
CARPENTERSENCYCLOPEDIA OF POPULAR CULTURE
441
Because they emerged following a decade (the 1960s) in which the
most influential performers were those who pushed the bounds of pop
music, they were often criticized for their wholesome, straightfor-
ward style. However, Karen Carpenter, with her extraordinary voice
and girl-next-door good looks, and Richard Carpenter, with his
world-class composing abilities, overcame the criticism to produce
19 top-10 singles during the 1970s.
Karen (1950-1983), who was both a singer and a drummer, and
Richard (1946—), who was the group’s arranger, producer, and
keyboardist, were born in New Haven, Connecticut, to Harold Bertram
Carpenter and Agnes Tatum. While children, they developed an
enthusiasm for popular music. While Richard pursued music avidly,
Karen played the flute briefly, but was more interested in sports. The
family moved to Downey, California, in 1963. In 1966, Karen and
Richard teamed up with bassist Wes Jacobs to form the Richard
Carpenter Trio, an instrumental band. Karen also signed a solo
singing contract with the Magic Lamp record label, and recorded
‘‘Looking for Love’’ and ‘‘I’ll Be Yours,’’ released as singles.
Shortly after, the Richard Carpenter Trio won ‘‘The Battle of the
Bands’’ at the Hollywood Bowl.
It wasn’t until 1969, however, that the band, refashioned as the
Carpenters and with Karen singing as well as playing drums, was
‘‘discovered’’ by world-famous trumpeter Herb Alpert, leader of the
Tijuana Brass, and co-founder of the A&M record label. Upon
hearing a demo tape of the Carpenters, he immediately recognized the
extraordinary quality of Karen Carpenter’s voice. ‘‘It was full and
round, and it was . . . amazing. This voice was buzzing into my body,
and it was the way they presented it.’’ Their first album, Offering, was
released on the A&M record label in 1969. It did not sell well,
although their cover of the Beatles’ ‘‘Ticket to Ride’’ reached number
54 on the U.S. singles charts. In 1970, their album Close to You,
included their first number one single of the same name (which sold
more than 300,000 copies), and the duo began international tours that
would include up to 200 concerts in a year. That year they also
released the hit singles ‘‘We’ve Only Just Begun,’’ and ‘‘For All We
Know.’’ They won Grammy Awards in 1970 for best contemporary
vocal performance by a group for ‘‘Close to You,’’ and also for best
new artist. In 1970, ‘‘For All We Know,’’ featured in the film
‘‘Lovers and Other Strangers,’’ captured an Academy Award.
Between 1970 and 1975, the Carpenters were one of the hardest
working bands in pop music. Richard was the guiding force behind
the duo’s production and arrangements, and also wrote songs with
Richard Bettis. But material supplied by songwriters Burt Bacharach,
Paul Williams, and Roger Nichols helped the Carpenters gain as-
tounding success with 17 million-selling albums between 1970 and
1981. Other well-known standards released by the duo during this
period were ‘‘Rainy Days and Mondays,’’ ‘‘Superstar,’’ ‘‘Sing,’’
‘‘Yesterday Once More,’’ and ‘‘Top of the World.’’ Their compila-
tion album, The Singles 1969-1973, was on the U.S. album charts for
115 weeks. By the late 1990s, the Carpenters had demonstrated that
their success was more than fleeting, with worldwide sales topping
100 million units.
The Carpenters bucked 1970s pop music trends by conveying a
wholesome, middle-class image, and were even mocked by the pop
music establishment, who viewed their songs as insipid and their
popularity as fleeting. Music critic Rob Hoerburger (New York Times,
Nov. 3, 1991) wrote ‘‘They always dressed as if they were going to
church, and they sang sticky songs about love (but never sex). Worst
of all, parents loved their music.’’ During their heyday, rock critics
described their music as ‘‘treacle,’’ ‘‘drippy easy listening,’’ ‘‘schlock
music,’’ and their personalities as ‘‘squeaky,’’ ‘‘smiley,’’ and ‘‘sac-
charine.’’ Fortunately for their record company, A&M, and their in-
house mentor, Herb Alpert, the listening public purchased their
records by the millions and their concerts sold out consistently. Their
popularity was not confined to the United States. They also had strong
fan bases in Great Britain and Japan, and they were also popular in
many other European and Asian countries. In 1973, they were
honored by then-President Richard Nixon by being asked to perform
at a state visit by West German Chancellor Willy Brandt.
The Carpenters enjoyed their greatest success between 1970 and
1975. After that time, the duo was beset by serious health problems.
Richard spent several years addicted to the sedative Quaalude, and
recovery took another several years. Karen, meanwhile, battled
anorexia nervosa, a psychophysiological disorder whose cluster of
symptoms begins usually with a fear of being overweight and
continues with severe weight loss due to self-starvation. She fought
this disease for years, with her ‘‘normal’’ weight of 120 pounds (she
was 5′4″ tall) dropping to 79 pounds several times between 1975
(when she collapsed onstage in Las Vegas while singing ‘‘Top of the
World’’), and her death in 1983. Though few were aware of anorexia
nervosa as a disease during the 1970s, Carpenter’s death from the
disorder drew a great deal of attention to the disease. Indeed, she may
be as important a figure in American popular culture because of the
way she died as because of the way she achieved fame. After her death
anorexia nervosa became well-known to the American public, and
many sought help for themselves or their (often) teenage daughters
after reading or hearing media accounts of her symptoms and the
cause of her death.
The Carpenters experienced a new surge of popularity in the late
1980s and 1990s as their catalog was re-released on compact disk,
most notably the four-disk set From the Top. In 1994, a compilation of
their songs entitled If I Were a Carpenter, performed by some of the
most popular ‘‘alternative’’ music groups, became a top-selling
record. Many of these rock stars, including Sonic Youth, Cracker, and
the Cranberries, said that they had been strongly influenced by the
Carpenters’ sound. Jeff McDonald of Redd Kross, one of the bands
featured on the CD, echoed the beliefs of many musicians and critics
who had reassessed their music almost twenty years after their peak
popularity. ‘‘I’d always been a huge fan of the Carpenters, and an
admirer of their songs. The quality of their songs was so wonderful,
they were lyrically very sophisticated, not this teenybop fare . . . Most
bands just want to write perfect pop songs. And these are perfect
pop songs.’’
Richard Carpenter’s music career continued on a considerably
reduced basis after his sister’s death, although he continues to tour
and produce. Most notably, he produced his sister’s last solo album,
Karen Carpenter, released in 1996, and his own album, Pianist—
Arranger—Composer—Conductor, came out in 1998.
—Jeff Merron
F
URTHER READING:
Coleman, Ray. The Carpenters: The Untold Story: An Authorized
Biography. New York, HarperCollins, 1994.