Дизайн на западе (сборник)

fw

afiu

]t|ocrml992

Argaix

xa

3anaas

MrH14crepcrBo

HayKu,

Bblcuei

ulKonbl

14

TexHl4qecKoi

nor]4TxKH

Pocglicroi <DeAepauur

BcepoccxicKhfi

HayqHo{lccneAoBaTenbcKri

t4HcTxrvr

rexxuqecxoi

gcreruru

,,

Eu6lr

orera

au3llineoa,,

Fnaexuri

pe4arrop:

fl .A.

Ky3bMhqea,

KaHArAar

l4cKyccrBoaeAeHra

PeAaKuroHHaF

Konrerra

:

O.[4. Fextcapercrcufi,

AoKTop

r4cKyccrBoBeAeHrF

C.tl.

CepoB,

KaHAxAar

rcKyccrBoBeAeSxF

B.O.

CrAopeHKo,

AoKTop

l,icKyccrBoBeaeHxa

E.B.

qepHeBt,|q,

KaHAhAar

ucKyccrBoBeAeHxF

A.n. EpMonaeB

Brrpa

ax4 Fepr

H.B. KrcroBa

3noxa

teo6apoxro

h.B. KoKKUHaKla

My3i

Ar.t3eiH8

B noflAoHe

B,F.

Kpuveecxri

florroarre

napru

HlAepaaraoa

MapK,

rorJraHAcxoro

algaifl

I

T. f.

KypbepoBa

,,tlto

Bnepeax?"

M.A. TuMo+eeBa

Oer{oMeH

cKaHIxHaBcKoro

A]{3aiHa

KoHqa

80.x

roaoB:

lronbrrKa

,Hrep[peraqrx

10.B.

TxMo+eeBa

,,Hoeoe

ceaepxoe ncxyccrao".

Bneraraexle

E.B,

t{epHeat,t,{

Cxra4

yua

xeue{xoro

angaixa

18

23

47

67

78

82

Mocxaa.-1992

v

AK

745.02

\-e7

|

,,6v6nno1

eKa

AVsai,He

pa"

Cepra,,3apy6exru i4

ansai4tr"

Peaarqroxnuri coBer

cephla :

O.14.

EeHrlcapercKlai,

B.@. Cr4.qopeHro,

E.B.

OlaoplHa,

E.B.

qepHeBrq

PeAaKTopcocraBhrenb E.B.

t{epHeBrq

PeqeH3€Hrbr E.B, Acc, 10.f. Fxe.qKoe

Peaarroprr T.A.

ApefioBa, C.14.

5e3tf,3br,{HaF

Trnorpag B.

F, Kprveecrcri

Texrllqecrlri

peAaKTop

E.A. fl

ocesa

Kopperrop l\il,3. KoLuenr

tlcro'iHl4K,,

4oroqrrar

:

Abitare. 1990. N

288

Architectural

Journal. 1 989.

N

16, august

The

Architecture

of

Frank

Gehry.

N. Y.,

1986

Form.

Function.

Fintand.

1989.

N 1,3.

Heiiastu ksia

suomesta.

Helsinki,

1981

HoBoe ceBepHoe

hcKyccrao: Karanor

BErcraBKq

e MocKee. 31.05-30.06.90.

Viborg

(Denmark),

1990

ArsaiH

aa

3anaae

gH'1MrO,1992,

c. 1-96

flo4n.

r neraru

01.06.92

Oopr,tar

60x90/8

6yr,rara

o$ceruan

Yq.-rsa.

n. 13,0

3a<as 38

Tupax

450

era.

Llera

goroeopran

Orne,raraHo

e

Sorononrrpa$u,recroru

qerrpe

BH

14t4T3

129223, Mocrcea, BBI-1,

Kopn. 115

Bcepoccricrri

Hay'{H

o-r-iccreAoBarenbcK14 i hHcrr4Tyr

TexHugecKoi

3creTl4Krl

(BH14r4T3).

1992

Ecn!4 Bbr, !HTarenb,3Haere |an|4, no KpaiHef

Me-

pe,

AoraAbrBaerecb,

,rro

,,+npMeHHbri

ToBap'i, 3anecr-

peBulrli

Ha noTKax, 6oiKo

pacnonoxrBuruxca

Ha

Ha-

ujxx

yltr4uax,

aaeT

o'reHb npeEpaTBoe flpeAcTaBteH[e

o

3anaAHoM

AusaUHe

I

u ecnh

Bbr He

pa3AenaeTe

Bce

6onee

pacnpocrpaHF|ou.lytoca

hAeonorulo Henpo+ec-

c{oHaI{3Ma

l.| He HaMepeHbr

aoBonbclBoBaTbca

oaHx-

M|4

ynpoqeHuFMx,

To Mhr, aBTopbr 3Toro c6opHi,lKa,

nl4canu

ero

anF

Bac-

AaneKas

x He 3aBficnUlaE

or

Hac xr.r3Hb 3apy6ex-

HOrO

A[3atHa

He

nepecTaeT, TeM He MeHee, Bbr3hrBaTb

HauJe 3a[HTepecoBaHHoe K Hei

orHoureHue.

Mhr He Mo-

xeM

oTKa3aTb ce6e B co6na3le HMeTb cBoe MHeHle

h

o

ToM. 9f0 He

aoBelocb

BIAeTb cBor4Ml4 fna3av[, v

Aaxe

Bbrpa6oranrr

HaBbrK

norpyxarbcn

B

penpoAyKqn!l

KaK a

peanbHble

npocTpaHcTBa h Bocflpr4HuMaTb KaK

AeicTB[TenbHyto,

no cyTx

AeIa,

Bbt'{l,tTaHHyto KapT14Hy

lu3arrHa.

3ror c6opnnx nocBau.leH coBpeMeHHoMy

3apy-

6exHoMy

ata3aiHy

x

aaer

npeacraBrreHue

o

Hax6onee

xHTepecHbrx

xyaoxecTBeHHbtx

ta 4HrenJteKTyaIbHbtx

co6brrtaax reKyqei xr3Hr

npo$ecchn. OH HanucaH

TeMl,, KTO

CneU!1aIbH0 3aH14MaeTcF r4ccneloBaHxeM

3a-

py6exHoro

tn3ai,Ha

v

He

paBHoAyueH

K cBoeMy npea-

MeTy. Hac He TaK

MHoro, no3ToMy KapTyHa

A[3aiHa

npeAcraBneHa 3Aecb

SparMeHTapno.

0ry

$parverrap-

HOCTb

Mbr OT9aCTX

AaXe

noAqepKHyn[,

pacnonoxxB

crarbu no an+aBhry

Hant!caBUlltx l4x aBTopoB.

Bac oxrAaer 3HaKoMcrBo

c npoeKTHoi Kynhry'

poi py6exa

80-90-x roAoB,

BocnpuH4Maroqei cBoe

cocToFH[e

KaK Kpl43r4cHoe ri HecTa6ulbHoe

14

yxe

nepe-

xrlBalouei cnHApoM

,.Koiqa

eera"; Bauevy

enrva-

Huro 6yqyr

npeAnoxeHbr:

o6sop

paspa6orannoi

Ot',la-

poM

Kana6pe3e KoHqenuu[

Heo6apoKKo,

BbtrBnarc-

qei

Ha'|6onee

xapaKlepHbre

np[3HaKh

,,BKyca

Hauei

3noxh"; aHarx3 nepuneruh

hrarbFHcKoi

Afi3aiHep.

cKoi Mbrcfll4,

o6Hapyx<hBuei

ycranocrb

x npechtuleH-

Hocrb coBpeMeHHoi

ersyanrHoi

Kyjlbryp6t; r4ccneAo-

BaHXe

ronIaHAcKoi

noqrogoi MapKn,

a no cyTt4

-

MeH-

TaJruTeTa .oflnaHAcKoi

Kynbrypbt;

oqepK xapaKTep-

Hbrx cpxeToB,

pa3ht

fpblBaeMbtx

Ha

ax3aiH-cqeHe

Tep-

MaHUU:

a TaKXe

ll49Hbte BneqaTneHhf

o HoBoM ulaea-

cKoM

ricKyccrBe,

o ,loHAoHcKoM

My3ee,qu3aiHa

h

06

apxureKType

Opox<a

Fepu.

o

A,fl.

Epvonaee

Bnrpa er4

f epr,i

ya[BhrenbHo...

Tur

enepeure

eleuJb Ha

3anaA, B

CtIA, |,MeHHo rVAa,

rae

pa6oraer

qenoEeK,

TBopqecrBo

Koroporo rbr

yc14JreHHo

nponaraHAhpyeLUb

60nee 15 ner

cpeax

cryaeHToB.

Konrea,

apy3ei.

Buauulu eTo no-

crpoiK|,l, e[o o$uc, ero

caMoro, apxureKrtpHyto

u.lKo'

ny,

peanh3Ytou.lyto

rBopqecKue npqHqhnhr MacTepa.

Bo3BpaulaeLubcF

-

14

Ha KaxaoM Ulary Bcrpe'{a'

eLUb ny6ruKaq/ o HeM.

B BV3e 3areBaeub co

cryAeHTaMr h3yqeHre

Mero-

aoe

ero

pa6orgr,

l,r B 3To xe BpeMn

y

HLlx noFBnFercF

cqacTruBaF Bo3Mor<Hocrb

yqacTBoBaTb

B apxl4reKTyp-

HoM KoHKypce RIBA

(KoponeBcKoTo

o6utecrBa

6pn-

TaHcKrx apxhreKTopoe) na

renty

,.1\,4oHyMeHT

ta

KoHT-

panyHKT".

cnpoeKTlpoBaB 3aaH e

My3eF nlo6llMoro

xyaoxHxKa B Bbt6paHHoi

arF

3Toro

cpeae.

HaKoHeu, re6e npeAlarapr BbrcKa3arb caol,| co-

o6paxeuan o

er-o HeaaBBet nocrpoiKe B EBpone, o ero

OTHOLll CH'1F X C

AI,I3A;HOM.

Ho

aoBonbHo

l4HTpxroaarb

-

pequ

aaer o6

arre.

p[KaHqe

Op3HKe Fepu

r

ero My:ee ve6enu

4na

$rp.

Mbr KoHropcKoi nae6enu,.Brrpa"

{Vitra

lMijbel)...

KaK Bce-TaKx xopolJo,

'rro

oAHaxAbr

3aHecno re-

6F B

Ah3aiHl

3To

crpauHo

-

ocraBarhcF B

KaKoi-r14-

60 cneu an|,3r,rpoBaHHoi c$epe: apx|4TeKType, xhBonl,t-

cx, cKynbnrype, KxHo. HayKe. nrreparype,

Ah3aiH

aaeT

Bo3MoxHocTb Bbtxoar4Tb

3a

paMK14.

3a

rpaHlLlbt,

hMeHHO B HeM

AaBHO

yxe

npOqCXOArlT

BCe

Xl4BOe ap-

xyTeKTypHoe,

xhBonlcHoe, HayqHoe, nfiTepaTypHoe,

floxoxe,

,{ro

ar3afiHepcKoe

npoeKTHoe MbrulreHtle B

nlo60; cdepe

raoprecxori

aKTrlBHocrr.l vetoBeKa

c006-

utaer ei B KaxAoM aKTe cBexecrb

ou.lyuleH

t, HoBl43-

Hy

BneqaTneHht,

HeTp

BIanbHocTb

,t

oaHoBpeMeHHo

ecTecTBeHHocrh

pean|/13aqHi,

nocTynKoB.

BoKpyr

a4-

3atHa

TBOpHTCF

TaK MHOTO r4HTepeCHOfO;

OH

-

14 BbtCO-

KaF

TexHonoal4F, a o6aaxeguaa

r]yBcrBl4reflbHocrb

xai-Taqa; oH

-

!4 MHoroclo;Hbte

npoeKTHbte nporpaM-

Mbr

nepeycrpoicrBa

c6ep

AeFTenbHocT6,

u

o$opMh-

TeIlbcKhe,,uaHcbr'- 14HTepbepoB

ToproBbrx

ueHTpoB;

ocrpoyMHeilrlas

Ah3aiH-rpa+uKa

-

r rrutura v6ra$r-

314K14 coBpeMeHHoi

yrrlqHoi

Ar3aiH-cKynbnrypbt.

My3ei Me6enta,

orxpurruri B HoF6pe 1989 roaa

6nh3

HeMeqKoro

ropoAKa

Baina-Ha-Per;He,9To Ha rpa-

Haqe

co LIBe;qaprei,

e

parioue

6a3enF,

-

oAHo t43

ra.

Kr,lx

iiyAec

AV3ahHa

Ha cTErKe c apxhTeKTypoi,

cKynhn-

rypoi,

ucropheri,

dunoco$nei.

dl.

5

:

E

My3ei

coAepxhr

rnaBHblM

06pa3oM

KotlneKq,4to

crvncee, coeaannirx

Ha'irHaF

c 1850

rona.

-

6onee

12OO 3KcnoHaroB.

Kornerqlra

co6pana

PolbooM

oenh-

6ayvor,a.

enaaenuqeM

ceMeiHoro

npeanplaf,Tfia,,Bur-

pa".

,[o

1976

Toaa,

Ao

aKT[BHoro

norpyxeHuF

B npea'

nprHlaMarenbcKyro

aeFTenbHocrb,

Oenb6ayM

pa6oran

B

pa3ru'{Hbrx

cdepax

Kynbrypbt,

6blr

peaaKTopoM Ha re'

neat

ae{uv,l43aareneM,

y'{[ncF

couronoll,u.

Ero

npea-

npuHhMaTenbcKaF

+!4rocosl,,|a

3aKn|o'{aeTca

B opl4eHTa'

ul,lu

Ha nrcaei c

poacTBeHHhlM

eMy oTHouleH4eM

K

arl'

sainy. Cau

Ax3aiH

oenb6ayM

noH[Maer

KaK

aeFTeflh'

Hocrb, npoayqlrpyloulylo

14HHoBaq|,|,.

14HHoBaqlaoHHoe

Mbrr!fleHl4e, no ero

MHeHrlo,

-

ocHoBa

ar3aiHa,

ocHoBa

BcFKoro

pa3B|,rha.

[lo3ToMy

1,1 My3ei,

nonHbti

3Kcno-

Haroa, 6ureurx

B cBoe BpeMa

npoayKraM[

cMenblx

3KCNEPTMEHTOB,

NOMABU}1X

NPCACTABIICH14F

O

TOM'

,,'rTo

TaKoe

xopotiJo

x

'{To

TaKoe

flnoxo'r, oH

pa3Mecr4tl

He B Cpeae

ropoaa,

'{To

Ka3anocb

6bl ecrecTaeHHblM,

a

Ha

orpMe,

BHyrpu

caMofo

npoh3BoacTBa,

-

3Kcno3!'1-

uxF,

3aaH|/|e

My3eF co3aarcr

Ana

coTpyaH14KoB

QxpMbl

arvoc$epy

nocToFHHoro

nol4cKa,

x!4Boro

rBop'{ecTaa.

Opuruxaruro

x

Vitra

Edition- cBoeo6pa3Hoe

,,143AaTerbcrBo",

npo!l3BoaFU]ee

B eahHcTBeHHOM

q14C-

re unr ManblMrl

ceplaMh

3KcnepuMeHTanbHble

npoeK_

Tbr cTynbeB

aBaHrapa[cToB

caMhlx

pa3Hblx

HanpaBne-

Hhi,

,,F

Bocxrru{apcb

,qu3aiHepaMx,

-

roBopl4T

oenh'

6ayM,

-

MeHa uHrepecyET

TauaHrnfiBEle

ntoA|,.

(tl3aa'

TenbcrBo)

-

vHcrpyMeHT

anf

coBMecrHoi

pa6orbl

c

Ia'

<ruu rroaur,ar"*.

l'lpeanpurttrr"larens,

peantl3ytou.ll4i

ce6F, B

VH[coH

c aBaHrapAHbtM

ar43aiHoM,

KaK xyAox-

Hr,,rK, cpoaHr/

ceroaHFLuHeMy

MHOTOCnOxHOMy,

MO6Unb'

HOMy,

nntopanucrt4qHoMy,

npoT14BopequBoMy

Ml1py.

,,flnrcpanrgu"

-

rnaBHaF

iapa<rcprcru<a

eroro

pe'a-

Horo.

+paaMeHTapHoro

Mhpa, a

,.aM6

BaneHTHocrb".

,,ABoicrBeHHocrb"

-

Knrc'{eBbte

Ana

eTo ocMblcneHuF

cnoBa.

floxsrno,

qro

anF

co3aaHtaF

My3ea,

3aayMaHHoro

KaK

FpqaiL!aF

HHHoBaqrF,

Oenu6ayt'a

Aonxett

6utn

norrnachTb

h BecbMa op14rHHaflbHoro

npoeKT!lpoBUlk'

Ka

-

xvAoxHhKa,

ar3a;Hepa.

To, vro eut6op

nar Ha

Ka'

nlrdopuricroro

,,reBaKa"

OpsHKa

Tep

,

6blno, npaB'

aa.

c'ly,{aiHocrbro,

Ho cnyqaiHocrbto

cqacrnvBoi.

Tep!4

noMoran

cBoeMy

apyfy.

aMephKaHcKoMy

cKynbnTopy

Kracy Orsaeu6ypry.

craBfirb cKyn6nrypy

HeAaneKo or

,,Burpblr'..TaM

oH r no3HaKoMr.'1tcF

c

ee BtlaaerbqeM.

Pe3vnhraroM 3HaKoMcrBa cHaqana

FBunacb

npacrpoliKa

HoBoro

Kphrra x

$a6prre

c

aByME

xapaKTepHblMt4

nnacrx'{ecKuMrr,,Bbr6pocaMh"

HaBcrpeqy 6yayueMy

My3eFO. a

3aTeM 14 CaMO 3AaHHe

My3eA.

*

Suche

nach

dem

Authentischen...

//Form.

1989.

N 12?.

s. 38.

:

a

I

:

B ror'a, vro

cyAb6a cBera

KynbrypHoro,

xHTennx-

relrxoro

Oenu6ayr,aa

x

AxKoro,

HenpeAcKa3yeMoro

Te-

pr1

MoxHo

BlAerb

Bert,lKyxl 3aKoHoMepHocrb.

CxM6x03

rpainei

oprautsoBaHHocrx,

ylatoi

oxonor,auru,

npe4-

np{Hr4MareJtbcrBa

rar

o6pasa

xh3Hn, KaK

Mxpogo3-

3peH|la h

TBop,{ecKoi

aHapxu|/.,

Ayxa

HoBlr3Hbt,

3Kc-

nepxMeHTa

ri ecTh

ToT nyTh,

no KoTopoMy

aBuxeTcF

ce-

roAHa

Ahsaix.

Bcrpeva

4eyx

aHeulHe

pa3nuqHbtx

nrc-

Aei,

3aHuMaou.lrlxcF

npooeccxoHanbHo

pa3HbtMr

Ae-

naMr,

Ho,

B cyulHocTll,

B

paBHot

cTeneHu

coeflhHFlo-

u.{ux,

KaxAbli no-cBoeMy,

aBaHrapA

c rpaArurei,

ero_

nOrUrc

C 3KCnepUMeHTaIhHbtMtt

nOUCKaMl,1,

l.tHHOBaUltK)

c SBonloquohSbtM pa3B4T[eM,

nopoaxj|a

yal,Bl,tTen6_

Hy|o

flocrpotKy.

34aaue uyaea

Aoeoriuto

npocro

B nnaHe: nror-

Han

rpynna

npFMoyrorbHbtx

o6-beMoB,

o6pa3ypqfix

AByxypoBHeabrt

gal

nocroarroi

gKcno3uql414,

3aJl

BpeMeHHbrx

BbtcraBoK,

xpaHhnxqe,

6h6rrioreKy,

He_

crconurco

ra6rxetoa,

aa

np[MbtKaloqlle

K H|4M

ti3BHe

nnacThqHbfe

necTHtt46,

|.JJaxfa,

nu6f,

HaKnoHHbte

ranepek

nepexoAoB,

HaBec

BxoAa. B

o6.beMe xe,

,t

oco6erxo

B HHTepbepax,

My3ei

Bhrpacraer

B

dyHKqho-

HanbHylo

cKynbnrypy,

opraHx30BaHxyro

rrpoi ceo_

6o[Hbrx,

3KcflpecchBHbtx,

Hapoquro

Heapr!,tKyflxpo-

BaHHbrx,

KaK

6bt

HeopraHri3oBaHHbtx

+opM.

Bne,{ar-

fleHre

xhBoi,

HaxoAFqeica

B

ABuxeHr.fl4

cKynbn-

Typbr

co3AarcT

pa3HoypoaHeBbti

non, MHoxecrBeHHbte

yfJtbr

HaKnoHa

nororKa,

MHoroo6pa3Ho

HeoxrAaBHbte

KoHcrpyKtlt4,

BepxHero

cBera.

CoqeTaHxe

npugvAnri_

Bbrx

@opM,

3aAarcqrx

Tonorpa+xlo

3Kcno3uqroHHbtx

npocrpaHcra,

c

pasHo{anpaBneHfibrM14

cBeroBbtMu

nb-

ToKaM{

nprAaeT

ocBeuleHt,||o

My3ea

daHTacr}i,{ecKrl

reoxuAasxuii

3$deKr.

CqeHapxi,

pear|a3yeMbri

My-

aeiroi

srcnoluquei,

xt4BeT

paAoM,

rogHee,

BHyrp!4

opraHu3oBaHHOf

O CAeTOnpOCTDaHCTBa.

f

epr xasur

earcr

apxxreKTopoM-xyAoxHxKoM,

6a-

naHcltpytoul14M

Ha rpaHfi

apxnTeKTypbt

x

xcKyccTBa.

He

no3BoflarcuthM

ce6e

ynacrb

B ry

l4rr4

Apyryrc

cropoHv,

Crapeiultna

aMepuKaHcKoi

apxnrerryprr

Ounln

lxoncon

roeopur

o HeM:

,,Op3HK

yHhKareH

B cBoel4

crpacrlt

,cnonb3oBarb

crpaHHbte

dopvur

r,r

B

vMeHtari

Bhr3brBaTb y

Bac

peaKqxto,

Koropyto

Bbr

oulyulaeTe

KuUJ_

xavu.

Ero 3AaHrF

uJoKxpytoT,

Fto

oHx 3acra8nStoT

Bac

npoH14KHyTbCA

TaIHCTBeHHbtM

rtyBCTBoM

BOCTOpra"

*.

tl[Tarera,

eu4e

re as6anoearloro

6uorpa$ravr

fept,t,

eogNaoxHo,

3axHTepecyer

MrrKpoorepK

o HeM.

PoArnca

Fepra

B 1929 roAy

e Toponro,

e ceruue

noJrbcK,lx

sMhTpaHToB.

Karc

npo+eccuonan

c+opMlapo-

Banca

B

Kyn6TypHoi

arMoc+epe

non-apTa,

B

o6qeH{|4

c

xyAoxHhKaM[

3Toro

HanpaBrreHha.

C K.

OnbAeH6Vp-

roM

cBfl3al

BCX)

CBOIO

TBopqecKyo

xl43Hb.

HaquHan

c

npoeKTxpoBaHt4F

r,iBTepbepoB

Mara3riHoB,

oSxcoB,

Top_

ToBhtx

qeHTpoB.

B

1962

foAy

orKpbtn

co6craeHHvro

KoHTopy

B Kanu+opHvv,

g

Caxra-MoHlarca.

Cei,tac.

nocne

30

neT

6opb6ht

3a

3aKa3bt

t4

yBaxeHre

K

ce6e.oH

uJxpoKo

Bonnou.taer

cBor

npoeKTbt

rar

e ClllA,

rar

u

B EBpone

|4 A3xx.

.trro,

xora

Tepu

BcefAa

roroe

3KcnepuMeHT[poBarb,

eMy

cBoicrBeHHbt

,,yBepeHHocrh r 3peJlocrb

_

Kagecr_

Ba, nd3aonnrculxe

xyAoxHt4Ky,

rca<

sro

6urno c [.lr<ac-

co,

'{yacrBoBarb

ce6F

cB0604HbtM

or Tex

orpaHrqeHxi.

O. fopr.

Kpecro l.t3

c6pl.t3|

,.MFrKrg

rpaHr',,

npeccoBaHHbri

roSpoKtproH.

1970

KOTOpbre

MOtyT

6btTb

pe3ynbTaToM

KaK KptlTt4qecKoTo

BocnpuFTl4ff

ero

pa6or,

TaK

ero

co6crBeHHoro

vcne-

xa".

3a nocle4nue

11

ner npevlto

Iplqxepa

eurcoroe

xloph

nplcyA4no

O|anrny

,IlxoHcoHy,

lZo

Mrrr flep,

flyxcy

EapparaHy,

KeHso

TaHre,

OcKapy

H[Meiepy.

Pa4ou

c nrrun

fep[

-

ayrcaiAep.

6yHrapb,

Bbtcrynarc-

ulhi npolrB

o6ulenpunarrrx

npeAcraBneHli

o KoHcr_

pyKqliax

h

MaTepxanax.

Xrcpla

BbtcoKo

oqeHqno

VHl4-

KanbHyrc

cnoco6Hocrb

Teph,,HaxoAy,rh

BblpaxeHhe

ana

coapeMeHHoro

o6qecTBa

h

ero aM6!4BaneHTHbtx

qeHHocreti"

t,t cpaBHhno

eto

npoeKTbt

c

,,AXa3oM.

Ha-

chrr4eHHbtM

t4MnpoBl43allxFMh

tl xl,abt

[4 HenpeacKa3ye.

vutru

4yxov"**.

An3ai,l

fepu

ornqqaercF

BbrpaxeHHoi

cKvrbn_

rypHocrblo

+opM.

Hapoquro pa3Apo6neHH6te.

o6reMbl

!a fpy6bre,

xeo6pa6olalture

Marep|aa'|bt

-

HeKpauJeHaF

+aHepa,

KpoBenbHaa

apaHKa,

KpoBerbHaF

xecrb

a Ka-

qecTBe

noKpblTtlF

cTeH,

npoBonoqHaF

ceTKa

aIa

3a6ooa

caMbrx

pa3Hbtx

ctpyKTyp

h np,

_

npou3BOAFT

nopaxa_

rourri

3+deKT, yAt4Bt{Terrbso

ro'{Ho

nepeAaBaa

arMoc_

$epy

xla3Hq

_coBpeMeHHoro

ropoAa.

Tepta

npftit4rnu_

aIbHO

HeOpTOrOHaJteH:

y

Heto

HeT

+acaaoB,

oH

TBOptiT

npocTpaHcTBa.

B TOM

gl4cne

h

ToTAa,

KOrAa

CO3AaeT

cBoro

yH[KanbHyto

N4e6ens

us rodpoKaproHa

_

napo-

AUI

Ha TpaAhquoHHbte,

fny6oKue,

MFrKhe

Kpecla.

B

o$rce fepr,r,

B

KoropoM

aBTop

qMen qecrh

no_

6tteats,

larlle

Kpecrla,

Bce

pa3Hbte,

croaT

oKono

Kax-

aoro

pa60gero

cToIa

14 flpeaHa3Ha'{eHbt

aJ|a

noceTlTe-

nei;

B Ka6rHere

M3Tpa,

orAeJteHHoM

or

o6utero 3a'la

ocTeKneHHOt

CTeHOfi,

TaKXX

Kpecen

Tpri,

aa

nflrcc

npoc-

Teiuri pa6oqxi

crofl,

KpoMe

roro,

HecKonbKo

doro

nocTpoeK,

HacTeHHbte

caeTunbHriKl4

B Bxae

3Meh

u

,{e-

penaxl1.

HxKaKux yrorHocreti,

HanoM{Halou{l,tx

o

AoMe,

o Bcrpe9ax

c h3eecrHhtMl,r

nrc4uvr,

o6 o6pasax

as

ger-

craa.

C

pa6ollx

Mecr,

n[uleHHbtx

KaK

6aHanbHo;

c|6_

ycrpoeHHocrt4,

TaK

r Hapogt4loi.

TexHonor4,{Hocft4

14

*

,,

y366

[4.

l4MnpoBu3aqroHHaH

apxhreKlvpa

epgHKa

fe-

pt

llA,uanor-CuA.

1990.

N0

43. C.32.

't*

TaM

xe, c. 30,

31.

}{Hrephep oaHoro

n3

o$rcoB

O.

fepn B Katr+opHrr.

1986

KOMnbrcTepoMaHl,|14,

14 Haq14HaercF

cBoeo6pa3xe

qyBcr'

EOBaHrA,

MbrCnri, xt 3H|4

6topo O.

rep!4.

Pa6o']re

Mecra

B

o6ueM

3are o6o3HaqeHht

HeBhlcoKtiM14 creHKaMu

,13

HaTyparbHoi

+aHepbl

ronql4Hoi 5

cM, ta3HyTpu

Kpa'

ueBHbre

6enrlraMti,

flol a o$rce

loxe

SaHepHblt4,

onopbr

-

cTaJrbHbre

aByTaBpbl,

orpaxaaou.ltle

cTeHbl

-

6erbre, noronoK

o6pa3oBaH

npoercarcueti

BaraMta 6e'

noi xe

creKrorKaHbp,

3aKphlBarculei

ero

HaquHKy,

nohepeqHbre

Hecyqxq

6attKu

reMHbte.aepeBFHHble.

K

Hl,M

nOABeUJeHO

MHOXeCTBO

CTapblX

3anbltleHHblx

Ma-

reroe, lVlarcetst

aeJrator

caMh

npoeKTupoBulxKtl

B

npoqecce

noxcKa

peuieHr,iF.

Cnaqana

re noApyqHoro

,,vycopa"

-

KaproHa,

neHonracra,

6yMarx,

3areM x3

KpaueHoro

aepeBa

Ha

Sanepnoi

ocroee.

Bce ero ta-

xoal,lTca Ha

BTopoM 3Taxe

KrpnlqHoro

gaalua

{rcra-

Tr,.r, caaBaeMoro

eraeu) c

rpaallutioHHoi

ara

fep[ or-

KOhtroi

Meraflrfr,tecKoi necrH!4qei,

creHaMh,

3aulll-

u.leHHbtMn

KpoBerbHbtM

xene3oM,

KtaaKot

143 MerlKo_

6eroHHbri

6noroe.

Kosrtper

Haa BXo[oM, ecrecrBeH-

Ho,

la3

OaHepbt.

Ayrcaiaep OpgHK

Fepu

aaaoeeal,

ruup... KoHeqHo

xe, 3To

3aMeqaTerbHo,

aaeT

noaaepx(Ky

BceM,

KTo

ao

nopbt

Haxoal4Tca

Ha

o6oghHe

ycnexa.

Ho

lae'To 3To l.l

yrpo3a

g!4crore

xaHpa. BMecre c

ycnexoM

|,| npu3HaHt-

eM rcnoaBonb

HapacTaer cTpeMneHve

cooTBeTcrBoBaTb

!1 nopaxarb.

My3ei Me6enu

B Baine,

Aa

l,,| MHoroe

Ao

Hero, KaxeTca

MHe

olqacTlt

nIacTMcKhM

fypMaHcT-

BOM,

raCTpOHOMreti.

He

TaKOB nOCTpOeHHb

i t4M

AnF

ce6F B 1979 roAy

3HaMeHHTbt;

AoM

B CaHTa-MoHr4Ka

-

abr3brBarculee

pa3apaxeH!4e

coceaei cbopyxeHxe

l43

nposrlnhpoBaHHofo

MeTarrna,

ceTqarbtx

cTpyKTyp

q

TOpgaUlxX

CTeKTAHHbtX

3pKepoB,

c

aepeBFHHbtM

cIpoeHueM

BHyTph ce6F.

Ocess 1990 roAa...

AoM

Tepx 3aMeqarenbHo

06-

ne3n,

noTpenaH, 3anhrlreH

-

HacToaull4],

KycoK np[po-

abr;

paaoM

c BxoaoM He

LlBeTyr,

KoHrpacTkpyF c

oK-

pyxaEult4Ml4

aoMaMri,

ropTeH3rl4,

He

BhaHo cTpt4xe-

Hblx KycToB,

Bo3aenaHHbtx

KaKTycoB,

fa3oH

BbtTon-

TaH,

-

Hl4qero raKoro

6orbLle Her

B Kaln$opnur.

Bepuee,

ecrr

oaHo

raKoe

Mecro

-

oKpecrHocrl.r

Car-.Quero: cpeAri

cBepxyxoxeHHoro

npocrpaHcrBa

nonynycTbrpb,

3aecb

B oKpyxeHxu

cepbtx xorrMoB

x

obne3nbrx

AepeBbeB,

Ha

ntocKoi nnardopMe

-

no-

crpoira'1964

roAa

BeJfrKoro Ilyuca

Kaaa,3to

lAuctu.

ryr

AoKropa

Conxa,

nyvutan nocrpoiKa

AMeprKx.

Ceortau

pannuun

rBopeHrrFMl,i

-

[oMoM

s

CaH-

Ta-l\roHqKa,

Bpevennoi

ranepeei

coBpeMeHHoro

hc-

Kyccraa

B floc-AHAXerece,

AercKt4M

My3eeM,

TaM

xe

-

Fepr

paeeraan

sce

6onee

yrny6nnoqyrcca

cerogna

tunnto,,tuxoh",,,MoneanvBoi"

apx[TeKTVpbt,

aHo-

ftr4MHoro,

Mt4Hl,iMan[cTcKoro

ax3aiHa.

l\4y3efi Me6enx

B Baine

-

norpacatoqe

MacrepcKaa

SyHKtl'loHanbHaF

cKynbnTypa

-

c ToqKt4

3peH[F

3TOrO nVT4, MOXeT

6brrb, HecKonbKo

MaHepHbti.

rlcKyccrBeHHhti...

ly' ace xe Fepr

coxpaHaer toHylo

HenocpeAcrBeH-

HOCTb

OTHOUTeHht

C MhpOM:

,,F

Clapatocb

x36aBxTbcfl

or 6peMeHh

Kynbrypbt

,1 t4cKarb

HoBoe

orHoujeHl4e K

TBopqecrBy.

F ne

xovy 6btrb Karerop,l.tH6tM.

He cyqe-

cTByeT

npaBhn, He

cyqecTByeT

npaB[IbHofo

14

Henpa-

Bl4nbHoro.

fl re

vory

cKa3aTh,

qTo

KpacrlBo.

a

'{To

ypoanqgo".

14 eute:

,,Panuute

MHe

Bceraa

xorenocb

cxaTbca,

KoTAa

a npeacTaBnFn

cBol4 nlaHbt

3aKa3qri-

KaM.

Teneph F

npeAcraBflFto

roToBbte

nDoeKTbt

-

h

MHe

anroarlpyroT.

lMre

rcaxelcn 3To

cTpaHHbtM.

fl He

yahBnrccb,

ecnh noTeparc

Bcex cBot4x

KITeHToB 14

MHe

npyaeTcF

HaqaTb

Bce cHaqana"".

Bce

e

urpe

HeoxuaaHHo

cxoaxrcF... Mur

co

cry-

AdHTaMu

Ka+eApbt,,Eu3ai4H

apxrrexryptoi

cpe4sr"

MApx14 uccneAyeM rBopqecrBo

Macrepa,

u3y'raeM

KHr4ry

o OpgHKe Fep[,

]aM noaapeHHyrc, npoeKrlpyeM

ruyseri

fepu

Ha Tpy6Hoi

nnoqaArl, c

yAxBneH!4eM

06-

Hapyxl4B,

9To

3To Mecro MocKBbt

Aa

h,Becb crapbti ro-

poa

B

qenoM

nopa3'lTenbHo

cooTBeTcTByroT cBot Mr/ He-

oqeBl4AHbrM14 crpyKrypaM14,

pl4TMaMx,

$arrypavu

oc-

HOBHbTM

XapaKTepl4crl4KaM

(popMoTBopqecTBa

KaII-

+opH[icKoro

Ax3aiHepa.

Bosnux

eonpoc: KaK

crarb

Fepu?

-

OrasureaercF,

oqeHb npocro. naAo

rolbKo

cMoTpefb

Ha Mhp

oTKpbtTbrMl4

Tna3aMrr. BnycKaTh

ero

B ce6F, a He HaBE3btBaTh

ce6E eMy,

6trtu ucrpetntv,

6btrb r,icroBbtM

-

To

ecrb

orAaaarhcF xu3Hr,1,

pa6ore,

TBopqecTay

a6conrcTHo,

TaK. KaK

3TO

nelaeT

MaCTep.

Cnacr6o euy aa

3Tta

orKpbrllF.

H.B. KlacnoBa

3noxa reo6aporxo

hTaK. Bce

cnoBa

vxe

cKa3aHbt.

lvlbt x BeM a

3noxy

,fcrouleHua,

,,ycTanocru"

asutra. Kro

nepeuti

3aMefhn 3To? Tenepb

He acfloMHl4Tb,

Aa

raK flx

gro

BaxBo

ao BpeMeHa, Koraa

Mhtcfll,1 9t cloBa Tupaxrpy-

torcn

c

ronoBoKpyxhrenhHoi

6urcrporoi

t,l B

Hecrbt-

xaHHb,x MacuJTa6ax,

Bo BpeMeHa ToTanEHoro

u4Trlpo-

BaHtan

aBTOLll,rTt4

pOB

aH t,ra,

OCO3HaHHOTO h 6eCCO3lli],

TeJrbHoro?

CeroAnn, xorAa

HoBoro cnoBa B

qrcroM

Bu-

ae

oxraaTb He npfixoaxrcF,

yaeloM

ryMaHrlrapl,eB,

Ka-,

xeTcF, cTano nriLlrh

x3o6pereHl4e

He6htBanhtx cnoaec-

Hbrx KoM6[HaUxi.

Aaxe

HoBbte,

Ha

nepBbli

B3rraA.

K

ynbTypofiofl,

qec

K4e TepM!|Hbt FBTSKTTCF,

B CyU1HOC.

rv, rv6pv\,aMu

noHar

i,

yxe

anpo6[poBaHHbtx l4cTo-

phel4

KylrbTypbr,

-

[ocTaTogHo

BcnoMHrTb

Bce eule He

cxo4nulri

caBaHcueHbt

Al4cKyccl4i,,nocrMoAepHu3M".

Bonpexr

rnu

6naroAapn

,,ycrartocrv"

croB

(no-

cKonbKy

HeyaoBneTBopeHHocTb

cKa3aHHhtM He [c'{ep-

nbrBaerca, a Bo3pacraer)

caMoaHarq3 3anaAHoi

Kynb-

Tvpbt

He cTaHoBt4Tca

MeHee

rHTeHc BHbtM. K

OTnhgh-

TeflbHblM

OCO6eHHOCTAM eTO HbtHeUJHerO

erana

-

80.x

u, KaK MOXHb

npeAB[AeTb,

90-X |OAOB

-

OTHOCT4TCA

cTpeMneHle

orTonKHvTbcF

oT xopoulo 3a6btTofo

cTa-

poro.

BBoAa e

o6uxo4 nopoi HeoxhAaHHbte

,crop|-

liecKl4e

napanlefl!.i. rlpl4

3ToM craBarcF

noa coMHeH[e

nonHoMoqlrF

TepM Ha

.,nocTMoaepH",

npeTeH,4vroqero

Ha

oKoHqarenbHocrb np[roBopa

HbtHeuJHei

da3e

hcro-

p

ta. KaKoBbr noBoabt

K ero

,,o6xanoBaHhrc"?

nopac-

npocTpaHeHHoMy

MHeHXrc, 3TOT

TepMXH HeyAaqeH XO-

TA 6br noToMy,

qro

aonycKaeT

npeBpaTHoe',TonKoBa-

HUe:

'racTo

B Hefo Heo6ocHoBaHHo

BKna[btBapT

c

M

btcn

orpr4qaHra

3KcneprMeHTa

B ucKyccrBe

l7l

.

BvAuMo,

He noclreAHrcrc

ponh

urpaer

3Aecb h ToT

QaKT,

qTO

B

cBoei crpyKType

repM|,H,,nocrMoAepH"

coAepxriT

HeqTo

npoTr4Bopeqauee

nopoa[BuJefr

ero norrKe. Toi

caMot4 nofrKe, KoTopaa

oTBeprna

,,Lapet4{t

crcKoe"

npeacTaBI|eHxeo

npFMonxHeiHo-nocTynaTeIbHoM,

oa-

Ho3HaqHo.nporpecc

BHoM xoae

uclopt tA u

npl4BneK'|a

sHt,rMaHle

x 6onee

rsou.gperribtM

MoAerFM rpaHc$op-

Maqhl

coquanbHbrx

x KynhrypH6lx

ct4cTeM.

3ra xe no-

rhKa

noAcKa3ana

Heo6xoAhMocrb

pefpocneKTl4BHoro

no{cKa

aHarorhi coBpeMeHHoi

cwyau,uu

-

ct4tyau\vu

Kpt 3t ca v HecTa6I

nbHocTt4. B

pe3ynbTaTe

TaKoro

poaa

norpyxeHkt

B r.rcrophro

noaB14ncF

TepMrH

.,Heo6apoK-

Ko". He6e3ycneuHo

Bbtcrynaou.lrli

ceroAHa B Kalrecr,

Be atbrepHar[Bht

nocrMoaepHx3My

(a

[Horaa

ta

g

ra-

qecrBe

yroqHarculero

AononHeH[a

K HeMy)

.

B

AaHHoi

craTbe Mhr npolnnrccTpt/pyeM

coaepxaHte

3To.o no,

HATUa,

a

TaKXe

npeacraBt4M

HeKoTopbtx

nIAepoB coB-

peMeHHo;

,,6apo<[

oll

pyroulei

"

Mbtcrl4

B

pasrsrx

c$e-

.

pax

xyaoxecTaeHHox

Kyn6ryp6l

,{pyroi

xervranoeaxuoi

oco6ennocrorc Kynbrypo.

norhqecK X

t4 14cKyccTBoBea'{ecKux

TeKcToB

ceroaHa

aBnFercF

onephpoBaHt,le

6pocK14

M14, napaAoKcanbHbtM14

KoM6rHaq14FM14

HecoqeTaeMbtx

c,loB.

por(Aa|oult4

Mu

He-

oaH03HaLtHbre, npoTrlBopeq4Bbte

accotluaqrr.

Tpy4to

npotTl4 Ml,rMo

TaKofo,

cKa)KeM. npri.lyAnhBoro

o6pa3a,

KaK

,,Becellbti

anoKa'luncl4c yH(BepMara".

Ecnu

yHu-

BepMaf

KaK chMBon

BaBIItoHcKofo

cToJtnoTBopeH[a

cnoco6eH

Bb13BaTb

B Bo06paxeHhh

KapT!4Hy

KoHqa cBe-

Ta, TO

qTO

e erov

gecenoro?

B

aanxov

coqeTaHl,h 3Ha-

Y366

M.,

c.38,47.

qeHlre

Tpar4iecKoro

cnoaa KaK

6br npxrnyuJeHo,

Ho

Tpeaora He rcqe3aer:

npx3paK 6-n[3Koi

Karacrposhl

MaaqrT 3a

noBeoxHocTHoi

BecerocTblo

foJlKoTHh

Ha

apMapKe xu3Hr,i... Bnpoveu,

ana

Hac Bce 3To BaxHo,

nocKonbKy

peqb

uaer aoBce

He

o

roproBoM 3aBeaeHu!1,

a o coBpeMeHHoM

l4cKyccrse,

npeacraBJleHHoM

Ha oa'

HoM

r43

caMbtx

npecrrxttuix

xyaoxecrBeHHbtx

Mepo-

npxFTr,ri

M

pa

-

BeHeqlaaHcKoi 6uerxare

t,tcKyccrB

1990'ro4a.

Onucuteaa BbtcraBKy,

+paHqy3cKri

Kpn-

T,|K

O.

l03ep

o6pyrlr,rBa€T

Ha

qllTarenF

KacKaa

scxaro-

,roruqecKtax

Mera+op:,,+plrBorbHaa"

6ueHHane npeA-

no'{l4Taer,,Bece-nbri anoKanl4nc|,|c

yH[BepMara

@yHAa-

MeHTanbHbtM sonpocaM

cnuulKoM

TpeBoxHoro

KoHqa

aeKa.

KoHAxqr,roHrpoearnuri aA

crapbrx

SopManrclla-

gecK|4x

TooKoB

eu.le MoxeT

HanocneaoK co3aarb

tl'|r'lto'

3Lrxl, npeacraB[B onbFHnroulee

Luoy"

[1

1, c.49]

.

Kn!1MarqgecKfie

ycnoara

sroi,,npe!|cnoaHefi"

onpeaenaer

raK Ha3brBaeMoe,,xonoaHoe6apoKKo".

Asrop

AaHHoi,,gnrrpaMMarhgecKoi

neSurutlt|'t"

-

xranbFHcKl4i

l4cKyccrBoBeA

PeHaro Eapvrnh,

oavH

lts

KyparopoB MonoaexHoTo

pa3aera

6ueHHane,,Anep-

ro"*, rae

o6brqHo

6braarcT

npeaciagnexut HoBeiune

reHAeHuur,l B lrcKyccrBe. C

nououluto napaaoKcanbHoi

+opMyn!apoBKl,|

6aprrnu o6oexavaer

Hau6onee

xapaK-

TepHvE cefoaHf,

c ero

ToqKr4 3peHxF, HanpaBneHHocTb

xvaoxecrBeHHbrx no[cKoB.

nocne

yBneqeH[fl

,,ropn-

,{t.rMl4"

3KcnpecclBHbtMla

SopMaMH,

norpyxeH(a

B crlt-

xr,1lo,{l,tcfori

xlrBonrcHocfl4

MaarH!1K !4cKyccrBa Bo

aropoi

nonoaraHe 80-x

roAoB

pe3Ko

KaqHytcF

B npo-

ruBononoxHylo cropory-

nnrc

oxnaxAeHrn,

ro ecrb

BO3BpaUleHlF

K aCKeT[qHblM,

XeCrrru

rexrlra|

(so-

rorpadraa), reoMerp['{ecK[M

crpyKTypaM,

anbrepHa-

rllBHbrM Marep[anav

(pear-rueia)

,

cxeMar[3My

KoH-

qenryanucrcKhx

nocrpoeHxfi 6brn

orMe,reH

Ha

6HeHHa-

ne 1986 ra 1988

roaoB. Tenepu, ror4a norroc

xotoaa

ocrarcg no3aAr,

HoBaa c[TyaqhF o6taaaer

npexMy-

qecTBoM

6onbuero

pasHoo6pag

n ',| rv6Kocrx xyao-

xecTgeHHbfx

peuJeH4i,

pacKpbtBaer

$upoKt i

arlana-

3OH BO3MOXHOCTe'.

flpq COxpaHeH[4

B

qenoM

,.npo-

xnaAHoi" arMocdepbr HbrHeuHrli

unrepec r o6uexry,

a6crpaKquh.

KoHqenryatrrl3My He oroxaecrBrFercF

c

Bo3BpaqeHl4eM K 70+u!

roaaM.

Coepeuengoe

rcxyccr-

BO

OTrl4qarcT

,,KO3+614UUeHT

3KCqeHTph,lHOCTI4 ",

,,Tpe3

-

Baf, npuxornxBocrb,

KoHrpon[pyeMar.pa3yMoM",

Ero

,,Kanpu3HaF

xonoaHocrb"

-

14Tor

onblra

,,xonoaHblx

7O-x" v

,.u3nuu-lP.e

pacKoBaHHbrx

B

cBoei ropa,{Hocru

80-x".

,,Msr

Bcrynxrh a 90e u uaeM

x 2000 roay c

3Tr.i

M

bBOeO6pa3HbrM

Cr4HTe3OM XOTOAHOTO

4 rOpA9ero,

Bhrgypnocrlr

14

Tpe3eocl4"

[4,

c. 18]

,

npeAynper<raF B03MoxHbre

Bonpocbr orHocl4renb-

Ho coeauHeHua e

$optuyne

,,xonoaHoe

6aporxo"

npo-

Tl4BOnonOXHbrX

Ha,tar,6apl4nrx

noacHaer: B caMoM

ae-

Jre, noHaTre

,,6apor<o"

Bceraa accoqrlxpoBanocb

He

TorbKo

c

ycnoxHeHHocrbo, runep6onuluoru, lo u c

qeM-To,,ropnqhM"

(6ypHoe

nsbnenexre svoqui) u op-

raHuqHbrM

(auanor

,renoeexa

c npxpoaoi)

. oanaro

coBpeMeHHoe

ucKVccrBo

KaK

6hl

nepeHocl4T 6aporHylo

'{lie3MepHocrb

!r u36brrortHocrh B

pe+neKculo

no noBo-

Ay,,yp6aHxcr[,{ecKoi,

l,lcKyccrBeHHoi,

rexHonorh.tec-

*oi"

waunuta\uu

[167

c. 264]

. Ero

ocHoeHar

npo-

6neMa

-

no!4cK co6crBeHHoro

Mecra B 3Toi nnorHofr,

3arpoMo)<AeHHoi BeqaMx,

neperpyxeHHoli

Bl,l3yanh-

HbtMl,t curHanaMl,

cpeae.

llpranarxuri rvAep

,,xonoaHoro

6apoKKo"

-

llxe+S

KyHc

(CllJA)

,

roroporo Eapnnnr

c.ruraer

Aperto

{xran,)

-

orkp61106 npocrpascrBo.

I

..durypoi

3M6neMaru,iecKoi", Crynrnrypa

Kyrca

,,Axedd

u l4noHa, cAenaHo ta ae6ecu"

-

npoBoKa-

uhoHHafl,

pacctlrraHHaf,

Ha cKaHAarbHutti

ycnex.

14tnlel-

Ho raKoi

ycnex

oHa

u cHl4cKana,

,,Mono[oi'{enoBeK,

a6conpriro

ronsri n

co

crorb

xe

Henp!,rKpbrrbrM

Bbrpa-

x€HleM nuqa,

y,Qo6Ho pacnonoxhnca

Ha neprrApone-

Boi 6noHA!4HKe.

qbr

urnenaHqbr

ra

ertcornx

xa6nyr-

Kax 14 cKynbre

aeTan[

[HTr4MHoro Tyanera co3aatoT

Heo6xoauMbre npodecclaoHanbHbre aKqeHTbr;

yrorHhrM

no'<eM

nape crvxaT H3BrlBbt frfaHTcKoto

apaKoHa

4nr

KaKoro-To

nor3yqero rana"

l12l

.

Snarupytou4ai

vo.

MeHT 3aKrrcgaercF

npe'<ae Bcero B ToM,

qTo

Bo BpeMa

3KCnOHlapOBaH[F npO[3BeAeH!4A O6a

nepCOtaXa

-

cau

aarop ta ero

no4pyra

l,lnoua CTannep

no npo3Bl,ruly

9rqqonrsa

(6brBUaF

nopHo3ge3aa, a HbrHe

- qneH

lzlranunrc<oro napnaMeHTa),,8o

nrol4

pa3rynlaBator

no

BeHeqrll4 KaK nlo[u, KoropbtM Heqero

cKpbtBarb or

oKpvxapu.l[x

"

(TaM

xe) .

llxeSO

KyHc

norb3yercF

cnaBo;

.,HoBoroyopxo-

na".

Pa6oian B

pycne

non€pra, oH

cBoeo6pa3Ho

Moae-

rl,tpver MaccoBoe 3creTr'{ecKoe

co3HaHl/|e. KprrhKr

ycMarpxBa|or

3Aecb nonbtrKy

u36aBurbca or anacru

K[Tqa nyreM

r

nepTpoQnpoBaHHoro

Bocnpo|,3Beae-

HlrF

Kr4TLregbrx uoaenei.

,,Heo-nopn"

-

orepe4noi

uJar B ToM xe HanpaBreHru.

,,Oxlaxaeanocrt"

noeu-

ql4!,f

xyAoxH[Ka, KaK

yBepFer

6apunnu,

BHe noao3pe-

Hvi, He 6yay,{r,,r cropoHHl4KoM

KpaiHe xecrKt4x,

,,acen-

ThqecKlax" cpeAcrB 6opu6ur c

,,ueero

o6pasr

utv npecut-

uleHreM" npeaulecrBynuero neploAa,

KyHc

reM He

MeHee He

paryer

3a

Bo3BpaueHlre

K

,,pyKorBopHblM

qeHHocTFM",

npeAno'{r,rTaa M!4p

peax.Mexa,,,aocTaToq-

Ho

6orarbli,

qro6ur

yaoenereopllTb

Bce HauJ[ norpe6-

Hocrr4", He

crolrr 14THopl4poBarb r ero 3MouHoHanbHble

acneKlbr,

nycrh

Aaxe

ecn[

peqb

uaer o6

,,sMoqrnx

a6-

conprHo

aypHoro

aryca", Krrr He[36ex<eH,

u

ocBo6o-

auTbca

oT

Hero MoxHo ronu<o acctittl ltn

rpya, a6cop6ta-

pyn,

nornou.lan ero

,,Bo

Bce

6ontLulax

ao:ax"

['16,

c.

2631 . no€fi,qHMoMy, cornacHo

3Tofi norrKe,

h ro-

paqHocrh

BoBneqeHHocTh,

t1 xonoa orraflKrgaHuF

paB-

Ho

HenpfieMneMbr. Ocraerca

pa6ora

B

pexuMe yMepeH-

Hbrx reMneparyp n a

lecnu

BepHyrhcn

K anoKanxnrta'

gecKrM

€tccoul4aqfinu)

,,re

n noxna4tocrb

"

pacrBope-

Hl4 4...

,{na

teroroptrx

Kpr4TxKoB oi{eB{aeH,,rMnrttr_

qr4THO

r 3KCnJtrU[rHO

nonllTliqecKhi

xapaKTep"

pa'

6or

Kynca, a Koropbrx

npohcxoAl4T

,,o6HaxeHle

noc-

ToFH

Ho K

pe

nHyqero

cop3a Mexay rcryccieotut

u ero-

novr,rxoi".

Ho r

orn

npr3Haxrr

npaBoMepHocrb

3pt1-

TerbcKoro HeaoyMeHqf,:

,,tlTo

3To, capKa3M

tin, l4c-

KpeHHocrb, Haa KeM

TaKt,tM

o6paaou

ulyrar?"

(Tat'l

xe,

c,278).

SSSercrxBHocrb

raBTonoTutlecKoro

Meroaa

pa3BeHqaHufl

qepe3

yBeKoBetleHl,e,

KaK

u3BecTHo, tlJl4

_

poKo

npl48FTofo

B coBpeMeHHoM

lrcKyccTBe, Bbl3blEa'

er

noHFTHbre coMHeHuF.

Ho,

ao acn<oru

cny,{ae,

KyHcy

He

oTKaxeuJb

B

cnoco6HocTl4

aeMoHcrp!'lpoBaTb

no'{Tl4

cBepxqenoBeqecKylo

ocBo6ox(AeHHocrb

He ronhKo or

KOMnneKCOB,

tO

U

Or

Ua-nefiUlei

Aorlh

caMooToxAecT'

BJreHoF

c. co6crBeuHbrM

rBopeH[eM.

I]o3yHr xyAox-

H[Ka:

Hu

rpaHa

cv6ue<rreHoro.

lrluexno noerovy on

caM He nplKacaeTca K cBol4M npou3BeaeH[FM

-

l,'lx

[3roraBrxBaK,r

B MacrepcKr4x. flepeg

epurenev,

rar

cKa3arb,

ToraF

o6texruaHocru.

Hecuorpn'ra

rrneppe-

anrcT!.tqHocTb

MaHephl, l,l30bpaxeHue

nonHocrblo

Jl9i_

ueHo

i{ero-r1460

n14'{HocTHoro,

npeBpaqeHo B

nnocKyto

ycnoBHoGTb,

a6cTpaKTHbri

cr,1 MBon

TeM He MeHee 3To He MeuJaer nDoaBneH,||o

or-

rprrroro Kyacou e ce6e npreeatna nponoBeaHlrKa

HOAOTO

AyXOBHOfO

yqeHUF,

qerb

KOTOpOTO

-

HaKOHeq-

ro

ocBo6oar,.rTh

qeI|oBeqecTBo

oT

qyBCTBa

Bl,Hbt,cTpaxa

f4 cThlAa.

npec4eavpulfix ero c MoMeHTa v3fHaHuF

u3

pa8.

Ha 3ToM nyrh noAcnopheM

xyAoxHr4Ky

cnyxaT

l,rcTopx

K

o

-K

ynbTypH

bre Moaenr. K KoTopbrM

oH

oxoT-

Ho

anenn!4pyer.

Onrcaxran cKynbnrypa uto6unyet

caKpanbHblMH KoHHoTau[aMl,, Haql,Haa

c

Ha3BaHnF.

Marep14ana

{pacrpaulenroe AepeBo,

orcbrrraFoutee

K

npocroAyr!Hoi

xpaMoBoi cKynbnrype npoBr4Hu[anb.

roro 6aporxo)

Ao

orAenbHbrx

r.r3o6pa3[TenbHbrx Mo-

ruaoe

{noeepxexHsti sl4efi ra r.

A.)

.

,,AyxoeHocru

aaxHa, oHa np

xoAxr

or

yBepeHHocr[

B ce6e, a

yEe-

peHHocrb

B ce6e

Aeraer

Hac

qacrbro

BeqHoro,

-

KoM-

MeHrqpyer

aBrop.

-

tlroHa

-

3To

Moe

xeraHre. H

cnoco6en

ero ocyqecrBlrrb, Bcrynaa B coto3, Koropbti

craHoBt4TcF obuerrugHutv

onbrroM,

TaK KaK Bce Mo.

panuuure

rox$lurrbl

ycrpaHeHbt...

Petl,aha

-

3To

OopMan

3aqha,

oHa

npeacraBnaer co6oi,

npa3una

u

crpyKrypy. Mbr

xe

AaeM

rorbKo

AyxoBHyro

A/.peKrn-

ay,

r60 Mbr

rrc6tlM

qenoaeqecreo"

[8,c.'13'l]

.

KaK BbracHFercF, KyHcy He

qyxAhr

,,TpaA[Llxr,1

Seprrur r lvluKenaHAxero"

kaK

,.Ben[,raiuJrlx

MaHl,-

nynaropoB MaccaMu,

Koropbre Koraa-nfi6o cyuecreo-

Ean/: Bca KoHqenquF

penufuv

npovcxoaul

q3

ux

npou:ee4enui

1...;

hcryccreo

AonxHo

MaHhnynlt-

poBarb

|,'| co6na3HFTb

<...>

F BcerAa clapanca cAenarb

ceorc

pa6ory

oqeHb

co6na3Hureruxori

n

npavofi

4...1

oqeHb

AocrynHoi,

,{To6br

ee MoT BocnpllHarb n|o6ofi

qeroBeK"

(TaM

xe,c.129,131)

.

Caprasru

naryrvnuvc-

KpeHHocrb

(a

crcopee, !4MeHHo

nptaHurnuanbHaF

aBy-

cvsrcneHrocru), Ho Ha

AocrhxeHye

qent,t

6poLUeHbl

nor4cr!.iHe

rpaHAho3Hbte

cpeAcraa. l\,4a'|o

roro,

,rro

3aMbrcnbt KyHca

pearta3ylorca

B

xyAoxecrBeHHbrx

MacrepcKr4x.

CKynbnrypHaa

Ipynna

Ha

6laeHnane

3KcnoHr.rpoBarrach

Ha

+oHe

rhraHTcxux

(npuvepno

2,5 x 3,5 v)

.

vpesaurvaito FpKt4x

xl4eonracHbrx no-

noreH

Ha

ror

xe crcxer, BbtnonHeHHhrx no

+ororpa.

SfiFM.

14 Becb

eror ancau6nu

-

acero flrrurb npeaM6y-

na h

peKnaMa

o6euaHHoro

ny6nure

$rnuvra,

a

ycnexe

KOTOOOTO

aBTOp H14ManO He COMHeBaeTCA,

HapacraHl,1e,,BHyrpeHHefr Karacrpo+br"

a

acKyc-

crBe H.A.

bepAFeB npeAaylen eqe B 1917

roAy,

Ba

3ape

,,nocneAHero

rBopqecKoro

AHA". ,,l

cKyccrBo

aonxHo

6hrrb

cBo6oAHo...

XyAoxecreeHFioe

raopqecr-

Bo He

AonxHo

6hrrh

noA,rl4HeHo BHeuiHl4M

AJ|F

Hero

HopMaM,

MopanbHbtM,

o6ulecrBeHHbrM

vnu

penvfuo3-

HbrM.

HO

aBTOHOMT4F

I4CKyCCTBa

COBCeM He O3HaqaeT

TO-

ro,

trTo

xyaoxecTBeHHoe

TBopqecTao

MoxeT l4n,l

ao'l-

xHo

6btrb oropBaHo

or

gyxoexoi

xrr3Hl4 14 or

AyxoB-

HoTo

pa3Burra

qenoBeKa.

Cgo6oAa He ecrb nycrora.

CBo6oAHoe rcKyccrBo

Bhrpacraer

la3

ayxoBHoi

rry6x-

Hbr

'{enoBeKa,

<a< ceo6oaH6ri

nnoa"

['1,c.

19] ,,,He

TOnbKO I4CKyCCTBO, HO l.l

BCe

TBOpqeCTBO

qenOBeqeCKOe

6e3Bo3BparHo

norH6Her

y

norpv3l4Tc8

B

,t3HaqanbHyto

TbMy,

ecn14 oHo He cTaHeT TBopqecTBoM xlr3H14, TBopqe-

crBoM HoBoro

qeroBeKa

u eroayxoBHhrM

nyreM".

Bbri-

Aer

nu

qcKyccrBo

u3

r(pt

3vca B

.,HoBbri

Ml4poBoi

eos"? Tar

unu u{a'!.e, eMy npeAcrot4T

BMecre

c KVnb-

Typoi B

qenoM

,.ao

KoHqa

3xuaarb

cBolo cyah6y"

$ata

xe,c.27,28l .

-

6btrb Moxer, Tpr,rB[aibHbre

noArrensr

Kyrca

-

clreacTBue

HeKoero

KoMnJleKca HenonHoueHHocT14,

cBa3dHHOrO

C aBTOH OM l43aquei, OT KOTOpOfO COBpeMeH-

HOe lrcKyccTBo

ao

ct4x nop He MoxeT nonHocTbro

ocBo'

6o4rruca. Kar

6rr eureoparuBaa Ha[3HaHKy rrcropr4-

'{ecKhe

MoAenx, KyHc

orKaquBaer

h3

Hlrx

Bo3Ayx l,

oc.

TaBrFer MeprByro

o6onovrcy.

fllaLuanch

Aocryna

K

Ay-

xoeroi

rry6axe.

rcKyccrBo

oKa3btBaercs

06pe,teHo

Ha

3KcnaHcl,lro

B

el43r1'tecKoM

npocrpaHcrBe.

noxoxe,

evy

ocTaeTca nqulb

KoHcTaTrjpoBarb.

,iTo

cBo6oAa

ecTb

nycrora.

,,XonoaHoe

6apoKKo"

npeAcraer

HeKuM

AV-

xoBHo

gbrxonouleHHblM

6apoKKo

-

HeKriM

6apoKKo

Hao6opor. Bl,recro

4yxoanoro

HanpRXeHHE,

HaKana,

KoropbtM

xxByr

+opMbt

l4cropt4qecKoro

6aporxo,

3Aecb

-

npoxnaaHaF

yMepeHHocrb,

r.ei

.tpanusauvia

,,MopanbHbrx

KoHdflr1KToB", pacrBopeHxe pa3nu,.I4i

MexAy

abtcoKl4M

14 MaccoBbtM,

,"qpeidypqaF,,

cncre_

Ma

qeHHocTei

{ HopM,

BHeU]HFF

Ug6UtTO,ttOCtr,

UOHV-

MeHTanbHoc16.

rpaHuqaulaF

c f

nt aHTovaHuei,

npu{Ltu

-

nuaJtbHaf,

noBepxHocTHocTb,

Aocf

ynHocrb...

HapacraHrie

.,BHyrpeHHei

KaracTpodbt"

ryr

yAlreurenuxrrv

o6pa-

30M

npocBe'{t,lBaer

cxeoau

a6connrnyrc

Heo6peMeHeH-

Hocrb

ApaMaru3MoM.

Ao

KoHqa raxaean

caorc

cy4u6y,

,.rcKyccTBo

ocTaeTcF

3epKaIoM,

oTpaxapu.luM

6recK !4

Hxqery

Lu4Bunh3a4l4|4

XX BeKa,

AVXoBHoe

cocroaHle

coapeMeHHlKa.

,,o,

ecnu

6u rul

6urn

xonoaet unr

ro-

p8g!

Ho

KaK Tbt

renn.

a

He

fopaq

r

He

xonoAeH, To

1,13.

BeprHy re6F

x3

ycr

Moaax. l46o

rst roaoplrruu:

a 6orar,

pae6oraren

lt

Hr B

qeM

He hMerc

HyxAbl;

a He 3Haeub,

qTO

Thf

HeCqacTeH,

14 XaI|OK,

tA HVUJ, U Cnen,

U

Haf"

(Anorc

3, 15-17)

.

3++eKrHas

Ae+uHlatln8

P, 5apunnu,

ra nepauri

B3rnf,a

coBepuJeHHo

opuruiHa'|bHaF,

BoBce He FB'|FeTCA

KaKIM-TO 3K3OTl,iqH6tM

UBeTKOM,

BbtpOCLll,4M

Ha nyc-

rurpe.

B

opaxxepee rana4toi

Kynhrypbt

HerpyaHo

on-

peAenurb

ee npoxcxox4eHle:

3To

oaHa l/i3

penrlK

Ha

AocraroqHo

aBTopxrerHyto

KoHuenul4|o

Heo6apoKKo,

cQopMyfl,|po8aHHyto

fiTanbaHcKtlM

|,.t c K

yccrB

oB

eAo M 14

KynbryponoroM

Orurapov

Kana6pese.

fiocKonbKy

'1Ma

STOrO

yteHOrO

noKa

eule Haxoat4Tca

aHe nona 3peHIa

HaLU4X

CneLl|4aflrCTOB,

npeACTaBnAeTCB

yMeCTHbtM

no-

3HaKOMl4Tb

qlTaTefiA

C

OCHOBHb|MI4 nO34qxAMI

Ull,tpo-

Ko ,i3BecrHoi

rrurt Kala6pese

,,3noxa

Heo6apoKKo",

r3AaHHoi

e

t987 roay

[7]

i

ABTop

Aenaer

nonbtrKy

orbtcKarb

,,npustaKn

HeKoero

BKyca Haurero

BpeMeHr

s caMhtx

pa3Hbtx

06-

nacfax

-

or HayKu

40

MaccoBbrx KoMMyHUKaU!4Ii,

oT

nxreparypbr

ao

Srloco$ru,

or 14cKyccrBa

4o

6urroeo-

ro

floBeaeHra

npaei"

(C,V)

.

OnqcaHue 3Toro aKVca

enoxlr

(uxave

roBopF,

MeHTanurera,

tanta

avxa

BpeMe-

rr), xoropuri Kala6peae

o6o3Ha,{aer cnoeov

,,aeo6a-

poKKo",

cocraenrer

npeaMer

ero

,,coqrarsHof,

ecre-

tu<u".

,,Moi

reHeparbHbti

Te3[c

3aKrrcqaerca

B

ToM,

qTo

MHoxecrBo

BaxHbtx FBneHl4i

KynhTypbt

HauJero

BpeMeHu

ornrlqaKrrcF

oflequ+la,{ecKoi

BHyrpeHHei

+opMoi.

HanoMhHaoulei

o

6aporro"

(C,17).

Paepa-

6arureaa cgoi MeroA,

Kana6pe3e

on

paerca

Ha

o6ulhp-

'rbrU

Kopnyc KaK

h3BecrHhtx, TaK

r HoBeiuJl4x Eccne-

AoBaHui

6apoKKo

(galrerru,

9To

3acrvxuBaer

BHrMa-

HlaF caM

+aKr

oco6oro !aHTepeca

r eroi reue

e rcryc-

crBo3HaH

h 70-€0-x

roaoe)

. Aerop rcxoAlar las nporlr-

aonocraBneHxa

KnacclaqecKofi

ur 6apoqxofi

KoHcraHT

B KyJrbrype,

orBepraF nAe|o

nx

qlxnrvecroi

cverur,

KaK craAql4

pacqBera

fi

ynaAKa

KynbrypHoli

ct4creMbt,

,. npeacTaBnFeT

l4x

KaK cocyu.tecrBypuue

r KoHKy-

pnpyroulxe.

He c.rhraF,

vro xeo6apo.rnuri

BKyc B Hauje

BpeMF rocnoAcrByer

6e3pa3AenbHo,

Kana6pe3e

ocrpo-

yMHo

conocraanFer

Kyflhrypy

c 6[pxeit, rAe Kypcbl

oAHxx

aKqrt

naAapr.

Apyf!4x

-

notrcKaK[Bapr. BHyr-

peHHhe

hMnylbcbt, onpeaenarcu.ll,e

BeKTopbt

pa3B,|Tt4F

+

3aecb

s

Aanee

nph

qurlrpoBaHnt,

aaHHoro

,croqHrKa

vKa3btBaeTca

TonhKo

ero cTpaHxqa.

Дизайн на западе (сборник)

Подождите немного. Документ загружается.