

npeAnaraer,

taKuM

o6pasov,

eue

oAHy

Bepc!flo

nprqhH

u cne4crBui,t

ABrlxqrenb,

oAHoBpeMeHHo

14croqHuK

t4cKyca

14 co6ra3Ha

pbtHoK

ulynanbqa

ero MeAHyMl4'{ecKoi

hH+pacrpVKrypbr,

qbe

npoqBeTaHhe

Bocnpor3BoacTBo

npeanonararcT

ta Tpe6yrcr

He 3aruxapulyro

Ha MfiHyry

.,o6paetiyro

uclept

tot', Hetas6exno

qpeBaryrc

,,ceMtaorhqecKr,tM

3a-

copeHl4eM".

apaKTep1430

H H btt; Bbtu]e

pa36poc

MHeHhi

or-

HOCUTeIIbHO

tMOAyCa

BVBeHAV"

nOCtuxaycrpuarrHofr

culyatlku

Mht

3ad[Kct4poBanl

llrLllb caMhte

pacnoo-

cTpaHeHHhle

u3 ropa3ao

6olee uroroquclelHbtx

Thno8

t,tHrepnperaqtax)

Aenaotcrplpyer

FBHyto HeoaHo-

3Ha'lHocrb

B eTo

onpeqeneHunvt,

no Bcei

Bt1[hMocrt4,

He-

Bo3MoxHocr6

HeaocroeepHocrs)

KaKoro-flr6o

oKoHqaTeflbHoTo

BblBoaa

3ToT cqeT,

KpoMe

pa3Be

qro

3aKnpqeHuF

ToM,

qTo

Bonpoc r<yaa

6onee

ulhpoK

t4 cJtoxeH,

qeM

6onee

tnI

MeHee

,tacTHaE,

BHyTprlnpo-

cpeccrroHaflhHaa

TeMa

MaHbep[3Ma

ynaaKa

aKVca

Au3aiHe.

BMecTe

c TeM

HeonpeAereHHocrb,

Bap[aHT-

Kax nlnuler

oAlaH r43

Har6oree

qMrroveMbrx

poB

Ax,

BarraMo

B r<Hqre

,,[ipo3pa,rHoe

o6r4ecrso", Beul, B

nocrMoaepHucrcKyro

3noxy

6yHKr.llroHupytor

KaK,,FpnbtKl,t

rpynnoBoli

qAeHTuOuKaqur".

To ectu,,3penbti

norpe6xrenb,,

uHTepecyercF

He BeutaMh

KaK TaKoBbtMX,

HO BeUlaMt

KaK 3Ha_

KaMu

cr,rMBonaMh

onpeAeneHloao

o6pata

xazau

l2j,

l]l,

HocTb

o6ulei

oqeHKh cr4Tyalll4|4,

rAe Ha

ponb

nepBoTon-

qKa

nonepeMeHHo

npereH[yror

rexro.norua

{marepr-

anwuri

nporpecc)

3KoHoMHKa

(psrHor

r Me1ual v

St,lnoco+tlF

Kynbrypht

(lraefisure

ycraHoaKfi,

np[opr4-

TeTHbre

qeHHocTl4

np.), He MoxeT

cnyxl4Tb

npuHqhnx-

anbHot

noMexoi

4nF

ocMhtclleHuF

o6.uextteuutx

cnea,

crgu/

u3 oroh cvrva\uu

ana

npoeKrHoi

Kynbrypbt

cy6!eKrxEHhtx

npoeKTHhtx

BbtBoAoB t43

Hee.

Taoprecrui

rocuoc

4naarina

80-x:

nocrl,|HAycTp,ajrbHoe

6htTl/|€

3epKa,|e nocTMoaepxrcrcKoro

co3HaHl{A

B ceoev

o6oope

ar3aiHa

8O-x roAoe

.[|x.

Eo3oHr4

BbtaetFeT

Tpl4

ocHoBHbtx

Tqna

npoeKTHoTo

Bbt6opa,

nlocTpt4pyF

14x

B6rcKa3brBaHlFMt4

Tpex

BhtaarculrxcE

lranbFHcKl4x

Ah3aiHepoa

3. I\4apr,t,

A. EpaHqri

!,|

Corrcacca.

Iloerqrln

Mapra.

o4Horo

h3 nocnelHrrx

npeAcraB

Tenei

,,repo[qecKoTo".

coqhan

bHo

-yronu

qec

Ko ro

Al4_

3akia

B Vran:w

gro

He[phMlipl4MaF

onno3rulrF.

,,CeroAHn

yron[n

MeprBa,

KoHcrarr4pver

oH.

O uei

aaxe

3anpeueHo

roBopl4Tb,

no6ea

qeroeer-

roeap.

floayrr

HauJero

BpeMeHh:

Bce

6oflhuJe

npoeK.

roe

sopr,re

npxKnaaHoro

hcKyccTBa

afla

KuTqeBbtx

norpe6Hocrei.

Haq[Han npoeKT4poBarh

noa 3HaKoM

yrom

TorAa

npoeKT(poBaHle

cq(Taflocb

VBeHqa-

HUeM

COqUanq3Ma,

Tenepb

BbtHyxaeH

BcF'tecKfi

hc,

xttTpaTbca,

qT06bt

He 6btTb

3aTFHyThtM

6OnoTo

aefe-

HepaT BHOfO

peafin3Ma,

anF

KOTOpOTO

npoeKTrpoBa_

Hre

3To

yBeH'taHue

roBapa"

115,

c. 1341 .

otnaqre

or 3Toi

o6peqeHHocr[

npooeccrroHa-

na,

nocTaB|4Bulero

,,abtcoKoe

aocTol,lHcTBo

noodec,

cvu",

no3uuvl

6panUr

yBepeHHo{nrhMl4crh'{ecKaa,

Aaxe

,,3i6op

qecKaF",

KaK

xapaKTeph3yer

ee 5o3oHl4.

.,H

y6exaen,

qro

qqKn,

Ha,taBU.ll4ilcn

ABaAuarb

ner Ha-

3aa,

noaxoal4T

3a8epueHqlo,

fl14ueT

SDaHuh-

1967-1968

rolax

HaqancF

npouecc

rauerenvrn

o6u.{e-

cTBa,

cyT6 KoTopoTo

Mht

MoxeM

noHFTh

nonHoi Me_

TonhKo

lenepl.

3ro r3MeHeHle,

nopo,

apaMaT4q-

rioe.

nopoi KoMt4ttHOe,

KaK

pa3

14 ecT6

(HaclynleHIe

nocTt4HAycTp

an6Hoi 3noxu),

3aTpar BaeT

oHo rpax-

aaHcKOe

O6UIeCTBO,

pbtHoK,

TexHonof!1p,

noBefleHxe,

npoh3BoIcTBo

v, caMo

co6oi4,

A[3aiH.

Eorree roro,

Al,t_

3aiH

EBnFeTcF

B rl3BecTHOM

cMhtcne

nporaToHhcToM

3ToTo

npo[ecca,

Har46onee

3Ha,]hrerbHhtM

x FpKxM

elo

crMnToMoM.

cei,lac

eror

npoqecc

3aEepL.rJxIcF, 14

o6ulectBo.

a raK)Ke

A[3aiH

BXoAFT

B HoByro

$a:y

cra,

6rlusocrr,

A norovy

Mor4

hHTepecbr

nepeMeulaoTcn

Kpr4lr,4qecKoro

aHarl,3a

Ha caMo

npoeKrrpoBaH4e,

no_

cKonbKy

npruIIa

nopa HacstTrTb

npoeKTqpoEaH4e

Bce,

M14

F3blKOBblM14

14 KynhTypHhtMl,l

HOBaUl4FMt4

AOCTT4-

xeHhFMh

nocneaHqx

fleT

ceroaHF

poM

bt LllneH

HocTh

.qocrlrna

$a:ut

3penocTt

ee npoAyKur48

3TO BeCb

oKpy)]<atoq14t

Mt4p,

e4l,1HCTBeHHO

BO3MO)|<HOe

AnF

Hee

HanpaBneHue pa3Burva

c$epa

Boo6paxeHua,

SaHra-

3UU, BhtqyMKU,

Happarh

BHocTh...

floao6Hhti

Bbtxoa

npoeKTfipoBaH[F

K HOBbtM

KyrbTypHbrM

foptl3oHTaM,

conpFXeHHbti,

Bo3MOXHo,

c npoqeccoM

peKoHcofll4Aa_

uux

npoeKTHoro

spoHTa,

MoxHo

paccMaTpraaTb

KaK

o6eulaHre,,Broporo

MoAepH143Ma':.,

B KoropoM

npoeK.

TrpoBaHhe

BHoBb

HabepeT

BstCoTy

HaqHeT onepl,po,

Barb

crparefhqecKrvr

vacLuta6aut...,,

(Tav

xe) .

HaKoHeu,

TpeTbf,

no3rqtlF

no3uuxF CoT"Icac-

3aMeqarenbHa

+oHe

AByx

npeAur[yutux

ceo'efr

o'reBhAHoi

BHeoMotl14oHanbHocrbto, yxe

AaBHo

cBoiicr-

BeHHbtM MaCTepy

on MnrlicKl4M

cnoKo;cTB

eM, KOTO.

Cau

Caxra<unpa

yenevex

paepa6orKoi,,peaK-

TI4BHOTO MOAyCa"

3TOi

3CTeTtiK14,

TO eCTb

MeraMopQo-

3aMx

Beqei

pe3ynbrare

ti B npouecce

peaKuu14

rHn

norpe6neHxa,

t{To

BnonHe

ayxe

6onee

ulupoKoi

KOMnbprepHoi

no3rl,K|4

coBpeMeHHoi

3noxh,

nocTy'

nara B3axMoaeicTBuq, AVanOf

genoBeKa

u ero oKpy-

xeHuE. ..TKaHr

c xl.1aKrlMl,1

Kpl,lCTanflaMU,

KOTOpble

MeHFK)T

UBeT

npU

Manei|'|leM l,l3MeHeHUr

TeMneparypbl,

doToqVBcTBlTen6Hbte

CqHreTu'{ecKue

MaTep[anbl,

x3_

MeHAlOUlle oKpacKy

3aaucuMocTl,

xapaKTepa oc'

BeuleHhE,

l4cKyccTBeHHoro

hnv ecTecrBeHHoro

(BaLua

py6auJKa,

6enaa

o$uce,

craHoBl'lrcF

KpacHoi,

Kor-

Bbt BhrxoaHTe

ynqqy

l4 oKa3blBaerecb

Ha corlHqel

Meraflflbr

(Bo3BparHo;

naMarbrc)

(lanpuvep,

nnoc'

KaF nnacr!4Ha

nph

KoMHaTHOi

TeMnepaType

cTaHoBl4T'

ca o6uevnoi

nenensxuuei)

3crerrKa

raKvx Mare'

o[anoB

BhlxoaHT

paMKH

qBeTonracfrqecKrx

napa-

MerpoB, 14

pa6ore

c HhMx

npeBpauaerca

MarlqecKylo

MaHrnynFu!1to

C nep+opMaT,tBHblM14

BO3MOXHOCTFMX'

Taxte uarepranut

!4HTepecHbl

He caM!'t

ce6e, a

B crnY

aocTynHbrx

qepe3

hx nocpeacTBo

ll4cTo

KoHuenTyanb_

Hbtx

3SSeKToB,

no3roMy

Ha3btaap

(hMMarep[-

anaMu)"

[33,

c. 100]

['locneaH|,i MaruqecKhi

npoeKT

CaHTaKbFpbl,

ocvulecrBneHHbri

ureeriqapcroi

Me6enbHoi

+!apMoi

,Bfipa",

raMMa ri3 Tpex crynheB

noa Ha3BaHueM

Sister

Chair

(,,Cecrput")

: MnrKtre

Aeranh

crynheB

(cnaeHhe,

cnnHKa)

3anorlHeHbr

KoMno3hrHhlM

Marep[-

anoM,

nocraBKa

Koropofo uaer

+opMe

naKeroB-ny'

3brpei

Koropbri o6flaaaer

SaHracr[qecKl,lM

a,|ana3o-

HoM

AocrvnHhrx

Bapfiaufli o6beMa,

ThlcF'{y

pa3

npe'

Bbttllarculr.rM

aHa'lorl4qHhle

Bo3MoxHOCTl,l

ra3ah

B coT-

Hro r6tcFg

xrtaKocrl4.

nepBaF

Moaenb

-,,3acreH'{rl'

BaF"

npr noBhltlleHl4h-

ronoca Ha'{l4Haef

cBelrTbca

KpacHhrM

cBegeH!1eM; BTopaF

-..O6ulrrenunas"-

noa

BO3AeiCrBheM

TeMneparypbl

TeIa

cfl}qau{eTo

Ha'{tlHaeT

o6aonaxrearu,

o6suvarr

ero;

TperbF

,,Kanpre'

HaF"

Me{Fer

qBer

o6hBKu

B 3aBr1cllMocrl,1

onnTb

reMnepaTypbr

Tena cuaFulero.

B HutHeuHei claryaqriu npecbtuleHHocrta

CaHTa'

Kbapa cnoBHo

Bo3poxaaeT

naneoTexHonortlqecKylo

no_

3ThKy

no3TtlKy

HakBHOTO

yAhBneHhF

BenrKoro

KOnAOBCTBa,

KOTOpble, B4AlrMo,

aBnFlorcF

HaEbonee

ct4JtbHblMl,

aprvMeHTaMrl

ryMaHuTapHoro onpaBAaHrF

TexHonorlth c

apegHe;Lullx

apeMen.

XaparrepHo,'iro

arMocsepe

nonynFpHoro

HhlHe

6plo3xaHnn

noBoay

cTafHaqur.r

a[3aiHa

caHTaKbFpa

|,13

Tex HeMHOTXX,

KTO

v36exan

yqacrx

HauJKoAtlBulero

pacneKaeMoro

3TO

Nlarbq14rlrK14 ;,,cpiAra

neovoAeptr3Ma,

Heo+yHK-

uloHaJlx3Ma,

MhHhManu3Ma

u 6onuarasua

6lAxai'

utre

roabl B nhaephl,

Bl4ahMo, BbtpBercF

3reKTpoH-

Hbrri

MeHTanfiTer

3KcrarltlecKaF

ticKyccrBeHHocrb,

MqHXaTrcp!13aqrf,

l/| M M arepran

bHocrb

MaTepharoB

Bo TnaBe c ero

npopoKoM

AeHlacoM

CaHTaKbFpoi"

[19,

c. 158]

HaKoHeu, eule oallH

cpe3

nocrxHAycrpuanbHox

chrVaux!.

couroKynbrypHbti,

To ecrb,

rpy6o

roBopF,

ournoqxo.norpe6rrerbcKl4i

c TogKh

3peHuF ero

no'

3TriqecKux

pe3epBoB,

KaK

KaxercF,

He HyxaaeTcn

cneqtaanbHoM

npeacraB'|eHu14.

06HaxeHHocrb,

KoHuerl'

Tp14poBaHHocTb

14 cuoxHo-l430ulpeHHaF

apruKyr!rpo'

BaHHOCTb

COLl14OKytbTypHblx

MexaHl,,|3MoB,

FBneHHblX B

nocTr,lHAVCTpUanbHO14

Cl,lTyaqLlu,

co3Aanl/l

no9By

anF

He'

BepoFTHoro

6yua

xynuryponoruqecKtax

rlccrleaoBaH]1t

He ronbKo B

HavKe

(rae

nopoatinh

ueny|o

cepup Ho-

Bblx

HayqHbtx

HanpaBneHxi

colll4oceM4oruKa,

ceMllo:

norxF n np.)

xo u e npoerrxoft

c+epe..

3aBB3ho

raKo-

ro 6yMa aBHnacb He

cronbKo

o6qaa,

raK cKa3arb

pHTo-

p[qecKaF,

ryMaHhcrhKa

{xoropaa,

npaBAa,

cbtrpana

onpeaeneHHyro

aeroHHpytoulyto

ponb

pa3Bane

Moaep-

H!,rcrcKoi lraeonorrn)

cKonbKo BnonHe

nprKnaaHble

npo6neuut

BHyrpeHHhx

MexaHh3MoB

14 crpyKTyphl

rVrurypoo6pasoeaHHa

(MexaHh3Mbt

3apoxaeH{F

SyH

Kul,roHHpoaaHu

u^eonorqi,

derrlLllrcrcKoe

co3-

HaHXe,

UeHHOCTta

!a nceBAoqeHHocTl4,

qnnp3vu

pealb'

Hocrb,

+opMhf

couxoKynhrypHoi

r,Ae{r/.6r/,Ka4

v, ap'

xeTrnbr

KorlteKThBSoro 6ecco3H

aTen

bHoro h T.

n-r.

ecrbnpo6neMbr

OyHKqrloHtapoBaHxF

3HaKOBO'

TKaHr Kvnbrypbl

B ee orHouJeHHn

MarepltanbHoMy

BHeKynbTypHoMy

Hnr{, cKOKeM.

qhB14nx3aquoHHoMy

cy6crpary.

Axryanrsaqr.a

noao6Boi

npoSneMarrK!4

caM xapaKTep

nocraBoBKI,t

np06neM,

KaK npaBhno,

noaqepKHVTo oS.heKTxBHcrcKHi,

06ycnoBneHbr.

KaK

KaxeTca,

hMeHHo x4aKTepHOi

nOCTMOAepH'ICTCKOi

nonugKpaHHocT!ro,

KonnaxHocrblo,

Mo3auqHocTblo,

cnoHcrocrbro

KynbrypHoro co3HaHrla.

nphuleatrlero

Ha cMeHv

MeHTanbHor,{

uenbHocrtl

3noxh

.,6onbLUt1x

uaeonorvi".

Taxrau

oSpa:ou,

B couloKynhrypHoM

nnaHe

nocrllftaycTpHajluroe

o6qecrBo

noralaeTcF

Tpt4yMQoM

rpoKAaHcKoro o6utecrBa,

ocHoaHbre

KoHcrxryxpylo-

ulHe ct]ltibl

N cocraBlerou${e

Koroporo cy16

Torarl434-

tltlF

rHoopMa.lrloHHo-Kos{MyHHKaThBHblX

crlcTeM

(,,npospa{xo€

06urecrgo"i,

roranr3aqhF aHTta3Tar!1cr-

croro rr6epanr:wa

i,,ropn3oHTanbHoe

o6uecrBo")

TOTaJrU3aqrf

3KO'.|O\tia\ecKoro

nh6epanh3Ma

6a3e

Bbrco'{aiujero

}?oBHF

rr3o6}1'|xF

(,,o6utecreo

norpe6-

neHua",

,,o6ulecaBo

n*6u.nua"l.

KaxAaa hg

3Txx coc-

TaBrapur{x

3?piree,

}-ooBHei

h ceqeHui

coapeMeH-

Horo 06qecrBa

ro€oeMy npoFBnFer,

aKUeHTtlpyeT

3HaKoBbri, oSpa3Ho-o4

vaonEqecKr14 xapaKTep

Kynbry'

pbr,

axnocra3vplgr ,.

rrn+Tpos4pyeT ero,

BnnoTb

.,reHepar

3ogek.lo i

t:repta"

(X.

Soaprainp)

!picraz

re-r

sr, c.

*n6opr'raqrosnsti

cpe3

06yc'

IoBnraaeru

OaKt',t€ci<,{

pearH

3yer

Bo3MoxHocTb

or_

cnaHBaHHF 3i{a<C€Ct:KaHH.

3HaKOBhlX

KOAOB, B

3Ha-

quTenbHotl

Mege A,'3r€-1+l6tx, A

HX npaKThtleCKOi

Ca'

MoaocraroqHoc-r

,;-1po3pa'r

Hocrb"

o6orput',locru

acei HHdopMa.yr

,!:o-r,r3KpaH)

;

aeuaeonoT

3l4poBaH'

nocra

(enenepaxrlLrgcKoe,,ropx3oHTanbHoe

o6ulecr-

Bo")

ToqHe€.

,,J,€o-roii,gecKhi nnrcpanq3M

penqru'

B143M, o6yctoB.ili

aa€i

cy6.beKThBHyto

npeApacnoflo'

xeHHocTb

'{tEno€

:a<oio

o6ulecrBa

cxBaTblBaTb

norll4-

3KOaH B

qenOCIHOC:,',

AO ECeM

UUOrOO6paSUr

axry'

aJlhHhrx

F Boo6o43trtrlErx

Mr.poB

l,1x B3aLlMHoM

orHo'

ueHuh,

cono-.:0x(eH7J,.

Hni{ oTTaIKhBaH|4'1,

nyTeL!ecTBO-

Barb

no 3THM

unpan,

oco6etxo

He npxKpennnacb

Hh K

oaHoMy

t3 l]nx; lta<oHeu,

3KoH oM 14'{eCKrli

tltl6epa'

nr3M cno@6c'IBieT o6Har<eBv|o

MaHunynarrBHblx

co-

f.lltilJf btf bf

x Mexart{3voB,,-oncKypcHH

Bnacfu"

t,,Bfla'

cJl4

aucKypcl,rH".

floc<ors<v 3Tn

rDo{lecchr ceMrorl.l3aqhr

r, co'

oTaeTcTBeHHO,

AeMarepraaJlH3aufih

peanulocru

o6pera'

tor

xat6onee

HHTeHcr,rBFbre

ra noKa3arenbHble

SopMbl

M4pe roaapHo{rpor,3aoAcrBeHHbtx

oTHoLleH14i,

co6cT_

BeHHO B npOUeC-Ce

np€BpaulesHF

npoayKTa

B ToBap

(.,06pauexne,

noKynKa,

npoaaxa,

npvo6petetrlre

6nar

h 06beKroB,

orMeqaet

EoapraiEp,

cocraBnFrcT

ce-

roaHF

Hau

F3brK, HauJ

Koa, nocpeacTBoM

KoTOpOTO

ooqecrBo

aHyrpe8He cBa3aHo

KoropblM oHo

pa3ro-

aapt4aaeT...

llo

otxouretxp

K 3roMy

F3blKy nOTpe6Ho'

crH

11 xHAHBlAyanbHbre

y[oBottbcrBnF cyrb

3S+eKTbl

peqx"

[13,

125])'.

ar.3aiH

oKa3brBaercF

3nuqeHr'

nocrMoAepHHcrcKoro

npouecca.

llpeacraBaF oaHo'

speMeHHo

rpex,Knp9eBbrx no3l4q|4ax

np4op

reTHo'

o6-beKTa

KynbryponorvgecKhx l4ccneaoBa8xi

{Hk-

KOrAa npexae

ah3aiH

He 3aHuMan

raKofo 3Halurerb-

HOTO MeCTa B

pa3Jll4qHOrO pOAa

ryMaH

rapHbrx

r 06-

ulecTBoBeaqecK(x

aqanv3ax,

BnnoTb

n[TepaTypo-

BeAeHHF h

Sr,rnoco+r,rr)

aBTop[TerHoro

cy6]eKra

npH-

Kna4Hbrx KynbTyponoTurrecKhx HccneaoaaHrlt t1 oaHo-

x3 Beayultlx

npoeKTaHToa

t1 opraHr3aTopoB

Bcei

HoBoi

(exarcoeoi) pearlhHocrh,

npoqHo

yAep-

xkBaeT 3Th

no3hqt4l4

BoT

yxe

20 ner, 9To BnorHe 06!-

FcHFer

..3iSoprqec<ni

ontrr'argr'a"

SpaHula v

aeMoH-

crpqpyer ero He6ecnoqBeHHocrb.

Hanovnrv,

qro

r.lMeHHo

6panqu

e corpy4utrvecr-

Be c

pFAoM

4pyrrx 4r:airepoB-Teoper[KoB

croHT

rcoru16e.nr

npoexrnoi Kynbryponorltu, enonne

cnoco6-

Hoi

npereHAoBalb

Ha craTyc npl4KnaAHoi HayKtl, onfi-

papulel4ca

Ha Meroabt v cpeacrBa npoeKTrlpoBaHrF.

Yxaxev e 3Toi cBF3l4 Ha

npoeKTHo-KoHuenryanbHbte

qccneaoBaHhF

crHnei x o6pa3oB

xr43Hh, apxeTrnoB

l,4

npororhnoB,

Seloveaoe

npecrrlxHoro norpe6neHl4F.

cy6xynuryprurx

dopMaufii,

KorrreKr4BHoro 6eccosHa-

TerbHoTo r.4 r. n.. KoToobre Benrcb

qTanbFHcKl/M

no!4c-

KoBbrM

ar,l3aiHoM

nporFXeH

rl 70-80-x roaoa, a

TaKXe

CfOnb xapaKTepHbte hMeHHo

ana

Ataluu nna-

cTh'iecKLle

penpe3eHTaqrlfi

cnoxHetuero

cneKynarra-

Ho-yMo 3pr ren bHoro

ypoBHF

coBpeMeHHot

Kynbrypo-

nor[,{ecKoi

pe$nexcar

{tenur

unrrcsrr u

o6uara,

a6-

cypaa

h napaaoKca, cKyccTBeHHoro

ecrecrBeHHoro,

BHyrpeHHl4x KoHSnhKToB npouecca !4HAhBr4AVanbHoi

aeHThShKauhrl

H np.)

aarneuJ[ecF

t{acrbp

KaK

Te-

Kyuero npoeKrxpo8aHrF,

TaK

r npoeKTHo{rpor,r3Boa-

crBeHHblx,

npoeKTHo{ollronofuqecKl.x v

npoqhx npo-

rpauna. Bcnovnru, HaKoHeq, noroK KHxr KpynHbrx

Ax3aiHepoB

(A.

Sparrrh, A. l\4eHA!.lHh, P.

Aarnsu,

Y. fla flserpa, 3. Corrcacc

) ,

e norHe

Hyu]r4x

yHAa

MeHTan6Hbte

HavqHbre hccJteaoBaHrF.

Fcto,

qro

no napaMerpaM cepuesroi HayqHocrr

au3ar,H

Be TorbKo He noTepFn B 3noxy

nocTMoaepHr3'

Ma, Ho 14 BbruJen K 6onee uypoK14M

roph3oHTaM.

qTo

KacaercF

SopMaflbHo{rl4nucrr4qecKoi

cropoHbl

Aefla.

ro a3btKoBbre,

nnacT!4qecKLre,

3KcnpecclB.

Hhre, reuJTanbrhcrcKqe

orKpbt14F,,l\4eM+hca",,,Ar-

xv1Mat4"

v Boo6ue

,,HoBoro avgafiHa"

caMoi urx-

poKoi

reorpaorara, BAoxHoBneHHble l4MeHHo nocrMo.

AepH

crcKt4M14

Kareropl4FM14 3SeMepHocrl4,

cKopo.

TeqHccr14, noBepiHocTHocr!4,

aeKoparhaHocTl4.

Konfl ax

Hocrt,

Aaxe

MuurypHocrr4 14 K4TqeBocrl,i,

6eaycnoero,

gbtaepxl4BaloT

cpaBHeHre c aHaJtoTlrrlH6lMl, oTKpbrrl,F-

Ml4

QyHKUt4OHanX3Ma,

ecnri He npeBOCXOAFT

14X.

9to <acaetcn co6creeHHo npoeKTHoro noreHqha-

na nocTMoaepHhcTcKoro co3HaHra, To Kph3[c u

aHHr-

runaqua

Ytonun.

xoropofi rocrcyer Mapv, eroro

sxep-

TeTlqecKoro, raeonofhtecKoro l4 HpaBcrBeHHoro

pe-

3epByapa MoaepHx3Ma, KaK Ka)KeTca, c rl4xBot Bo3-

Meuaerca reM,

qro

SpaHqra Ha3btBaer

.,Happar[BHbt-

M14 Bo3MoxHocrnM!4"

flepcneKTrBo!i npoeKTxpo-

Barh MHoxecrBeHHbte

pryanbHbre,

co6hrr!.iHhte

pF.

Abl,

cueHapl rKt43HV, He roBopF

yxe

o npoeKTHot

peTponor[x

l4cKyccTBe [3Bne']eHl4F u

aKryanv3a-

qv,

apxerrnoB crpoeH

aHTpon

ocdepsr

, 14 ronu cropo

nocrMoAepHrcrcKaF

chcreMa norpe6neH

F. rhnep$e-

Tr4uJt4CTCKaA

nO CBOel4 CyTl,4, OCHOaaHa Ha,,CTpaCTh KO.

aa"

(Eonpr,riep)

BoxAeneH[h

OopMbr

o6reKroB

r ux

,.$opuaruroi

nurypruu"

(KaK

cpeAcrBa rpynno-

eoi uaeHrla$rrauur)

xoropere

npaKTrlqecKr

Bbrrec-

HFloT 6tlo3KoHoMHqecKxe

6!ao+yH Kr.lxoHar bH bre Mo'

treut notpe6nexra.

ecnta, cneAoBarenbHo.,.3penofo

no-

rpe6utena't

rlHTepecyET

He Beu.l,

caM|a no ce6e. Ho 3a-

AaBaeMbfe

vMn c\eHapw

xlr3Hl,

noBeAeHhF,

opKecT.

poera

a$$exrreroro

npoqecca, To

ecrb

SaHTa3Maru.

qecKoe

r3MepeHLle

esa[[4oorHouJeH!4i

qeroBeKa

H Be-

u.[14, ro 14

nepea

Ah3aiHepoM

Bcraer HoBaF

3aaaqa:

,,npoeKTrpoBarb

crpareft tn,

3o6perarb cqeHap!414

xH3-

H h norpe6neHua,

KaK nocpeacrBoM

HoBoi

opraHx3a-

r.lr,1ri

yxe

cyuecrByroul|/|x

ToBapoB,

TaK h co3aaBaF Ho.

Bbre

OopMbr

npoAyKToB-roBapoB,

c reM

qro6br

3anon-

Hrirb

MHoro'i cneHHbre naKyHbr

p6tHKa,

Koropbtt, He-

cMoTpa Ha cBolo

nepeHachruleHHocTb,

oKa3htBaeTcF

He-

Aocratovnuru"

I27,

c. 151'.

HaKoHeu,

nocTt4HAycTpuanbHaF

cpeaa cTaHoB14TcF

I4CTOqHI4KOM

Cepbe3HOrO xaHpOBOrO

l,l CTI4fleBOTO

06'

HoBreHrF

Al4saiHa.

BosHnraer

noBceMecrHo

pacnpo.

ctpaHFeTcF u.ioy.Ar3atH,

cBoefo

poAa

cpeAoTo'l14e nocr-

r,tH[ycrpfianbHoi

cneqla$xK|a

Bo Bcex

ee cpe3ax: Mera-

eh3l4Kt4

BpeMeHI,r

(ero

Te'reHHa, cKopoTeqHocTt4,

3Oe-

vepHocrr)

TexHonorHtlecKoro

MeraMopd[3Ma !a

SaH.

roMonorrr,

coLltaoKynhrypftoi

(roeapHorrrHoqHoi)

caMopeKfla MHocTh,

aeM

oH cTpaTr4 B

HocTV, 3pervuJHocft/1,

flrUeAeicTBa.

AeKopaq'|oHHocrr4,

x14TpoyMha, To'{Ho

paccqrraHHoi

MexaH Krl

coBpauleHrF, co6na3HeHrF,

3aBIeqeH'1F,,.fl

pOAaXHOCTh

Uoy-qr,tsaiH

KaK

ocrerr{ecKaE

MoAerb

nocTt{HAycTptajrbHoi

3noxt

llloy-ar4

gailFr

B cBoeM,,Harypanbnou errpaxenrr

B3pacraer Ha

noqBe

iipexae

etopoctenerroi

otpacnr

AV3ahHa,

qMeHHo

3Kcno3uqr4oxroro

Ar:afira

pa:noro

poaa,

Bbrpbrearcueroca e 80e roabt Ha

ponb

nrAepa

hMeHyeMoro

HbrHe,,BTopbtM

poe

rcrrpoearueu

xo-

Topoe

aKTrlBHo npoAyuupyer

co6crBeHHbte npoeKTHhte

o6!eKTbr, BocnptaHtaMaeMbte

KaK oco6eHHo thnrl'{Hhte

AnF

nocTMoAepHhcrcKot Kynbrypbr.

nepByro

o'{epeAb,

3To, <onevro,

o6utrptaa

pa3Hoo6pa3HaF

cSepa

co6creeuro 3Kcno3hr.|,4i

ToptoBbtx

3anoB

xyaoxecTBeHHbtx

BbrcTaBoK

14 My-

3eeB, cSepa

AnF Au3atHa

rpaA!4r.{r,roHHaF,

Aocrl4ruJaF

HeBtlAaHHhtx

npexge vacutra6oB

u cnoBHo Bo3poAl4B-

LlaFcF

nocle

Aecq'r

tervh npo3a6aHxF Ha 3aABopKax

,,6onru.ioro AV3aiHa"

K 3HeprulqHoMy

rhnonorr'{ecKo-

pa3Brrhto.

AocraroqHo

cKa3arb.

qro

,,arnecrl.Me+-

ro",

rax

tatutearcT

gry

o6nacrb a Vltannu, B TeqeHr4e

80-x roaoe

nocreneHHo 3aHhno

qyr6

nta He

rnaBeHcr-

Byroulee MecTo B TBopqecTBe

MacfepoB. KoTophte npex'

olHochnrcb

noAo6Hoi Luoy-cUeHorpaohra

Aaxe

HeKorophrM

npeHe6pexeH[eM. TaK.

cepnF

!4HTepbepoB

MaTa3rlHoB

Esprit Corrcacca

Vcrynaer

no 3Ha'{!4Mo-

crtl

nonvnFpHocrh

ero 3HaMeHrToi Me6eflfi

AnF

,,1\4eMStaca"

aBToM arta 3h

poBaH

Hbr M

oStacaM

AnB

,,Orueefiu".

raoxno

crcagaru

grccnolrurnx

l-leLue,

coe4aeruero cpeAu npoqero,

cyan

or3hl-

BaM, Heqro r3

pFAa

BoH BbrxoAFulee Ha HeAaBHei

Bbtc-

raBKe

KpearrlB

-|y'

ranua"

B AnoHqv.

Apyroi

cropoHbr, ulxpoKre

nepcneKrhBbt or-

KpbrBaeT

nepea

aB3ar4HoM

ynoMaHyTaE

fhnororrqec-

KaF 38OnnqUF LlOV{peAbt.

nocleatlle

ro[bt

Bce

'iaue

Bce cepbe3Hee

pac.

cy)]<Aalor

o napaAoKcanbHoM c6nuxeuuu roproBo, h

My3eiHoi

cpeAbr,

AByx

rlanoB

cpeAbt,

Koropbte .po3af

yxe

6nnxaiu.rr..re

IoAbt

crarb noqr[ Hepa3nhql4Mbt-

Mh, npeBpaTrBuI4cb

B cpeaoBbre

arnoMepauhh ToproBo-

O cevronorr,rqecKxx

KoHqenuuFx

derMuJfi3Ma B

3noxv

nocruHAycrpranbHoro

06qecrBa cM. e

pa6ore

[8].

Kynhryp

Ho-{4 HQopM aqroH

Ho-pa3BreK

areJr bH brx

qeHT

poB,

llo

KoMMepqecKoi' nnHt A 3ro npo!,rcxoAlrT B

npo-

uecce

nepepoxaeHxF cynepMapKeToB B TaK Ha3hrBae-

Mbre,,aparcTop",

06!earHFroqhe

ToproBbti

qeHTp,

6u6nrorery,

{orore<y,

cnoprhBHy}o craHq

rc, aBTo-

cToFHKy, Kr4HOTeaTp, Bl4Aeo3anbt h

np. YTO KaCaeTCA

My3eeB, To

eule B 30-e

ro4ur

reueqrri

SHnocod

B, SeHbFMhH

orMeqa x cxoAcrBo c 6a3apoM. B Hauu

AHfi

coBpeMeHHbre My3eiHbre KoMnneKcbt npFMo

yno.

Ao6nnrcrca

cynepMapKery: 3Aecb c MaKchManbHhtM

yao6crBoM

14 6brcrporoi

norpe6nnercn oaqH

143

caMbrx

npecrhxHbrx 14

Aoporr/x

roBapoB

Kynbrypa. BKnrc-

qeH{e

My3eeB B rlHAycTplrro

pa3BneqeHhh

KaK

oaHoro

Ha 6oree npecr4xHbtx, Ho oAHoapeMeHHo x Hara6o-

nee xpynKlx

ee 3BeHbeB BeaeT K napaaoKcarbHoMy

nepepoxAeH[|o My3eiHbtx

SyHKqlai,

Co6crBeHHo 3Kc-

no3l4ul4oHHaa

qacfb

npeBpauaeTcF B

cBoeto

poaa

pe.

nuKBapvi,,

cBfl

Tr.4ll,rule

ana

noceauleHHbtx.

3HaToKoB.

Opllsr

xe,,coepeveHHbrx

norpe6hreflei" nponycrcarcr-

,9pe3

3To cBaThnhule Ha HeBepoFTHot

cKopocr!4 u

lar6onee

3KoHoMHbrM MapulpyTaM,

'rTo

BnonHe

oT-

eevaer cyry6oi cr4MBonrqHocTr4 caMoi

noTpe6Hocrh,

KOTOpaA C

yCneXOM yAOBneTBOpFeTCF

CrpeMrTenbHO

pa3peciatouletcH

!4H+opMau

oHHo-AocyToBo'KoMMep.

qec,<oi

hH+pacrpyKType My3eiHbrx

KoMnneKcoB. Ko-

HetrHo,

3Tor

rax

Hasuteae^ruti fast.museum

(no

aHano-

rqI

fast-food)

AaneKo

He eA HcTBeHHbri B ceroAHFL!-

HeM My3eiHoM

cTpoxrdnbcrBe,

xota, voxer 6urrs,

Hau6onee

xapaKrepHbll,1.

AnF

Ah3aiHa

oH npe4craBrFer

06ulpHoe, Ho 14

AocraroqHo

6aHanbHoe

nore nprnoxe,

Hl4F Crn, tlHTepecHee

B 3TOM CMbtCJte

noaBnaK,ull4ecF

Tyr h raM npoeKTbt

3KcnepuMeHTanbHbrx

vyseea

(ran-

phMep.

TaKTrn6Hbrx

My3eeB

Ann

crenstx)

rAe nepeA

av3ahqepaMu

oTKpbtBaKrrcF

Bo3MoxHocTt4 KOHqenTya-

nq3aql4u

caMoTo

+eHoMeHa

My3ee$lrKaq!4

xl,,t3H t4

ocraHoBKr,4

ueflu

6ecnpepbrerurx

rpancSopvaqlri

[36].

Apyroi

cyuecrBeHHbr; KaHan

yrBepxAeH14f,

uroy-ah3a14Ha

TeaTpaJrl43oBaHHaE

cpeaa. l,cKyccTBo

cqeHotpa+uh

!1 cpeAoBoro nep+opMaHca, HbrHeLIlH

;

6yv roroputx raxxe

o6ycnoBneH nocrMoaepHucrcKlrM

cocroFHueM. HapBAy

c rpa4uquornoi

c$epot

Tear.

poM,

cTarrlBarcru{t4M

Ha ce6a B Haull,l

aHl4

llyquJue apx[-

reKrypHo-ah3aiHepcKt,te

clrhr

(nanpuuep,

pa6ora

F. Aynenrra

SnopeHrlicKoi

cryAt4l4 3Kcnepr4MeH-

ranunoro Tearpa

rlyKh PoHKoHt4

[17]

e nhaepur npo,

eKTHOTO

UHTepeca BbIXOAFT

A14CKOTeKr.

Ecnt,l cynepMapKer.

BbtcraeKa, MV3ei, Tearpanb-

HaF CUeHOrpa(DrF,

nph

oqeBr4aHoi

aoMhHaHTe

arlpTv.

anbHo-co66rr14iHbtx

napaMerpoB

cpeAoo6pa3oBaHl,a.

BCe

Xe COXpaHF|oT

CBS3b C Cy6CTaH

qroHanbH

Oi npOCT.

paHcrBeHHo-nnacrrl'tecKoi

TpaArluuei,

AhcKoreKa

npaKTr'lecKr

norHocTbro

l4cqepnbtBaercF

$aHTa3Mar

qecKhM

143MepeH|4eM.

lvllpaxHocTh.

cKopoTeqHocrh,

edeueprocru

cpe4oBoro

o6pa3a

AllcKoreK'| Al4Kryrorca

KOMMep'{eCKuMh

Coo6paxeH[FMt4.

nocKonbKy

ee no-

Tpe6neHhe

xecTKo

3aBF3aHo

Ha MoAHble

qrxnut.

,,Cpe4.

Hr4i

CpOK Xr,43Hq

nOMeUleHrlFl

AI4CKOTeKh

rph rOAa,

,flrurenutoctr

MoaHoro

qhKna

B oaexae, Mv3brKe.

noBeAeHhh

6onee Tpex uecaqee.

Ta<rv

o6pa3oM,

3a Tpu roaa

[hcKoTeKa

ao,lxHa

[MeT6

no KoaiHei

Mepe

aecffTb

xopol!r4x

xaei, oaHa

KoTopbtx

Bbl-

ure

cpeaHeTo

ypoBHa,

ecnl4

arlcKo-Kny6

xoqeT

Bbt6 T6.

cF B top"

[23,

c.6ll.

3rofi nnxopa4ovroir roHKh

MOfyr

[36exaTb

aaxe

nefeHAapHhte MecTa,

Thna Hblo.

froprcc<oro

flanna4ryva,

rAe MtnnuapAibti

rHiepbep

BenuKoro

Aparbr

ly'cog:arl

He nporFHyn

60']buje

AByx

ner.

Bnpovev,

cqhraBuleeca

rhnororxqecK[

o6pa3qo-

BbrM B CepearHe

g0-x

roaoe

peuJeHhe

3ToTo xHTepbepa

Ayxe ,,TeXHOnOr!4'{eCKOaO

6apOKKO", C

MHOrO'tl,CneH.

HhfMr4

B'l[eo- h na3epHbrMx 36SeKTaMr

v ncvxoaenv-

qecKoi

My3brKoi,

ceiqac B

npqHr.Une 6e3HaAexHo

ycrapeno.

TexHonorH,recKoe

BonrouleHve

3+eMepHo-

cTl4 KaxeTcF HbrHe

cnqL!KoM

apoMo3aKt4M 14

aoporo'

cToaulxM,

TnaBHoe

crarhqHhrM, KaK 6br BHeRpe-

MeHHbrM.

3deMepHocrb

aHcKoreKt-r

KoHqa 80-x

cTonbKo

aeMoHcrparBBHa,

cKonbKo

pealhHa,

l4 B 3ToM

cMbrcne

oHa oTpaxaeT

peanbHyro

gBonloqhlo

nocTMo-

AepHkcrcKoi ,,o6pa3Hoi

v,cleptAu"

ece

6oruureuy

l4cToHbuJeHHrc,

HCTaHBaHr.rIo,qaxe IMMaTep|/1anhHot

cy6cranqrr a,{hcro r-rAeanbHo; HapparuBHocrta. XapaK.

TepHo

3TOM

CMbrCre CpaBHeH e

AICKO-CpeAbr

Kt4-

3a3KpaHHbll npOClpaHCTBOM,

KI4HO3nU3OAOM,

Ay6reta,

ra< srr4 t.Haqe

cpexxccx

poBaH

btM 14 cbrrpaH-

HbrM,

a6cotorHo

peanbHbrM,

u a6conorHo

t4nJrFl3opHErM.

FcHo,

,rro

rpaArql.4oHHoMy ta

aaxe

aBaHrapaHoMy

SH3atHy

3[ecb notT HeqeTo

aenaTb.

Teoperavec<u

AH3a;Hep AonxeH

3Aech

pa6orar6

ypoaHe

xecToBoM,

r,t11M11qecKoM,

co3aaBaF HeqTo Bpo.

Ae Vnbr6Kh

9eurpcrcoro Kota

H orge,ran

TeM caMbrM

KynbTypHoi

SyHKrlran

AHcKoTeKh

pacKpenouleHhp

BapBapcKoi, nepBo6brrHoir,

|'1peaep6anbHoi xecroBo-

cTl4, KOTOpaA, nO

CyTr, OCTaeTCFT eAIHCTBeHHbtM npoq-

HbtM

ocHoBaHrreNr calroagelrr$raraqt4u B

ycKonb3a-

rouleM

coBpeMeHHor,r $,rpe. npaKTHqecKl4

3ro HorAa

yAaercF,

Ho,

6yAy,r!! npeBep6anbHbrM,

ycKollb3aeT

l,lcKyccTBoBeaqecKoio

onHcaHHS 14

aHanh3a,

Ecnr

grcxore<a

qacro

paccMarphBaercFr

KaK

Mt4KpoMoAenb

KynbryDHoi nosrHKM nocTHHAyclpxanh.

HoTo

o6ulecTBa,

ponh

uaxpovogenr o6urtno

npeAcTaeT

coBo-.veHibr; i.rerano'lr4c

06pa3oBaHhe

npaKT'lqecKn

aTorTLr9cKoe.

e[Ba cTpyKTypt4poBaHHoe

,.noroKaMH

ioBapoB,

HHcbopMaqrh h

ycnyr"

(A.

SpaH-

uh)

. TeMa

rorai5'ro; tlleTpononHH

qpe3Bbr'rafiHo qacTo

Bo3HhKaer

trr3e;depcKoi.

nHTeparype !4

flpoeKTHo;

npaKTHKe

80-x roAoe,

oAHaKo caMa

MeTponon[F

pac-

cMaTp!rBaercfi

o65tvro

iH60

yMo3phreJrbHo,

KaK

HeKhi

r4AeanbHbri

o6!eK'

rxors

r. cyrqecrByroull4l,i

peanhHo,

AocrynHbr;

B@rp;lFrHro nHuJb B cBorx

dpaTMeHfax

|4 3QSeKTax)

r-1;160 ariarroT'lqecKLl. BMecTe

TeM

o.ql,aH

peajlbHbli

o6pa3eU Bce xe KoqyeT v3 crarhv

B cTaTbrc.

3ro

Toryo,

a raK><e

FnoHha

ueroM,

rAe,6laroAapn

ocTpoBHoMy

cyul€ciBoBaHr{ro,

oKa3anca B03MoxeH

no,{TH

,rHcrbri

3dOeKT ToIanbHoi

l,tc K

ycc

rBeH Holi

cpe-

Abr,

6naaoAapa HHOopMaqxoHHoMy

r,4 TexHonoTuLte.

cKoMy nhAepcrBy

crp?Hbr M HeBepoFTHoi npeAnphH14-

MaTenbcKoi

ee aKTljBHocTr4

36SeKT'nynbcaqrln 3Toi

cpeabr B

pexhMe

oaHTa3MaTHK!.r,

ecrb nocToaHHorc

q3MeHeHrF

o6nLrKa. TeKy,{ecB4,

3SeMepHocrl4

yp6aHl4-

crl,,lqecKrlx uer

ao6pa:o

aar

r.ri,

Koropbte

cpaBH14Ba|or

oaHoBpeMeHHo

H c 3a3epKanbeM, l4 c

orpoMHbtM

Top-

roablM

3anoM

LUOy.3anoM.

Hectrorps

npeAcraa!areJrbHocrb

nepeqhcfleH-

Hbtx

Bbrure

o6-beKToa

AnF

Uloy-Aq3aiHa,

6utro 6rt

our6Koi

cBoahrb

ero TorbKo K HeKoeMy

06beKTHoMy

KOMnneKCy?

nocKonbKy

noHarHe uoy-al,l3aiHa

06o3Ha-

qaer

raKxe,

Moxer

6brrb, h

nepByro

oi.iepeAb, xaHp

n crun6

au3aiuepcKoro

npoe<TrpoBauun. 6oree

roro,

hcnonb3yF repMhHonornrc

Sapra

[2] .

r.aoxno

ynoAo6r4Tb

Lroy-Al43aiH

TperheMy

no cqery runy

,,nficbMa

ycTophqecKoM

cTaHoBneHMq

av3ai4Ha

nocne

npoMbtuneHHot'o

Aq3aiHa,

TraBeHcrBytoulefo

rlHAycrpkanbHyro

3noxy,

h apr-A,fiai'1a,

nt4lepa

nepexoAHoro

nep!ioIa

aHTrMoAepHHcrcKoro

6VHTapcr-

Ba. KaK r.r

ABa ApYrr,1x

l,ina npoeKTHolo

,,nucbMa",

LJoy-ax3afH npeanonaraer

cneq!4SfiqecKyro

{opuy

ar-

raxhpoBaHHocrll

Jloc,t nv

,,Moparb

dopMbr",

no on-

peAerleHrrc

Toro xe 6apra,

Ecnu

eroc npoMbtuJneHHoro

au3aiHa

3q)KArncF

Ha npuHuhne o6leKTuBHoi

h roru'

,iecKx

Bepu$qql4pyeMoi,

pauuoHanbHoi, nore3Hoi

cBF3tl c o6ulecrBoM,

a 3Toc apr-Ah3atHa

Kpenlnc8

|4c'

noBeaaHueM

vHxBepcanbHocrt4

Bceraa opxThHanbHot

HenoBTool4Moil

rBop,{ecKoi l4HTeHql411,

crHpatoqel4

rpaHb Mexay npoeKThpoaaHl4eM

fi norpe6neHheM,

cBF-

3r c o6uiecrBoM,6ecnonesHoi

npaKT['{ecKU,

Ho aBra-

rcu.teicF taHcrpyMeHToM

KynbryporBopvecroi lrxrqla-

ur4r4

3Toro o6qecrBa,

,,Mopanb

+opMb('

uoY'au3ai-

Ha 3aaaeTcn npheMaMh

TunHoTl4qecKoi eopox6ut

u ver'

rco

paccvurauxoi pex[ccypbr

aeicrgeHHoro

BoBreqe-

Hl4F 3pkrena-norpe6fiTena

B 3aayMaHHbti

cqeHapui

3a'

BeaoMo

paq[oHanhHor4

l4rpbl Ha rppaquoHanbHblx

acp-

deKTax,

npheMaMri

veanvvt,tqHocrv

{eo

Bcex cMbtcnax

3TOrO CnOBa

14 B 3HaqeHhX

,,MeN

a",,1 I

3HaqeHrltt

,.Mea|,yM")

. HaKoHeq,

Luoy-Ah3aiH, noao6Ho

npo-

MbrL!neHHoMY E apT-AX3aiHy, BhrABhraef

co6cTBeHHble

np14opl.lTeTHbte o6]eKTbt.

Ecnu

ann

npoMblt!tleHHoTo

Al43aiHa

raK!aM

o6]eKroM

6ctlo

r'aaccoeoe, TexH14qecKl,

cnoxHoe u3aenxe, cKpoMHbri cnyla o6leKTvBHblx

norpe6Hocrei !enoBeKa, a

anF

apr-Av3aiHa

yH,lKanb-

HOe, 3KCTpaBaraHTHOe

U3AenUe, nO,1T14 My3etHaF Beulb,

c14MBOn

HeO6-beKTt4Bl,tpyeMhrx collt4oKynhrypHbtx

qeH-

Hocre; n noBeoeHHhri

HenoBToo14Moi

qenoBeqecKoi

cy6reK Tri BHocrr4, To

afln

uloy-at13aiHa ero

gequ

ca-

MOM

L!l4pOKOM

CVU|Cre)

MaCCOBOe U He

KaAb-

Haa, Ho,,ny6rL1qHaF".

CorracHo 6apry,

rrn

,.nucbMa"

npeanojlaraer

BnoiHe onpeAeneHHbre npeacraBneHlaa o

$opue

r co-

aepxaHhl4,

cMcTeMy

ycnoBHocTel4.

TexHli{ecK e

np[e.

ML,t. To

ecr6, no

6onuruotr,ty cqery. onpeaeneHHyro

3cre-

TxKy,

Scfer[Ka

uoy-ax3aiHa

3ro 3creruKa

llloy B

co6crBeHHoM cMbtcI]e, MaccoBoro 3penlaula B

3noxy

MaccoBbrx KoMMyHhKaqfi

B cBoeM

KoHueHTplrpoBaHHoM BhAe raKaa 3cre-

rxKa cKraabtBaercn, ecnta

o6parvrbca

K ee

Hah6onee

q14cTr,rM,

cqeHhqecKkM npoFBneHFFM,

l,i3 KapHaBanb-

Hoi,

npa3AHla,]H0-6e3AyMHoi

Mr,rmypHocrl,l,

AnF

Koro-

poi

xapaKTepHa ocna6neHHocr6

nph'{14HHo-creacrBeH-

Hbtx cBE3ei, 3aMeHFeMbrx napaAoM TproKoB l,1 arrpaK-

tll4oHoB, noaaHHhrx

KpynHo !1

pa3MauhcTo,

r,13

coqera-

Hha TexHonorl,'{ecKori l43oupeHHocT14 h

.,neuepHoh

npuMur14BHocr14,ryBcrB",,,3d$eKTHocru,

orFro-

uleHHoi cMbtcnoM, fi afpecc14BHoto

KoKeTcTBa", 3anhc-

Horo

ocrpFqecrBa, opuruHaflbHlrqaHbn

h 6aHanhHocr14,

,.KoKTeirF

dapca

u rhHbona.

KouMapa h

ryanb-

Horo

06paAa",,,$eeprr neorouvareJrbHbrx

npeBpaule-

Hl4i"

oAHhM

cnoBoM, lro

,,Beceno

hcKpr4BreHHbri

Ml4p, l4Ml4Tl4pyrou-ll4i

co6crseHHoe 6e3yMl.4e", oAHaKo

aenalou.lt4t

gro

c npLlBKycoM Khrqa, xaJrrypbr

ayueB'

Hoi ennocrv. Taroi

,,nepeuttaveHHhri

Mup,

apa3Hf.

ulni HenpaBAonoAo6[eM 14 Hapo'{r4Tocr6ro,

no3Bonaer

nto6oi

hsno[4 r onpaBAbraaer nrc6yrc

npereHuro3-

nocru"

[10]

HerpyaHo

3aMer[rb,

qro

npecnoByrbri

,,nycroi

SopMa']h3M",

MaHbepr3M, 3K3anbraqra ocrporo xec-

Ta.,

,,o6pa3HaF

ncrepnq' u r. n., BocnprHhMarculhecFl

KaK

,,ceM

horhqecK ui, wyu", FBnFlorcF B 3To; ocrerx-

'{ecKoi

cr4cTeMe BnonHe

oco3HaHHb:M,

npl,eMaMl4 no-

crpoeHuF

SopMbr,6oflee

roro. npueMaMu,

o6na[arcu

6e:ycloeroi ceMaHTttqecKoi nnorHocrbro

no-

npaH[eM.

Ho Bbrpa)KeHrleM

onpeAeneHHoro

cMbrcna. rl

BbtacHeHhe Toro, B

qeM

xe cocTohT 3ToT cMbtcr, Mo-

xeT, KaK

KaxeTcF, nponuTh

cBeT Ha

cMblcn Bcet

,,ae-

xaAerrcxoi"

nocrMoAepHhcrcKoi,

cvry a\uv.

C oaroi

croponut.

gro,

6e3ycrbBHo,

3crerh're-

crcni,

raoprecrri

n npoercrnuti cMbrcr.

BcnoMHrlM,

9TO

BCa

3nonefl aHTllMOAepHu3Ma

A!43aiHe

6blna OAy-

L!eB,leHa 3aaa'{et

allcKpeahTaq14h

oKocTeHeBtllhx

KBa-

314npo$ecchoHanbHbtx

qeHHocTei

TaK

Ha36lBaeMOfO

,.6orbuJoro {xopoLuero)

avsaiHa"

Bo hMa

peaHrlMa'

ur4t1

Mnyrbq4BHocTl4

TBopqecKoTo norcKa

pacuJHpe-

Hhfl

npo6eccHoHanbHoTo

Topx30HTa.

oCyUleCrennnocu

3ro nyreM norpyxeHHF

a,3aiHa

,,peanulyo"

('tu-

Tai

,,MaccoByro")

Kynhrypy:

,Hu3KVe"

xaHpbl,

no-

nynpodeccuoHarbHbre

r npocro

caMoaeFrerhHbre

Sop'

Mbl. Kr4T9 t1 T. n.

B ennrapnou

croe noficKoBoTo

a[3aiHa

3To

,,xoxaet[e

napo4"

aano

uenyto

ceptato

,lHTepecHet-

u.il4x npoeKTHhlx

3KcnephMeHToB

tl npoeKTHblx

npo-

rpaMM:

.,6aHarbHbt

an3ai'{"

,,Artxvt|,r'.tA1'

lVleHAhHx,

,,Heo-Mepqe"

(,.noeuri

roeap") CaHraKbFpbt.

Heonpu-

M,lThB143M

6paHuu,,.l\reMShc"Coltcacca,

naxoneu,

caM

BcenpoHrKalou[i

SeHoMeH

uoy-lx3aiHa

,,pa-

aocrHbrt

cqM6H03 3n

16r

Macc.Kynurov"

[10]

AeMoHcrp!4pytoul!1i

He ronbKo

ycneulHocrh

onpouleHhE

3nnrapHoro

npoeKTHofo aaaHrapaa, npeoaoneBuJero

KOMnTeKC CaMOl,|36paHHOCTl,,r

14 CO6na3H aBTOphTapHOrO

Mr4ccvoHepcrBa,

Ho u 6necrauthi

ycnex

onepaq!4h

BO3BeAeHr4lO,,H|43KOTO"

Xaapa,,,UUZ<Oh"

Kynbrypbl

,iuz<oi"

3crerriKu Ha Onr,tun

,,6onsuroro

AA3aV,Ha".

apyroi

croposut, 3aHlMaFch

lcrert,rqecKo;

pea-

6unutaqnei,,BHe3crerr'{ecKoTo".

otrputeaa

ece tto-

Bbre hcTo']Ht4K14

xr,1Bor,1 Boabt ecrecrBeHHor-o

KytlbTypo-

rBop,iecTBa

(npaBAa.

onephpys

nph

3roM oTBre'{eHHbl'

Kyjlbryporor

qecKhMl,

floHFTr4FMu Mnqa,

apxel{-

na, nplrvrrrea)

norpyxaach B Boabr

,,aHrpononor

qe-

cKoi u3Ha,{arbHocrl,r",

npocnaBnFfi

,,x.nBo/.t

Buranh'

Hbri

xaoc"

qeruocrei,

dopv,

gHa'reriqi

l, cMbrcnoB,

yn14Baflcb

nepcneKTl,Boi

HapparxBHbtx Bo3MoxHocret4

N/.3ahHa

u vAeei KonneKTrlBHoro Boo6paxaeMoro,

pe3BFCh

B nnlopar|4cThqHbrx,

3KneKT!4qHbrx,

penFrrB-

HbtxJ

nofl rBaneHTHhrx

BonHax KoMMyHrKauut,

ToBapoB

l4Aeonorvil

npe3upapulero Kpv\epw 14 flepapxuto

Ka-

qecrBa

nocTnHAycTpl,anbHoro MopF,

l4aeonor14 nocr'

uoaepxuctcroi anbrepHarhBbt 14,.HoBoro

peanr3Ma"

BbtKa3a'|h h3aecrHyro

nauanocru

(ne

6y4eM

yrny6nFTb-

ca B Bonpoc, HacKonbKo

Bceraa n14

3To 3a6nyxaeH e

6utao

4o6pocoaecrHbtM)

orHocl,lTerlbHo

MexaHtaKh

caMo-

aBhxeHEn

14 cMbtcnoo6pa30BaHnf,

Bo>KAeneHHoi

cnoH_

TaHHot,

HcKaxeHnoi

yrutnoi pe$nercuei,,,

u zayunoh

MeprBe,{uHoi coqranbHoro

A!i3aiHa

KynbrypHoi

Aeicr-

BrrenbHocrlr.

C l4seecrHoi HarFxKoi 3aecb

MoxHo

6br'

no 6hr npoBecr[ aHanornp c crryaqlrei

Sh3rKoB,

Koro.

pbte,

IB14xr4Mbre

6ecxopsrcTr'rori cTpacThlo

K no3HaHhrc,

co3aanra

aroMHyro

6oM6y, Ha Koropyro

ryr xe HauJrl4cb

TOnnbr

BnonHe KopbrcTHbtx npereHAeHToB. tlHbtMl,r

cro-

BaM[, Bbt6paBurcb Ha

aexaeoroTt43l4poBaHHoe

nnaTo

nocrhHAycrpdanhHot

cucTeMbr

14 xaAHo

EAbrxaF

Bonb-

Hhrt

Bo3Ayx

nrrcpanh3Ma,

nepBonpoxoAUbr,,HoBoTo

pean'l3Ma"

,,ropFqero Au3ai,Ha"

3aMerunh,

'{To

BAhfxaET

BecenFul[i

ra3,

o6naAaloqvi

ecnu a Be

HepBHo.napanurriqecKl,M, To nc14xorponHbrM

AeicrB14-

eM. 14 ecntl

TaKue rrlraHTbt,

KaK Corrcacc, B

nphHq[ne

o6raAanq

Aocraro,{Ho,

reoprecroi uoulurc,

qto6ur.

aAanrupyFcb

peanbHocr14

(..cevuorrvecroi

nutnuroi

6ype")

coxpaHFrb 3a co6oi npaao

rpaBecrupoBa-

Hl4e

peanbHocTr,l

onno3hLt[ro el4, To ocHoBHaF

Macca

An3a;HepcKoi

MonoAex14,

plrHyBUel4cF

HuMt1,

cAa-

rtacb Ha Ml4nocr6

flobeAl,fenF

Afi3arH

npeBparqn-