subsequent reac tions use two NADPH
2
and two ATP to produce phosphoglyceraldehyde
(PGAL, or glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate). Most of the PGAL goes on to be converted back
into the ribulose, to keep the cycle go ing. This requires another ATP.
Two of every 12 PGALs formed are converted to another triose, which leaves the chlor-
oplast for the cytoplasm. There they can be converted to glucose or other carbohydrates in
the second pathway. The enzymes for forming glucose are the same as the ones in glyco-
lysis, acting in reverse. In fact, PGAL is one of the key intermediates in glycolysis. PGAL
can also be converted into glycerol and fatty acids for fats, or into amino acids for pro-
teins. Overall, since each turn of the cycle incorporates a single CO
2
, it takes six cycles to
produce one molecule of glucose. The overall stoichiometry for the Calvin cycle is
6CO
2
þ 12 NADPH
2
þ 18 ATP ) C
6
H
12
O
6
þ 12 NADP þ 18 ADP þ18 P
i
þ 6H
2
O
ð5:58Þ
Strangely, most plants have a wasteful side reaction, called photorespiration, which
uses the same enzyme as reaction (5.57). The reaction occurs during hot, dry conditions
when leaf pores close to conserve water. CO
2
is depleted inside the leaf and O
2
builds up.
The oxygen competes with the CO
2
for the enzyme, producing a side reaction with the
ribulose-1,5 biphosphate. Waste products are formed instead of carbohydrates, and ATP is
consumed. There seems to be no benefit to the plant. This is a major drain on biological
productivity for the world’s plants and can reduce the net efficiency of photosynthesis
below 1%.
A minority of plants (about 100 species are known) have developed a mechanism to tilt
the balance back toward normal CO
2
fixation. This has occurred in plants that grow in hot,
arid regions. Closing the stomates to limit water loss also limits CO
2
entry to the leaf. In
these plants, instea d of forming the three-carbon phosphoglycerate in reaction (5.57), cells
near the outside of the leaf use a different reaction that forms the four-carbon oxaloace-
tate, which is then reduced by NADPH
2
to the four-carbon malate. The malate diffuses to
other cells in the leaf interior, where it reacts to form pyruvate, CO
2
, and NADPH
2
.This
has the net effect of transporting CO
2
and NADPH
2
to the inner cells at a higher concen-
tration, where they enter the Calvin cycle. Twelve additional ATPs are used per glucose,
but the net efficiency increases because photorespiration is relatively low. Plants that do
this include the important food crops sorghum, corn, and sugarcane. Because they form a
four-carbon product with CO
2
, they are called C
4
plants. The more common plants with-
out this ability are called C
3
plants.
Actual maximum photosynthetic efficiencies of the C
4
crops sugarcane (Saccharum
officinale), sorghum (Sorghum vulgare), and corn (Zea mays) have been measured to
range from 2.5 to 3.2%; for the C
3
crops alfalfa, sugar beet, and the alga Chlorella, the
range is 1.4 to 1.9%. C
3
plants can fix 15 to 40 mg of CO
2
per dm
2
of leaf surface per
hour, while C
4
plants can fix 40 to 80 mg/dm
2
per hour. C
4
plants lose much less water by
transpiration than do C
3
plants. The optimum daytime temperature for growth of C
4
plants
is higher: 30
to 35
C vs. 20
to 25
C for C
3
plants. Examples of C
3
crop grasses are
wheat (Triticum aestivum), rye (Secale cereale), oats (Avena sativa), and rice (Oryza
sativa).
A third strategy for photosynthesis is carried out by succulents such as the jade
plant and some cacti. These are called CAM (for ‘‘crassulacean acid metabolism’’)
plants. CAM plants fix carbon at night with the stomata (pores in the leaves) open. During
the heat of the day the stomata close, and the Calvin cycle obtains its carbon from the
112 ENERGY AND METABOLISM