nationalinterest,stilldedicatedtotheself‐confidentperceptionofworldorderby
whichAmericanidealismhadrestoredwar‐ravagedsocietiesandturnedenemies
intoallies.Nixonwasathisbest.Hemadeaneloquentspeech:Hehadnever
askedthosepresentfortheirsupportonVietnam.Buttheyhadneverdisagreed
onNATO.ThePresidentrecalledthatsincetheEightiethCongress,when
PresidentTrumanproposedtheNorthAtlanticTreatyandrelatedprogramsanda
RepublicanCongresssupportedthem,wehadalwaysbeenatoneonthissubject.
InopposingtheMansfieldamendment,herepresentedthecontinuityof
Americanpolicy.AlludingtothetitleofAcheson’sautobiography,hesaidthathe
toohadbeen“presentatthecreation.”Perhapswewereonthevergeofa
breakthroughwiththeCommunistworld(hewasthinkingofSALTandthe
preparationsformytriptoPeking).Butwecouldachievethesegoalsonlyifthe
AtlanticAlliancestayedstrong.
Allpresentrespondedinthesamespirit.Therewassomediscussionabout
thedesirabilityofcompromise.ButAcheson,whosharednoneofNixon’s
reluctancetoengageinface‐to‐faceconfrontations,effectivelysquelchedit.Ata
strategicmomentAchesonsurfacedabriefstatementofsupportfortheothersto
sign.Rogers—unawarethatNixonhimselfhadoriginatedthenotionofan
Achesondraft,perhapsputoffbytheelegantself‐assuranceofhispredecessor,
perhapsworriedaboutMansfield,withwhomhewouldhavetocontinueto
work—urgedthatitbekeptinabeyance.Acheson,whoknewthattheexisting
consensusmightevaporateonceeveryonereturnedtohisnormalpressures,
urgedagreementinprincipleonthespotandreleaseofthestatementassoonas
possible,butnolaterthanSaturday,May15,orforty‐eighthourslater.Nixon
managedtoconveytohisSecretaryofStatethathewasinaccord,andRogers
joinedtheconsensus.
Achesonwasselectedtoreporttothepress.Reticencewasnothisstyle.He
gaveashisimpressionthatthePresidentwasadamantagainsttheMansfield
proposalandanyvariationofit.Itwouldbe“asinine,”hesaid,and“sheer
nonsense,”tocutforceswithoutacutinSovietforces.Hesaidhethoughtthat
wecouldwinthevote.HereportedthatthePresidenthadcalledonthepeople
whocreatedNATOandsawitthroughfortwentyyears.“Allofushadourfighting
gloveson.”Askedwhythemeetingtooksolong,hereplied,“wearealloldand
wearealleloquent.”GeorgeBalladdedthatitwasarelieftobetoldbythe
Presidentthathedidnotwanttocompromise.