generally not much liked, as it is seen as somehow unnatural: people speaking without a
regional accent are judged cold, distant and to some extent also as show-offs. On the
other hand, regionally accented Italian elicits a more negative evaluation from a
socioeconomic point of view but a more positive one in personality terms: people
speaking it are viewed as less affected and more friendly. This positive evaluation,
however, tends to decrease with a marked increase of dialectal traits in the regional
variety.
Within these general tendencies, striking differences occur among the various regions.
In particular, southern varieties enjoy lower prestige than the northern or central ones,
and the Florentine variety has definitely lost the privileged status it enjoyed in the past.
The following are some of the most important results from several detailed studies using
both direct questioning and indirect techniques (for example, matched-guise tests, where
judgements on language are elicited by asking for judgements on the actual speakers).
While Milanese people associate a Sicilian accent with low socioeconomic and
educational levels only, Venetians give it a negative evaluation also in personality terms,
as they consider speakers with a Venetian accent more likeable and reliable than those
with a Sicilian accent. Interestingly, this prejudice is also found among Sicilians
themselves, from both the socioeconomic and personal points of view, as Sicilians living
in Padua consider speakers with a Venetian accent to be more educated, more successful,
more beautiful and richer than they themselves are, thus showing a general low self-
image. An even lower self-image is shown by Sicilians living in Sicily, who give
Venetians more positive judgements on the socio-economic level than the ones expressed
by their co-regionals residing in the Veneto. Like the Milanese, Romans and Florentines
also generally claim to prefer their own accent most of all and to wish it for their children
as well; in particular, the Milanese variety enjoys high prestige, given that even the
Florentines opt for it as their second preferred one. The Florentine accent, although it is
never the preferred one outside Tuscany, still retains some prestige, as it is the second
preferred accent by both Milanese and Roman people; on the other hand, the Florentines
do not reciprocate the favour to the Romans, as a Roman accent is not much liked in
Florence.
With regard to dialects, negative attitudes towards them tend to become stronger in
connection with women. In fact, women are both harsher judges of the dialects than the
men, and targets of harsher judgements when they speak them themselves. Furthermore,
certain regional groups stigmatize their own dialect more than others do; for example, the
Sicilians seem to favour their own dialect least. As well as gender and region, other
variables have been investigated such as age, level of education, and socioeconomic
status. A comparison between younger and older Venetians of similar socioeconomic
background, for example, shows major differences in their perception of their own
dialect, with the older group displaying much more favourable attitudes towards it, to the
preference even of locally accented Italian. In Sicily, on the other hand, the younger the
age of the people expressing their attitudes, the milder appear their reactions in terms of
both the directions of maximum dislike and maximum favour of dialect. Furthermore, the
most severe judgements on the dialect are expressed by older women, with limited
education, living in smaller towns.
See also: dialects; Italian language; Italian phonology; varieties of Italian
Encyclopedia of contemporary italian culture 448