
18.8 Reactions of Esters 897
PROBLEM 18.9 Write mechanisms for acid- and base-induced transesterification.
WORKED PROBLEM 18.10 There is an important difference between the reaction
of an ester with hydroxide (
OH) and of an ester with alkoxide (
OR).The reac-
tion with hydroxide is neither catalytic nor reversible, whereas the reaction with
alkoxide is both catalytic and reversible. Analyze the mechanisms of these reac-
tions and explain these observations.
ANSWER Look at the final products of the two reactions. Reaction with hydroxide
leads to a carboxylic acid (pK
a
4.5) and an alkoxide ion. These two species
must react very rapidly to make the more stable carboxylate anion (resonance sta-
bilized) and the alcohol (pK
a
17). The hydroxide reagent is consumed in this
reaction, and the overall process is so thermodynamically favorable that it is irre-
versible in a practical sense.
'
'
O
..
..
–
..
..
..
C
OR
R
..
..
OR
..
..
O
..
..
C
R
..
O
..
..
C
OH
H
R
..
..
OH
–
(–)
–
+
..
..
..
OR
O
..
..
With an alkoxide reagent, things are different. Now the product is not a car-
boxylic acid but another ester. There is no proton that can be removed, and there
is a new molecule of alkoxide generated. The reaction is approximately ther-
moneutral. The reaction is reversible.
OR
+
O
..
..
C
OR
R
..
..
–
..
..
..
+
O
..
..
C
R
..
..
–
..
..
..
OR
OR
WORKED PROBLEM 18.11 Given that there are acid- and base-catalyzed transester-
ification reactions, should there not be both acid- and base-catalyzed Fischer
esterifications as well? Explain clearly why there is no base-catalyzed version of
Fischer esterification (i.e., RCOOH RO
RCOOR HO
does not occur).
ANSWER The reaction of a carboxylic acid with an alkoxide can’t proceed by
addition–elimination to give an ester because there is another much easier reac-
tion available; that reaction is simple removal of the carboxylic acid hydroxyl
proton to give the resonance-stabilized carboxylate anion. They don’t call these
compounds “acids” for nothing! The lesson in this problem is that you have to
“think simple.” Look first for “trivial” reactions (loss of the proton) before pro-
ceeding on to more complicated processes (addition–elimination).
U
OR
..
..
O
..
..
C
R
..
O
..
..
C
OH
H
R
..
..
–
–
..
..
..
OR
O
..
..
pK
a
~4.5 pK
a
~17
+
O
..
..
C
R
–
..
..
O
..
–
..
..
..
RO
–
..
..
..
HO
O
..
..
C
OR
R
..
..
O
..
..
OH
R
..
..
C
++